Bashkirs
Башҡорттар (Bashkir) | |
---|---|
Total population | |
approx. 2 million[1] | |
Regions with significant populations | |
Russia 1,584,554[2] • Bashkortostan 1,268,806 | |
Kazakhstan | 41,000[3] |
Uzbekistan | 58,500[4] |
Ukraine | 4,253[5] |
Belarus | 1,200[citation needed] |
Turkmenistan | 8,000[6] |
Moldova | 610[7] |
Latvia | 177-205[8][9] |
Lithuania | 400[citation needed] |
Estonia | 112[10] |
Kyrgyzstan | 1,111[11] |
Georgia | 379[12] |
Azerbaijan | 533[13] |
Armenia | 145[14] |
Tajikistan | 8,400[citation needed] |
Languages | |
Bashkir, Russian, Tatar[15] | |
Religion | |
Predominantly Sunni Islam | |
Related ethnic groups | |
Volga Tatars, Kazakhs,[16] Nogais,[17][18] Crimean Tatars,[19] Hungarians[20] |
The Bashkirs or Bashkurts (
Most Bashkirs speak the
doctrine. Previously nomadic and fiercely independent, the Bashkirs gradually came under Russian rule beginning in the 16th century; they have since played a major role through the history of Russia, culminating in their autonomous status within the Russian Empire, Soviet Union and post-Soviet Russia.Ethnonym
This section needs additional citations for verification. (March 2023) |
The etymology and indeed meaning of the
The name Bashqurt has been known since the 10th century, most researchers etymologize the name as "main/leader/head" (bash) + "wolf" (qurt being an archaic name for the animal), thus "wolf-leader" (from the totemic hero ancestor).
This prevailing
Although this is the prevailing theory for an etymology of the term bashqurt, other theories have been formulated:
- In 1847, the historian V. S. Yumatov speculated the original meaning to have been "beekeeper or beemaster".[22]
- oghurs". Since modern sh corresponds to l in Bulgar language. Therefore, Dunlop proposes the ethnonyms Bashqurt and Bulgar are equivalent.[23] Zeki Velidi Togan also suggested this.[24]
- Historian and ethnologist A. E. Alektorov has suggested that Bashqurt meant "distinct nation".[citation needed]
- compound word meaning "wolf-children" or "descendantsof heroes", on the basis of the words bacha "descendant, child" and gurd "hero" or gurg "wolf".
- Historian and
- According to the orientalist Douglas Morton Dunlop, the ethnonym Bashqort was derived from beshgur (or bashgur) which means "five tribes" in the modern Bashkir language.[citation needed]
- Ethnologist N. V. Bikbulatov suggested that the term originated from the name of a legendary Yayıqriver.
- Ethnologist R. G. Kuzeev derived the ethnonym from the morphemes bash "leader, head" and qurt "tribe".[citation needed]
- Historian and Old Hungarian Majer).[26]
History
Origins
The Bashkir group was formed by
The migration to the valley of the Southern Urals took place between the end of the 9th century and the beginning of the 10th century, in parallel to the Kipchak migration to the north.
Middle Ages
This article needs additional citations for verification. (January 2022) |
The first report about Bashkirs may have been in the Chinese chronicle Book of Sui (636 AD). Around 40 Turkic Tiele tribes were named in the section "A Narration about the Tiele people"; Bashkirs might have been included within that narration, if the tribal name 比干 (Mandarin Bǐgān ← Middle Chinese ZS: *piɪX-kɑn) (in Book of Wei) were a scribal error for 比千 (Bĭqiān ← *piɪXt͡sʰen) (in History of the Northern Dynasties), the latter reading being favored by Chinese scholar Rui Chuanming.[27]
In the 7th century, Bashkirs were also mentioned in the Armenian
However, these mentions may refer to the precursors of the
In the 9th century, during the migration of the Bashkirs to the Volga-Ural region, the first
In the 10th century, the Persian historian and polymath
The earliest source to give a geographical description of Bashkir territory,
The first European sources to mention the Bashkirs were the works of
By 1226, Genghis Khan had incorporated the lands of Bashkortostan into his empire. During the 13th and 14th centuries, all of Bashkortostan was a component of the Golden Horde. The brother of Batu-Khan, Sheibani, received the Bashkir lands east of the Ural Mountains.
After the disintegration of the Mongol Empire, the Bashkirs were divided among the Nogai Horde, the Khanate of Kazan and the Khanate of Sibir, founded in the 15th century.
Early modern period
In the middle of the 16th century, Bashkirs were gradually conquered by the Tsardom of Russia.[28] Primary documents pertaining to the Bashkirs during this period have been lost, although some are mentioned in the shezhere (family trees) of the Bashkir.[citation needed]
During the Russian Imperial period, Russians and Tatars began to migrate to Bashkortostan which led to eventual demographic changes in the region. The recruitment of Bashkirs into the Russian army and having to pay steep taxes pressured many Bashkirs to adopt a more settled lifestyle and to slowly abandon their ancient nomadic pastoralist past.[28]
In the late 16th and early 19th centuries, Bashkirs occupied the territory from the river
Bashkir rebellions of the 17th–18th centuries
The Bashkirs participated in the
At the founding of
The southern side of Bashkiria was partitioned by the Orenburg Line of forts. The forts ran from
In 1774, the Bashkirs, under the leadership of Salavat Yulayev, supported Pugachev's Rebellion. In 1786, the Bashkirs achieved tax-free status; and in 1798 Russia formed an irregular Bashkir army from among them.
Napoleonic Wars
During the
Establishment of First Republic of Bashkortostan
After the
Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic
In March 1919, the Bashkir Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic was formed based on agreements of the Russian Government.
World War II
During World War II, Bashkir soldiers served in the Red Army to defend the Soviet Union and fought against the Germans during the German invasion of the Soviet Union.[32]
Second declaration of independence
On October 11, 1990, Declaration of State Sovereignty by the Supreme Council of the Republic was proclaimed. On March 31, 1992
Bashkir tribes
North-eastern group: Aile, Badrak, Bikatin, Bishul, Duvan, Kalmak, Katai, Kossy, Kuvakan, Kudey, Kumruk, Murzy, Salyut, Syzgy, Synryan, Syrzy, Tabyn, Tersyak, Upey.[citation needed]
Northwest group: Baylar, Balyksy, Bulyar, Gaina, Gere, Duvaney, Elan, Adyak, Adey, Irekte, Kanly, Karshin, Kirghiz, Taz, Tanyp, Uvanysh, Un, Uran, Jurmi.[citation needed]
South-eastern group: Burzyan, Kypsak, Tamyan, Tangaur, Usergan, Jurmaty.[citation needed]
Southwest group: Ming.[citation needed]
Genetics
Haplogroups
Maternal haplogroups
Mitochondrial (
Paternal haplogroups
Genetic studies on
In some specific regions and clans of ethnic Bashkir, the North Asian and Eastern Siberian haplogroup (N3) range from moderate to high frequencies (29 to 90%).[37]
Archaeogenetic analyses show a similarity between historical Hungarians, whose homeland is around the Ural Mountains, and Bashkirs; analysis of haplogroup N3a4-Z1936 which is still found in very rare frequencies in modern Hungarians, and showed that Hungarian "sub-clade [N-B539/Y13850] splits from its sister-branch N3a4-B535, frequent today among Northeast European Uralic speakers, 4000–5000 ya, which is in the time-frame of the proposed divergence of Ugric languages", while on N-B539/Y13850+ sub-clade level confirmed shared paternal lineages with modern Ugric (Mansis and Khantys via N-B540/L1034) and Turkic speakers (Bashkirs and Volga Tatars via N-B540/L1034 and N-B545/Y24365); these suggest that the Bashkirs are mixture of Turkic, Ugric and Indo-European contributions.[38]
A genetic study published in Scientific Reports in November 2019 examined the remains of 29 Hungarian conquerors of the Carpathian Basin. The majority of them (60%) carried Y-DNA of West Eurasian origin, but at least 40% of East Eurasian (N1a-M2004, N1a-Z1936, Q1a and R1a-Z2124). They carried a higher amount of West Eurasian paternal ancestry than West Eurasian maternal ancestry. Among modern populations, their paternal ancestry was the most similar to modern Bashkirs. Haplogroup I2a1a2b was observed among several conquerors of particularly high rank. This haplogroup is of European origin and is today particularly common among South Slavs. A wide variety of phenotypes were observed, with several individuals having blond hair and blue eyes, but also East Asian traits. The study also analyzed three Hunnic samples from the Carpathian Basin in the 5th century, and these displayed genetic similarities to the conquerors. The Hungarian conquerors appeared to be a recently assembled heterogenous group incorporating both European, Asian and Eurasian elements.[39][40] A group of Bashkirs from the Burzyansky and Abzelilovsky districts of the Republic of Bashkortostan in the Volga-Ural region who belong to the R1a subclade R1a-SUR51 are the closest kin to the Hungarian Árpád dynasty, from which they got separated 2000 years ago.[41][42]
Autosomal DNA
According to Suslova, et al. (2012) the Bashkir population shared immune genes with both West and Eastern Eurasian populations.[43]
A genetic study by Yunusbayev et al. 2015 found that the Bashkirs display a significant amount of
A full genome study by Triska et al. 2017 found that the Bashkir genepool is best described as a multi-layered amalgamation of Turkic, Uralic, and Indo-European contributions. They further argue that "this disparity between cultural and genetic affinities of Tatar and Bashkir can be attributed to a phenomenon of cultural dominance: the population ancestral to Bashkir adopted the Turkic language during Turkic expansion from the east (language replacement event)".[47]
A genetic analysis on genetic data of Hun, Avar and Magyar conqueror samples by Maroti et al. 2022, revealed high genetic affinity between Magyar conquerors and modern day Bashkirs. They can be modeled as ~50% Mansi-like, ~35% Sarmatian-like, and ~15% Hun/Xiongnu-like. The admixture event is suggested to have taken place in the Southern Ural region at 643–431 BC.[48]
Language
The
The first appearance of a "Bashkir" language is dated back to the 9th century AD, in the form of stone inscription using a Runic alphabet, most likely, this alphabet derives from the Yenisei variant of the old Turkic runic script. This archaic version of a Bashkir language would be more or less a dialect of the proto-Kipchak language, however, since then, the Bashkir language has been through a series of vowel and consonant shifts, which are a result of a common literary history shared with the Idel Tatar language since the formation of the Cuman-Kipchak confederation, when the Oghuric Volga Bulgars started to receive Kipchak Turkic influence and became the Idel Tatars, most likely between the 10th and 11th centuries.
The Nogai and Karachay-Balkar languages are most likely the closest-sounding extant languages to the extinct Proto-Kipchak Bashkir language.
From an arc of time of roughly 900 years, the Bashkir language and Idel Tatar language, previously being completely different languages, "melded" into a series of dialects of a common
For example, the dialects spoken by Bashkirs, tend to have an accent which mostly resembles other Kipchak languages, like Kyrgyz, Kazakh, Nogai, Karakalpak, and many other languages of the Kipchak sub-group, while the dialects spoken by Idel Tatars, have accents more resembling the original Oghuric Volga-Bulgar language spoken before the Cuman invasion.
At the beginning of the 20th century, most notably during the
The Cyrillic alphabet is the official alphabet used to write Bashkir.
Demographics
The ethnic Bashkir population is estimated at 2 million people (2009
Culture
The Bashkirs traditionally practiced agriculture, cattle-rearing and bee-keeping. The half-nomadic Bashkirs travelled through either the mountains or the steppes, herding cattle. Wild-hive beekeeping is another attested tradition, which is practiced in the same
Traditional Bashkir dish
Epic poems and mythology
The Bashkirs have a rich folklore referencing the genesis and early history of the people. Through the works of their oral folk art, the views of ancient Bashkirs on nature, their wisdom, psychology, and moral ideals are preserved. The genre composition of the Bashkir oral tradition is diverse: epic and fairy tales, legends and traditions, riddles, songs (ritual, epic or lyrical), etc.
The Bashkir poems, like the epic creations of other peoples, find origin in the ancient Turkic mythology, in fact the Bashkir epic tale culture can be considered a more developed and expanded version of old Turkic epic culture. Majority of the poems of Bashkir mythology have been written down and published as books at the beginning of the 20th century, these poems compose a great part of the literature of the Bashkir people and are important examples of further-developed Turkic culture.
Some of these poems became important on a continental level, for example the epic poem the "Ural Batyr", which tells the tale of the legendary hero Ural, is the origin of the name of the Ural mountains. Other poems constitute a great part of the Bashkir national identity, other tales apart from the Ural Batyr include "Aqbuzat", "Qara yurga", "Aqhaq qola", "Kongur buga", and "Uzaq Tuzaq".
The Ural-Batyr and its impact
The poem
People live on the earth, the best of whom pledge honor and respect to the existence of nature. The third world is the underground world, where the Devas (also singular Deva or Div) live, incarnated as a snake, the incarnation of the dark forces, who live underground. Through the actions and divisions of the world related in the Ural Batyr, the Bashkirs express a manichaean view of good and evil. The legendary hero Ural, possessing titanic power, overcoming incredible difficulties, destroys the deva, and obtains "living water" (the idea of water in nature, in the pre-Islamic Bashkir pantheon of the Turkic mythology, is considered a spirit of life).
Ural thus obtains the "living water" in order to defeat death in the name of the eternal existence of man and nature. Ural does not drink the "living water" to live eternally. Instead, he decides to sparkle it around himself, to die and donate eternity to the world, the withered earth turning green. Ural dies and from his body emerge the Ural Mountains; the name of the Ural mountain range comes from this poem.
Music
The Bashkirs have a style of overtone singing called özläü (sometimes spelled uzlyau;
Mentality
The Bashkirs give rise to the following essential characteristics of the Bashkir mentality: philosophical, poetic thinking, hospitality and courage, serenity, simplicity, modesty, tolerance, pride, a keen sense of justice and competitiveness. The fundamental value of the Bashkir mentality is humanism, it is this idea that runs through the entire axis of the culture of the people.[citation needed]
Religion
In the pre-Islamic period the Bashkirs practised animism and shamanism, and incorporated the cosmogony of Tengrism.[49][50]
Bashkirs began converting to Islam in the 10th century.
Religious revival among the Bashkirs began in the early 1990s.[53] According to Talgat Tadzhuddin there were more than 1,000 mosques in Bashkortostan in 2010.[54]
The Bashkirs are predominantly
Notable Bashkirs
- See List of Bashkirs
See also
- Bashkir horse
- Karayakupovo culture
- Bashkir mentality
- National Liberation Struggle of the Bashkir People
Notes
- ^ These sources may have confused Bashkirs with Hungarians, since the area of Modern Bashkortostan is often referred as "Magna Hungaria", the zone where the Magyar tribes dwelled before their migration to Europe; it is believed that Bashkirs may have come into contact with these Magyar tribes, since some of the Northern Tribes of the modern Bashkirs do have genetic correspondence with Hungarians
References
- ^ Lewis, M. Paul (ed.) (2009). "Ethnologue: Languages of the World, Sixteenth edition". Ethnologue. Dallas, Tex.: SIL International.
{{cite news}}
:|author=
has generic name (help) - ^ "ВПН-2010". Perepis-2010.ru. Archived from the original on 2013-12-04. Retrieved 2015-03-16.
- ^ "PeopleGroups.org - Bashkir of Kazakhstan". peoplegroups.org.
- ^ "PeopleGroups.org - Bashkir of Uzbekistan". peoplegroups.org.
- ^ Population by national and/or ethnic group, sex and urban/rural residence: each census, 1985—2003
- ^ "Итоги всеобщей переписи населения Туркменистана по национальному составу в 1995 году". Archived from the original on 2013-03-13. Retrieved 2013-03-11.
- ^ "Демоскоп Weekly - Приложение. Справочник статистических показателей". www.demoscope.ru.
- ^ "Population by ethnicity at the beginning of year – Time period and Ethnicity | National Statistical System of Latvia". data.stat.gov.lv.
- ^ Latvijas iedzīvotāju sadalījums pēc nacionālā sastāva un valstiskās piederības, 01.01.2023. - PMLP
- ^ "Vali tabel". andmed.stat.ee.
- ^ [Национальный статистический комитет Кыргызской Республики. Численность постоянного населения по национальностям по переписи 2009 года]
- ^ "Демоскоп Weekly - Приложение. Справочник статистических показателей". www.demoscope.ru.
- ^ "Демоскоп Weekly - Приложение. Справочник статистических показателей". www.demoscope.ru.
- ^ "Демоскоп Weekly – Приложение. Справочник статистических показателей".
- ^ "8. НАСЕЛЕНИЕ НАИБОЛЕЕ МНОГОЧИСЛЕННЫХ" (PDF). Gks.ru. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2019-07-13. Retrieved 2015-03-16.
- ^ Бижанова М. Р. (2006). "Башкиро-казахские отношения в XVIII веке". Вестник Башкирского Университета (журнал). 11 (4) (Вестник Башкирского университета ed.): 146–147.
- ^ Кузеев Р.Г. Происхождение башкирского народа. Этнический состав, история расселения. Издательство "Наука", Москва, 1974 г.
- ^ Трепавлов В. В. Ногаи в Башкирии, XV—XVII вв. Княжеские роды ногайского происхождения. Уфа: Урал. науч. центр РАН, 1997. 72 с. (Материалы и исследования по истории и этнологии Башкортостана. № 2)
- ^ Салихов А.Г. О башкирско-крымско-татарских культурных связях. Издательство "ГУП РБ Издательский Дом «Республика Башкортостан»", Уфа, 2017
- ^ Nature.com [1] Y-chromosomal connection between Hungarians and geographically distant populations of the Ural Mountain region and West Siberia, 2019.
- ^ "УРАЛ-ВОЛГА БУЙЫ ТӨРКИ ТЕЛЕ". bashenc.online. Retrieved 2024-04-10.
- ^ "О названии башкирцев" (in Russian). Оренбургские губернские ведомости. 1847: 297.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) - ^ D. M. Dunlop (1967). The History of the Jewish khazars. New Jersey. p. 34.
{{cite book}}
: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - TDV Encyclopedia of Islam (44+2 vols.) (in Turkish). Istanbul: Turkiye Diyanet Foundation, Centre for Islamic Studies. 1988–2016.
- ^ Peter B. Golden, Haggai Ben-Shammai & András Róna-Tas, The World of the Khazars: New Perspectives, Leiden/Boston, Brill, 2007, pp. 422.
- ISBN 978-963-9116-48-1.
- ^ Cheng, Fangyi. "The Research on the Identification Between Tiele and the Oghuric Tribes": 83–84.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) - ^ ISBN 1-57958-468-3.
- ^ Lozynskyj, Askold S. "Opinion: Lessons from History: Russia's Repression of the Bashkirs". Get the Latest Ukraine News Today - KyivPost.
- ^ Акманов И. Г. Башкирские восстания XVII–XVIII вв. Феномен в истории народов Евразии. – Уфа: Китап, 2016
- ^ a b Vershinin, Alexander; RIR, specially for (2014-07-29). "How Russia's steppe warriors took on Napoleon's armies". www.rbth.com. Retrieved 2020-01-14.
- PMID 3287647.
- ^ www.khazaria.com Genetics – DNA of Russia's Turkic people of Bashkortostan http://www.khazaria.com/genetics/bashkirs.html Genetics – DNA of Russia's Turkic people of Bashkortostan. Retrieved 2019-04-24.
{{cite web}}
: Check|url=
value (help); Missing or empty|title=
(help) - ISSN 1608-3369.
- PMID 21917723.
- ^ a b "Лобов А. С. Структура генофонда субпопуляций башкир. Диссертация кандидата биологических наук. — Уфа, 2009.- 131 с." (PDF) (in Russian). Archived from the original (PDF) on August 16, 2011.
- ^ http://ftp.anrb.ru/molgen/Lobov_AS.PDF
- PMID 31127140.
- PMID 31719606.
- ISSN 1866-9565.
- PMID 32636469
- ^ "R-SUR51 Y-DNA Haplogroup". YFull.
- S2CID 20804610.
- PMID 25898006.
- PMID 25898006. "For example, the present-day Tatars, Bashkirs, Kazakhs, Uzbeks, and Kyrgyz span from the Volga basin to the Tien-Shan Mountains in Central Asia, yet (Fig 5) showed evidence of recent admixture ranging from the 13th to the 14th centuries. These peoples speak Turkic languages of the Kipchak-Karluk branch and their admixture ages postdate the presumed migrations of the ancestral Kipchak Turks from the Irtysh and Ob regions in the 11th century [37]."
- ISSN 2513-843X.
- PMID 29297395.
- S2CID 246191357.
- ^ Shireen Hunter, Jeffrey L. Thomas, Alexander Melikishvili, "Islam in Russia: The Politics of Identity and Security", M.E. Sharpe Inc.
- ^ К вопросу о тенгрианстве башкир // Compatriot, Popular Science Magazine (in Russian)
- ^ Shirin Akiner, "Islamic Peoples Of The Soviet Union", Second edition, 1986
- ^ Allen J. Frank, "Islamic Historiography and "Bulghar" Identity Among the Tatars and Bashkirs", Brill, 1998
- ^ Jeffrey E. Cole, "Ethnic Groups of Europe: An Encyclopedia", Greenwood publishing group
- ^ Интерфакс. Говорить о притеснении ислама в России кощунственно, считает Талгат Таджуддин // Interfax, 17 December 2010
- ^ "Bashkortostan and Bashkirs", Encyclopedia.com
Further reading
- Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). . Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 3 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. p. 466.
- Rudenko, S. I. (2006). Башкиры: историко-этнографические очерки [The Bashkirs: historical and ethnographic essays] (in Russian). Ufa: Kitap. ISBN 5-295-03899-8.
- Kuzeev, R. G. (2010). Происхождение башкирского народа. Этнический состав, история расселения [The origin of the Bashkir people. Ethnic composition, history of settlement] (in Russian). Ufa: DizainPoligrafServis. ISBN 978-5-94423-212-0.
- Bermisheva, M. A.; Ivanov, V. A.; Kinyabaeva, G. A.; et al. (2011). Антропология башкир [Anthropology of the Bashkirs] (in Russian). Saint-Petersburg: Aleteya. ISBN 978-5-91419-386-4.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2009). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. I [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. I] (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. ISBN 978-5-02-037010-4. Archived from the originalon 2017-03-06. Retrieved 2016-10-02.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2012). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. II [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. II] (in Russian). Ufa: Gilem. ISBN 978-5-91608-100-8. Archived from the originalon 2017-03-21. Retrieved 2016-10-02.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2011). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. III [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. III] (in Russian). Ufa: Gilem. ISBN 978-5-7501-1301-9.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2011). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. IV [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. IV] (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. ISBN 978-5-02-038276-3.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2009). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. V [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. V] (in Russian). Ufa: Gilem. ISBN 978-5-7501-1199-2. Archived from the originalon 2016-03-05. Retrieved 2016-10-02.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2009). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. VI [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. VI] (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. ISBN 978-5-02-036494-3. Archived from the originalon 2017-01-15. Retrieved 2016-10-02.
- Kulsharipov, M. M., ed. (2012). История башкирского народа: в 7 т. Т. VII [History of the Bashkir people: 7 vol. Vol. VII] (in Russian). Ufa: Gilem. ISBN 978-5-4466-0040-3. Archived from the originalon 2014-10-06. Retrieved 2016-10-02.
- Asfandiyarov, A. Z., ed. (2013). Военная история башкир: энциклопедия [Military history of Bashkirs: Encyclopedia] (in Russian). Ufa: Bashkir encyclopedia. ISBN 978-5-8818-5076-0.
- Kuzeev, R. G.; Danilko, E. S., eds. (2015). Башкиры [The Bashkirs] (in Russian). Moscow: Nauka. ISBN 978-5-02-039182-6.
- Ilgamov, M.A., ed. (2015–2016). Башкирская энциклопедия: в 7 томах [Bashkir encyclopedia: 7 vol.] (in Russian). Ufa: Bashkir encyclopedia. ISBN 978-5-88185-306-8. Archived from the originalon 2020-01-22. Retrieved 2017-02-19.
- Karagöz, Erkan (2021). İdil-Ural (Tatar ve Başkurt) sihirli masalları üzerine karşılaştırmalı motif çalışması: Aktarma – motif tespiti (motif - İndex of Folk-Literature’a göre) – motif dizini (in Turkish). Vol. 1. Ankara: Atatürk Kültür Merkezi Başkanlığı. pp. 587–950 (Bashkir tales). ISBN 978-975-17-4742-6.