Therapeutic index
The therapeutic index (TI; also referred to as therapeutic ratio) is a quantitative measurement of the relative safety of a drug. It is a comparison of the amount of a therapeutic agent that causes toxicity to the amount that causes the therapeutic effect.[1] The related terms therapeutic window or safety window refer to a range of doses optimized between efficacy and toxicity, achieving the greatest therapeutic benefit without resulting in unacceptable side-effects or toxicity.
Classically, for clinical indications of an approved drug, TI refers to the ratio of the dose of the drug that causes adverse effects at an incidence/severity not compatible with the targeted indication (e.g. toxic dose in 50% of subjects, TD50) to the dose that leads to the desired pharmacological effect (e.g. efficacious dose in 50% of subjects, ED50). In contrast, in a drug development setting TI is calculated based on plasma exposure levels.[2]
In the early days of pharmaceutical toxicology, TI was frequently determined in animals as lethal dose of a drug for 50% of the population (
For many drugs, severe toxicities in humans occur at sublethal doses, which limit their maximum dose. A higher safety-based therapeutic index is preferable instead of a lower one; an individual would have to take a much higher dose of a drug to reach the lethal threshold than the dose taken to induce the therapeutic effect of the drug. However, a lower efficacy-based therapeutic index is preferable instead of a higher one; an individual would have to take a higher dose of a drug to reach the toxic threshold than the dose taken to induce the therapeutic effect of the drug.
Generally, a drug or other therapeutic agent with a narrow therapeutic range (i.e. having little difference between toxic and therapeutic doses) may have its dosage adjusted according to measurements of its blood levels in the person taking it. This may be achieved through therapeutic drug monitoring (TDM) protocols. TDM is recommended for use in the treatment of psychiatric disorders with lithium due to its narrow therapeutic range.[3]
Term | Full form | Definition |
---|---|---|
ED | Effective Dose | the dose or concentration of a drug that produces a biological response.[4][5] |
TD | Toxic Dose | the dose at which toxicity occurs in 50% of cases. |
LD | Lethal Dose | the dose at which toxicity occurs in 50% of cases.[6]: 73 |
TI | Therapeutic Index | a quantitative measurement of the relative safety of a drug by comparison of the amount of a therapeutic agent that causes toxicity to the amount that causes the therapeutic effect[7] |
Types
Based on
- Safety-based therapeutic index
LD50 is ensured to be as high as possible to decrease risk of lethal effects (often leading to death), and for larger therapeutic window. In the above formula, LD50 is taken in the numerator and ED50 is taken in the denominator because the higher the LD50 and the lower the ED50, the higher the , the higher the difference between ED50 and LD50. Hence, a higher safety-based therapeutic index indicates a larger therapeutic window.
- Efficacy-based therapeutic index
ED50 is ensured to be as low as possible for faster drug response and larger therapeutic window, whereas TD50 is ensured to be as high as possible to decrease risk of toxic effects of drugs. In the above formula, ED50 is taken in the numerator and TD50 is taken in the denominator because the lower the ED50 and the higher the TD50, the lower the , the higher the difference between ED50 and TD50. Hence, a lower efficacy-based therapeutic index indicates a larger therapeutic window.
- Protective index
Similar to safety-based therapeutic index, the protective index uses TD50 (median toxic dose) in place of LD50.
For many substances, toxicity can occur at levels far below lethal effects (that cause death), and thus, if toxicity is properly specified, the protective index is often more informative about a substance's relative safety. Nevertheless, the safety-based therapeutic index () is still useful as it can be considered an
Since the protective index (PI) is calculated as TD50 divided by ED50, it can be mathematically expressed that:
which means that is a reciprocal of protective index.
All the above types of therapeutic index can be used in both
Drug development
A high safety-based therapeutic index () is preferable for a drug to have a favorable safety profile. At the early discovery/development stage, the clinical TI of a drug candidate is unknown. However, understanding the preliminary TI of a drug candidate is of utmost importance as early as possible since TI is an important indicator of the probability of successful development. Recognizing drug candidates with potentially suboptimal TI at the earliest possible stage helps to initiate mitigation or potentially re-deploy resources.
TI is the quantitative relationship between pharmacological efficacy and toxicological safety of a drug, without considering the nature of pharmacological or toxicological endpoints themselves. However, to convert a calculated TI into something useful, the nature and limitations of pharmacological and/or toxicological endpoints must be considered. Depending on the intended clinical indication, the associated unmet medical need and/or the competitive situation, more or less weight can be given to either the safety or efficacy of a drug candidate in order to create a well balanced indication-specific safety vs efficacy profile.
In general, it is the exposure of a given tissue to drug (i.e. drug concentration over time), rather than dose, that drives the pharmacological and toxicological effects. For example, at the same dose there may be marked inter-individual variability in exposure due to polymorphisms in metabolism, DDIs or differences in body weight or environmental factors. These considerations emphasize the importance of using exposure instead of dose to calculate TI. To account for delays between exposure and toxicity, the TI for toxicities that occur after multiple dose administrations should be calculated using the exposure to drug at steady state rather than after administration of a single dose.
A review published by Muller and Milton in Nature Reviews Drug Discovery critically discusses TI determination and interpretation in a translational drug development setting for both small molecules and biotherapeutics.[2]
Range of therapeutic indices
The therapeutic index varies widely among substances, even within a related group.
For instance, the
Less safe are
Even less safe are drugs such as digoxin, a cardiac glycoside; its therapeutic index is approximately 2:1.[11]
Other examples of drugs with a narrow therapeutic range, which may require drug monitoring both to achieve therapeutic levels and to minimize toxicity, include dimercaprol, theophylline, warfarin and lithium carbonate.
Some antibiotics and antifungals require monitoring to balance efficacy with minimizing adverse effects, including: gentamicin, vancomycin, amphotericin B (nicknamed 'amphoterrible' for this very reason), and polymyxin B.
Cancer radiotherapy
Radiotherapy aims to shrink tumors and kill cancer cells using high energy. The energy arises from
Cancer cells cause an imbalance of signals in the
The effective therapeutic index can be affected by
Safety ratio
Sometimes the term safety ratio is used, particularly when referring to
The Certain Safety Factor, also referred to as the Margin of Safety (MOS), is the ratio of the lethal dose to 1% of population to the effective dose to 99% of the population (LD1/ED99).[16] This is a better safety index than the LD50 for materials that have both desirable and undesirable effects, because it factors in the ends of the spectrum where doses may be necessary to produce a response in one person but can, at the same dose, be lethal in another.
Synergistic effect
A therapeutic index does not consider drug interactions or synergistic effects. For example, the risk associated with benzodiazepines increases significantly when taken with alcohol, opiates, or stimulants when compared with being taken alone.[medical citation needed] Therapeutic index also does not take into account the ease or difficulty of reaching a toxic or lethal dose. This is more of a consideration for recreational drug users, as the purity can be highly variable.
Therapeutic window
The therapeutic window (or pharmaceutical window) of a drug is the range of drug dosages which can treat disease effectively without having toxic effects.[17] Medication with a small therapeutic window must be administered with care and control, frequently measuring blood concentration of the drug, to avoid harm. Medications with narrow therapeutic windows include theophylline, digoxin, lithium, and warfarin.
Optimal biological dose
Optimal biological dose (OBD) is the quantity of a drug that will most effectively produce the desired effect while remaining in the range of acceptable toxicity.
Maximum tolerated dose
The maximum tolerated dose (MTD) refers to the highest dose of a radiological or
MTD is an essential aspect of a drug's profile. All modern healthcare systems dictate a maximum safe dose for each drug, and generally have numerous safeguards (e.g. insurance quantity limits and government-enforced maximum quantity/time-frame limits) to prevent the prescription and dispensing of quantities exceeding the highest dosage which has been demonstrated to be safe for members of the general patient population.
Patients are often unable to tolerate the theoretical MTD of a drug due to the occurrence of side-effects which are not innately a manifestation of toxicity (not considered to severely threaten a patient's health) but cause the patient sufficient distress and/or discomfort to result in non-compliance with treatment. Such examples include emotional "blunting" with antidepressants,
See also
- Drug titration – process of finding the correct dose of a drug
- Effective dose
- EC50
- IC50
- LD50
- Hormesis
References
- ISBN 978-0-07-178924-0.
The therapeutic index is the ratio of the TD50 (or LD50) to the ED50, determined from quantal dose–response curves.
- ^ S2CID 29777090.
- PMID 17205880.
- PMID 7569511.
- ^ Street, Farnam (2014-02-13). "The Minimum Effective Dose: Why Less is More". Farnam Street. Retrieved 2023-05-23.
- ISBN 9780071624428.
- ISBN 978-0-07-178924-0.
The therapeutic index is the ratio of the TD50 (or LD50) to the ED50, determined from quantal dose–response curves.
- PMID 16389318.
- ^ PMID 15139867.
- PMID 17227290. Vol. 12, No. 3–4, pp. 250–275
- PMID 17352523.
- ^ PMID 20832013.
- .
- ^ "Ataxia Telangiectasia". National Cancer Institute. Retrieved 2016-04-11.
- .
- ^ "FAQs: Dr. Damaj". Retrieved 4 October 2015.
- ISBN 978-0-7020-5362-7.
- ^ "maximum tolerated dose". Dictionary of Cancer Terms. National Cancer Institute. Retrieved 26 July 2010.
- ^ This article incorporates public domain material from Jasper Womach. Report for Congress: Agriculture: A Glossary of Terms, Programs, and Laws, 2005 Edition (PDF). Congressional Research Service.