Church of the East

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Church of the East
ܥܕܬܐ ܕܡܕܢܚܐ
Seleucia-Ctesiphon (410–775)[3]
Baghdad (775–1317)[4]
FounderJesus Christ by sacred tradition
Thomas the Apostle
OriginApostolic Age, by its tradition
Edessa,[5][6]
Mesopotamia[1][note 1]
Branched fromNicene Christianity
SeparationsIts schism of 1552 divided it originally into two patriarchates, and later four, but by 1830 it returned to two, one of which is now the Chaldean Catholic Church, while the other sect split further in 1968 into the Assyrian Church of the East and the Ancient Church of the East.
Other name(s)Nestorian Church, Persian Church, East Syrian Church, Assyrian Church, Babylonian Church[11]

The Church of the East (

Chalcedonian Church (whose Eastern branch would later become the Eastern Orthodox Church
).

Having its origins in the pre-Sasanian Mesopotamia, the Church of the East developed its own unique form of Christian theology and liturgy. During the early modern period, a series of schisms gave rise to rival patriarchates, sometimes two, sometimes three.[16] In the latter half of the 20th century the traditionalist patriarchate of the church underwent a split into two rival patriarchates, namely the Assyrian Church of the East and the Ancient Church of the East, which continue to follow the traditional theology and liturgy of the mother church. The Chaldean Catholic Church based in Iraq and the Syro-Malabar Church in India are two Eastern Catholic churches which also claim the heritage of the Church of the East.[2]

The Church of the East organized itself initially in the year 410 as the

Divine Liturgy of Saints Addai and Mari
.

The Church of the East, which was part of the Great Church, shared communion with those in the Roman Empire until the Council of Ephesus condemned Nestorius in 431.[1] Supporters of Nestorius took refuge in Sasanian Persia, where the Church refused to condemn Nestorius and became accused of Nestorianism, a heresy attributed to Nestorius. It was therefore called the Nestorian Church by all the other Eastern churches, both Chalcedonian and non-Chalcedonian, and by the Western Church. Politically the Sasanian and Roman empires were at war with each other, which forced the Church of the East to distance itself from the churches within Roman territory.[18][19][20]

More recently, the "Nestorian" appellation has been called "a lamentable misnomer",[21][22] and theologically incorrect by scholars.[15] However, the Church of the East started to call itself Nestorian, it anathematized the Council of Ephesus, and in its liturgy Nestorius was mentioned as a saint.[23][24] In 544, the general Council of the Church of the East approved the Council of Chalcedon at the Synod of Mar Aba I.[25][5]

Continuing as a dhimmi community under the Sunni Caliphate after the Muslim conquest of Persia (633–654), the Church of the East played a major role in the history of Christianity in Asia. Between the 9th and 14th centuries, it represented the world's largest Christian denomination in terms of geographical extent, and in the Middle Ages was one of the three major Christian powerhouses of Eurasia alongside Catholicism and Greek Orthodoxy.[26] It established dioceses and communities stretching from the Mediterranean Sea and today's Iraq and Iran, to India (the Saint Thomas Syrian Christians of Kerala), the Mongol kingdoms and Turkic tribes in Central Asia, and China during the Tang dynasty (7th–9th centuries). In the 13th and 14th centuries, the church experienced a final period of expansion under the Mongol Empire, where influential Church of the East clergy sat in the Mongol court.

Even before the Church of the East underwent a rapid decline in its field of expansion in

Saint Thomas Syrian Christians in the Malabar Coast (modern-day Kerala
, India).

The Church faced a major

Shimun VII, leading to the formation of the Chaldean Catholic Church (an Eastern Catholic church in communion with the pope). Divisions occurred within the two factions (the traditionalist and the newly formed Eastern Catholic) but by 1830 two unified patriarchates and distinct churches remained: the traditionalist Assyrian Church of the East and the Eastern Catholic Chaldean Church. The Ancient Church of the East split from the traditionalist patriarchate of the Church of the East in 1968. In 2017, the Chaldean Catholic Church had approximately 628,405 members[28] and the Assyrian Church of the East had 323,300 to 380,000,[29][30]
while the Ancient Church of the East had 100,000.

Background

The Church of the East's declaration in 424 of the independence of its head, the

Jerusalem), all of which were for it "Western Christianity".[31]

Theologically, the Church of the East adopted the dyophysite doctrine of Theodore of Mopsuestia[32] that emphasised the "distinctiveness" of the divine and the human natures of Jesus; this doctrine was misleadingly labelled as 'Nestorian' by its theological opponents.[32]

In the 6th century and thereafter, the Church of the East expanded greatly, establishing communities in India (the Saint Thomas Syrian Christians), among the Mongols in Central Asia, and in China, which became home to a thriving community under the Tang dynasty from the 7th to the 9th century. At its height, between the 9th and 14th centuries, the Church of the East was the world's largest Christian church in geographical extent, with dioceses stretching from its heartland in Upper Mesopotamia to the Mediterranean Sea and as far afield as China, Mongolia, Central Asia, Anatolia, the Arabian Peninsula and India.

From its peak of geographical extent, the church entered a period of rapid decline that began in the 14th century, due largely to outside influences. The Chinese Ming dynasty overthrew the Mongols (1368) and ejected Christians and other foreign influences from China, and many Mongols in Central Asia converted to Islam. The Muslim Turco-Mongol leader Timur (1336–1405) nearly eradicated the remaining Christians in the Middle East. Nestorian Christianity remained largely confined to communities in Upper Mesopotamia and the Saint Thomas Syrian Christians of the Malabar Coast in the Indian subcontinent.

In the early modern period, the schism of 1552 led to a series of internal divisions and ultimately to its branching into three separate churches: the Chaldean Catholic Church, in full communion with the Holy See, the independent Assyrian Church of the East and the Ancient Church of the East.[33]

Description as Nestorian

Christological spectrum during the 5th–7th centuries showing the views of The Church of the East (light blue)

Patriarch of Constantinople from 428 to 431, whose doctrine represented the culmination of a philosophical current developed by scholars at the School of Antioch, most notably Nestorius's mentor Theodore of Mopsuestia, and stirred controversy when Nestorius publicly challenged the use of the title Theotokos (literally, "Bearer of God") for Mary, mother of Jesus,[34] suggesting that the title denied Christ's full humanity. He argued that Jesus had two loosely joined natures, the divine Logos and the human Jesus, and proposed Christotokos (literally, "Bearer of the Christ") as a more suitable alternative title. His statements drew criticism from other prominent churchmen, particularly from Cyril, Patriarch of Alexandria, who had a leading part in the Council of Ephesus of 431, which condemned Nestorius for heresy and deposed him as Patriarch.[35]

After 431, the state authorities in the Roman Empire suppressed Nestorianism, a reason for Christians under Persian rule to favour it and so allay suspicion that their loyalty lay with the hostile Christian-ruled empire.[36][37]

It was in the aftermath of the slightly later Council of Chalcedon (451), that the Church of the East formulated a distinctive theology. The first such formulation was adopted at the Synod of Beth Lapat in 484. This was developed further in the early seventh century, when in an at first successful war against the Byzantine Empire the Sasanid Persian Empire incorporated broad territories populated by West Syrians, many of whom were supporters of the Miaphysite theology of Oriental Orthodoxy which its opponents term "Monophysitism" (Eutychianism), the theological view most opposed to Nestorianism. They received support from Khosrow II, influenced by his wife Shirin. Shirin was a member of the Church of East, but later joined the miaphysite church of Antioch.[citation needed]

Drawing inspiration from

Chalcedonian churches.[43][44][45]

The justice of imputing Nestorianism to Nestorius, whom the Church of the East venerated as a saint, is disputed.[46][21][47] David Wilmshurst states that for centuries "the word 'Nestorian' was used both as a term of abuse by those who disapproved of the traditional East Syrian theology, as a term of pride by many of its defenders [...] and as a neutral and convenient descriptive term by others. Nowadays it is generally felt that the term carries a stigma".[48] Sebastian P. Brock says: "The association between the Church of the East and Nestorius is of a very tenuous nature, and to continue to call that church 'Nestorian' is, from a historical point of view, totally misleading and incorrect – quite apart from being highly offensive and a breach of ecumenical good manners".[49]

Apart from its religious meaning, the word "Nestorian" has also been used in an ethnic sense, as shown by the phrase "Catholic Nestorians".[50][51][52][53]

In his 1996 article, "The 'Nestorian' Church: a lamentable misnomer", published in the Bulletin of the John Rylands Library, Sebastian Brock, a Fellow of the British Academy, lamented the fact that "the term 'Nestorian Church' has become the standard designation for the ancient oriental church which in the past called itself 'The Church of the East', but which today prefers a fuller title 'The Assyrian Church of the East'. Such a designation is not only discourteous to modern members of this venerable church, but also − as this paper aims to show − both inappropriate and misleading".[54]

Organisation and structure

At the

Persian capital Seleucia-Ctesiphon, who in the acts of the council was referred to as the Grand or Major Metropolitan, and who soon afterward was called the Catholicos of the East. Later, the title of Patriarch
was used.

The Church of the East had, like other churches, an

consecrate a patriarch.[55] The Patriarch also has the charge of the Province of the Patriarch
.

For most of its history the church had six or so Interior Provinces. In 410, these were listed in the hierarchical order of:

Karka de Beth Slokh (Kirkuk, northeastern Iraq). In addition it had an increasing number of Exterior Provinces further afield within the Sasanian Empire and soon also beyond the empire's borders. By the 10th century, the church had between 20[36] and 30 metropolitan provinces.[48] According to John Foster, in the 9th century there were 25 metropolitans[56] including those in China and India. The Chinese provinces were lost in the 11th century, and in the subsequent centuries other exterior provinces went into decline as well. However, in the 13th century, during the Mongol Empire, the church added two new metropolitan provinces in North China, one being Tangut, the other Katai and Ong.[48]

Scriptures

The

Syro-Malabar Catholic Church and the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
.

The

Hebrew and not from the Septuagint.[57]

The New Testament of the Peshitta, which originally excluded certain disputed books (Second Epistle of Peter, Second Epistle of John, Third Epistle of John, Epistle of Jude, Book of Revelation), had become the standard by the early 5th century.

Iconography

It was often said in the 19th century that the Church of the East was opposed to religious images of any kind. The cult of the image was never as strong in the

biblical prophets.[59] As such, the Church was forced to get rid of icons.[59][60]

There is both literary and archaeological evidence for the presence of images in the church. Writing in 1248 from

Sultaniya in Persia, writing about 1330 of the East Syrians in Khanbaliq says that they had 'very beautiful and orderly churches with crosses and images in honour of God and of the saints'.[58] Apart from the references, a painting of a Christian figure discovered by Aurel Stein at the Library Cave of the Mogao Caves in 1908 is probably a representation of Jesus Christ.[61]

An illustrated 13th-century Nestorian Peshitta Gospel book written in Estrangela from northern Mesopotamia or Tur Abdin, currently in the State Library of Berlin, proves that in the 13th century the Church of the East was not yet aniconic.[62] The Nestorian Evangelion preserved in the Bibliothèque nationale de France contains an illustration depicting Jesus Christ in the circle of a ringed cross surrounded by four angels.[63] Three Syriac manuscripts from early 19th century or earlier—they were published in a compilation titled The Book of Protection by Hermann Gollancz in 1912—contain some illustrations of no great artistic worth that show that use of images continued.

A life-size male stucco figure discovered in a late-6th-century church in Seleucia-Ctesiphon, beneath which were found the remains of an earlier church, also shows that the Church of the East used figurative representations.[62]

Early history

Although the Nestorian community traced their history to the 1st century AD, the Church of the East first achieved official state recognition from the Sasanian Empire in the 4th century with the accession of Yazdegerd I (reigned 399–420) to the throne of the Sasanian Empire. The policies of the Sasanian Empire, which encouraged syncretic forms of Christianity, greatly influenced the Church of the East.[65]

The early Church had branches that took inspiration from Neo-Platonism,[66][67] other Near Eastern religions[68][65] like Judaism,[69] and other forms of Christianity.[65]

In 410, the

Sasanian emperor.[70][71]

Under pressure from the Sasanian Emperor, the Church of the East sought to increasingly distance itself from the

Eastern Roman Empire). Therefore, in 424, the bishops of the Sasanian Empire met in council under the leadership of Catholicos Dadishoʿ (421–456) and determined that they would not, henceforth, refer disciplinary or theological problems to any external power, and especially not to any bishop or church council in the Roman Empire.[72]

Thus, the Mesopotamian churches did not send representatives to the various church councils attended by representatives of the "

The theological controversy that followed the Council of Ephesus in 431 proved a turning point in the Christian Church's history. The Council condemned as heretical the Christology of Nestorius, whose reluctance to accord the Virgin Mary the title Theotokos "God-bearer, Mother of God" was taken as evidence that he believed two separate persons (as opposed to two united natures) to be present within Christ.

The Sasanian Emperor, hostile to the Byzantines, saw the opportunity to ensure the loyalty of his Christian subjects and lent support to the

Babai
(497–503) confirmed the association of the Assyrian Church with Nestorianism.

Parthian and Sasanian periods

West Azerbaijan Province, Iran
.

Christians were already forming communities in

Mari and Thomas the Apostle. Leadership and structure remained disorganised until 315 when Papa bar Aggai (310–329), bishop of Seleucia-Ctesiphon, imposed the primacy of his see over the other Mesopotamian and Persian bishoprics which were grouped together under the Catholicate of Seleucia-Ctesiphon; Papa took the title of Catholicos, or universal leader.[76] This position received an additional title in 410, becoming Catholicos and Patriarch of the East.[77][78]

These early Christian communities in Mesopotamia, Elam, and Fars were reinforced in the 4th and 5th centuries by large-scale deportations of Christians from the eastern

Simeon bar Sabba'e (341),[81] Shahdost (342), and Barba'shmin (346).[82] Afterward, the office of Catholicos lay vacant nearly 20 years (346–363).[83] In 363, under the terms of a peace treaty, Nisibis was ceded to the Persians, causing Ephrem the Syrian, accompanied by a number of teachers, to leave the School of Nisibis for Edessa still in Roman territory.[84] The church grew considerably during the Sasanian period,[36] but the pressure of persecution led the Catholicos, Dadisho I, in 424 to convene the Council of Markabta of the Arabs and declare the Catholicate independent from "the western Fathers".[85]

Assyrian Mar Toma church near Urmia, Iran.

Meanwhile, in the Roman Empire, the

Mar Babai I (497–502) reiterated and expanded upon his predecessors' esteem for Theodore, solidifying the church's adoption of Dyophisitism.[36]

Geramon
.

Now firmly established in the Persian Empire, with centres in Nisibis,

Khosrau I; this ended in 545. The church survived these trials under the guidance of Patriarch Aba I, who had converted to Christianity from Zoroastrianism.[36]

By the end of the 5th century and the middle of the 6th, the area occupied by the Church of the East included "all the countries to the east and those immediately to the west of the Euphrates", including the Sasanian Empire, the

The Church of the East also flourished in the kingdom of the

Lakhmids until the Islamic conquest, particularly after the ruler al-Nu'man III ibn al-Mundhir
officially converted in c. 592.

Islamic rule

Ecclesiastical provinces of the Church of the East in 10th century
A 9th-century mural of a cleric of the Church of the East from the palace of al-Mukhtar in Samarra, Iraq.

After the Sasanian Empire was

archbishops, and over 20 bishops east of the Iranian border of the Oxus River.[91]

Patriarch

India.[92] By the 10th century the Church of the East had a number of dioceses stretching from across the Caliphate's territories to India and China.[36]

Nestorian Christians made substantial contributions to the Islamic

physicians of the Abbasid Caliphs were often Assyrian Christians such as the long serving Bukhtishu dynasty.[95][96]

Expansion

Church of the East at its largest extent during the Middle Ages.

After the split with the Western World and synthesis with Nestorianism, the Church of the East expanded rapidly due to missionary works during the medieval period.

Nestorian Stele, a Christian tablet written in Chinese found in China dating to 781 AD. Their most important conversion, however, was of the Saint Thomas Christians of the Malabar Coast in India, who alone escaped the destruction of the church by Timur at the end of the 14th century, and the majority of whom today constitute the largest group who now use the liturgy of the Church of the East, with around 4 million followers in their homeland, in spite of the 17th-century defection to the West Syriac Rite of the Syriac Orthodox Church.[98] The St Thomas Christians were believed by tradition to have been converted by St Thomas, and were in communion with the Church of the East until the end of the medieval period.[99]

India

The Christian "King of Colombo" (Kollam in India, flags: , identified as Christian due to the early Christian presence there)[100] in the contemporary Catalan Atlas of 1375.[101][102] The caption above the king of Kollam reads: Here rules the king of Colombo, a Christian.[103] The black flags () on the coast belong to the Delhi Sultanate.

The

Cranganore, or (perhaps nominally) in Mylapore, where the Shrine of Thomas was located.[105]

In the 12th century Indian Nestorianism engaged the Western imagination in the figure of

Syro-Malabar Catholic Church). The rest, which became known as the Malankara Church, soon entered into communion with the Syriac Orthodox Church. The Malankara Church also produced the Syro-Malankara Catholic Church
.

Sri Lanka

Nestorian Christianity is said to have thrived in Sri Lanka with the patronage of King Dathusena during the 5th century. There are mentions of involvement of Persian Christians with the Sri Lankan royal family during the Sigiriya Period. Over seventy-five ships carrying Murundi soldiers from Mangalore are said to have arrived in the Sri Lankan town of Chilaw most of whom were Christians. King Dathusena's daughter was married to his nephew Migara who is also said to have been a Nestorian Christian, and a commander of the Sinhalese army. Maga Brahmana, a Christian priest of Persian origin is said to have provided advice to King Dathusena on establishing his palace on the

The Anuradhapura Cross discovered in 1912 is also considered to be an indication of a strong Nestorian Christian presence in Sri Lanka between the 3rd and 10th century in the then capitol of Anuradhapura of Sri Lanka.[109][110][111][112]

China

Nestorian Stele
, created in 781, describes the introduction of Nestorian Christianity to China

Christianity reached China by 635, and its relics can still be seen in Chinese cities such as

Nestorian Stele, set up on 7 January 781 at the then-capital of Chang'an, attributes the introduction of Christianity to a mission under a Persian cleric named Alopen in 635, in the reign of Emperor Taizong of Tang during the Tang dynasty.[113][114] The inscription on the Nestorian Stele, whose dating formula mentions the patriarch Hnanishoʿ II (773–80), gives the names of several prominent Christians in China, including Metropolitan Adam, Bishop Yohannan, 'country-bishops' Yazdbuzid and Sargis and Archdeacons Gigoi of Khumdan (Chang'an) and Gabriel of Sarag (Loyang). The names of around seventy monks are also listed.[115]

Nestorian Christianity thrived in China for approximately 200 years, but then faced persecution from Emperor Wuzong of Tang (reigned 840–846). He suppressed all foreign religions, including Buddhism and Christianity, causing the church to decline sharply in China. A Syrian monk visiting China a few decades later described many churches in ruin. The church disappeared from China in the early 10th century, coinciding with the collapse of the Tang dynasty and the tumult of the next years (the Five Dynasties and Ten Kingdoms period).[116]

Christianity in China experienced a significant revival during the Mongol-created Yuan dynasty, established after the Mongols had conquered China in the 13th century. Marco Polo in the 13th century and other medieval Western writers described many Nestorian communities remaining in China and Mongolia; however, they clearly were not as active as they had been during Tang times.

Mongolia and Central Asia

Mongol tribes that adopted Syriac Christianity ca. 600 – 1400

The Church of the East enjoyed a final period of expansion under the

Kerait clan, as did their sons in turn. During the rule of Genghis's grandson, the Great Khan Mongke, Nestorian Christianity was the primary religious influence in the Empire, and this also carried over to Mongol-controlled China, during the Yuan dynasty. It was at this point, in the late 13th century, that the Church of the East reached its greatest geographical reach. But Mongol power was already waning as the Empire dissolved into civil war; and it reached a turning point in 1295, when Ghazan, the Mongol ruler of the Ilkhanate
, made a formal conversion to Islam when he took the throne.

Jerusalem and Cyprus

A Nestorian church (1350) in Famagusta, Cyprus.

Franciscan accounts indicate.[118] At Famagusta, Cyprus, a Nestorian community was established just before 1300, and a church was built for them c. 1339.[119][120]

Decline

The expansion was followed by a decline. There were 68 cities with resident Church of the East bishops in the year 1000; in 1238 there were only 24, and at the death of Timur in 1405, only seven. The result of some 20 years under Öljaitü, ruler of the Ilkhanate from 1304 to 1316, and to a lesser extent under his predecessor, was that the overall number of the dioceses and parishes was further reduced.[121]

When

Amid (modern Diyarbakır), Mêrdîn (modern Mardin) and Edessa to the west, Salmas to the east, Hakkari and Harran to the north, and Mosul, Kirkuk, and Arbela (modern Erbil) to the south - a region comprising, in modern maps, northern Iraq, southeast Turkey, northeast Syria and the northwestern fringe of Iran. Small Nestorian communities were located further west, notably in Jerusalem and Cyprus, but the Malabar Christians of India represented the only significant survival of the once-thriving exterior provinces of the Church of the East.[124] The complete disappearance of the Nestorian dioceses in Central Asia probably stemmed from a combination of persecution, disease, and isolation: "what survived the Mongols did not survive the Black Death of the fourteenth century."[122] In many parts of Central Asia, Christianity had died out decades before Timur's campaigns. The surviving evidence from Central Asia, including a large number of dated graves, indicates that the crisis for the Church of the East occurred in the 1340s rather than the 1390s. Several contemporary observers, including the Papal Envoy Giovanni de' Marignolli, mention the murder of a Latin bishop in 1339 or 1340 by a Muslim mob in Almaliq, the chief city of Tangut, and the forcible conversion of the city's Christians to Islam. Tombstones in two East Syriac cemeteries in Mongolia have been dated from 1342, some commemorating deaths during a Black Death outbreak in 1338. In China, the last references to Nestorian and Latin Christians date from the 1350s, shortly before the replacement in 1368 of the Mongol Yuan dynasty with the xenophobic Ming dynasty and the consequential self-imposed isolation of China from foreign influence including Christianity.[125]

Schisms

From the middle of the 16th century, and throughout following two centuries, the Church of the East was affected by several internal schisms. Some of those schisms were caused by individuals or groups who chose to accept union with the Catholic Church. Other schisms were provoked by rivalry between various fractions within the Church of the East. Lack of internal unity and frequent change of allegiances led to the creation and continuation of separate patriarchal lines. In spite of many internal challenges, and external difficulties (political oppression by Ottoman authorities and frequent persecutions by local non-Christians), the traditional branches of the Church of the East managed to survive that tumultuous period and eventually consolidate during the 19th century in the form of the Assyrian Church of the East. At the same time, after many similar difficulties, groups united with the Catholic Church were finally consolidated into the Chaldean Catholic Church

Schism of 1552

Around the middle of the fifteenth century Patriarch Shemʿon IV Basidi made the patriarchal succession hereditary – normally from uncle to nephew. This practice, which resulted in a shortage of eligible heirs, eventually led to a schism in the Church of the East, creating a temporarily Catholic offshoot known as the Shimun line.

Franciscan missionaries were already at work among the Nestorians,[129] and, using them as intermediaries,[130] Sulaqa's supporters sought to legitimise their position by seeking their candidate's consecration by Pope Julius III (1550–5).[131][55]

Sulaqa went to Rome, arriving on 18 November 1552, and presented a letter, drafted by his supporters in Mosul, setting out his claim and asking that the Pope consecrate him as Patriarch. On 15 February 1553 he made a twice-revised profession of faith judged to be satisfactory, and by the bull Divina Disponente Clementia of 20 February 1553 was appointed "Patriarch of Mosul in Eastern Syria"[132] or "Patriarch of the Church of the Chaldeans of Mosul" (Chaldaeorum ecclesiae Musal Patriarcha).[133] He was consecrated bishop in St. Peter's Basilica on 9 April. On 28 April Pope Julius III gave him the pallium conferring patriarchal rank, confirmed with the bull Cum Nos Nuper. These events, in which Rome was led to believe that Shemʿon VII Ishoʿyahb was dead, created within the Church of the East a lasting schism between the Eliya line of Patriarchs at Alqosh and the new line originating from Sulaqa. The latter was for half a century recognised by Rome as being in communion, but that reverted to both hereditary succession and Nestorianism and has continued in the Patriarchs of the Assyrian Church of the East.[131][134]

Sulaqa left Rome in early July and in Constantinople applied for civil recognition. After his return to Mesopotamia, he received from the Ottoman authorities in December 1553 recognition as head of "the Chaldean nation after the example of all the Patriarchs". In the following year, during a five-month stay in

Amadiya, who invited Sulaqa to ʿAmadiya, imprisoned him for four months, and put him to death in January 1555.[128][134]

The Eliya and Shimun lines

This new Catholic line founded by Sulaqa maintained its seat at

Seert
.

The Eliya-line Patriarch Shemon VII Ishoyahb (1539–1558), who resided in the Rabban Hormizd Monastery near Alqosh, continued to actively oppose union with Rome, and was succeeded by his nephew Eliya (designated as Eliya "VII" in older historiography,[137][138] but renumbered as Eliya "VI" in recent scholarly works).[139][140][141] During his Patriarchal tenure, from 1558 to 1591, the Church of the East preserved its traditional christology and full ecclesiastical independence.[142]

The next Shimun Patriarch was likely

Heleen Murre believe that, in the period between 1570 and the patriarchal election of Yahballaha, he or another of the same name was looked on as Patriarch.[144] Yahballaha's successor, Shimun IX Dinkha (1580–1600), who moved away from Turkish rule to Salmas on Lake Urmia in Persia,[145] was officially confirmed by the Pope in 1584.[146] There are theories that he appointed his nephew, Shimun X Eliyah (1600–1638) as his successor, but others argue that his election was independent of any such designation.[144]
Regardless, from then until the 21st century the Shimun line employed a hereditary system of succession – the rejection of which was part of the reason for the creation of that line in the first place.

Two Nestorian patriarchs

The ancient Rabban Hormizd Monastery, former residence of the Patriarchs of the Church of the East.

The next Eliya Patriarch, Eliya VII (VIII) (1591–1617), negotiated on several occasions with the Catholic Church, in 1605, 1610 and 1615–1616, but without final resolution.[147] This likely alarmed Shimun X, who in 1616 sent to Rome a profession of faith that Rome found unsatisfactory, and another in 1619, which also failed to win him official recognition.[147] Wilmshurst says it was this Shimun Patriarch who reverted to the "old faith" of Nestorianism,[144][148] leading to a shift in allegiances that won for the Eliya line control of the lowlands and of the highlands for the Shimun line. Further negotiations between the Eliya line and the Catholic Church were cancelled during the Patriarchal tenure of Eliya VIII (IX) (1617–1660).[149]

The next two Shimun Patriarchs, Shimun XI Eshuyow (1638–1656) and Shimun XII Yoalaha (1656–1662), wrote to the Pope in 1653 and 1658, according to Wilmshurst, while Heleen Murre speaks only of 1648 and 1653. Wilmshurst says Shimun XI was sent the pallium, though Heleen Murre argues official recognition was given to neither. A letter suggests that one of the two was removed from office (presumably by Nestorian traditionalists) for pro-Catholic leanings: Shimun XI according to Heleen Murre, probably Shimun XII according to Wilmshurst.[150][144]

Qochanis.[153]

The Josephite line

As the Shimun line "gradually returned to the traditional worship of the Church of the East, thereby losing the allegiance of the western regions",

Amid (Diyarbakır), the original headquarters of Shimun Sulaqa, became subject to the Alqosh Patriarch. In 1667 or 1668, Bishop Joseph of that see converted to the Catholic faith. In 1677, he obtained from the Turkish authorities recognition as holding independent power in Amid and Mardin, and in 1681 he was recognised by Rome as "Patriarch of the Chaldean nation deprived of its Patriarch" (Amid patriarchate). Thus was instituted the Josephite line, a third line of Patriarchs and the sole Catholic one at the time.[155] All Joseph I's successors took the name "Joseph". The life of this Patriarchate was difficult: the leadership was continually vexed by traditionalists, while the community struggled under the tax burden imposed by the Ottoman
authorities.

In 1771,

Joseph IV of the Amid Patriarchate resigned in 1780, Rome likewise made his nephew, Augustine Hindi
, whom he wished to be his successor, not Patriarch but Administrator. No one held the title of Chaldean Catholic patriarch for the next 47 years.

Consolidation of patriarchal lines

When

Chaldean Catholic Patriarch of Babylon
, marking the last remnant of the hereditary system within the Chaldean Catholic Church.

This also ended the rivalry between the senior Eliya line and the junior Shimun line, as

Shimun XXI Eshai
.

Accordingly, Joachim Jakob remarks that the original Patriarchate of the Church of the East (the Eliya line) entered into union with Rome and continues down to today in the form of the Chaldean [Catholic] Church,[161] while the original Patriarchate of the Chaldean Catholic Church (the Shimun line) continues today in the Assyrian Church of the East.

See also

Explanatory notes

  1. Nestorian Schism". However, the Church of the East already existed as a separate organisation in 431, and the name of Nestorius is not mentioned in any of the acts of the Church's synods up to the 7th century.[7] Christian communities isolated from the church in the Roman Empire likely already existed in Persia from the 2nd century.[8] The independent ecclesiastical hierarchy of the Church developed over the course of the 4th century,[9] and it attained its full institutional identity with its establishment as the officially recognized Christian church in Persia by Shah Yazdegerd I in 410.[10]
  2. ^ The "Nestorian" label is popular, but it has been contentious, derogatory and considered a misnomer. See the § Description as Nestorian section for the naming issue and alternate designations for the church.

Citations

  1. ^
    S2CID 160590164
    .
  2. ^ a b Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 2.
  3. ^ Stewart 1928, p. 15.
  4. ^ Vine, Aubrey R. (1937). The Nestorian Churches. London: Independent Press. p. 104.
  5. ^ a b Meyendorff 1989, p. 287-289.
  6. .
  7. ^ Brock 2006, p. 8.
  8. ^ Brock 2006, p. 11.
  9. ^ Lange 2012, pp. 477–9.
  10. ^ Payne 2015, p. 13.
  11. ^ a b Paul, J.; Pallath, P. (1996). Pope John Paul II and the Catholic Church in India. Mar Thoma Yogam publications. Centre for Indian Christian Archaeological Research. p. 5. Retrieved 2022-06-17. Authors are using different names to designate the same Church : the Church of Seleucia - Ctesiphon, the Church of the East, the Babylonian Church, the Assyrian Church, or the Persian Church.
  12. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 3,4.
  13. ^ Orientalia Christiana Analecta. Pont. institutum studiorum orientalium. 1971. p. 2. Retrieved 2022-06-17. The Church of Seleucia - Ctesiphon was called the East Syrian Church or the Church of the East .
  14. ^ Fiey 1994, p. 97-107.
  15. ^ a b c Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 4.
  16. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 112-123.
  17. ^ .
  18. ^ Procopius, Wars, I.7.1–2
    * Greatrex–Lieu (2002), II, 62
  19. ^ Joshua the Stylite, Chronicle, XLIII
    * Greatrex–Lieu (2002), II, 62
  20. ^ Procopius, Wars, I.9.24
    * Greatrex–Lieu (2002), II, 77
  21. ^ a b Brock 1996, p. 23–35.
  22. ^ Brock 2006, p. 1-14.
  23. ^ Joseph 2000, p. 42.
  24. ^ Wood 2013, p. 140.
  25. ^ Moffett, Samuel H. (1992). A History of Christianity in Asia. Volume I: Beginnings to 1500. HarperCollins. p. 219.
  26. .
  27. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 84-89.
  28. ^ The Eastern Catholic Churches 2017 Archived 2018-10-24 at the Wayback Machine Retrieved December 2010. Information sourced from Annuario Pontificio 2017 edition.
  29. ^ "Holy Apostolic Catholic Assyrian Church of the East — World Council of Churches". www.oikoumene.org. January 1948.
  30. . The number of the faithful at the beginning of the twenty - first century belonging to the Assyrian Church of the East under Mar Dinkha was estimated to be around 385,000, and the number belonging to the Ancient Church of the East under Mar Addia to be 50,000-70,000.
  31. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 3, 30.
  32. ^ a b Brock, Sebastian P; Coakley, James F. "Church of the East". e-GEDSH:Gorgias Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Syriac Heritage. Retrieved 27 June 2022. The Church of the East follows the strictly dyophysite ('two-nature') christology of Theodore of Mopsuestia, as a result of which it was misleadingly labelled as 'Nestorian' by its theological opponents.
  33. ^ Wilmshurst 2000.
  34. ^ Foltz 1999, p. 63.
  35. ^ Seleznyov 2010, p. 165–190.
  36. ^ a b c d e f "Nestorian". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved January 28, 2010.
  37. ^ "Nestorius". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 11 November 2018.
  38. ^ Kuhn 2019, p. 130.
  39. ^ Brock 1999, p. 286−287.
  40. ^ Wood 2013, p. 136.
  41. ^ Hilarion Alfeyev, The Spiritual World Of Isaac The Syrian (Liturgical Press 2016)
  42. ^ Brock 2006, p. 174.
  43. ^ Meyendorff 1989.
  44. ^ a b Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 28-29.
  45. ^ Payne 2009, p. 398-399.
  46. ^ Bethune-Baker 1908, p. 82-100.
  47. ^ Winkler 2003.
  48. ^ a b c Wilmshurst 2000, p. 4.
  49. ^ Brock 2006, p. 14.
  50. ^ Joost Jongerden, Jelle Verheij, Social Relations in Ottoman Diyarbekir, 1870-1915 (BRILL 2012), p. 21
  51. ^ Gabriel Oussani, "The Modern Chaldeans and Nestorians, and the Study of Syriac among them" in Journal of the American Oriental Society, vol. 22 (1901), p. 81
  52. ^ Albrecht Classen (editor), East Meets West in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Times (Walter de Gruyter 2013), p. 704
  53. ^ Brock 1996, p. 23-35.
  54. ^ a b c Wilmshurst 2000, p. 21-22.
  55. ^ Foster 1939, p. 34.
  56. ^ Syriac Versions of the Bible by Thomas Nicol
  57. ^ . Retrieved 23 July 2018.
  58. ^ a b Baumer 2006, p. 168.
  59. ^ "The Shadow of Nestorius".
  60. ^ Kung, Tien Min (1960). 唐朝基督教之研究 [Christianity in the T'ang Dynasty] (PDF) (in Chinese (Hong Kong)). Hong Kong: The Council on Christian Literature for Overseas Chinese. p. 7 (PDF page). 佐伯博士主張此像乃景敎的耶穌像
  61. ^ a b Baumer 2006, p. 75, 94.
  62. ^ Drège 1992, p. 43, 187.
  63. ^ O'Daly, Briton (Yale University) (2021). "An Israel of the Seven Rivers" (PDF). Sino-Platonic Papers: 10–12.
  64. ^
    JSTOR 41927279
    .
  65. .
  66. ^ Khoury, George (1997-01-22). "Eastern Christianity on the Eve of Islam". EWTN. Retrieved 2023-03-01.
  67. OCLC 123079516
    .
  68. – via JSTOR.
  69. ^ Fiey, Jean Maurice (1970). Jalons pour une histoire de l'Église en Iraq. Louvain: Secretariat du CSCO.
  70. ^ Chaumont 1988.
  71. ^ Hill 1988, p. 105.
  72. ^ a b Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 354.
  73. ^ Outerbridge 1952.
  74. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 1.
  75. ^ Ilaria Ramelli, "Papa bar Aggai", in Encyclopedia of Ancient Christianity, 2nd edn., 3 vols., ed. Angelo Di Berardino (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2014), 3:47.
  76. ^ Fiey 1967, p. 3–22.
  77. ^ Roberson 1999, p. 15.
  78. ^ Daniel & Mahdi 2006, p. 61.
  79. ^ Foster 1939, p. 26-27.
  80. ^ Burgess & Mercier 1999, p. 9-66.
  81. ^ Donald Attwater & Catherine Rachel John, The Penguin Dictionary of Saints, 3rd edn. (New York: Penguin Books, 1993), 116, 245.
  82. ^ Tajadod 1993, p. 110–133.
  83. ^ Labourt 1909.
  84. ^ Jugie 1935, p. 5–25.
  85. ^ Reinink 1995, p. 77-89.
  86. ^ Brock 2006, p. 73.
  87. ^ Stewart 1928, p. 13-14.
  88. ^ Stewart 1928, p. 14.
  89. ^ Foster 1939, p. 33.
  90. ^ Fiey 1993, p. 47 (Armenia), 72 (Damascus), 74 (Dailam and Gilan), 94–6 (India), 105 (China), 124 (Rai), 128–9 (Sarbaz), 128 (Samarqand and Beth Turkaye), 139 (Tibet).
  91. ^ Hill 1993, p. 4-5, 12.
  92. . Neither were there any Muslims among the Ninth-Century translators. Amost all of them were Christians of various Eastern denominations: Jacobites, Melchites, and, above all, Nestorians.
  93. ^ Rémi Brague, Assyrians contributions to the Islamic civilization Archived 2013-09-27 at the Wayback Machine
  94. ^ Britannica, Nestorian
  95. ^ Jarrett, Jonathan (2019-06-24). "When is a Nestorian not a Nestorian? Mostly, that's when". A Corner of Tenth-Century Europe. Retrieved 2023-03-01.
  96. ^ Ronald G. Roberson, "The Syro-Malabar Catholic Church"
  97. ^ "NSC NETWORK – Early references about the Apostolate of Saint Thomas in India, Records about the Indian tradition, Saint Thomas Christians & Statements by Indian Statesmen". Nasrani.net. 2007-02-16. Archived from the original on 3 April 2010. Retrieved 2010-03-31.
  98. .
  99. .
  100. .
  101. .
  102. ^ Frykenberg 2008, p. 102–107, 115.
  103. ^ a b Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 52.
  104. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 53.
  105. ^ "Synod of Diamper". britannica.com. Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 11 July 2022. The local patriarch—representing the Assyrian Church of the East, to which ancient Christians in India had looked for ecclesiastical authority—was then removed from jurisdiction in India and replaced by a Portuguese bishop; the East Syrian liturgy of Addai and Mari was "purified from error"; and Latin vestments, rituals, and customs were introduced to replace the ancient traditions.
  106. ^ . Then the pope decided to throw one more stone into the pool. Apparently following a suggestion made by some among the cattanars, he sent to India four discalced Carmelites - two Italians, one Fleming and one German. These Fathers had two advantages – they were not Portuguese and they were not Jesuits. The head of the mission was given the title of apostolic commissary, and was specially charged with the duty of restoring peace in the Serra.
  107. ^ .
  108. ^ "Mar Aprem Metropolitan Visits Ancient Anuradhapura Cross in Official Trip to Sri Lanka". Assyrian Church News. Archived from the original on 2015-02-26. Retrieved 6 August 2013.
  109. ^ Weerakoon, Rajitha (June 26, 2011). "Did Christianity exist in ancient Sri Lanka?". Sunday Times. Retrieved 2 August 2021.
  110. ^ "Main interest". Daily News. 22 April 2011. Archived from the original on 2015-03-29. Retrieved 2 August 2021.
  111. ^ Ding 2006, p. 149-162.
  112. ^ Stewart 1928, p. 169.
  113. ^ Stewart 1928, p. 183.
  114. ^ Moffett 1999, p. 14-15.
  115. ^ Jackson 2014, p. 97.
  116. ^ Luke 1924, p. 46–56.
  117. ^ Fiey 1993, p. 71.
  118. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 66.
  119. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 16-19.
  120. ^ a b Peter C. Phan, Christianities in Asia (John Wiley & Sons 2011), p. 243
  121. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 105.
  122. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 345-347.
  123. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 104.
  124. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 19.
  125. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 21.
  126. ^ a b Wilmshurst 2000, p. 22.
  127. ^ Lemmens 1926, p. 17-28.
  128. ^ a b Fernando Filoni, The Church in Iraq CUA Press 2017), pp. 35−36
  129. ^ a b Habbi 1966, p. 99-132.
  130. ^ Patriarcha de Mozal in Syria orientali (Anton Baumstark (editor), Oriens Christianus, IV:1, Rome and Leipzig 2004, p. 277)
  131. ^ Assemani 1725, p. 661.
  132. ^ a b Wilkinson 2007, p. 86−88.
  133. ^ a b Wilmshurst 2000, p. 23.
  134. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 22-23.
  135. ^ Tisserant 1931, p. 261-263.
  136. ^ Fiey 1993, p. 37.
  137. ^ Murre van den Berg 1999, p. 243-244.
  138. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 116, 174.
  139. ^ a b Hage 2007, p. 473.
  140. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 22, 42 194, 260, 355.
  141. ^ Tisserant 1931, p. 230.
  142. ^ a b c d Murre van den Berg 1999, p. 252-253.
  143. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 114.
  144. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 23-24.
  145. ^ a b Wilmshurst 2000, p. 24.
  146. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 352.
  147. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 24-25.
  148. ^ a b Wilmshurst 2000, p. 25.
  149. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 25, 316.
  150. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 114, 118, 174-175.
  151. ^ Murre van den Berg 1999, p. 235-264.
  152. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 24, 352.
  153. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 119, 174.
  154. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 263.
  155. ^ Baum & Winkler 2003, p. 118, 120, 175.
  156. ^ Wilmshurst 2000, p. 316-319, 356.
  157. ^ Joseph 2000, p. 1.
  158. ^ Fred Aprim, "Assyria and Assyrians Since the 2003 US Occupation of Iraq"
  159. ^ Jakob 2014, p. 100-101.

General and cited references

External links