Edmund Gettier
Edmund Gettier | |
---|---|
Baltimore, Maryland, U.S. | |
Died | March 23, 2021 | (aged 93)
Era | Contemporary philosophy |
Region | Western philosophy |
School | Analytic philosophy |
Doctoral advisor | Norman Malcolm |
Main interests | Epistemology |
Notable ideas | Gettier problem |
Edmund Lee Gettier III (
Life
Edmund Lee Gettier III was born on October 31, 1927, in
Gettier obtained his
Gettier taught philosophy at Wayne State University from 1957 until 1967[2] initially as an Instructor, then as an assistant professor, and, latterly, as an associate professor.[4] His philosophical colleagues at Wayne State included, among others, Alvin Plantinga and Héctor-Neri Castaneda.[5]
In the academic year of 1964–65, he held a postdoctoral
In 1967, Gettier was recruited to the faculty of philosophy at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, being promoted to full professor there in 1972.[4] He taught there until his retirement, as Professor Emeritus, in 2001.[4]
Gettier died on March 23, 2021, aged 93.[4]
Gettier's fame rests on a three-page article, published in
Work
Gettier problem
Gettier provides several examples of beliefs that are both true and justified, but that we should not intuitively term knowledge. Cases of this sort are now termed "Gettier (counter-)examples". Because Gettier's criticism of the justified true belief model is systemic, other authors have imagined increasingly fantastical counterexamples. For example: I am watching the men's Wimbledon Final, and John McEnroe is playing Jimmy Connors, it is match point, and McEnroe wins. I say to myself: "John McEnroe is this year's men's champion at Wimbledon". Unbeknownst to me, however, the BBC were experiencing a broadcasting fault and so had broadcast a tape of last year's final, when McEnroe also beat Connors. I had been watching last year's Wimbledon final, so I believed that McEnroe had bested Connors. But at that same time, in real life, McEnroe was repeating last year's victory and besting Connors! So my belief that McEnroe bested Connors to become this year's Wimbledon champion is true, and I had good reason to believe so (my belief was justified) — and yet, there is a sense in which I could not really have claimed to "know" that McEnroe had bested Connors because I was only accidentally right that McEnroe beat Connors — my belief was not based on the right kind of justification.
Gettier inspired a great deal of work by philosophers attempting to recover a working
- Gettier's use of "justification" is too general, and only some kinds of justification count.
- Gettier's examples do not count as justification at all, and only some kinds of evidence are justificatory.
- Knowledge must have a fourth condition, such as "no false premises" or "indefeasibility".
- Robert Nozick suggests knowledge must consist of justified true belief that is "truth-tracking" — a belief such that if it was revealed to be false, it would not have been believed, and conversely.
- Colin McGinn suggests that knowledge is atomic (it is not divisible into smaller components). We have knowledge when we have knowledge, and an accurate definition of knowledge may even contain the word "knowledge".[10]
A 2001 study by Weinberg, Nichols, and Stich suggests that the effect of the Gettier problem varies by culture. In particular, people from Western countries seem more likely to agree with the judgments described in the story than do those from East Asia.[11] Subsequent studies were unable to replicate these results.[12]
Complete works
- "Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?"
- "Review: [Untitled]" The Philosophical Review 74, no. 2 (1965): 266–69. https://doi.org/10.2307/2183277
- “Comments on A. J. Ayer’s ‘The Concept of a Person’,” in Intentionality, Minds, and Perception: Discussions on Contemporary Philosophy, ed. Hector-Neri Castañeda (Detroit, 1967).
See also
References
- ^ "Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?"
- ^ ISBN 978-0-19-975466-3, retrieved 2021-04-13
- JSTOR 20123871.
- ^ a b c d e "In Memoriam: Edmund L. Gettier III (1927–2021) : Department of Philosophy : UMass Amherst". www.umass.edu. Archived from the original on 2021-04-21. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
- S2CID 38338054.
- ^ "66 Andrew Mellon Fellowships Awarded At Pitt | Digital Pitt". digital.library.pitt.edu. August 17, 1964. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
- ISBN 978-90-277-2674-2.
I met Gettier in Pittsburgh while I was a graduate student there and he a visiting scholar; I immediately envied him his counterexamples, his smile, and the fun he got out of doing philosophy brilliantly.
- JSTOR 2183277.
- S2CID 170763145., p. 657.
- ISBN 978-0-19-823823-2.
- .
- .