Frederik van Leenhof
Frederik van Leenhof | |
---|---|
Spinozism | |
Main interests | Ethics, theology |
Frederik van Leenhof (1 September 1647 – 13 October 1715)
Education and career
Leenhof studied
In his correspondence with Wittich, Leenhof argues that the universe must always have existed; a
Whilst studying his religion and exploring modern ethics during his second period of writing (1700–04), Leenhof came into contact with the early
The Leenhof controversy
In agreement with Baruch Spinoza (1632–77), Leenhof eventually came to reject belief in a personal god, which was considered heresy in contemporary Christendom. Leenhof's book Heaven on Earth, published simultaneously in Zwolle and Amsterdam in June 1703, is written completely in Spinozist (pantheist) thought, although he always denied being an adherent of the then hugely controversial Spinoza. In fact, the book did not 'refer explicitly to any forbidden philosopher or doctrine', but the unorthodox way in which he presented his ideas, one after the other, almost devoid of any Christian context, caused uproar amongst his readers.[8]
Contents of Heaven on Earth
Noble truth fails to triumph in the world and ignorance and superstition prevail. Everywhere one encounters false ideas, such as that comets are portents of pending doom, that there are ghosts and demons, and that gold can be obtained through alchemy.
– Frederik van Leenhof, Heaven on Earth[9]
Leenhof opined that every human being could realise
Heaven on Earth attacked and defended
His book was hotly debated by the Zwolle government and the
Secular versus religious authorities
On 20 March 1704, Leenhof took the initiative to convene the Zwolle church council to ask his colleagues' support, and declared that nothing he had written contradicted the teachings of the dominant
Articles of Satisfaction
Meanwhile, the Zwolle consistory drafted, with Leenhof's help, the ten Articles of Satisfaction, published in August 1704, clarifying that his thought differed from Spinozism, that is to be utterly condemned for its incongruity with Christianity.[16] The Articles were ratified unanimously by the consistory and government of Zwolle, and proclaimed from the pulpits of the city's largest three churches on the first Sunday of November.[17] Again, this failed to placate his critics. The States and Synods outside of Overijssel continued to pressure Zwolle to condemn and ban Leenhof's 'Spinozistic' last three books, which the States of Holland imposed in their own province on 18 December 1706. During a meeting of the States General on 29 December 1706, the other provinces urged Overijssel to impose a similar ban on the books, but the delegates of Overijssel responded that 'this would only provide further encouragement to read them', and stressed their province's autonomy in the matter.[18] In 1708, the Synod of Overijssel called for Leenhof to be fired and excommunicated from the Reformed Church, lest his views led his congregation and others astray, and discussed tighter controls against 'licentious books' in general.[19] The call of censorship of radical writings was echoed by religious and sometimes secular authorities in other provinces as well, although the regenten feared this would strengthen the Church's power at their disadvantage. Sanctions against Zwolle were imposed by several provincial synods in 1708, including that of North Holland and Guelders that no preacher from Zwolle could participate in any church gathering in their regions. Finally, the deadlock in the States of Overijssel was resolved in March 1709, when the majority ruled against the wish of Zwolle that Leenhof had to sign additional Articles of Satisfaction drafted by the synod to utterly repudiate Spinozism. At a synod and States' commissioners' meeting in Deventer in June 1709, Leenhof defiantly denied having ever taught Spinozism, but only orthodoxy, and that he could not retract more than he had already done, and not recant his last three books. After this, Leenhof's books were banned in Overijssel, but the Zwolle magistrate refused to strip him from his pastoral position.[20] In December 1710, they finally requested him to resign, which Leenhof did. However, he remained a popular figure within Zwolle, receiving both salary and sacraments and retaining his preacher's seat in church. His still favoured position led to continued debates and harsh words around the country against the consistory and magistrate of Zwolle. Eventually, a majority in the consistory of Zwolle voted to excommunicate Leenhof in 1712.[21]
Outside of the Netherlands
Although discharged honourably from his pastoral position in 1710, and excommunicated disgracefully in 1712, Leenhof's ideas spread far and wide. Heaven on Earth was translated in many languages and spread all across Europe, via
Works
- 1678–1682: Keten der Bybelsche Godgeleerdheit ("Chain of Biblical Theology"), 2 volumes.
- 1700: Prediker ("Preacher". Original title: De Prediker van den wijzen en magtigen Konink Salomon: Kort en leerzamelijk verklaart, en op onze tijden en zeden toegepast, "The Preacher of the Wise and Mighty King Solomon: Explained Briefly and Informatively, and Applied to Our Times and Ethics.").
- 1703: Hemel op aarde ("Heaven on Earth". Original title: Den hemel op aarden; of een korte en klaare beschrijvinge van de waare en stantvastige blydschap, "Heaven on Earth; or a Short and Clear Description of True and Steadfast Happiness").
- 1704: Hemel op Aarde Opgehelderd, "Heaven on Earth Clarified", better known as Opheldering or "Clarification".
- 1704: Kort Antwoord, "Short Answer".
References
- ^ "Frederik van Leenhof". Biografisch portaal van Nederland. Huygens Institute for the History of the Netherlands. Retrieved 11 March 2016.
- ^ Joris van Eijnatten & Fred van Lieburg, Nederlandse Religiegeschiedenis (2006), p. 214. Second Edition.
- ISBN 9780191622878.
- ^ National Library of the Netherlands. Retrieved 11 March 2016.
- ^ Israel, 406–7.
- ^ Israel, 407–8.
- ^ Israel, 408–10.
- ^ Israel, 410.
- ^ a b Israel, 411.
- ^ a b Harry Jansen, Triptiek van de Tijd (2010), p. 244–245.
- ^ Israel, 412.
- ^ Jan Pieter de Bie & Jacob Loosjes (1931). "Barend Hakvoord". Biographisch woordenboek van protestantsche godgeleerden in Nederland. Deel 3. DBNL. Retrieved 20 May 2016.
- ^ Israel, 412–14.
- ^ Israel, 414–15.
- ^ Israel, 416.
- ^ Israel, 417.
- ^ Israel, 419.
- ^ Israel, 424.
- ^ Israel, 427.
- ^ Israel, 428–29.
- ^ Israel, 430.
Literature
- ISBN 9780191622878.
- "Biographical data Frederik van Leenhof". Poortmans repertorium. National Library of the Netherlands. Retrieved 11 March 2016.