Judiciary of Malawi
This article needs additional citations for verification. (December 2013) |
Part of a series on |
---|
Malawi portal |
The Judiciary of Malawi is the branch of the
Supreme Court of Appeal
The
High Court
The High Court of Malawi has unlimited original jurisdiction to hear and determine any civil or criminal proceedings.[7] It has a General Division which may also hear appeals from subordinate courts, and a Commercial Division, dealing with commercial or business cases. Most High Court cases are heard before a single judge, without a jury, but cases on constitutional matters must be heard by three judges.
Subordinate courts
One subordinate court is the Industrial Relations Court with jurisdiction over employment issues.[8] Cases before it are heard informally, and with some restrictions on legal representation, by a panel consisting of a chairperson and one representative each of employers and employees. Other subordinate courts are the magistrates' courts and local or traditional courts.[9] These have defined criminal and civil jurisdiction depending on their level, but expressly excluding cases of treason, murder or manslaughter.
History
During colonial rule, the hierarchy of courts began with magistrates' courts in the towns, rising to a High Court and finally a Supreme Court of Appeal. In addition, mainly in rural areas, there were several levels of local courts with varying powers to hear disputes such as divorces and other matrimonial issues, inheritance and access to land based on traditional customary law. These courts also heard minor criminal cases specified in the Malawi Penal Code, using an expedited procedure. These were subordinate to the High Court, and subject to legislation giving the guarantee of a fair trial, including the right to legal representation and the right to appeal to the High Court.[10]: 44
After independence in 1964, Prime Minister
From 1970, the system of traditional courts was transformed. Three regional traditional courts and a National Traditional Court of Appeal were created above the existing network of lower-level traditional courts, and given jurisdiction over virtually all criminal trials, including murder and treason, involving Africans of Malawian descent, using "customary" rules of evidence and procedure. Appeals were directed to a National Traditional Court of Appeal rather than the Malawi High Court, as had been the case before 1970. The High Court and Supreme Court of Appeal remained in existence, and mainly dealt with civil law cases outside customary law. Although these courts retained their criminal jurisdiction, in practice the vast majority of criminal cases were heard in the traditional courts. The traditional courts were supposed to operate in accordance with African law and custom, although they applied an authoritarian, restrictive and punitive version of customary law, in line with the views of Banda. The majority of the judges were chiefs without legal training, appointed by and liable to dismissal by Banda, without any judicial independence. Defendants were not allowed lawyers to plead their cases and had no automatic rights either to call witnesses or to appeal (these were at the discretion of the courts and the Minister of Justice). They were not given a summary of the charges against them before the trial, so they could not prepare a defence.[11][12]: 363
The traditional courts gained a reputation for corruption and for prosecuting Banda's political opponents, for example the high-profile trials in 1976 of Albert Muwalo, Secretary General of the
In October 1993 the three regional traditional courts and the National Traditional Appeal Court were suspended indefinitely. A new Constitution came into force on 18 May 1994, with recognition of customary law as an integral part of the legal system, and the conversion of many lower traditional courts into magistrates' courts. It also provided for a new system of Traditional Courts but legislation for this was not introduced until 2011.[10]: 43–46 The 2011 legislation provided for two levels of customary law courts: several Local Courts were established in each of Malawi's 27 districts, mainly in rural areas, and one District Appeals Local Court in each district (to hear appeals from the Local Courts). Further appeals may be made to the High Court, to which both types of Local Courts are subordinate. Each Local Court and District Appeals Local Court was headed by a chairperson, who need not be a lawyer, but with a reasonable standard of education, proficiency in English and an adequate knowledge of the customary law and language of the area that the court serves.[14]
List of chief justices
- 1964–? Sir Frederick Southworth
- 1969-1970: Sir Philip Pike[15]
- 1970–1985: James John Skinner
- 1985-1992: Friday Lewis Makuta SC (First Malawian to hold office of Chief Justice)
- 1992–2002: Chief Justice of Swaziland, 2007)
- 2003–2007: Leonard E. Unyolo
- 2007-2013: Lovemore Munlo
- 2013–2015: Anastasia Msosa
- 2015–2021 Andrew K.C. Nyirenda
- 2021- Rizine Mzikamanda
See also
- Traditional Courts in Malawi
- Politics of Malawi
References
- ^ "Structure of Courts". Judiciary of Malawi. Archived from the original on 29 October 2013. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ "Malawi court annuls 2019 election results and calls for new ballot". the Guardian. February 3, 2020.
- ^ "Malawi's Supreme Court rules new presidential polls in July". AP NEWS.
- ^ "Malawi judges on shortlist of nominees for Chatham House Prize 2020". Malawi Nyasa Times - News from Malawi about Malawi. July 21, 2020.
- ^ "Chatham House Prize: Malawi Judges Win for Election Work". Chatham House – International Affairs Think Tank. October 26, 2020.
- ^ Sangala, Tom (February 18, 2018). "Chief Justice Announces Supreme Court Directions". Daily Times Newspaper. Retrieved August 28, 2022.
- ^ "High Court of Malawi General Division". Judiciary of Malawi. Archived from the original on 29 October 2013. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ "Industrial Relations Court". Judiciary of Malawi. Archived from the original on 29 October 2013. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ "Jurisdiction". Judiciary of Malawi. Archived from the original on 29 October 2013. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ a b F. E. Kanyongolo (2006). Malawi: Justice sector and the Rule of Law, Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa.
- ^ a b M. Chanock (1976). "Neo Traditionalism and the Customary Law in Malawi" (PDF). Journal of Legal Pluralism. pp. 80–84. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ S2CID 143353723.
- ISBN 978-0-92969-273-9.
- ^ Megan Crouch (18 August 2011). "Improving Legal Access for Rural Malawi Villagers". Jurist Legal News and Research Services. Retrieved 22 December 2013.
- ^ "Southern Africa". South Africa, Limited. 1970.