Mouse models of breast cancer metastasis
Breast cancer metastatic mouse models are experimental approaches in which mice are
Breast cancer metastasis
.Genetic diversity between primary and metastatic tumor
The classical theory developed in the early 70's anticipated that metastasis is due to genetically determined subpopulations in primary tumours.
Genes involved in organ specific metastasis
Breast cancer
Generating mouse models of breast cancer
Targeted expression of
Mice in genetic research
- In 1909, Clarence C. Little developed the first inbred strain, the DBA(Dilute, brown non-Agouti) mouse.
- In 1915, N.M Haldane identified first linkage in mouse between Albino mice and pink eye dilution on chromosome seven.
- In 1921, C57BL became one of the most widely used mice in genetics and was the first strain to have its genome sequenced.
- In 1982, transgenic mice genetically engineered to express dominant oncogenes.[20]
- In 1982, the stimulation of expression from the
Human and mouse: a genomic comparison
Genetic studies of common diseases in humans suffer significant limitations for practical and ethical reasons.[22] Human cell lines can be used to model disease but it is difficult to study processes at the tissue level, within an organ or across the entire body. Mice can be a good representation of diseases in humans because:.[23]
- There are close similarities of physiology, development and cell biology between mice and humans.
- Humans and mice both have around 30,000 protein-coding genes. The number of mouse genes without a corresponding human homologue is less than 1%.
- 90% of the human and mouse genomes are syntenic.
- 40% of both human and mouse genomes can be aligned at the nucleotide level.
- Mice have relatively short gestation periods.
- Mice take a brief time to reach sexual maturity.
- Mice have large litter sizes.
- The availability of hundreds of mutations affecting almost every tissue and aspect of development.
Mice may not be an ideal model for breast cancer. This is mainly due to the lack of precision in many of the models. When looking at metastasis, it is difficult to determine the precise location as well as its frequency. Another issue revolves around the epithelial sub types and the inability to specifically target them when targeting a mutation. An example of this would be determining the development of tumors in K14-Cre BRCA2 mice. In a standard case, the excision of BRCA2 resulted in no tumorgenesis, but if p53 was mutated and inactivated, tumorgenesis would occur. Therefore, there is not a definitive answer in terms of the origin of the tumor, due to the extra mutation in p53.[24]
Metastatic mouse mammary carcinoma cell lines
Various mouse mammary carcinoma cell lines, like 4T1[25] and TS/A, are metastatic in syngeneic immunocompetent mice and can be used to identify genes and pathways involved in the metastatic process.[26]
Simple tumor transplantation models
Transplantation of tumor cells into
- Cardiac injection: Bone
- Tail vein injection: Lung
- Splenic injection: Liver
- Carotid artery Injection: Brain
Tumor tissue transplant models
The specific immunodeficient mice that were used were the NOD/SCID mouse (non-obese diabetic/severe conditional immunodeficient). These mutations allow for the integration of new xenograft tissue. The mouse must first have their mammary fat pads humanized by injecting human telemorase-immortalized human mammary stromal fibroblasts(RMF/EG fibroblasts) into the mammary fat pads. Without this injection, the human mammary epithelial cells en-grafted onto the pad are unable to colonize and grow. The RMF/EG fibroblast must then be irradiated to allow the expression of key proteins and growth factors. After 4 weeks of development, the newly en-grafted human mammary epithelial cells expanded within the fat pad.[35]
Genetically engineered mice to study metastasis
Genetically engineered mice are constructed to model human
- The use of bacteria-derived tetracycline-inducible system permitting the switching on or off (Tet-On/Tet-Off system)[36]
- Targeted mutations by
- Introduction of retro viral mutations[38]
- Introduction of chemically induced mutations
Transgenic mouse models of breast cancer
The mice undergoing the process of transgenesis are known as transgenic mice. A basic transgene has a promoter region, Protein coding sequence, Intron and a stop codon. Mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV), is a retro virus that has been a known promoter to cause breast tumors once activated.[39] MMTV is a heritable somatic mutagen whose target range is limited. It harbors a regulatory DNA sequence called the long terminal repeat (LTR), which promotes steroid-hormone-inducible transcription.[40][41] Tumorgenesis that was induced by the mouse mammary tumor virus can also be done by integration of the viral genome. The sites of integration have been known to be critical genes for cellular regulation.[42] Whey acidic protein (WAP),[43] is another common promoter used to generate mouse mammary cancer models. For a list of other mammary gland specific promoters and mouse models see.[44]
MMTV-PyMT
MMTV-PyMT is the model of breast cancer metastasis, in which MMTV-LTR is used to drive the expression of mammary gland specific
- PI3K/Akt signalling in metastasis can be demonstrated in MMTV-PyMT; Akt1−/− mice.[46]
- Chemoattractive paracrine loop of colony-stimulating factor-1 (CSF-1) and EGF ligands between tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs) and tumor cells, and the lung metastasis can be studied by crossing MMTV-PyMT mice with Csf-1−/− mice.[47]
- The role of an innate and adaptive immune response to assist metastasis can be studied in MMTV-PyMT; Rag1−/− mice in which CD4+ T cells are selectively lost. Interleukin-4 (IL4) lacking model of MMTV-PyMT; IL4−/− mice.[48]
- Role of the adhesion molecule CD44 in lung metastasis.[49]
- Conditional ablation in MMTV-PyMT breast cancer cells has been done to reveal pro-metastatic actions of the angiogenic factors, Vascular endothelial growth factor A (VEGF-A).[50]
- The role of autocrine transforming growth factor beta 1(TGF-β1) signaling on motility and survival in PymT cells derived from an MMTV-PymT mouse mammary cancer.[51]
- Others are MMTV-PyMT; uPA-/-[52] and MMTV-PyMT; MEKK1-/-.[53]
MMTV-HER2/neu
The MMTV-LTR can also be used to promote receptor tyrosine-protein kinase ErbB2 to transform the mouse mammary epithelium. ErbB2 is an oncogene amplified and overexpressed in around 20% of human breast cancers. The mice harbouring this oncogene develop multifocal adenocarcinomas with lung metastases at about 15 weeks after pregnancy.[54][55] To create a more accurate representation of HER2 gene mutations, researchers have fused the mouse gene containing neu and a rat gene containing neu. This addresses the issue in terms of modeling the amplification of HER2 in mice development. In the non-fused mouse, the mammary gland would revert to a near virgin, but with this addition the mammary gland maintained the developed function.[56]
Bi-transgenic models
Mouse models having two transgenes are called bi transgenic. To check the cooperation of two oncogenes, Tim Stewert and group made the first bi-transgenic mouse models in 1987, MMTV-
Tri-transgenic models
Tri-transgenic mouse models constitute of more than two genes. Multiple combinations and genetic modifications are made in such a way that either one or all the genes are put into a continuously expressed status, or in a controlled fashion to activate them at different time points. For example, TOM( TetO-myc); TOR; MTB mice, where both the myc (M) and ras (R) genes are under the control of tetracycline operators. They can also both be activated or deactivated by adding doxycycline. Other combinations in this respect are TOM; Kras; MTB, where myc can be induced and uninduced at various time points while Kras is in continuous expressed state, and myc; TOR; MTB model is vice versa.[60]
Applications of genetically modified mice to study metastasis
Metastatic cascade can be studied by keeping the gene activation under control or by adding a reporter gene e.g. Beta actin GFP (Green fluorescent protein) or RFP (Red fluorescent protein).
Identification of genes that regulate metastasis
By knocking in/knocking out specific genes by homologous recombination, the extent of metastasis can be measured and new target genes identification can be achieved e.g. a gene that consistently regulates metastatic behavior of cancer cells is TGF-β1. Acute ablation of TGF-β signaling in MMTV-PyMT mammary tumor cells leads to a five-fold increase in lung metastasis.[61] Certain enhancer regions can also be analyzed and can be determined to be a crucial part of cell proliferation e.g. an enhancing region that is associated with a cancer critical gene p53 which was determined via CRISPR-Cas9.[62]
Lineage tracing in metastasis models
The quantitative lineage-tracing strategies have proven to be successful in resolving cell fates in normal epithelial tissues either using tissue –specific or
Circulating tumor cells
Another tool to study breast cancer metastasis is to look for circulating tumor cells in transgenic mice e.g. MMTV-PyMT mice can respond to various therapies in shedding tumor cells in the blood leading to lung metastasis.[65] Not only in blood but cells can be detected in bone marrow e.g. cytokeratin-positive cells in the bone marrow of MMTV-pyMT and MMTV-Neu transgenic mice were identified but not in the wild type controls.[66]
Limitations
In the absence of specific markers for mammary cells, models with genetic marking of tumor cells gives the best experimental advantage, however the low volume of peripheral blood that can be obtained from live animals limits the application of this technique.
In vivo imaging of metastatic mouse models
Transgenic mouse models can be imaged by various non-invasive techniques.
Bioluminescence imaging
Bioluminescence imaging relies on the detection of light produced by the enzymatic oxidation of an exogenous substrate. The substrate luciferin, is oxidized to oxyluciferin in the presence of luciferase and emits light, which can be detected using an IVIS system such as a Xenogen machine. Dissociated mammary cells from MMTV-PyMT: IRES: Luc; MTB (Internal ribosome entry site: Luciferin) animals (which were not exposed to doxycycline) can be injected into the lateral tail veins of immunodeficient mice on a doxycycline-free diet. No bioluminescence signal will be observed in the lungs of recipient mice until they are given doxycycline food. Bioluminescence can then be detected in the chest within 2 weeks of the start of doxycycline exposure.[31] Luciferase is injected just before taking the images.
Fluorescent imaging
Intravital microscopy with multi photon excitation is a technique to visualize genetically engineered cells directly in vivo. Multi step metastatic cascades can be visualized by labelling with unique fluorescent colour under fluorescence microscope.[67][68]
Radioisotopic imaging
MRI Imaging
Magnetic resonance imaging requires the use of nano-particles(liposomes) and an MRI contrast agent called gadolinium. The particles were then placed in vesicles via a polycarbonate membrane filter. The nano-particles are injected into the metastases evolved mice, and left there for twenty-four hours. These mice are then scanned, and in the imaging software there are accumulations of these particles in certain areas where cells have metastasized.[22]
See also
- Ensemblgenome database of model organisms
- Fate mapping
- Firefly luciferin
- Gene targeting
- Gene trapping
- Genetic recombination
- History of model organisms
- Homologous recombination
- Recombinase-mediated cassette exchange
- Site-specific recombinase technology
References
- PMID 10647931.
- PMID 4512654.
- PMID 22628410.
- PMID 19812674.
- PMID 20099298.
- S2CID 22296676.
- S2CID 4321110.
- S2CID 9161392.
- PMID 22277639.
- PMID 19363497.
- S2CID 33824409.
- S2CID 22599771.
- PMID 9108466.
- S2CID 36147250.
- PMID 18381931.
- PMID 12808139.
- PMID 18582095.
- PMID 17409287.
- ^ Gupta, PB; Kuperwasser, C. (2004). Disease models of breast cancer. Drug Discovery Today: Disease Models 1(1), 9-16. doi: 10.1016/j.ddmod.2004.05.001
- PMID 1422050.
- S2CID 46024617.
- ^ a b Goldman, E; Zinger, A; Silva, DD; Yaari, Z; Vardi-Oknin, D; Goldfeder, M; Schroeder, JE; Shainsky-Roitman, J; Hershkovitz, D; Schroeder, A; (2017). Nanoparticles target early-stage breast cancer metastasis in vivo. Nanotechnology 28(43), 1-13. doi: 10.1086/13616528/aa8a3d
- PMID 12466850.
- ^ Wagner, KW. (2003). Models of Breast Cancer: quo vadis, animal modeling? Breast Cancer Research 6(31), 31-38.doi: 10.1186/bcr723
- ^ Pulaski BA, S Ostrand-Rosenberg. 2001. "Mouse 4T1 breast tumor model". Curr Protoc Immunol. Chapter 20:Unit 20.2. doi: 10.1002/0471142735.im2002s39
- ^ Knott SRV, E Wagenblast, S Khan, SY Kim, M Soto, M Wagner, M-O Turgeon, L Fish, N Erard, AL Gable, AR Maceli, S Dickopf, EK Papachristou, CS D’Santos, LA Carey, JE Wilkinson, JC Harrell, CM Perou, H Goodarzi, G Poulogiannis, and GJ Hannon. 2018. "Asparagine bioavailability governs metastasis in a model of breast cancer". Nature. doi:10.1038/nature25465
- PMID 15358632.
- PMID 19735549.
- PMID 1540948.
- PMID 15210113.
- ^ PMID 18755941.
- PMID 17322365.
- PMID 20064377.
- S2CID 44649920.
- ^ Kuperwasser, C; Chavarria, T; Wu, M; Magrane, G; Gray, JW; Carey, L; Richardson, A; Weinberg, RA. (2004). Reconstruction of functionally normal and malignant human breast tissue in mice. Pnas 101(14), 4966-4971. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0401064101
- PMID 1319065.
- PMID 2783482.
- PMID 17090666.
- PMID 10713682.
- S2CID 20773799.
- PMID 6305596.
- ^ Ross, RS. (2010). Mouse mammary tumor virus molecular biology and oncogenesis. Viruses 2(9), 2000-2012. doi: 10.3390/v2092000
- PMID 6095207.
- PMID 16887003.
- PMID 1312220.
- PMID 23478237.
- PMID 11257139.
- PMID 19647220.
- PMID 16061657.
- PMID 15765121.
- PMID 15604265.
- PMID 15472905.
- PMID 16568086.
- PMID 3798106.
- S2CID 33754359.
- ^ Fry, EA; Taneka, P; Inoue, K. (2016). Oncogenic and tumor-suppressive mouse models for breast cancer engaging HER2/neu. International Journal of Cancer 140(3), 495-503. doi:10.1002/ijc.30399
- S2CID 43820016.
- PMID 12808151.
- S2CID 34303003.
- PMID 18356293.
- PMID 18339861.
- ^ Korkmaz, G; Lopes, R; Ugalde, AP; Nevedomskaya, E; Han, R; Myacheva, K; Zwart, W; Elkon, R; Agami, R. (2016). Functional genetics screens for enhancer elements in the human genome using CRISPR-Cas9. Nature Biotechnology 34, 192-198. doi: 10.1038/nbt.3450
- PMID 11299042.
- PMID 17804725.
- PMID 17415413.
- PMID 18167340.
- PMID 20627072.
- PMID 21959234.
- PMID 26630973.
External links
- http://www.la-press.com/tetracycline-regulated-systems-in-functional-oncogenomics-article-a200 A detailed overview of Tet-systems in functional oncogenomics