New Rochelle 250th Anniversary half dollar
United States | |
Value | 50 cents (0.50 US dollars) |
---|---|
Mass | 12.5[1] g |
Diameter | 30.61 mm (1.20[1] in) |
Thickness | 2.15 mm (0.08[2][3] in) |
Edge | Reeded[1] |
Composition |
|
Silver | 0.36169 Fleur de lis |
Designer | Gertrude K. Lathrop |
Design date | 1937 |
The New Rochelle 250th Anniversary half dollar is a
Aware of the many commemorative issues being authorized by the
New Rochelle's coin committee sold the half dollar for $2 locally, and by mail order to all 48 states and internationally, during late 1937 and early 1938. When sales slowed, 9,749 pieces were returned to the mint for redemption and melting. They have risen in price and now sell in the low hundreds of dollars. Lathrop's work has been both praised and criticized by numismatic commentators.
Background
The city of
Sparked by new issues with low mintages for which the demand was greater than the supply, the market for
By April 1936, Congress had reacted to these practices, adding protections to commemorative coinage bills. These included a requirement that all coins be struck at a single mint, rather than all three then operating as with earlier issues (the use of mint marks would force coin collectors to buy three near-identical coins to have a complete set).[9] Such provisions were in the New Rochelle half dollar bill; they could only be coined at one mint and all pieces were required to bear the date 1938, though the authorization took place in 1936 and the striking of the coins in 1937.[10] They would be issued at face value to a committee of not less than three members appointed by the mayor of New Rochelle.[2]
The moving force behind the New Rochelle issue was the Westchester County Coin Club, including collectors Julius Guttag (of Guttag Brothers, a prominent New York City coin dealer) and Pitt M. Skipton, who planned the issue to avoid the abuses of earlier commemoratives.
Legislation
Bills for a New Rochelle half dollar were introduced in both houses of Congress in January 1936; in the Senate by Royal S. Copeland and in the House by Charles D. Millard, both of New York.[13] Skipton had contacted both legislators, who had agreed to help, though Senator Copeland had warned, "The President is pretty hard-boiled on this subject."[14] The House bill reported back favorably from the Committee on Coinage, Weights, and Measures on February 17, 1936, proposed amendments increasing the authorized mintage from 20,000 to 25,000 and requiring there to be a committee of not less than three people to order the coins on behalf of New Rochelle.[13] The House adopted the amendments and passed the bill without debate on March 16, 1936.[15]
The Senate bill was referred to the Committee on Banking and Currency; it was one of several commemorative half dollar bills to be considered on March 11, 1936, by a subcommittee led by Colorado's Alva B. Adams.[16] Senator Adams had heard of the commemorative coin abuses of the mid-1930s, when issuers increased the number of pieces needed for a complete set by having them issued with different dates and mint marks; authorizing legislation placed no prohibition on this.[17] Lyman W. Hoffecker, a Texas coin dealer and official of the American Numismatic Association, testified and told the subcommittee that some issues, like the Oregon Trail pieces, had been issued over the course of years with different dates and mint marks. Other issues had been entirely bought up by single dealers, and some low-mintage varieties of commemoratives were selling at high prices. The many varieties and inflated prices for some issues that resulted from these practices angered collectors trying to keep their collections current.[18]
The Senate took no further action on Copeland's bill,[13] but on March 26, 1936, Senator Adams reported back the House bill to the Senate, entirely rewriting it to incorporate protections such as requiring all of the New Rochelle coins to have the same date and mint mark, and to be issued to the sponsoring organization in lots of not less than 5,000. He recommended that future commemorative coin bills have similar protections.[19] The Senate considered the bill on March 27, the fifth in a series of six commemorative coin bills being considered by that body, and like the others, the New Rochelle bill was amended and passed without debate or dissent.[20]
As the two houses had passed different versions, the bill returned to the House of Representatives. On April 17, 1936,
Preparation
The New Rochelle Commemorative Coin Committee was formed by Mayor Harry Scott of New Rochelle with the membership being Pitt Skipton as chair, Ernest H. Watson as treasurer and Jere Milleman as secretary.
Members of the CFA almost immediately reconsidered. Sculptor-member Lee Lawrie believed the design about the best that Wise could do, and given the few sculptors he believed capable of the work, was inclined to let the issue go ahead. Eugene Savage and Gilmore Clarke, also members, did not agree and after rejecting a design revision on October 23, the CFA asked that the New Rochelle Committee hire a new sculptor.[28] By mid-November, the Skiptons had seen an example of the Albany Charter half dollar, designed by Gertrude K. Lathrop, who was hired to replace Wise and who spent many hours in New Rochelle, studying local views.[29] Lathrop's appearance in New Rochelle came as something of a surprise to Pitt and Amy Skipton, who knew of her as G.K. Lathrop, and had assumed she was a man.[30] After several meetings between Lathrop and Pitt Skipton, both decided on the fatted calf for the obverse and a fleur-de-lis, an element of the shield of New Rochelle, for the reverse.[29]
The CFA took some time to decide, apparently under the impression the old coat of arms reverse was still to be used.
Design
Beautiful coin, so silvery white
Little did Huguenots dream in their flight
That a city they'd found like our own New Rochelle
Where folks of all creeds in amity dwell.
On your reverse you bear the Lily-of-France
While on obverse once more the "fatt calfe" doth prance
And Lord Pell in a costume befitting the day
Receives him as "quit rent"—so our annals do say.
North, South, East and West, little coin, you have sped
With New Rochelle's story of heroes long dead
Who feared not the hardships but stubbornly fought
For the Faith that they loved and the Freedom they sought.
God grant, little coin, that the story thus told
May live on forever and character mold
In a form where there's Beauty, Faith, Hope, Truth and Love
And over us hover sweet Peace like the dove.
"The New Rochelle Half Dollar", by Amy C. Skipton[34]
The
Arranged in arcs around the periphery of the obverse are the legends "NEW•ROCHELLE•NEW•YORK" and "SETTLED•1688•INCORPORATED•1899". The artist’s initials "GKL" appear to the right of the calf’s forelegs. The half dollar's reverse depicts a
Frank Duffield, editor of The Numismatist, wrote at the time of issue that "Again Miss Gertrude K. Lathrop, of Albany, has scored with her designs for the New Rochelle half dollar. The Albany coin, also designed by her, is regarded by many collectors as one of the most attractive in the entire commemorative series."[41] Numismatist Stuart Mosher, in his 1940 work on commemorative coins, praised the New Rochelle piece, stating that Lathrop "has produced in this one a most pleasing effect. The calf was modeled from life, and the colonial costume on the figure of Lord Pell has been accurately reproduced according to the style of that period. One of the handicaps belaboring every artist who attempts to design a coin for the United States government is the multiplicity of legends that must be used so as to comply with our coinage laws. In this instance the artist has arranged them in an orderly manner on the reverse, thus avoiding the cramped effect so often found on our coins when the designer attempts to crowd too many ideas into a small space."[42]
Art historian
Distribution and collecting
In April 1937, a total of 25,015 New Rochelle half dollars were struck at the
Fifty pieces were struck in proof condition on polished planchets, each placed in a box along with a silver medal and presented to dignitaries, members of the Coin Committee, and selected members of the Westchester County Coin Club. At least one piece was struck in matte proof for Mint Chief Engraver John R. Sinnock.[39]
By 1940, the New Rochelle half dollar sold for $1.75, and reached $6 by 1950. By 1970, the market price was $67 and by 1985, $500.
The requirement that Pell's family be presented with a fatted calf became void after the
References
- ^ a b c d e f Yeoman, p. 1093.
- ^ a b c d Flynn, p. 354.
- OCLC 1123997620.
- ^ a b Taxay, p. 200.
- ^ Slabaugh, p. 149.
- ^ Bowers, pp. 62–63.
- ^ a b Yeoman, pp. 1068–77.
- ^ Swiatek, p. 304.
- ^ Flynn, p. 116.
- ^ a b Flynn, p. 131.
- ^ Bowers, p. 419.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 2–3.
- ^ a b c "New Rochelle, New York 250th Anniversary Commemorative 50-Cent Pieces (legislative history)". Retrieved October 5, 2019 – via ProQuest.
- ^ Skipton, p. 3.
- ^ 1936 Congressional Record, Vol. 80, Page 3800 (March 16, 1936)
- ^ Senate hearings, pp. title page, 1–2.
- ^ Senate hearings, pp. 11–12.
- ^ Senate hearings, pp. 18–23.
- ^ "Authorize coinage of 50-cent pieces in commemoration of the two-hundred-and-fiftieth anniversary of the founding and settlement of New Rochelle, N.Y. (congressional report)". United States Senate. March 26, 1936. Retrieved December 22, 2019 – via ProQuest.
- ^ 1936 Congressional Record, Vol. 80, pp. 4489–90 (March 27, 1936; Archived May 23, 2019, at the Wayback Machine)
- ^ 1936 Congressional Record, Vol. 80, Page 5653 (April 17, 1936)
- ^ 1936 Congressional Record, Vol. 80, Page 6275 (April 27, 1936)
- ^ Bowers, p. 420.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 5–6.
- ^ a b Swiatek, p. 403.
- ^ Taxay, pp. v–vi, 194–96.
- ^ Skipton, p. 7.
- ^ Taxay, pp. 195, 199.
- ^ a b Taxay, pp. 199–200.
- ^ Skipton, p. 8.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 10–11.
- ^ Flynn, p. 306.
- ^ Swiatek, p. 402.
- ^ Skipton, p. unnumbered, following preface.
- ^ Fuljenz, p. 265.
- ^ a b Swiatek & Breen, pp. 169, 172.
- ^ Fuljenz, p. 266.
- ^ Skipton, p. 10.
- ^ a b Swiatek, p. 404.
- ^ Yeoman, pp. 1093–94.
- ^ Duffield, p. 305.
- ^ Bowers, pp. 420–21.
- ^ Vermeule, p. 203.
- ^ Vermeule, pp. 203–04.
- ^ Bowers, p. 421.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 12–13.
- ^ a b Bowers, pp. 421–24.
- ^ "Westchester County Coin Club". The Numismatist. American Numismatic Association: 532. June 1937. Archived from the original on June 18, 2021.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 23–26.
- ^ Skipton, pp. 19, 29–30.
- ^ Bowers, p. 422.
- ^ Kriss, Gary (July 3, 1988). "One Fatt Calfe". The New York Times. Archived from the original on June 18, 2021. Retrieved October 5, 2019.
Sources
- ISBN 978-0-943161-35-8.
- Duffield, Frank (uncredited) (April 1937). "New Rochelle commemorative half dollar". The Numismatist. American Numismatic Association: 305.
- Flynn, Kevin (2008). The Authoritative Reference on Commemorative Coins 1892–1954. OCLC 711779330.
- Fuljenz, Michael (February 1983). "The Fatt Calfe: New Rochelle's commemorative half dollar". The Numismatist. American Numismatic Association: 263–68.
- Skipton, Amy C. (1939). One Fatt Calfe. OCLC 181163409.
- Slabaugh, Arlie R. (1975). United States Commemorative Coinage (second ed.). ISBN 978-0-307-09377-6.
- Swiatek, Anthony (2012). Encyclopedia of the Commemorative Coins of the United States. ISBN 978-0-9817736-7-4.
- Swiatek, Anthony; ISBN 978-0-668-04765-4.
- ISBN 978-0-668-01536-3.
- United States Senate Committee on Banking and Currency (March 11, 1936). Coinage of commemorative 50-cent pieces. United States Government Printing Office.
- ISBN 978-0-674-62840-3.
- ISBN 978-0-7948-4580-3.