Nocebo
A nocebo effect is said to occur when negative expectations of the patient regarding a treatment cause the treatment to have a more negative effect than it otherwise would have.[1][2] For example, when a patient anticipates a side effect of a medication, they can experience that effect even if the "medication" is actually an inert substance.[1] The complementary concept, the placebo effect, is said to occur when positive expectations improve an outcome. The nocebo effect is also said to occur in someone who falls ill owing to the erroneous belief that they were exposed to a toxin, e.g. a physical phenomenon they believe is harmful, such as EM radiation.[3]
Both placebo and nocebo effects are presumably psychogenic, but they can induce measurable changes in the body.[1] One article that reviewed 31 studies on nocebo effects reported a wide range of symptoms that could manifest as nocebo effects, including nausea, stomach pains, itching, bloating, depression, sleep problems, loss of appetite, sexual dysfunction, and severe hypotension.[1]
Etymology and usage
The term nocebo (
Response
In the narrowest sense, a nocebo response occurs when a drug-trial subject's symptoms are worsened by the administration of an inert, sham,
The worsening of the subject's symptoms or reduction of beneficial effects is a direct consequence of their exposure to the placebo, but those symptoms have not been chemically generated by the placebo. Because this generation of symptoms entails a complex of "subject-internal" activities, in the strictest sense, we can never speak in terms of simulator-centered "nocebo effects", but only in terms of subject-centered "nocebo responses". Although some observers attribute nocebo responses (or placebo responses) to a subject's gullibility, there is no evidence that an individual who manifests a nocebo/placebo response to one treatment will manifest a nocebo/placebo response to any other treatment; i.e., there is no fixed nocebo/placebo-responding trait or propensity.[10]
McGlashan, Evans & Orne found no evidence in 1969 of what they termed a placebo personality.[11] Also, in a carefully designed study, Lasagna, Mosteller, von Felsinger and Beecher in 1954,[12] found that there was no way that any observer could determine, by testing or by interview, which subject would manifest a placebo reaction and which would not. Experiments have shown that no relationship exists between an individual's measured hypnotic susceptibility and their manifestation of nocebo or placebo responses.[13][14][15]
Based on a biosemiotic model (2022), Goli explains how harm and/or healing expectations lead to a multimodal image and form transient allostatic or homeostatic interoceptive feelings, demonstrating how repetitive experiences of a potential body induce epigenetic changes and form new attractors, such as nocebos and placeboes, in the actual body.[16]
Effects
Side effects of drugs
It has been shown that, due to the nocebo effect, warning patients about side effects of drugs can contribute to the causation of such effects, whether the drug is real or not.[17][18] This effect has been observed in clinical trials: according to a 2013 review, the dropout rate among placebo-treated patients in a meta-analysis of 41 clinical trials of Parkinson's disease treatments was 8.8%.[19] A 2013 review found that nearly 1 out of 20 patients receiving a placebo in clinical trials for depression dropped out due to adverse events, which were believed to have been caused by the nocebo effect.[20]
In January 2022, a systematic review and meta-analysis concluded that nocebo responses accounted for 72% of adverse effects after the first COVID-19 vaccine dose and 52% after the second dose.[21][22]
Many studies show that the formation of nocebo responses are influenced by inappropriate health education, media work, and other discourse makers who induce health anxiety and negative expectations.[23]
Electromagnetic hypersensitivity
Evidence suggests that the symptoms of electromagnetic hypersensitivity are caused by the nocebo effect.[24][25]
Pain
Verbal suggestion can cause hyperalgesia (increased sensitivity to pain) and allodynia (perception of a tactile stimulus as painful) as a result of the nocebo effect.[26] Nocebo hyperalgesia is believed to involve the activation of cholecystokinin receptors.[27]
Ambiguity of medical usage
Stewart-Williams and Podd argue that using the contrasting terms "placebo" and "nocebo" to label inert agents that produce pleasant, health-improving, or desirable outcomes versus unpleasant, health-diminishing, or undesirable outcomes (respectively), is extremely counterproductive.
A second problem is that the same effect, such as
Ambiguity of anthropological usage
Some people maintain that belief kills (e.g.,
Certain anthropologists, such as Robert Hahn and Arthur Kleinman, have extended the placebo/nocebo distinction into this realm in order to allow a distinction to be made between rituals, like faith healing, that are performed in order to heal, cure, or bring benefit (placebo rituals) and others, like "pointing the bone", that are performed in order to kill, injure or bring harm (nocebo rituals). As the meaning of the two inter-related and opposing terms has extended, we now find anthropologists speaking, in various contexts, of nocebo or placebo (harmful or helpful) rituals:[34]
- that might entail nocebo or placebo (unpleasant or pleasant) procedures;
- about which subjects might have nocebo or placebo (harmful or beneficial) beliefs;
- that are delivered by operators that might have nocebo or placebo (pathogenic, disease-generating or salutogenic, health-promoting) expectations;
- that are delivered to subjects that might have nocebo or placebo (negative, fearful, despairing or positive, hopeful, confident) expectations about the ritual;
- which are delivered by operators who might have nocebo or placebo (malevolent or benevolent) intentions, in the hope that the rituals will generate nocebo or placebo (lethal, injurious, harmful or restorative, curative, healthy) outcomes; and, that all of this depends upon the operator's overall beliefs in the harmful nature of the nocebo ritual or the beneficial nature of the placebo ritual.
Yet it may become even more terminologically complex, for as Hahn and Kleinman indicate, there can also be cases where there are
Ethics
A number of researchers have pointed out that the harm caused by communicating with patients about potential treatment
See also
- Autosuggestion
- Clinical trial
- Placebo studies
- Psychosomatic illness
- Scientific control
- Self-fulfilling prophecy
- Subject-expectancy effect
- Suggestibility
- Suggestion
- Therapeutic effect
- Thomas theorem
Notes
- ^ a b c d Häuser, Hansen & Enck 2012.
- ^ Enck & Häuser 2012.
- ISBN 978-3030407452.
- Perseus Project.
- Perseus Project.
- ^ a b Kennedy 1961.
- ^ Benedetti et al. 2007.
- ^ Miller 2003.
- ^ Bingel et al. 2011.
- PMID 25006673.
- ^ McGlashan, Evans & Orne 1969, p. 319.
- ^ Lasagna et al. 1954.
- ^ McGlashan, Evans & Orne 1969.
- ^ Stam 1982.
- ^ Stam & Spanos 1987.
- ISBN 978-3-031-17677-7
- ^ Colloca & Miller 2011.
- ^ Barsky et al. 2002.
- ^ Stathis et al. 2013.
- ^ Mitsikostas, Mantonakis & Chalarakis 2014.
- PMID 35040967.
- ^ Smith, Ian (19 January 2022). "'Nocebo effect' cause of most COVID vaccine side effects, study says". euronews.
- ISBN 978-3-319-35091-2
- ^ Rubin, Nieto-Hernandez & Wessely 2009.
- ^ Geary, James (4 March 2010). "The Man Who Was Allergic to Radio Waves". Popular Science. Retrieved 1 December 2014.
- S2CID 44220488.
- ^ Enck, Benedetti & Schedlowski 2008.
- ^ a b c d Stewart-Williams & Podd 2004.
- ^ Colloca & Benedetti 2007.
- ^ Cannon 1942.
- ^ Zusne & Jones 1989, p. 57.
- ^ Róheim 1925.
- ^ Rubel 1964.
- ^ a b Hahn & Kleinman 1983.
- ^ Milton 1973.
- S2CID 45271769.
- PMID 22318275.
References
- Barber, Theodore Xenophon (1961). "Death by suggestion. A critical note". Psychosomatic Medicine. 23: 153–155. S2CID 5451746.
- Barker, J.C. (1968). Scared to Death: An Examination of Fear, its Cause and Effects. London: Frederick Muller.
- Barrett, G. V.; Franke, R. H. (1970). "'Psychogenic' Death: A Reappraisal". Science. 167 (3916): 304–306. S2CID 31798499.
- Barsky, Arthur J.; Saintfort, R.; Rogers, M. P.; Borus, J. F. (2002). "Nonspecific Medication Side Effects and the Nocebo Phenomenon". JAMA. 287 (5): 622–7. PMID 11829702.
- Benedetti, F.; Lanotte, M.; Lopiano, L.; Colloca, L. (2007). "When words are painful: Unraveling the mechanisms of the nocebo effect". Neuroscience. 147 (2): 260–271. S2CID 7737716.
- Cannon, Walter B. (1942). "'Voodoo' Death". American Anthropologist. 44 (2): 169–181. .
- Charcot, J.M. (January 1893). "The Faith-Cure". The New Review. 8 (44): 18–31.
- Cohen, Sanford I. (1985). "Psychosomatic death: Voodoo death in a modern perspective". Integrative Psychiatry. 3 (1): 46–51.
- Colloca, Luana; Miller, Franklin G. (2011). "The Nocebo Effect and its Relevance for Clinical Practice". Psychosomatic Medicine. 73 (7): 598–603. PMID 21862825.
- Colloca, Luana; Benedetti, Fabrizio (2007). "Nocebo hyperalgesia: How anxiety is turned into pain". Current Opinion in Anesthesiology. 20 (5): 435–439. S2CID 24905510.
- Dein, Simon (2003). "Psychogenic death: Individual effects of sorcery and taboo violation". Mental Health, Religion & Culture. 6 (3): 195–202. S2CID 144763261.
- Blasi, Zelda Di; Harkness, Elaine; Ernst, Edzard; Georgiou, Amanda; Kleijnen, Jos (2001). "Influence of context effects on health outcomes: A systematic review". The Lancet. 357 (9258): 757–762. S2CID 6740675.
- Enck, Paul; Benedetti, Fabrizio; Schedlowski, Manfred (2008). "New Insights into the Placebo and Nocebo Responses". Neuron. 59 (2): 195–206. S2CID 2614166.
- Enck, Paul; Häuser, Winfried (10 August 2012). "Beware the Nocebo Effect". The New York Times.
- Goddard, Henry H. (1899). "The Effects of Mind on Body as Evidenced by Faith Cures". The American Journal of Psychology. 10 (3): 431–502. JSTOR 1412143.
- Hahn, Robert A. (1997). "The Nocebo Phenomenon: Concept, Evidence, and Implications for Public Health". Preventive Medicine. 26 (5): 607–611. S2CID 42723963.
- Hahn, Robert A.; Kleinman, Arthur (1983). "Perspectives of the Placebo Phenomenon: Belief as Pathogen, Belief as Medicine: 'Voodoo Death' and the 'Placebo Phenomenon' in Anthropological Perspective". Medical Anthropology Quarterly. 14 (4): 3–19. .
- Harrington, E.R. (1998), The Nocebo Effect: A Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Suggestion on Reports of Physical Symptoms (PhD Dissertation), Temple University
- Häuser, Winfried; Hansen, Ernil; Enck, Paul (2012). "Nocebo Phenomena in Medicine". Deutsches Ärzteblatt Online. 109 (26): 459–465. PMID 22833756.
- Houston, W. R. (1938). "The Doctor Himself as a Therapeutic Agent". Annals of Internal Medicine. 11 (8): 1416. .
- Kennedy, WP (1961). "The nocebo reaction". Medical World. 95: 203–205. PMID 13752532.
- Kirsch, Irving (1985). "Response expectancy as a determinant of experience and behavior". American Psychologist. 40 (11): 1189–1202. .
- Kirsch, Irving (1997). "Response expectancy theory and application: A decennial review". Applied and Preventive Psychology. 6 (2): 69–79. .
- Lasagna, Louis; Mosteller, Frederick; von Felsinger, John M.; Beecher, Henry K. (1954). "A study of the placebo response". The American Journal of Medicine. 16 (6): 770–779. PMID 13158365.
- Lorenz, Jürgen; Hauck, Michael; Paur, Robert C.; Nakamura, Yoko; Zimmermann, Roger; Bromm, Burkhart; Engel, Andreas K. (2005). "Cortical correlates of false expectations during pain intensity judgments—a possible manifestation of placebo/nocebo cognitions". Brain, Behavior, and Immunity. 19 (4): 283–295. S2CID 40078373.
- S2CID 45824998.
- Merton, Robert K. (1936). "The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action". American Sociological Review. 1 (6): 894–904. S2CID 8005707.
- Miller, Franklin G. (2005). "William James, Faith, and the Placebo Effect". Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. 48 (2): 273–281. S2CID 37123891.
- Miller, Franklin G. (2003). "Sham Surgery: An Ethical Analysis". The American Journal of Bioethics. 3 (4): 41–48. S2CID 2223466.
- Milton, G.W. (1973). "Self-Willed Death or the Bone-Pointing Syndrome". The Lancet. 301 (7817): 1435–1436. PMID 4122997.
- Mitsikostas, Dimos D.; Mantonakis, Leonidas; Chalarakis, Nikolaos (2014). "Nocebo in clinical trials for depression: A meta-analysis". Psychiatry Research. 215 (1): 82–86. S2CID 24653639.
- Murray, Danielle; Stoessl, A. Jon (2013). "Mechanisms and therapeutic implications of the placebo effect in neurological and psychiatric conditions". Pharmacology & Therapeutics. 140 (3): 306–318. PMID 23880289.
- Perlman, Lawrence M. (2001). "Nonspecific, unintended, and serendipitous effects in psychotherapy". Professional Psychology: Research and Practice. 32 (3): 283–288. .
- Phillips, D. P.; Liu, G. C.; Kwok, K.; Jarvinen, J. R.; Zhang, W.; Abramson, I. S. (2001). "The Hound of the Baskervilles effect: Natural experiment on the influence of psychological stress on timing of death". BMJ. 323 (7327): 1443–1446. PMID 11751347.
- Pyysiainen, Ilkka (2002). "Mind and Miracles". Zygon. 37 (3): 729–740. .
- Rief, Winfried; Avorn, Jerry; Barsky, Arthur J. (2006). "Medication-Attributed Adverse Effects in Placebo Groups". Archives of Internal Medicine. 166 (2): 155–160. PMID 16432082.
- Richter, Curt P. (1957). "On the Phenomenon of Sudden Death in Animals and Man". Psychosomatic Medicine. 19 (3): 191–198. S2CID 41952151.
- Róheim, G (1925). "The Pointing Bone". The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. 55: 90–114. JSTOR 2843694.
- Rubel, Authur J. (1964). "The Epidemiology of a Folk Illness: Susto in Hispanic America". Ethnology. 3 (3): 268–283. JSTOR 3772883.
- Rubin, G. James; Nieto-Hernandez, Rosa; Wessely, Simon (2009). "Idiopathic environmental intolerance attributed to electromagnetic fields (formerly 'electromagnetic hypersensitivity'): An updated systematic review of provocation studies". Bioelectromagnetics. 31 (1): 1–11. S2CID 10993481.
- Shapiro, Arthur K. (2007). "A contribution to a history of the placebo effect". Behavioral Science. 5 (2): 109–135. .
- Shapiro, Arthur K. (1968). "Semantics of the placebo". The Psychiatric Quarterly. 42 (4): 653–695. S2CID 2733947.
- South, Robert (1727). "A Sermon Delivered at Christ-Church, Oxon., Before the University, Octob. 14. 1688: Prov.XII.22 Lying Lips are abomination to the Lord". Twelve Sermons Preached Upon Several Occasions. Vol. I (6th ed.). London: J. Bettenham. pp. 458–500.
- Spiegel, Herbert (1997). "Nocebo: The Power of Suggestibility". Preventive Medicine. 26 (5): 616–621. S2CID 7017712.
- Staats, Peter; Hekmat, Hamid; Staats, Arthur (1998). "Suggestion/Placebo Effects on Pain". Journal of Pain and Symptom Management. 15 (4): 235–243. PMID 9601159.
- Stam, Henderikus (1982). Hypnotic analgesia and the placebo effect: controlling ischemic pain (PhD thesis). Carleton University. .
- Stam, Henderikus J.; Spanos, Nicholas P. (1987). "Hypnotic analgesia, placebo analgesia, and ischemic pain: The effects of contextual variables". Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 96 (4): 313–320. PMID 3693680.
- Stathis, P.; Smpiliris, M.; Konitsiotis, S.; Mitsikostas, D. D. (2013). "Nocebo as a potential confounding factor in clinical trials for Parkinson's disease treatment: A meta-analysis". European Journal of Neurology. 20 (3): 527–533. S2CID 41163200.
- Stewart-Williams, Steve; Podd, John (2004). "The Placebo Effect: Dissolving the Expectancy Versus Conditioning Debate". Psychological Bulletin. 130 (2): 324–340. S2CID 10297875.
- Bingel, U.; Wanigasekera, V.; Wiech, K.; Ni Mhuircheartaigh, R.; Lee, M. C.; Ploner, M.; S2CID 207775719.
- Wilson, Ian (1991). The Bleeding Mind: An Investigation into the Mysterious Phenomenon of Stigmata. London: Paladin. ISBN 978-0-586-09014-5.
- Zusne, L.; Jones, W.H. (1989). Anomalistic Psychology: A Study of Magical Thinking (2nd ed.). New York: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
External links
- Nocebo and nocebo effect
- The nocebo response
- The Nocebo Effect: Placebo's Evil Twin
- What modifies a healing response
- The science of voodoo: When mind attacks body, New Scientist
- The Effect of Treatment Expectation on Drug Efficacy: Imaging the Analgesic Benefit of the Opioid Remifentanil
- This Video Will Hurt (The Nocebo Effect), via YouTube
- BBC Discovery program on the nocebo effect
- What is the Nocebo effect?