Pierre Gassendi
17th-century philosophy | |
---|---|
Region | Western philosophy |
School |
|
Institutions | University of Aix-en-Provence Collège Royal |
Main interests | Philosophical logic, physics, ethics |
Notable ideas | Calor vitalis (vital heat) |
Part of a series on |
Catholic philosophy |
---|
|
Pierre Gassendi (French:
He wrote numerous philosophical works, and some of the positions he worked out are considered significant, finding a way between
Biography
Early life
Gassendi was born at
He lectured principally on the Aristotelian philosophy, conforming as far as possible to the traditional methods while he also followed with interest the discoveries of Galileo and Kepler. He came into contact with the astronomer Joseph Gaultier de la Vallette (1564–1647), the Grand Vicar of the Archbishopric of Aix.[14]
Priesthood
In 1623 the
He spent some time with his patron
During this time he wrote some works, at the insistence of Marin Mersenne. They included his examination of the mystical philosophy of Robert Fludd,[20] an essay on parhelia,[21] and some observations on the transit of Mercury.
1640s
Gassendi then spent some years travelling through Provence with the duke of Angoulême, governor of the region. During this period he wrote only the one literary work, his Life of Peiresc, whose death in 1637 seemed to afflict him deeply;[22] it received frequent reprintings and an English translation. He returned to Paris in 1641, where he met Thomas Hobbes.[23] He gave some informal philosophy classes, gaining pupils or disciples; according to the biographer Grimarest, these included Molière, Cyrano de Bergerac (whose participation in classes is disputed),[24] Jean Hesnault and Claude-Emmanuel Chapelle, son of Lullier.[25][26]
In 1640 Mersenne engaged him in controversy with
In 1645 he accepted the chair of mathematics in the
In 1648 ill-health compelled him to give up his lectures at the Collège Royal. Around this time he became reconciled to Descartes, after years of coldness, through the good offices of César d'Estrées.[34]
Death and memorial
He travelled in the south of France, in the company of his
Scientific achievements
As part of his promotion of empirical methods and his anti-Aristotelian and anti-Cartesian views, he was responsible for a number of scientific 'firsts':
- He explained parheliain 1629 as due to ice crystals.
- In 1631, Gassendi became the first person to observe the transit of a planet across the Sun, viewing the Kepler had predicted. In December of the same year, he watched for the transit of Venus, but this event occurred when it was night time in Paris.
- Use of camera obscura to gauge the apparent diameter of the Moon.
- Dropping a stone from the mast of a ship (in De motu) conserves horizontal momentum, removing an objection to the rotation of the Earth.
- Measurement of speed of sound (to about 25% accuracy), showing that it is invariant of pitch.
- Satisfactory interpretation of Pascal's Puy-de-Dôme experiment with a barometer in the late 1640s; this suggested a created vacuum is possible.
- He asserted and defended (in "Syntagma philosophiae Epicuri", 1649, see Philosophical Writings below) the notion that matter is made of atoms, following Epicurus.
In addition to this he did work on determining longitude via eclipses of the Moon and on improving the Rudolphine Tables. He addressed the issue of free fall in De motu (1642) and De proportione qua gravia decidentia accelerantur (1646).[36]
Writings
Edward Gibbon styled him "Le meilleur philosophe des littérateurs, et le meilleur littérateur des philosophes" (The greatest philosopher among literary men, and the greatest literary man among philosophers).
Exercitationes
The Exercitationes excited much attention, though they contain little or nothing beyond what others had already advanced against Aristotle. The first book expounds clearly, and with much vigour, the evil effects of the blind acceptance of the Aristotelian dicta on physical and philosophical study; but, as occurs with so many of the anti-Aristotelian works of this period, the objections show the usual ignorance of Aristotle's own writings[citation needed]. The second book, which contains the review of Aristotle's dialectic or logic, throughout reflects Ramism in tone and method. One of the objections to Descartes became famous through Descartes's statement of it in the appendix of objections in the Meditations.
Animadversiones
His book Animadversiones, published in 1649, contains a translation of
In the book, he maintains his maxim "that there is nothing in the intellect which has not been in the senses" (nihil est in intellectu quod non prius fuerit in sensu), but he contends that the imaginative faculty (phantasia) is the counterpart of sense, because it involves material images, and therefore is intrinsically material, and that it is essentially the same both in men and brutes. However, he also admits that the classic qualifier of humanity, intellect, which he affirms as immaterial and immortal, comes to an understanding of notions and truths that no effort of sensation or imagination could have attained (Op. ii. 383). He illustrates the capacity to form "general notions"; the conception of universality (ib. 384), which he says brutes never are able to partake in, though they utilize phantasia as truly as men; the notion of God, whom he says we may imagine as corporeal, but understand as incorporeal; and lastly, the reflex by which the mind makes the phenomena and operations within it the objects of its attention.
The English Epicurean Walter Charleton produced an English free adaptation of this book, Physiologia Epicuro-Gassendo-Charletonia, in 1654.[36]
Syntagma philosophicum
The Syntagma philosophicum sub-divides, according to the usual fashion of the
, is truly canonic), physics and ethics.The logic contains a sketch of the history of the science De origine et varietate logicae, and is divided into theory of right apprehension (bene imaginari), theory of right judgment (bene proponere), theory of right inference (bene colligere), theory of right method (bene ordinare). The first part contains the specially empirical positions which Gassendi afterwards neglects or leaves out of account. The senses, the sole source of knowledge, supposedly yield us immediate cognition of individual things; phantasy (which Gassendi takes as material in nature) reproduces these ideas; understanding compares these ideas, each particular, and frames general ideas. Nevertheless, he admits that the senses yield knowledge—not of things—but of qualities only, and that we arrive at the idea of thing or substance by
In the second part of the Syntagma, the physics, appears the most glaring contradiction between Gassendi's fundamental principles. While approving of the Epicurean physics, he rejects the Epicurean negation of God and
claimed that all this portion of Gassendi's system contains nothing of his own opinions, but is introduced solely from motives of self-defence.The positive exposition of
In the third part, the ethics, over and above the discussion on freedom, which on the whole is indefinite, there is little beyond a milder statement of the Epicurean moral code. The final end of life is happiness, and happiness is harmony of soul and body (tranquillitas animi et indolentia corporis). Probably, Gassendi thinks, perfect happiness is not attainable in this life, but it may be in the life to come.
Views
According to
There remains some controversy as to the extent to which Gassendi subscribed to the so-called libertinage érudit, the learned
In his dispute with Descartes he did apparently hold that the evidence of the senses remains the only convincing evidence; yet he maintains, as is natural from his mathematical training, that the evidence of reason is absolutely satisfactory.
Vegetarianism
Gassendi acknowledged that while the complete realisation of the continual pursuit of ultimate pleasure through communion with God might not occur in one's lifetime, he argued against the consumption of meat, considering it a significant obstacle to achieving a divine vision. Drawing support from scripture and the natural world, he envisioned a restored paradise where humans and animals coexisted in peaceful dominion, contrary to the tyranny displayed in the butchering of animals for pleasure.[2]
Gassendi supported his case for vegetarianism with arguments from medicine, history, and scripture. Inspired by Neoplatonic vegetarians and early Christian thinkers, he aligned vegetarianism with Christian doctrines, emphasizing the immortality of the soul. Gassendi, a Catholic priest, advocated for a plant-based diet without dogmatism, asserting that decisions in this lifetime were crucial for preparing the body and mind for the next. He admired the historical virtue of vegetarian practitioners and urged scholars to extract and follow the best ideas from throughout history, asserting that, especially among humanists, a vegetarian lifestyle should be embraced.[2]
Gassendi himself was not a vegetarian, but admitted that "if I were wise, I would abandon this food bit by bit, and nourish myself solely on the gifts on the earth ... I do not doubt that I would be happier for longer and more constantly in better health."[42]
Early commentary
See also
- Ontological pluralism
- List of Roman Catholic scientist-clerics
Notes
- ^ a b c Fisher, Saul (August 28, 2014). "Pierre Gassendi". In Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University – via Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- ^ Vere Claiborne Chappell(ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Locke, Cambridge University Press, 1994, p. 56.
- ^ Peter Harrison, The Fall of Man and the Foundations of Science, Cambridge University Press, p. 220: "There has been considerable discussion in the secondary literature about the impact of Boyle's theological voluntatism on his approach to natural philosophy."
- ^ Caruso 1981, p. 443.
- ISBN 978-2-8011-0581-8.
- ISBN 978-94-010-8187-0– via link.springer.com.
- ^ "Brundell, B., Pierre Gassendi from Aristotelianism to a New Natural Philosophy, D. Reidel Publishing, 1987" (PDF).
- ISBN 978-0-387-31022-0. Retrieved August 22, 2012.
- ^ a b Fisquet, p. 249.
- ^ Bougerel (1737), p. 6.
- ^ Ferdinand Belin (1896). Histoire de l'ancienne université de Provence, ou Histoire de la fameuse université d'Aix: période. 1409-1679 (in French). Paris: A. Picard et fils. pp. 183, 340–341.
- ^ "Pierre Gassendi - Biography". Maths History.
- ^ Fisquet, p. 250.
- ^ Bougerel (1737), pp. 8-9. Dictionary of Scientific Biography, Gassendi (Gassend), Pierre, retrieved: 2017-08-02.
- ^ J J O'Connor and E F Robertson, Pierre Gassendi, retrieved: 2017-08-02 [self-published source]
- ^ Bougerel, p. 15.
- ^ a b Galileo Project page. Bougerel, p. 15.
- ^ The Archimedes Project, Gassendi, Pierre (actually Pierre Gassend) Archived 2012-02-20 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ Fisquet, pp. 248, 252, 256.
- ^ Epistolica Exercitatio, in qua precipua principia philosophiae Roberti Fluddi deteguntur, 1631.
- ^ Epistola de parheliis.
- ^ a b "Gassendi - Pierre Gassendi - Biography - Information - Links - Dr Robert A. Hatch".
- ^ Patricia Springborg (editor), The Cambridge Companion to Hobbes's Leviathan (2007), p. 422.
- ^ "www.paulvates.com". www.paulvates.com.
- ^ "LoveToKnow: Advice you can trust". Archived from the original on 2009-01-25. Retrieved 2009-01-07.
- ^ "Encyclopedie de l'Agora".
- ^ Nolan, Lawrence (August 28, 2021). "Descartes' Ontological Argument". In Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University – via Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- ^ Gassendi, Pierre (1644). Disquisito metaphysica, seu dubitationes et instantiae adversus Renati Cartesii metaphysicam et responsa (in Latin). Vrin.
- ISBN 978-1-60384-350-8.
- ^ Cottinghm, Stoothof, Murdoch, Vol. II, CUP 1984, pp. 234-237
- ISBN 978-2-7116-1306-9.
- ^ De vita, moribus, et placitis Epicuri, seu Animadversiones in X. librum Diog. Laër. Lyons, 1649; last edition, 1675.
- ^ Lyons, 1649; Amsterdam, 1684.
- ^ Desmond M. Clarke, Descartes: A Biography (2006), p. 377.
- ^ "THE ESSENTIAL GUIDE TO ASTRONOMY - Moon map" (PDF).
- ^ a b c Fisher, Saul (2009). "Pierre Gassendi". Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- ^ Geschichte des Materialismus, 3rd ed., i. 233.
- ^ Richard Popkin, The History of Scepticism from Erasmus to Spinoza (1979), p. 104.
- ^ Keith Thomas, Religion and the Decline of Magic (1973), p. 418 and p. 770.
- ^ "Ueberweg". Archived from the original on 2009-02-03. Retrieved 2009-01-06.
- ^ Amesbury, Richard Fideism Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 26 September 2012
- ISSN 1091-2339. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
- ^ "Scepticism - Lecture 7b". Archived from the original on 2012-02-14. Retrieved 2023-08-09.
References
- Seventeenth to nineteenth-century commentary
- Bougerel, Joseph (1737). Vie de Pierre Gassendi (in French). Paris: Imprimerie de Jacques Vincent.
- Johann Gottlieb Buhle, Geschichte der neuern Philosophie, (1802) iii. 1, 87-222
- Jean Philibert Damiron, Mémoires pour servir à l'histoire de la philosophie au XVIIe siècle (1864)
- Feuerbach, Ludwig (1833). Geschichte der neuern Philosophie von Bacon von Verulam bis Benedict Spinoza. Ansbach: C. Brügel. pp. 127–150. Retrieved 2012-02-05.
- Fisquet, Honoré (1864). La France pontificale: Metropole d'Aix: Digne, 1re partie: Digne et Riez (Paris: Étienne Repos 1864).
- C. Güttler, "Gassend oder Gassendi?" in Archiv für Geschichte d. Philos. x. (1897), pp. 238–242.
- F. X. Kiefl, P. Gassendis Erkenninistheorie and seine Stellung zum Materialismus (1893) and "Gassendi's Skepticismus" in Philos. Jahrb. vi. (1893)
- Heinrich Ritter, Geschichte der Philosophie, (1851) X. 543-571
- Pierre-Félix Thomas, La Philosophie de Gassendi (Paris, 1889)
- Twentieth- and twenty-first-century commentary
- Caruso, Esther (1981). "Sul nominalismo di Gassendi". Rivista critica di storia della filosofia. 36 (4): 438–450. JSTOR 44022083.
- Alberti Antonina (1988). Sensazione e realtà. Epicuro e Gassendi, Florence, Leo Olschki. ISBN 88-222-3608-4
- Olivier Bloch (1971). La philosophie de Gassendi. Nominalisme, matérialisme et métaphysique, La Haye, Martinus Nijhoff, ISBN 90-247-5035-0
- George Sidney Brett (1908). Philosophy of Gassendi, London, Macmillan
- Barry Brundell (1987). Pierre Gassendi. From Aristotelianism to a New Natural Philosophy, Dordrecht, Springer
- Franz Daxecker (2004). The Physicist and Astronomer Christoph Scheiner: Biography, Letters, Works, Innsbruck, Publikations of Innsbruck University 246, ISBN 3-901249-69-9
- Saul Fisher (2005). Pierre Gassendi's Philosophy and Science, Leiden/Boston, Brill. ISBN 978-90-04-11996-3
- Lynn Sumida Joy (1987). Gassendi the Atomist: Advocate of History in an Age of Science, Cambridge, UK/New York, Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-52239-0
- Antonia Lolordo (2007). Pierre Gassendi and the Birth of Early Modern Philosophy, Cambridge, UK/New York, Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-86613-2
- Marco Messeri (1985). Causa e spiegazione. La fisica di Pierre Gassendi, Milan, Franco Angeli. ISBN 88-204-4045-8
- Margaret J. Osler (1994). Divine Will and the Mechanical Philosophy: Gassendi and Descartes on Contingency and Necessity in the Created World, Cambridge, UK/New York, Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-46104-9
- Rolf W. Puster (1991). Britische Gassendi-Rezeption am Beispiel John Lockes, Frommann-Holzboog. ISBN 3-7728-1362-3
- Lisa T. Sarasohn (1996). Gassendi's Ethics: Freedom in a Mechanistic Universe. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
- Reiner Tack (1974). Untersuchungen zum Philosophie- und Wissenschaftsbegriff bei Pierre Gassendi: (1592–1655), Meisenheim (am Glan), Hain. ISBN 3-445-01103-6
- Pierre Gassendi (1654). The Life of Copernicus (1473–1543). The Man Who Did Not Change the World, with notes by Oliver Thill, XulonPress, 2002,
- Tertiary sources
- public domain: Adamson, Robert (1911). "Gassendi, Pierre". Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 11 (11th ed.). pp. 503–504. This article incorporates text from a publication now in the
External links
- Media related to Pierre Gassendi at Wikimedia Commons
- Works by or about Pierre Gassendi at Wikisource
- Quotations related to Pierre Gassendi at Wikiquote
- Works by Pierre Gassendi at Open Library
- Fisher, Saul. "Pierre Gassendi". In Zalta, Edward N. (ed.). Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
- De proportione qua gravia decidentia accelerantur (1646)
- Concerning Happiness
- MathPages - Mercurius in Sole Visus
- Timeline