Pittsburgh Town
"Pittsburgh Town", sometimes titled as "Pittsburgh" or "Pittsburgh is a Great Old Town", is a folk song written by
Creation
There are several stories behind the origin of the song. Several historians trace "Pittsburgh Town" to the
The liner notes of Seeger's Songs of Struggle and Protest, 1930–50 tell a different story of the song's creation;[5] they state that Guthrie wrote the song while airborne on a flight into Pittsburgh. While looking out the window at the smoky skies, he quickly jotted down the lyrics.[6]
Lyrics and themes
Pittsburgh town is a smoky ol' town
Solid iron from McKeesport down[7]
The song's verses alternate between ones that speak of the environmental problems of Pittsburgh and ones that speak of its labor problems.
The first verse refers to Pittsburgh as a "smoky ol' town", and the third complains that the speaker does nothing more than "cough and choke" because of the steel industry's output.[8] The smoke was an ever-present part of life in Pittsburgh at the time of the song's writing; steel mills on the banks of the city's three rivers made the sky glow red and continually released smoke.[4] Modern environmentalist reviewers of the song believe that the pollution-oriented verses show that the song was written to protest the environmental conditions in which workers were forced to live.[9]
The second and fourth verses focus on the labor disputes that the city was experiencing at the time. The second verse uses a pun on the name of Jones and Laughlin Steel to ask what the company stole from its workers ("What did Jones and Laughlin steal?"),[4] while the fourth and final verse ends with the statement that all of the mill workers are "joining up with the CIO."[10]
Recordings and adaptations
The song has been covered by several artists and community groups. Pete Seeger Released a studio version on his 1956 album American Industrial Ballads[11] and a live version of the song on his 1964 album Songs of Struggle and Protest, 1930–50.[12] Both versions by Seeger feature him singing and playing the banjo without any additional accompaniment. In the live version, the crowd's clapping and singing along can be heard. Folk bands in the Pittsburgh area, such as the NewLanders, have both recorded and performed Seeger's version of the song.[10]
Composer Paul Hindemith's Pittsburgh Symphony, written in 1958 for the 200th anniversary of the city's founding, quotes the melody of Pittsburgh Town, named "Pittsburgh Is a Great Old Town" by the composer, in the final movement.[13] Gunther Schuller described the use of the tune in the symphony in his review as "the ultimate in paucity of imagination and tastelessness."[14] However, Stephen Luttmann felt that Schuller's criticism misses the point of why Hindemith decided to the motif.[15]
In 1959, Vivien Richman released an adaptation of the song on her album Vivien Richman Sings Folk Songs of West Pennsylvania;[16] her version of the song includes several additional verses about the landscape and geography of the region. The song has also been covered by students at Pittsburgh Public Schools,[11] using verses that are less political than the original Guthrie composition and closer to the Richman version than the Seeger version. The change in verses was partly because by the middle of the 1950s, enforcement of the Smoke Control Ordinance of 1941 cleaned up the air.[16] Lyrics about the smokiness of the town were replaced with the line "Pittsburgh Town is a Great Old Town."
References
Footnotes
- ^ a b Jackson 2007, p. 106
- ^ Silber 1992, pp. 1, 6
- ^ Cray & Terkel 2006, p. 221
- ^ a b c d Cray & Terkel 2006, p. 222
- ^ Cohen 2012, p. 34
- ^ Seeger 1964, p. 2
- ^ Seeger 1964, p. 7
- ^ Longhurst 2010, Ch. 2 p. 1
- ^ Longhurst 2010, Ch. 2 p. 2
- ^ a b Potter 2005
- ^ a b Silber 1992, p. 6
- ^ Ruhlmann 2013
- ^ Leonard
- ^ Luttmann 2009, p. 278 quoting Schuller 1961, p. 143
- ^ Luttmann 2009, p. 278
- ^ a b Richman 1959, p. 8
Bibliography
- Cohen, Ronald (2012). Woody Guthrie. London: Routledge. ISBN 978-1-135-76935-2.
- Cray, Ed; Terkel, Studs (2006). Ramblin' Man: The Life and Times of Woody Guthrie. New York: W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 978-0-393-32736-6.
- Jackson, Mark Allan (2007). Prophet Singer: The Voice and Vision of Woody Guthrie. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi. ISBN 978-1-60473-146-0.
- Leonard, James. "Pittsburgh Symphony, for orchestra". AllMusic. Retrieved 18 November 2019.
- Longhurst, James (2005). "1 to 100: Creating an Air Quality Index in Pittsburgh". Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 106 (1–3): 27–42. S2CID 29896372.
- ——— (2007). "Smoky Ol' Town: The Significance of Pittsburgh in U.S. Air Pollution History". EM Magazine (June).
- ——— (2010). Citizen Environmentalists. Lebanon, NH: University Press of New England. ISBN 978-1-58465-859-7.
- Luttmann, Stephen (2009). Paul Hindemith: a Research and Information Guide (2nd ed.). New York: Routledge. ISBN 978-0415994163.
- Potter, Chris (2005). "Other cities have had songs about them: Has Pittsburgh?". Pittsburgh City Paper. Retrieved 17 February 2013.
- Richman, Vivien (1959). Vivien Richman Sings Folk Songs of West Pennsylvania (liner notes). Vivien Richman. Washington DC: Folkways Records. ASIN B000S9AIFK.
- Ruhlmann, William (2013). "Songs of Struggle & Protest: 1930-1950". AllMusic. Retrieved 21 May 2013.
- Schuller, Gunther (1961). "Review of Pittsburgh Symphony". Notes. 1.
- Seeger, Pete (1964). Songs of Struggle and Protest, 1930–50 (liner notes). Pete Seeger. Washington DC: Folkways Records. ASIN B00242VPWY.
- ——— (1992). American Industrial Ballads (liner notes). Pete Seeger. Washington DC: Folkways Records. ASIN B000001DIW.
External links