Federalism in Quebec
This article needs additional citations for verification. (April 2011) |
Federalism in Quebec (French: Fédéralisme au Québec) is concerned with the support of confederation in regards to the federal union of Canada: that is, support for the principles and/or political system of the government of Canada (status quo). This issue has been summarized as revolving around the concepts of Quebec remaining within Canada and opposition to the desires of Quebec sovereigntists.
Throughout the
Supporters of independence point to their belief that Quebec is a
Most major federal political parties, including the
Historical context
This article needs additional citations for verification. (June 2021) |
The idea that the
Ideological branches
While the usual denomination for all followers is simply federalist, two main branches can be sketched out.
Quebec nationalist federalism and autonomism
Federalist Quebec nationalists defend the concept of Quebec remaining within
The
Recently, the Université de Montréal political philosopher Charles Blattberg has put forward a series of arguments aimed at integrating Québécois nationalism within a renewed Canadian federalism, one that recognizes Canada's multi-national character.[1]
The centre-right, autonomist and Quebec nationalist
More recently at the federal level, the
On the Right, former the Progressive Conservative Party leader and prime minister Joe Clark (who also opposed the Clarity Act), and some Quebec figures within the modern Conservative Party of Canada have also taken a stance in favour of greater autonomy for Quebec within Canada.
Notable asymmetrical federalists have included
"Status-quo" federalism
Currently, governmental oversight is shared amongst a federal legislature and a number of legislatures whose power is distributed as per the Constitution.[2]
Federalists in favour of the status quo, or symmetrical federalists, also defend Quebec remaining within Canada; however, they support the status quo division of powers between Ottawa and Quebec City and the current Constitution. Current Liberal Party leader and Prime Minister of Canada, Justin Trudeau at one point suggested that gaining Quebec's signature to the Constitution was not a priority, putting him at odds with many past federalists from his home province.[citation needed]
This strain of Canadian federalism is strictly against reopening the Constitution and supports policies of shared and exclusive provincial jurisdiction in areas such as taxation, healthcare and immigration. They defend the federal government occasionally encroaching on areas that Quebec governments (both federalist and sovereigntist) consider their rightful jurisdiction. In general, federalists of this school of thought are opposed to officially recognising Quebec as a "nation" or "distinct society" within Canada, and support the Clarity Act (legislation introduced by the Chrétien government, essentially giving the federal government the right to establish a "clear majority" threshold for any sovereignty referendum at its own discretion and after the fact - this is opposed by the Quebec Liberal Party).[citation needed]
Notable symmetrical federalists have included Pierre Trudeau, Jean Chrétien, Stéphane Dion and Justin Trudeau.
Although this strain of uncompromising, centralising Canadian federalism is most often associated with the Liberal Party of Canada and the political tradition of Pierre Trudeau, it also has adherents from other parties and across the political spectrum.
Related Terms
In French, fédération can be defined as: (1) a methodical approach of defining a set of types in regards to complex realities, applied to state organization.
a grouping of various associations, unions, parties, and clubs. It can also be used as synonym for federal state.[3]
In English, federalism has been defined as a "mode of political organization that unites separate states or other polities within an overarching political system in such a way as to allow each to maintain its own fundamental political integrity".[4]
This compromise as political system has been called a “quasi-federal concept”,[2] as well as described as a "post-nation" state.[5]
Federalist parties
Represented in the Parliament of Canada
- Liberal Party of Canada
- Conservative Party of Canada
- New Democratic Party
Represented in the National Assembly of Quebec
- Quebec Liberal Party – They have alternated in power with the sovereigntist PQ since the 1970s. The Party disaffiliated itself from the Liberal Party of Canada in 1960. For decades it has acted as a broad tent for federalists from across the political spectrum. Important leaders have included Jean Lesage, Claude Ryan, Robert Bourassa, Jean Charest and Philippe Couillard
- Coalition Avenir Québec – Currently government party in Quebec, originally formed by members of the PQ and Liberal Party, wishing to move past the National Question, the CAQ is now officially opposed to sovereignty albeit it supports a significant degree of autonomy. Its founding leader François Legault is a former member of the Parti Québécois and former sovereigntist, and its ideology is generally speaking fiscally conservative and Quebec autonomist. In the 2018 election, his party won a majority.
See also
- Politics of Quebec
- History of Quebec
- Politics of Canada
- History of Canada
- Quebec nationalism
- Canadian nationalism
- Canadian federalism
- Quebec sovereignty movement
- Autonomism in Quebec
Compare
- Unionism in the United Kingdom (Unionism in Ireland, Unionism in Scotland, Unionism in Wales, Unionism in England)
- Belgian nationalism
- Yugoslavism
- Soviet socialist patriotism
- Zhonghua minzu (China)
- Austroslavism / Austromarxism / National personal autonomy
References
- ISBN 0-7735-2547-5.
ISBN 2-7606-1948-6. - ^ a b Federalism at The Canadian Encyclopedia, accessed September 1, 2019
- ^ "Définitions : fédération - Dictionnaire de français Larousse". Larousse.fr. Retrieved 2022-08-31.
- ^ "Federalism | Definition, History, Characteristics, & Facts".
- TheGuardian.com. 4 January 2017.