Schism of the Russian Church

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
(Redirected from
Raskol
)

Old Believer Priest Nikita Pustosvyat Disputing with Patriarch Joachim on Matters of Faith. Painting by Vasily Perov (1880)

The Schism of the Russian Church, also known as Raskol (

Patriarch Nikon
in 1653, which aimed to establish uniformity between Greek and Russian church practices.

Church reforms and reaction to them

The members of an influential circle called the

Archbishop of Novgorod
, Nikon himself, the future Patriarch.

With the support from the Russian

Epifany Slavinetsky
began to produce corrected versions of newly translated divine service books.

A traditional, widespread view of these reforms is that they only affected the external ritualistic side of the Russian Orthodox faith and that these changes were deemed a major event by the religious

Russian people
. However, these reforms, apart from their arbitrariness, established radically different relations between the church and the faithful. It soon became obvious that Nikon had used this reform for the purpose of centralization of the church and strengthening of his own authority. Nikon's forcible introduction of the new divine service books and rituals caused a major estrangement between the Zealots of Piety and Nikon. Some of its members stood up for the old faith (staroobryadsty : Old Ritualists) and opposed the reforms and patriarch's actions.

Avvakum and Daniel first petitioned to the tsar to officialize the two-finger sign of the cross and

Catholic print houses and that they had been exposed to Roman Catholic influences. Moreover, it had been a long time already for the Greece to be under the influence of the Ottoman Empire, and, therefore, some elements of Islam also integrated in the life of Greek people and to the church. Also the opponents of the reform were deeply concerned that it was supposed (and, in the end, done this way) to take as the reference for corrections of old Russian liturgical books (rus. "knizhnaya sprava", "книжная справа") the concrete Greek liturgical books printed in Venice around 1605 - so it appeared, that the original argument of "bringing outdated and mutated Russian liturgical books into line of original Greek sources" was invalid. Ivan Neronov spoke against the strengthening of patriarch's authority and demanded democratization
of ecclesiastic management. This conflict between Nikon and defenders of the old faith took a turn for the worse and soon Avvakum, Ivan Neronov and others would be persecuted and eventually executed in 1682.

Sign of the Cross
: with two fingers, rather than with three.

The case brought by the defenders of the old faith found many supporters among different strata of the Russian society, which would give birth to the Raskol movement. A part of the old faith low-ranking clergy protested against the increase of

feudal
oppression, coming from the church leaders. Some members of the high-ranking clergy joined the Raskol movement due to their discontent over Nikon's aspirations and the arbitrariness of his church reforms.

Some of them, such as Bishop

Feodosiya Morozova
, her sister Princess Urusova, and some other courtiers openly supported or secretly sympathized with the defenders of the old faith.

The unification of such

martyrdom in the name of the old faith as the only way towards salvation were intertwined with criticism of feudalism and serfdom
. Different social strata were attracted to different sides of this ideology.

The most radical apologists of the Raskol preached about approaching Armageddon and coming of the Antichrist, Tsar's and patriarch's worshiping of Satan, which ideas would find a broad response among the Russian people, sympathizing with the ideology of these most radical apologetes. The Raskol movement thus became a vanguard of the conservative and at the same time democratic opposition.

Uprisings and persecution

The Raskol movement gained in strength after the

church sobor in 1666–67, which had anathemized the defenders of the old faith (staroobryadsty : Old Ritualists) as heretics and made decisions with regards to their punishment. Especially members of the low-ranking clergy, who had severed their relations with the church, became the leaders of the opposition. Propagation of the split with the church in the name of preservation of the Orthodox faith as it had existed until the reforms was the main postulate of their ideology. The most dramatic manifestations of the Raskol included the practice of the so-called ognenniye kreshcheniya (огненные крещения, or baptism by fire), or self-immolation
, practiced by the most radical elements in the Old Believers' movement, who thought that the end of the world was near.

A Muscovite Voivode Putting Down the Solovetsky Monastery uprising. An early 19th-century hand-drawn lubok, attributed to Mikhail Grigoriev.

The Old Believers would soon split into different denominations, the Popovtsy and the Bespopovtsy. Attracted to the preachings of the Raskol ideologists, many posad people, mainly peasants, craftsmen and cossacks fled to the dense forests of Northern Russia and Volga region, southern borders of Russia, Siberia, and even abroad, where they would organize their own obshchinas. This was a mass exodus of common Russian people, who had refused to follow the new ecclesiastic rituals. In 1681, the government noted an increase among the "enemies of the church", especially in Siberia. With active support from the Russian Orthodox Church, it began to persecute the so-called raskolniki (раскольники), i.e., "schism-makers".

In the 1670s–1680s, the exposure of certain social vices in the Russian society gained special importance in the Raskol ideology. Some of the Raskol apologetes, such as Avvakum and his brothers-in-exile at the

allowed them
to practice their faith freely.

In the late 17th – early 18th century, the most radical elements of the Raskol movement went into recession after it had become obvious that the reforms could not be reversed. The internal policy of

Peter the Great eased the persecution of the Old Believers. The Tsar, however, did impose higher taxes on them. During the reign of Catherine the Great
, Old Believers who had fled abroad were even encouraged to return to their motherland. However, the position of Old Believers in Russia remained illegal until 1905.

A scene from the times of the Raskol, by Sergey Ivanov

The Raskol (schism) still exists, and with it a certain antagonism between the Russian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate and the Old Believers, although on an official level both sides have agreed on a peaceful coexistence. From an ecclesiastic and theological point of view the Raskol remains a highly controversial question and one of the most tragic episodes of Russian history.

Literary reference

The term is etymologically related to the family name of Rodion Raskolnikov, the protagonist of Dostoevsky's well-known novel Crime and Punishment.

See also

References

In English

  • Cherniavsky, M (1955), "The Reception of the Council of Florence in Moscow", Church History (article), XXIV: 147–57.
  • Crummey, Robert O (1970), The Old Believers & The World of Antichrist; The Vyg Community & The Russian State, Wisconsin UP.
  • Gill, T (1959), The Council of Florence, Cambridge{{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link).
  • Shevchenko, I (1955), "Ideological Repercussions of the Council of Florence", Church History (article), XXIV: 291–323,
    S2CID 159708744
    .
  • Zenkovsky
    , Serge A (1957), "The ideology of the Denisov brothers", Harvard Slavic Studies, III: 49–66
    .
  • ——— (1956), "The Old Believer Avvakum", Indiana Slavic Studies, I: 1–51.
  • ——— (1967) [1960], Pan-Turkism and Islam in Russia, Harvard UP
  • ——— (1957), "The Russian Schism", .

In Russian

  • Голубинский (Golubinskij), ЕЕ (1900), История русской церкви [History of the Russian Church], Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link).
  • ——— (1905), К нашей полимике со старообрядцами [Contribution to our polemic with the Old believers], ЧОИДР (ČOIDR).
  • Дмитрев (Dmitrev, AD) (1937), Инквизиция в России [Inquisition in Russia], Москва (Moscow) : ГАИЗ (State anti-religious publishing){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  • Зеньковский, СА (Zenkovskij, SA) (2006), Русское старообрядчество [Russia's Old Believers], vol. I, II, Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
  • Каптерев, НФ (Kapterev, NF) (1913), Патриарх Никон и его противники в деле исправления церковныx обрядов [Patriarch Nikon and his opponents in the correction of church rituals], Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
  • ——— (1914), Характер отношений России к православному востоку в XVI и XVII вв [Character of the relationships between Russia and the orthodox East in the 16th and 17th centuries], Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
  • Карташов, АВ (Kartašov, AV) (1959), Очерки по иситории русской церкви [Outlines of the history of the Russian church], Париж (Paris){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
  • Ключевский, ИП (Ključevskij, IP) (1956–59), Сочинения [Works], vol. I–VIII, Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
  • Кутузов, БП (Kutuzov, BP) (2003), Церковная "реформа" XVII века [The church "reform" of the 17th century], Москва (Moscow){{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link).
This page is based on the copyrighted Wikipedia article: Raskol. Articles is available under the CC BY-SA 3.0 license; additional terms may apply.Privacy Policy