SR Merchant Navy class
SR Merchant Navy class British Railways | |
---|---|
Class | SR / BR: Merchant Navy |
Power class |
|
Locale | South West Main Line |
Disposition | All modified (see below) |
The SR Merchant Navy class (originally known as the 21C1 class, and later informally known as Bulleid Pacifics, Spam Cans – which name was also applied to the Light Pacifics – or Packets) is a class of air-smoothed 4-6-2 (Pacific) steam locomotives designed for the Southern Railway by Oliver Bulleid. The Pacific design was chosen in preference to several others proposed by Bulleid. The first members of the class were constructed during the Second World War, and the last of the 30 locomotives in 1949.
Incorporating a number of new developments in British steam locomotive technology, the design of the Merchant Navy class was among the first to use
Due to problems with some of the more novel features of Bulleid's design, all members of the class were modified by
Background
The Southern Railway was the most financially successful of the "
Bulleid's first suggestion was for an eight-coupled locomotive with a
Design
Most of the detailed design for the Merchant Navy class was undertaken by the drawing office at Brighton works, but some work was also undertaken by Ashford and Eastleigh. This division of responsibility was possibly due to Bulleid's wish to restrict knowledge of the new class to a limited number of personnel.[17] The design incorporated a number of novel features, compared to then-current steam locomotive practice in Great Britain.
Cylinders, valve gear, wheels and brakes
Three 18 inches (46 cm) diameter cylinders drove the centre coupled axle. The inside cylinder was steeply inclined at 1:7.5 but the outside cylinders were horizontal.[18]
It was originally intended to use a gear-driven
The locomotives were equipped with the unusual 6 ft 2 in (1.88 m)
The spaces between driving wheels housed steam-powered clasp brakes, that gripped the wheels by way of a "scissor" action.[20] The two middle brake hangers held two brake blocks each, whilst the two outside hanger on the leading and rear driving wheels held one block each.[22] These were connected together by outside rodding for ease of access, and the whole system was operated from the footplate.
Boiler and welded firebox
The maximum boiler pressure was higher than any other British regular service locomotive (except the
Bulleid decided on cheaper all-welded fireboxes for the boilers as opposed to more common riveted construction, and a steel inner firebox which was 1.5 long tons (1.5 t) lighter than a more usual copper example.
However he soon discovered that the Southern Railway lacked the facilities to manufacture welded boilers of this size,[21] so the first ten boilers were ordered on outside contract from the North British Locomotive Company.[21]
Air-smoothed casing, smokebox and blastpipe
The boiler was enveloped by Bulleid's air-smoothed sheet-steel casing, which was not for the purposes of
Tender
Bulleid designed a new 5,000 imperial gallons (22,730 L; 6,000 US gal)
Other innovations
Construction
The Southern Railway placed an order for ten of the new locomotives to be built at
A second batch of ten followed, beginning in December 1944 and culminating in June 1945. These were entirely constructed at Eastleigh
Just prior to the
Numbering and naming the locomotives
Bulleid adopted a new numbering scheme for all his locomotives based on
The Southern Railway considered naming the locomotives after victories of the
A new design of nameplate was created, featuring a circular plate with a smaller circle in the centre. The inner circle carried the colours of the shipping company on a stylised flag, on an
During their operational career, the class gained several nicknames; the most obvious, Bulleid Pacific, simply denoted the designer and wheel arrangement. The colloquial name Spam Can arose from their utilitarian appearance, enhanced by the flat, boxy air-smoothed casing, and the resemblance of this to the distinctive
Operational details
As the class appeared during the War, there were no heavily laden Continental Boat Trains from
Subsequent development
As mentioned, the main production batch of Southern-built locomotives differed from the two prototypes, Channel Packet and Union Castle. The steam-operated firehole door treadle was removed, and a new type of boiler cladding was utilised in response to the worsening supply situation during the Second World War.[33] Modification was also made to the air-smoothed casing surrounding the smokebox after reports were made of drifting smoke obscuring the locomotive crew's vision ahead. Initially, the only form of smoke deflection was a narrow slot in front of the chimney, intended to enable air to lift the smoke when the locomotive was travelling. This proved inadequate because of the relatively soft exhaust blast that came from the multiple-jet blastpipe, which failed to be caught by the air flow.[34] After several trials, the air flow was increased by extending the casing roof over the front of the smokebox to form a cowling whilst side smoke deflector plates were also incorporated into the front of the air-smoothed casing. The latter added to the poor visibility from the footplate and the expedients combined never fully solved the smoke drift problem.[35]
During the time they operated under the Southern Railway, further modifications were applied to the class, such as the reduction in boiler pressure to 250 psi (1.72 MPa) and the redesign of the footplate spectacle plates.[36] These are the small windows on the front face of the cab, which were redesigned to a wedge-shaped profile, a feature to be seen on all Bulleid-designed locomotives post-nationalisation.[3] They had been introduced in Britain in 1934 with the Gresley-designed Cock o' the North.[3] Originally, the spectacle plates of the Bulleid Pacifics were at the conventional right-angle to the direction of the locomotive, and offered limited vision ahead along the air-smoothed casing.[37] The Southern-built batches also had variations in the material used for the air-smoothed casing with a change from sheet steel to an asbestos compound, forced upon the manufacturer by wartime expediency.[33] This resulted in several class members having a horizontal strengthening rib running down the length of the casing.[33] The final Southern Railway-initiated experiment involved equipping 21C5 Canadian Pacific with a Berkeley mechanical stoker imported from Canada.[3] Little improvement in performance was seen when trialled under British Railways auspices in 1948 and the locomotive was re-converted to hand-firing.[38]
As mentioned, the British Railways batch had detail differences to previous versions. The most significant modification was the reduction of weight using lighter materials unavailable during wartime. From 1952 the air-smoothed casing ahead of the cylinders was removed to ease maintenance and lubrication.[39] This coincided with the removal of the tender 'raves' on all locomotives, as they quickly rotted, obstructed the packing of coal into the bunker and restricted the driver's view when reversing the locomotive.[40] The resultant 'cut-down' tender included new, enclosed storage for fire-irons, revised step ladders and glass spectacle plates to protect the crew from flying coal dust when running tender-first.[41]
Performance of the unmodified locomotives
The new locomotives demonstrated that they could generate enormous power using mediocre quality fuel, due largely to Bulleid's excellent boiler. They also ran very smoothly at high speed.[42] Partly as a result of having so many novel features, the first few years of service by the Merchant Navy class were beset by a variety of technical problems. Some of these were merely teething troubles, but others remained with the class throughout their working lives. These may be summarised as follows:
- Adhesion problems. The locomotives were often prone to wheelslip, and required very careful driving when starting a heavy train from rest, but once into their stride they were noted for their free running, excellent steam production and being remarkably stable when hauling heavy expresses.[3]
- Maintenance problems. The chain driven valve gear proved to be expensive to maintain and subject to rapid wear. Leaks from the oil bath onto the wheels caused oil to splash onto the boiler lagging in service.axlebox lubricators onto the wheels when stationary to be flung upwards into the boiler lagging in service.[44] In either case, the local fire brigade would invariably be called to put the fire out, with cold water coming into contact with the hot boiler, causing stress to the casing. Many photographs show an unmodified locomotive with a 'buckled' (warped) casing, the result of a lagging fire.[20]
- High fuel consumption. This became very apparent in the 1948 Locomotive Exchange Trials and at trials at the Rugby locomotive testing plant in 1952.[45] This was largely attributed to the variability of valve events due to the chain-driven valve gear.
- Restricted driver visibility due to the air-smoothed casing. The exhaust problem was never adequately resolved, and continued to beat down onto the air-smoothed casing when the engine was on the move, obscuring the driver's vision from the cab.[46]
As a result of these problems, in 1954 serious consideration was given to scrapping the class and replacing them with Britannia class locomotives.[47] However, the locomotives had excellent boilers and several other good features and so the decision was taken to rebuild them, removing several of Bulleid's less successful ideas.
Modification
BR Modified Merchant Navy class British Railways | |
---|---|
Class | Merchant Navy |
Power class | 8P |
Locale | South West Main Line |
Withdrawn | 1964–1967 |
Disposition | 11 preserved, remainder scrapped |
Partially because of the Crewkerne incident, and due to the incessant modification of Bulleid's original design, British Railways took the decision to rebuild the entire class to a more conventional design by
The fast-moving and unpredictable Bulleid
Performance of the modified locomotives
There is no doubt that rebuilding the class solved most of the maintenance problems, whilst retaining the good features, thereby creating excellent locomotives. One minor drawback was that the 'modifieds' put greater loads on the track as a result of
Accidents and incidents
- On 17 December 1942, No. 21C6 Peninsular & Oriental S. N. Co. sustained a broken chain near Honiton. The sump was fractured leading to an oil fire.[54]
- On 7 October 1943, No. 21C1 Channel Packet sustained a broken chain at Salisbury. The sump was fractured leading to an oil fire.[54]
- On 29 January 1945, No. 21C12 United States Lines sustained a broken chain.[54]
- On 24 April 1953, the crank axle on the central driving wheel of No. 35020 "Bibby Line" fractured whilst approaching Crewkerne station at speed.[55] No-one was injured, but the incident resulted in the withdrawal of all Merchant Navy class locomotives from service whilst the cause was ascertained.[56] An examination of other class members showed that the fracture, caused by metal fatigue, was a common fault.[57] To cover the motive power shortage caused by the mass withdrawal of thirty locomotives, classes from other British Railways regions were drafted in to deputise.[58] The incident resulted in a redesign and replacement of the crank axle.[56]
Withdrawal
Their principal work was on the
Year | Quantity in service at start of year |
Number withdrawn | Quantity withdrawn |
Locomotive numbers |
---|---|---|---|---|
1964 | 30 | 7 | 7 | 35001–02/06/09/15/18/25 |
1965 | 23 | 7 | 14 | 35004–05/16/19–21/24 |
1966 | 16 | 6 | 20 | 35010–11/17/22/27/29 |
1967 | 10 | 10 | 30 | 35003/07–08/12–14/23/26/28/30 |
Preservation
Eleven of the class survived into preservation, thanks largely to the high workload of
Ten locomotives ended up at Barry Scrapyard. One however, 35028 Clan Line, was purchased by the Merchant Navy Locomotive Preservation Society direct from British Railways service in 1967. Clan Line has since been regarded as the flagship of the class.[20] Five examples have returned to steam, but it is unlikely that many of the remainder will do so,[61] as the class is too large and heavy for use on most of today's heritage railways.
As the entire fleet was rebuilt from 1956 onwards, no examples exist in their original condition, although a team is attempting to reverse-engineer 35011 General Steam Navigation with its air-smoothed casing and chain-driven valve gear.[62] Other relics of the class have survived in the guise of locomotive nameplates and smokebox number plates, which were taken from their locomotives towards the end of steam on the British Railways Southern Region in the 1960s. As a result, many exist in private collections and several have been seen at auctions, selling for several thousands of pounds.[63]
Number | Name | Built | Rebuilt | Withdrawn | Service life | Location | Livery | Status | Main line certified | Image | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
35005 | Canadian Pacific | Dec 1941 | May 1959 | Oct 1965 | 23 Years, 10 months | Eastleigh Works | BR Lined Green, Late Crest (on completion) | Under overhaul | No | Owned by Mid Hants Railway Preservation Society | |
35006
|
Peninsular & Oriental S.N. Co.
|
Dec 1941 | Oct 1959 | Aug 1964 | 22 Years, 8 months | Gloucestershire Warwickshire Railway | BR Lined Green, Late Crest | Operational, boiler ticket expires 2025 | No | ||
35009 | Shaw Savill | Jul 1942 | Mar 1957 | Sept 1964 | 22 Years, 2 months | East Lancashire Railway | N/A | Undergoing restoration from scrapyard condition | No, to be certified | Owned by Ian Riley of Riley & Son, Bury | |
35010 | Blue Star | Aug 1942 | Jan 1957 | Sept 1966 | 24 Years, 1 month | Colne Valley Railway | N/A | Stored, awaiting restoration | No | ||
35011 | General Steam Navigation | Dec 1944 | Jul 1959 | Feb 1966 | 21 Years, 2 months | Swindon and Cricklade Railway[64] | N/A | Undergoing restoration to as-built condition with air-smoothed casing | No, to be certified | ||
35018 | British India Line
|
May 1945 | Feb 1956 | Aug 1964 | 19 Years, 3 months | Carnforth MPD | BR Lined Green, Late Crest | Operational, boiler ticket expires: 2027 | Yes (2017 – ongoing) | First of the class to be rebuilt | |
35022 | Holland America Line | Oct 1948 | Jun 1956 | May 1966 | 17 Years, 7 months | Crewe Diesel TMD | N/A | Stored, awaiting restoration from scrapyard condition | No, to be certified | ||
35025 | Brocklebank Line | Nov 1948 | Dec 1956 | Sept 1964 | 15 Years, 10 months | Private Site, Sellindge, Kent | N/A | Undergoing restoration from scrapyard condition[65] | No | ||
35027 | Port Line | Dec 1948 | May 1957 | Sept 1966 | 17 Years, 9 months | Crewe Diesel TMD | N/A | Stored, awaiting overhaul | No, to be certified | Last ran in 2003 | |
35028 | Clan Line | Dec 1948 | Oct 1959 | Jul 1967 | 18 Years, 7 months | Stewarts Lane TMD | BR Lined Green, Late Crest | Undergoing Repairs, boiler ticket expires: 2034[66] | Yes (2017 - ongoing) | Undergoing firebox repairs and retube.[67] | |
35029 | Ellerman Lines | Feb 1949 | Sept 1959 | Jul 1966 | 17 Years, 7 months | National Railway Museum | BR Lined Green, Late Crest | Static display | No | Sectioned on fireman's side to show internal workings |
Livery
Southern Railway
Livery was Southern Railway
21C1 Channel Packet originally had an inverted horseshoe on the smokebox door, indicating its Southern origin, but crews believed this to be unlucky.[3] A resultant re-design meant that this became a roundel, the gap being filled by the year of construction, so it acted as a builder's plate.[3] The background was painted red. Early members of the class had cast-iron numberplates and gilt 'Southern' plates on the tender, but these were subsequently replaced by transfers.[3]
British Railways
After
Operational assessment
The class in both as-built and modified forms has been subject to a range of divergent opinions. The utilisation of welded steel construction and the various innovations that had not previously been seen in British locomotive design meant that the class earned Bulleid the title "Last Giant of Steam".[70] The constant concern for ease of maintenance and utility had not previously been seen on locomotives of older design, whilst their highly efficient boilers represented the ultimate in British steam technology, the hallmark of a successful locomotive design.[38] Despite this, the number of innovations introduced at the same time made the class unreliable and difficult to maintain during the first few years of service. Many of these difficulties were overcome during the rebuilding, leading to D.L. Bradley's statement that the modified locomotives were "the finest express locomotives to work in the country".[71] Overall, the class was largely successful, with half of the locomotives completing more than 1 million miles in revenue-earning service.[72]
Models
Makers of models of Merchant Navy locomotives include Hornby Railways, Graham Farish and Minitrix.[73] The first OO gauge model of an as-built locomotive was produced by Graham Farish in 1950 followed by Hornby/Wrenn in 1962 and by the modified version.[74]
Hornby and Graham Farish currently produce the rebuilt version of the class in OO gauge and
In March 2015, Hornby announced the inclusion of a new as-built version of the class in OO gauge in their 2016 range; this model was subsequently postponed to the 2017 range.
See also
References
Notes
- ^ a b Harvey (2004)
- ^ Arlett (1989), pp. 29–30
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u Bulleids in Retrospect
- ^ Burridge (1975), p. 60
- ^ OCLC 63292071.
- ^ "35005 Canadian Pacific (SR 21C5, BR s21C5 & 35005)". Preserved British Steam Locomotives. WordPress.com. 23 June 2017. Archived from the original on 20 October 2020. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
- ISBN 9781465436580. Archivedfrom the original on 19 October 2021. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
- doi:10.15180/181010. Archivedfrom the original on 26 October 2020. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
- ^ Whitehouse & Thomas, p. 49
- ^ a b c d Whitehouse & Thomas, p. 59
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Bradley (1976), p. 3-52.
- ^ Marsden, Richard. "Oliver Bulleid". LNER Encyclopedia. Winwaed Software Technology LLC. Archived from the original on 10 March 2017. Retrieved 4 November 2020.
- ^ Bulleid (1977), pp. 52–53
- ^ Speare, Rob; Smith, David. "The Background To Bulleid's Revolutionary 'Merchant Navy' Class". Bulleid Locos. Archived from the original on 21 October 2020. Retrieved 4 November 2020.
- ^ Harvey (2004), pp. 6–9
- ^ a b Creer & Morrison (2001), p. 7
- ^ Bradley (1976) p.4
- ^ a b Locomotive Publishing Co. (1945), p.49.
- ^ Chain-driven valve gear diagram, retrieved 13 April 2007 Archived 30 December 2006 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Herring (2000), pp. 148–149, 156–157
- ^ a b c d Bradley (1976), p. 8
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Bradley (1976), p. 9
- ^ Bradley (1976), p. 10
- ^ Creer & Morrison (2001), p. 21
- ^ a b Bradley (1976), p.19
- ^ Day-Lewis (1964), pp. 149–150
- ^ Harvey (2004), p. 33
- ^ a b Harvey (2004), pp. 46–50
- ^ a b c Bradley (1976), p. 22
- ^ Ian Allan Abc 1958–59 "MN"
- ^ a b c Burridge (1975), p. 61
- ^ Southern E-Group (2004) Bulleid MN "Merchant Navy" Class 4-6-2 Archived 21 November 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved April. 16, 2007. For details of the naming process.
- ^ a b c Harvey (2004), p. 21
- ^ Harvey (2004), p. 25
- ^ Harvey (2004), p. 40
- ^ Whitehouse & Thomas, p. 61
- ^ Creer & Morrison (2001), pp. 40–41
- ^ a b Whitehouse & Thomas, p. 47
- ^ Harvey (2004), p. 50
- ^ Southern E-Group (2008) Removal of raves Archived 6 February 2009 at the Wayback Machine, retrieved 14 September 2009
- ^ Southern E-Group (2008) Tender modifications Archived 6 February 2009 at the Wayback Machine, retrieved 14 September 2009
- ^ Bradley (1976), pp. 11–14
- ^ Southern E-Group (2004) Bulleid MN "Merchant Navy" Class 4-6-2: Notes from a Bulleid Fundamentalist Archived 21 November 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 16 April 2007. For details on the lagging fires which were common on both Merchant Navys and Light Pacifics.
- ^ Southern E-Group (2004) Bulleid MN "Merchant Navy" Class 4-6-2: Notes from a Bulleid Fundamentalist Archived 21 November 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 25 August 2010. For the cause of the lagging fires which were common on both Merchant Navys and Light Pacifics.
- ^ Bradley (1976), pp. 31–35
- ^ Creer & Morrison (2001), p. 13
- ^ Bradley (1976), p. 38
- ^ Southern E-Group (2004) Modified Bulleid MN 'Merchant Navy' Class 4-6-2 Archived 7 June 2008 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 16 April 2007. For more pictures of the rebuilt locomotives.
- ^ Creer & Morrison (2001), p. 94
- ^ a b Creer & Morrison (2001), pp. 74–75
- ^ Bradley (1976), p.41
- ^ Bradley (1976), p.42
- ^ Creer & Morrison (2001), p. 96
- ^ ISBN 978-0-9554110-2-1.
- ^ Leigh (1993), p. 6
- ^ a b Leigh (1993), p. 9
- ^ Leigh (1993), p. 8
- ^ Leigh and Strange (1993), p. 13
- ^ Hicks (2007), pp. 57–61
- ^ "SR Bulleid "MN" Class 4-6-2". www.brdatabase.info. Archived from the original on 18 April 2018. Retrieved 17 April 2018.
- ^ Langston (2008), p. 112
- ^ "General Steam Navigation Locomotive Restoration Society". 35011gsn.co.uk. Archived from the original on 2 October 2021. Retrieved 19 October 2021.
- ^ "The Railway Magazine" (2007), p.25
- ^ "35011 General Steam Navigation". Swindon and Cricklade Railway. Archived from the original on 21 December 2019. Retrieved 16 April 2019.
- ^ "35025 Brocklebank Line | Restoration". www.southern-locomotives.co.uk. Retrieved 27 March 2022.
- ^ https://www.clan-line.org.uk/news/progress-in-devon-10/ Testing Has Started
- ^ https://www.railadvent.co.uk/2022/10/steam-locomotive-35028-clan-line-withdrawn-from-service-for-repairs.html 35028 Withdrawn for repairs
- ^ Mannion (1998), p. 72
- ^ Harvey (2004), p. 65
- ^ Day-Lewis (1964), p. 7
- ^ Bradley (1976), p. 44
- ^ Bradley (1976), p.53
- ^ John Russell (2003) N Gauge RTR Steam Locos Archived 20 July 2010 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 15 December 2010. For manufacturer details.
- ^ John Russell (2003) 00 Gauge RTR Steam Locos Archived 23 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 15 December 2010. For details of the earlier releases.
- ^ a b Southern E-Group (2009) Hornby's Modified Merchant Navy Class loco Archived 27 May 2010 at the Wayback Machine, Retrieved 15 December 2010. For details of the Hornby model.
Bibliography
- Arlett, Mike: The Train Now Departing: Personal memories of the last days of steam (London: BBC Books, 1989) ISBN 0-563-20696-9
- Bradley, D.L. : Locomotives of the Southern Railway. Part 2 (London: Railway correspondence and Travel Society, 1976) ISBN 0-901115-31-2
- Bulleid, H. A. V.: Bulleid of the Southern (Hinckley: Ian Allan Publishing, 1977) ISBN 0-7110-0689-X
- Bulleids in Retrospect, Transport Video Publishing, Wheathampstead, Hertfordshire
- Burridge, Frank: Nameplates of the Big Four (Oxford Publishing Company: Oxford, 1975) ISBN 0-902888-43-9
- Creer, S & Morrison, B: The Power of the Bulleid Pacifics (Oxford Publishing Company: Oxford, 2001) ISBN 0-86093-082-3
- Day-Lewis, S: Bulleid, Last Giant of Steam (London: George Allen & Unwin, 1964)
- Harvey, R. J.: Bulleid 4-6-2 Merchant Navy Class (Locomotives in Detail series volume 1) (Hinckley: Ian Allan Publishing, 2004), ISBN 0-7110-3013-8
- Herring, Peter: Classic British Steam Locomotives (Abbeydale Press: London, 2000) Section "Merchant Navy Class" ISBN 1-86147-057-6
- Hicks, Bryan: 'A Southern Calling' Part Two (Steam World: 244, October 2007)
- Ian Allan ABC of British Railways Locomotives, winter 1958–59 edition
- Langston, Keith: British Steam Preserved: Illustrated Comprehensive Listing of Ex-British Railways Steam Locomotives (Horncastle: Morton's Media Group Ltd., 2008)
- Leigh, Chris: 'Crisis on the Southern: behind the scenes' (Steam World: 71, May 1993)
- Leigh, Chris and Strange, Richard: 'Crisis on the Southern; from the lineside' (Steam World: 71, May 1993)
- Leigh, Chris: Crisis on the Southern: behind the scenes (Steam World, 1993 (71)), pp. 6–9.
- Leigh, Chris and Strange, Richard: Crisis on the Southern: from the lineside (Steam World, 1993 (71)), pp. 10–13.
- Locomotive Publishing Co: Modern locomotive classes (Locomotive Publishing, 1945)
- Mannion, Roger J. The Southern Pacifics (Sutton Publishing: Stroud, 1998) ISBN 0-7509-1734-2
- The Railway Magazine (January, 2007)
- Whitehouse, Patrick & Thomas, David St.John: SR 150: A Century and a Half of the Southern Railway (Newton Abbot: David and Charles, 2002)
Further reading
- Nock, O.S. (10 June 1960), ""Merchant Navy" Locomotives Performance and Efficiency Tests on Southern Region" (PDF), The Engineer, 209: 975–979, archived from the original(PDF) on 4 March 2014