Self-fulfilling prophecy
This section needs additional citations for verification. (August 2019) |
A self-fulfilling prophecy is a prediction that comes true at least in part as a result of a person's belief or expectation that the prediction would come true.[1] In the phenomena, people tend to act the way they have been expected to make the expectations come true.[2] Self-fulfilling prophecies are an example of the more general phenomenon of positive feedback loops. A self-fulfilling prophecy can have either negative or positive outcomes. Merely applying a label to someone or something can affect the perception of the person/thing and create a self-fulfilling prophecy.[3] Interpersonal communication plays a significant role in establishing these phenomena as well as impacting the labeling process.[4]
American sociologists W. I. Thomas and Dorothy Swaine Thomas were the first Western scholars to investigate this phenomenon. In 1928, they developed the Thomas theorem (also known as the Thomas dictum): "If men define situations as real, they are real in their consequences."[5] Another American sociologist, Robert K. Merton, continued the research, and is credited with coining the term "self-fulfilling prophecy" and popularizing the idea that "a belief or expectation, correct or incorrect, could bring about a desired or expected outcome."[1][6] The works of philosophers Karl Popper and Alan Gerwith also contributed to the idea.[7]
History
This section needs additional citations for verification. (August 2019) |
An early precursor of the concept appears in
The phrase "self-fulfilling prophecy" was coined by Robert K. Merton, a sociologist who also developed the ideas of anomie, social structure, and the modes of individual adaption.[8] In his book Social Theory and Social Structure, he uses the example of a bank run to show how self-fulfilling thoughts can make unwanted situations happen. In his illustration, rumors spread about the town that the local bank is going to file for bankruptcy, causing many people to rush to the bank and close their accounts. Because banks do not keep their total assets in cash, the bank was unable to fulfill all its customers' withdrawals, which eventually caused the bank to go bankrupt. Merton concludes with the analysis, "The prophecy of collapse led to its own fulfillment".[9]
While Merton's example focused on self-fulfilling prophecies within a community, self-fulfilling prophecies also apply to individuals, as individuals often conform to the expectations of others. This is also known as the Pygmalion effect, based on the experiments by Robert Resenthal and Lenore Jacobson, where teachers were told that a random selection of students were expected to perform exceptionally well; those students showed a significant increase in test scores at the end of the year.[3][10][11]
Philosopher Karl Popper called the self-fulfilling prophecy the Oedipus effect:
One of the ideas I had discussed in The Poverty of Historicism was the influence of a prediction upon the event predicted. I had called this the "Oedipus effect", because the oracle played a most important role in the sequence of events which led to the fulfilment of its prophecy. [...] For a time I thought that the existence of the Oedipus effect distinguished the social from the natural sciences. But in biology, too—even in molecular biology—expectations often play a role in bringing about what has been expected.[12]
The idea is similar to that discussed by the philosopher William James as "The Will to Believe." But James viewed it positively, as the self-validation of a belief.[citation needed]
Applications
This section needs additional citations for verification. (August 2019) |
Examples abound[
In the United States, the concept was broadly and consistently applied in the field of public education reform, following the "
The phenomenon of the "inevitability of war" is a self-fulfilling prophecy that has received considerable study.[22]
Fear of failure leads to deterioration of results, even if the person is objectively able to adequately cope with the problem. For example, fear of falling leads to more falls among older people.[23]
Americans of Chinese and Japanese origin are more likely to die of a heart attack on the 4th of each month, due to the number four being considered unlucky and a portent of death.[24][25]
Moore's law predicting that the number of transistors in an integrated circuit (IC) doubles about every two years is often considered as a self-fulfilling prophecy.
The belief that a bank is insolvent may help create the fact, but confidence in the bank's prospects may improve them.[citation needed] Similarly, stock-exchange panics and speculative bubbles can be both triggered by a widespread belief that the stock will go down (or up), thus starting the selling/buying mass move, etc.
People adapt to the judgments and assessments made by society, regardless of whether they were originally correct or not. There are certain prejudices against a socially marginalized group (e.g., homeless people, drug addicts or other minorities), and therefore, people in this marginalized group actually begin to behave in accordance with expectations.[26]
Relationships
A leading study by Columbia University found that self-fulfilling prophecies have some part in relationships: the beliefs by people in relationships can impact the likelihood of a breakup or the overall health of the relationship. L. Alan Sroufe suggested that "rejection expectations can lead people to behave in ways that elicit rejection from others."[27] The study looked at the inner workings behind the role of self-fulfilling prophecies in romantic relationships of people who were deemed high in rejection sensitivity, which was defined as "the disposition to anxiously expect, readily perceive, and overreact to rejection". The study found that women were more likely to experience rejection sensitivity in comparison to the negativity held by men about the future of their relationships, and that women sensitive to rejection "may be more likely to behave in ways that exacerbate conflicts," which could lead to behavior that would "erode their partners' relationship satisfaction and commitment."[27]
Other specific examples discussed in psychology include:
- "Clever Hans" effect
- Observer-expectancy effect
- Hawthorne effect
- Placebo effect
- Nocebo effect
- Pygmalion effect
- Stereotype threat
International relations
Self-fulfilling prophecies have been apparent throughout history with the '
Another example of self-fulfilling prophecies is the United States' invasion of Iraq in 2003. The invasion was based on the assumption that Iraq posed a terrorist threat to the United States,[29] though evidence shows that no threat was actually posed.[30][31][32] The invasion and subsequent overthrowing of the regime resulted in Iraq becoming a stronghold for the terrorist organization Al Qaeda, thus fulfilling the initial belief of a potential threat.[citation needed]
Stereotype
Self-fulfilling prophecies are one of the main contributions to racial prejudice and vice versa.[citation needed][clarification needed] According to the Dictionary of Race, Ethnicity & Culture, "Self-fulfilling prophecy makes it possible to highlight the tragic vicious circle which victimizes people twice: first, because the victim is stigmatized with an inherent negative quality; and secondly, because he or she is prevented from disproving this quality."[33] An example is given where white workers expected that black people would be against the principles of trade unionism because they considered black workers to be "undisciplined in traditions of trade unionism and the art of collective bargain-ing."[34] Due to this belief, black workers were not hired at white-owned businesses, which made black workers unable to learn the principles of trade unionism, and thus prevented them from unionizing.
Teachers can encourage stereotype-based courses and can interact with students in a manner that encourages self-fulfilling thoughts: for example, female students may seem to be bad at math if teachers never encouraged them to improve their mathematical abilities.[35]
The term "self-fulfilling prophecy" made its first appearance in educational literature in the 1960s, when African-American psychologist Kenneth B. Clark studied the responses of black children to black and white dolls.[3] The responses from Clark's study ranged from some children calling the black doll ugly to one girl bursting into tears when prompted to pick the doll she identified with. The black children internalized the inferiority they learned and acted accordingly.[citation needed] Clark, whose work pushed the Supreme Court to desegregate schools, noted the influence of teachers on the achievement levels between Black and White students. This prompted Clark to begin a study in ten inner-city schools where he assessed the attitudes and behaviors of teachers. The belief held by teachers was that minority students were unintelligent, and therefore the teachers put no effort into teaching them. This led to a feedback loop of those students not being educated, and thus being perceived as unintelligent.[citation needed]
Literature, media, and the arts
This section needs additional citations for verification. (August 2023) |
In literature, self-fulfilling prophecies are often used as
Classical
Many myths, legends, and fairy tales make use of this motif as a central element of narratives that are designed to illustrate inexorable fate, fundamental to the Hellenic world-view.[36] In a common motif, a child, whether newborn or not yet conceived, is prophesied to cause something that those in power do not want to happen, but the prophesied events come about as a result of the actions taken to prevent them.
Greek
The word "prophet" is derived from the Greek word prophete, meaning "one who speaks for another."[37]
The best-known example from Greek legend is that of Oedipus. Warned that his child would one day kill him, Laius abandoned his newborn son Oedipus to die, but Oedipus was found and raised by others, and thus in ignorance of his true origins. When he grew up, Oedipus was warned that he would kill his father and marry his mother. He sought to avoid this, and, believing his foster parents to be his real parents, left his home and travelled to Greece, eventually reaching the city where his biological parents lived. There, he got into a fight with a stranger, killed him, and married his widow, only to discover that the stranger he had killed was his biological father, and his new wife was his biologial mother.
Although the legend of Perseus opens with the prophecy that he will kill his grandfather Acrisius, the prophecy is only self-fulfilling in some variants. In some, he accidentally spears his grandfather at a competition—an act that could have happened regardless of Acrisius' response to the prophecy. In other variants, his presence at the games is due to his hearing of the prophecy. In still others, Acrisius is one of the wedding guests when Polydectes tries to force Danaë to marry him, and is accidentally killed when Perseus turns all the guests to stone with the Gorgon's head.
Greek historiography provides a famous variant: when the Lydian king
When it was predicted that Cronos would be overthrown by his son, and usurp his throne as King of the Gods, Cronus ate his children, each shortly after they were born, enraging his wife, Rhea. To get revenge, when she bore Zeus, she gave Cronos a stone to eat instead, sending Zeus to be raised by Amalthea. Cronos' attempt to avoid the prophecy made Zeus his enemy, ultimately leading to its fulfilment.
Roman
The story of
Arabic
A variation of the self-fulfilling prophecy is the self-fulfilling dream, which dates back to medieval
Another variation of the self-fulfilling prophecy can be seen in "
Hinduism
Self-fulfilling prophecies appear in classical
Ruthenian
European fairy tales
Many fairy tales, such as
Another fairy tale occurs with older children. In The Language of the Birds, a father forces his son to tell him what the birds say: that the father would be the son's servant. In The Ram, the father forces his daughter to tell him her dream: that her father would hold an ewer for her to wash her hands in. In both, the father takes the child's response as evidence of malice and drives the child off; this allows the child to change so that the father will not recognize his own offspring later and so offer to act as the child's servant.
In some variants of Sleeping Beauty, such as Sun, Moon, and Talia, the sleep is not brought about by a curse, but a prophecy that she will be endangered by flax (or hemp) results in the royal order to remove all the flax or hemp from the castle, resulting in her ignorance of the danger and her curiosity.
Shakespeare
Modern
Fiction
A more modern example would be
In George R. R. Martin's book series A Song of Ice and Fire, Cersei Lannister kills a friend of hers after hearing a prophecy, from Maggy the Frog, that said friend will soon die.
The song "Iron Man" by British heavy metal band Black Sabbath follows the story of a self-fulfilling prophecy of a man who travels into the future and sees the apocalypse and tries to warn people, but ends up causing the apocalypse.
New age religion
The law of attraction is a typical example of self-fulfilling prophecy. It is the name given to the belief that "like attracts like" and that by focusing on positive or negative thoughts, one can bring about positive or negative results.[43][44] According to this law, all things are created first by imagination, which leads to thoughts, then to words and actions. The thoughts, words and actions held in mind affect someone's intentions which makes the expected result happen. Although there are some cases where positive or negative attitudes can produce corresponding results (principally the placebo and nocebo effects), there is no scientific basis to the law of attraction.[45]
Sports
Robert Barnsley showed that in an elite group of ice hockey players, 40% are born between January and March, as opposed to the approximately 25% as would be predicted by statistics, which could be explained by the relative age effect leading to selected players being exposed to higher levels of coaching, playing more games, and having better teammates. These factors make them the best players, fulfilling the prophecy, while the real selection criterion was age.[46][clarification needed]
The same relative age effect has been noticed in football,[47] baseball,[48] basketball,[49] handball,[50] tennis[51] and many other sports.
Some researchers from 2008 found that in basketball, the head coaches gave more biased feedback while the assistant coaches gave more critical feedback. They predicted this was due to the external expectations from the coaches to the athletes which could have resulted in the Pygmalion effect with positive and negative results.[52]
Researcher Helen Brown published findings of two experiments performed on athletes, investigating the effect that the media has on them, and concluded that the athlete's performance was impacted by and aligned with expectations of their performance.[53] A follow-up experiment in London found that such expectations can impact their judgement and thought processes, and can even have a dangerous and destructive impact on some athletes.[53]
Causal loop
A self-fulfilling prophecy may be a form of causality loop.
See also
- Anticipation
- Baskerville effect
- Begging the question
- Bootstrap paradox
- Cognitive behavioral therapy
- Confirmation bias
- Copycat effect
- Eschatology
- Expectation (epistemic)
- Fake it till you make it
- Mind over matter
- Moore's law
- Nineteen Eighty-Four
- Nominative determinism
- Pygmalion effect
- Reflexivity (social theory)
- Subject-expectancy effect
- Selection bias
- Self-defeating prophecy
- Self-licking ice cream cone
- Self-validating reduction
- Tinkerbell effect
Notes
- ^ ISBN 9781412986892
- ISBN 978-1-107-64513-4.
- ^ S2CID 145466315.
- ^ Watson, James (2015). Self-fulfilling prophecy. Dictionary of Media and Communication Studies.
- ^ The child in America: Behavior problems and programs. W.I. Thomas and D.S. Thomas. New York: Knopf, 1928: 571–572
- ^ Oxford English Dictionary. self-fulfilling.
1832 Morning Post 4 Apr. Suffice it to say, the licensed fabricators of self-fulfilling prophecies are again upon their stools.
- ISSN 1521-9488. Retrieved 9 October 2023.
- ^ Bush, M (2014). Merton, Robert. The Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice.
- OCLC 34116334.
- )
- ISBN 978-0-387-77579-1.
- OCLC 2927208.
- ^ Carrasco-Villanueva, M. A., El Efecto "Pricebo": Cómo los precios pueden influenciar la percepción sobre la calidad del cannabis y sus implicaciones en las políticas de precios. Pensamiento Crítico, vol. 22, no. 2, pp 175–210.
- ^ Stangor, Dr Charles; Jhangiani, Dr Rajiv; Tarry, Dr Hammond (26 January 2022). "4.3 Changing Attitudes by Changing Behavior". Retrieved 28 November 2022.
- S2CID 12853629.
- ^ )
- JSTOR 2112523.
- ^ Brameld, T. (1972). "Education as self-fulfilling prophecy". Phi Beta Kappa. 54 (1): 8–11, 58–61 [p. 9]. Quoted by Wilkins (1976), p. 176.
- S2CID 26933326.
- .
- S2CID 1584019.
- ^ Allport, G. (1950). "The role of expectancy". In Cantrill, H. (ed.). The Tensions That Cause Wars. Urbana: University of Illinois. pp. 43–78.
- S2CID 73024878.
- ^ Gupta, Sumit (2 August 2020). "What Is The Baskerville Effect and Why Your Thoughts Matter?". Deployyourself. Retrieved 2020-12-01.
- PMID 11751347.
- PMID 30873095.
- ^ PMID 9731324.
- OCLC 896343523.
- OCLC 741479156.
- S2CID 143931232.
- S2CID 145446765.
- .
- ^ Citation error. See inline comment how to fix. [verification needed]
- ISSN 0950-4125. [verification needed]
- S2CID 58617821.
- . "Very often the bases for false definitions and consequent self-fulfilling prophecies are deeply rooted in the individual or group norms and are subsequently difficult to change". (Wilkins 1976:177).
- ^ "Prophecy | Encyclopedia of Time: Science, Philosophy, Theology, & Culture - Credo Reference". search.credoreference.com. Retrieved 2020-08-19.
- ^ Herodotus Histories 1.88
- ISBN 1-86064-983-1.
- ISBN 1-86064-983-1.
- ISBN 1-57607-204-5.
- ^ Stith Thompson, The Folktale, p 139, University of California Press, Berkeley Los Angeles London, 1977
- ^ Whittaker, S.: Secret attraction Archived 2016-03-04 at the Wayback Machine, The Montreal Gazette, May 12, 2007.
- ^ Redden, Guy: Magic Happens: A New Age Metaphysical Mystery Tour, Journal of Australian Studies 101
- ^ Carroll, Robert Todd (12 September 2014). "law of attraction". The Skeptic's Dictionary. Retrieved 25 May 2020.
- ISBN 978-0-316-01792-3.
- Tim Goodenough. "Is it because of talent that athletes succeed?". rugbyIQ. Archived from the original on 2011-08-14.
- S2CID 24013421.
- S2CID 231651477.
- S2CID 244177676.
- PMID 32214322.
- PMID 26336351.
- ISSN 1041-3200.
- ^ S2CID 255927292– via 20-22.
- S2CID 143485859.
- ISBN 9780198240112.
- ^ Dodds, E.R. (1966), Greece & Rome 2nd Ser., Vol. 13, No. 1, 37–49
- ISBN 9781439168486.
Further reading
- Sayers, Dorothy L.: Oedipus Simplex: Freedom and Fate in Folklore and Fiction.