Sovereigntism
Part of the Politics series |
Politics |
---|
Politics portal |
Sovereigntism, sovereignism or souverainism (from French: souverainisme, pronounced [su.vʁɛ.nism] ⓘ, meaning the ideology of sovereignty) is the notion of having control over one's conditions of existence, whether at the level of the self, social group, region, nation or globe.[1] Typically used for describing the acquiring or preserving political independence of a nation or a region, a sovereigntist aims to "take back control" from perceived powerful forces,[2] either against internal subversive minority groups (ethnic, sexual or gender),[3] or from external global governance institutions,[4] federalism and supranational unions. It generally leans instead toward isolationism, and can be associated with certain independence movements, but has also been used to justify violating the independence of other nations.[5][6]
Classification
Sovereigntism has a cultural as well as political component and can take the form of hostility towards outsiders having different values or different countries or regions of origin.[7] Sovereigntist groups are associated with populism since they typically claim legitimacy for carrying out the sovereign will of the people.[8] While leftist sovereigntists tend to think of their national border as a defensive line against the corrosive effects of neo-liberal economics, right wing sovereigntists see it more as a filter protecting the sovereign people from undesired new members.[9]
Though there are wide differences in ideology and historical context between sovereigntist movements, those of the twenty first century can be thought of as belonging to three separate categories: conservative sovereigntism, archeo-sovereigntism, and neo-sovereigntism.
In a paper published in the European Review of International Studies outlining these three major tendencies, researchers Alles and Badie summarised them thus:[11]
Contemporary types of sovereigntism | Conception of sovereignty | Claim | Protest | Approach of globalisation |
---|---|---|---|---|
Neo-sovereigntism | Self-affirmation | Equality | Hierarchy | Example |
Archeo sovereigntism | Specificity | Identity | Globalisation | Antagonist |
Conservative sovereigntism | Normative | Hierarchy | Emergence of challengers | Selective |
Europe
In Europe, sovereigntist political movements divide (on the one hand) between those that seek to leave the European Union completely (or oppose joining it) and (on the other), those who aim for a "Europe of the nations", a less integrated Europe respecting the individual characteristics and sovereignty of constituent states.[12] Supporters of these doctrines tend to regard themselves as Euro-realists opposed to the Euro-federalists and call for a more confederal version of a European Union. (The European Union is not a federation but shares many characteristics of one.) Thus, sovereigntism in Europe is opposed to federalism and typically involves nationalism, particularly in the United Kingdom (which withdrew from the EU in 2020) and in France where parties on the left and right margins lean strongly towards it.
France
This article is part of Conservatism in France |
The souverainiste doctrine is particularly influential in France, where numerous political movements adhere to it:
- Democratic Rally (centrist and monarchist)
- French Action (monarchist, far-right reactionary)
- France Arise (Gaullist and republican)
- French Nationalist Party (neofascist, ethnic nationalism)
- France Unbowed (left-wing)
- Mouvement for France (conservative)
- Citizen and Republican Movement (left-wing)
- right-wing nationalist)
- right-wing nationalist)
- Nouvelle Action Royaliste (monarchist)
- Rally for France (Gaullist and republican)
- Popular Republican Union (Gaullist and republican)
- Pole of Communist Revival in France (Marxist–Leninist)
Germany
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntist can be also found in Germany:
- Alternative for Germany (right-wing, ethnic nationalist, conservative)
- neofascist)
Greece
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntists can also be found in Greece:
- Syriza (left-wing, economic nationalism, democratic socialist)
- hard Euroscepticism)
- Independent Greeks (right-wing, ethnic nationalist, conservative)
- Communist Party of Greece (Marxist–Leninist)
- neofascist)
- religious conservatism)
Hungary
Prime Minister
Italy
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntist can be also found in Italy:
- League (right-wing populist, conservative, federalist)
- national conservative)
- Italexit (populist, conservative)
- Five Star Movement (populist, left-wing populism)
- anti-capitalist)
- third positionist)
- third positionist)
- Communist Party (Marxist–Leninist)
Romania
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntist can be also found in Romania:
- Alliance for the Union of Romanians (nationalist, traditionalist, conservative, right-wing populist)
- Romanian Nationhood Party (national conservative, Islamophobic)
- Alliance for the Homeland (economic patriotism, syncretic)
- Christian Democratic National Peasants' Party (Christian right, national conservative)
Russia
Since 2006,
Serbia
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntist can be also found in Serbia:
- Enough is Enough (right-wing populist, eurosceptic)
- Serbian Radical Party (ultranationalist, eurosceptic)
- Dveri (national conservative, Christian democratic)
- Democratic Party of Serbia (national conservative, Christian democratic)
Spain
Parties with tendencies that could be described also as sovereigntist can be also found in Spain:
- far-right, ethnic nationalist)
- third positionist)
- Vox (right-wing, national conservative)
Catalonia
In the Parliament of Catalonia, parties explicitly supporting independence from Spain are
United Kingdom
Parties with policies that could be described as sovereigntist can be also found in
North America
Canada
In the
Quebec
- Parti Québécois (centre-left, nationalist and social democratic)
- Bloc Québécois (centre-left, nationalist and social democratic, represents Quebec separatism in Canada's federal parliament)
- Option nationale (centre-left, nationalist and progressive)
- Québec solidaire (left-wing, democratic socialist)
United States
Coupled with its history of isolationism and sense of American exceptionalism, US sovereigntism is largely a conservative perspective, celebrating both American self-definition and liberty to engage in unilateral action.[17] Sovereigntism in foreign policy is charactized by opposition to multilateral regimes relating to climate change, war crimes, arms control and international declaration of human rights.[18]
The dominant US sovereigntist perspective is currently that of Trumpism[19][20] and has three dimensions:[21]
- World order and peace is best secured by sovereign states looking after themselves, as opposed to rules based international order of interdependent and integrated countries.
- The needs of the American people come first before any other concern of government. Any other prioritization violates the sovereignty of the people.
- Sovereigntism is used partisan weapon, where anyone who differs with Trumpian formulations of sovereignty are identified as political enemies.
A more extreme conservative view of popular sovereignty involves a radical unwinding of centralized government and an expansion of regional sovereignty, where freedoms are controlled at the local level, not adjudicated at the federal level. From the perspective of the
See also
- Autonomism (political doctrine) – Acquiring or preserving political autonomy
- Euroscepticism – Body of criticism of the European Union
- Nationalism – Political ideology that promotes the interests of a nation
- Quebec sovereignty movement – Quebec independence movement
- Regionalism (politics) – Ideology that seeks to promote subnational administrative division interests
- Separatism – Advocacy for separation from a larger group
- Sovereigntism (Puerto Rico) – Movement to achieve sovereignty
- Suzerainty – Rights and obligations of a dominant state
- Vassal state – State subordinate to another state
References
- Alles, Delphine; Badie, Bertrand (2016). "Sovereigntism in the International System: From Change to Split" (PDF). European Review of International Studies. 3 (2): 16–18. .
Minakov, Mikhail (2022). "Sovereignty as a Contested Concept: The Cases of Trumpism and Putinism". Inventing Majorities: Ideological Creativity in Post-Soviet Societies. Stuttgart: ibidem-Verlag.
- . Retrieved 2022-07-01.
- ^ Kallis 2018, p. 3.
- ^ Minakov (2022), p. 307.
- S2CID 155699112.
- ^ Minakov (2022), p. 299.
- ^ a b Alles & Badie (2016), p. 16.
- S2CID 244164991.
- ^ Azmanova 2022, p. 167.
- S2CID 158092242.
- ^ Minakov (2022), p. 292.
- ^ Alles & Badie (2016), p. 18.
- )
- ^ Minakov (2022), p. 306-307.
- S2CID 155015782. Retrieved 2022-06-29.
- ISBN 9781442231382.
- ISBN 978-1-4422-3138-2.
- ^ Resnick, Judith. "Law as Affiliation: Foreign Law, Democratic Federalism, and the Sovereigntism of the Nation-State". International Journal of Constitutional Law. 6 (1): 34–35. Retrieved 2022-07-01.
- JSTOR 20049963.
- ^ Minakov (2022), p. 297.
- ^ Ash, Timothy Garton (2018-09-28). "It's not just Trump. Much of America has turned its back on Europe". The Guardian. Retrieved 2022-07-02.
- S2CID 203085341.
- ^ Minakov (2022), pp. 295–296, 305.