The Detective (1968 film)

The Detective
Theatrical release poster
Directed by	Gordon Douglas
Screenplay by	Abby Mann
Based on	The Detective 1966 novel by Roderick Thorp
Produced by	Aaron Rosenberg
Starring	Frank Sinatra Lee Remick Ralph Meeker Jack Klugman Lloyd Bochner William Windom Tony Musante Al Freeman, Jr. Robert Duvall Jacqueline Bisset
Cinematography	20th Century Fox
Release date	May 28, 1968 (1968-05-28)
Running time	114 minutes
Country	United States
Language	English
Budget	$4.5 million [1]
Box office	$6.5 million (rentals)[2]

The Detective is a 1968 American neo-noir^[3] crime drama film directed by Gordon Douglas, produced by Aaron Rosenberg, and starring Frank Sinatra, based on the 1966 novel of the same name by Roderick Thorp.^[4]

Co-stars include

.

The Detective marked a move towards — and was billed as — a more "adult" approach to depicting the life and work of a police detective while confronting, for one of the first times in mainstream cinema, previously taboo subjects such as homosexuality. Here, the detective in question is Joe Leland, who is trying to juggle marital issues with a murder case that seemed to be open-and-shut at first but runs much deeper than he could have imagined.

The Detective was Sinatra's fourth collaboration with director Douglas, having worked together on

(1968).

Plot

New York City police detective Joe Leland is called to the home of a murder victim who has been beaten to death, head crushed, and has had his penis removed. Puzzled and disgusted, the police on call are left bemused, and Leland holds things together with his direct, no-nonsense approach.

Few leads are found, other than the fact that a housemate of the victim remains conspicuous by his absence. All the while notions about the victim's sexuality and personal interests warp the ideals of the officers assigned to the task. Leland tries to remain focused on the case while dealing with the breakdown of his marriage to wife Karen.

Eventually, the victim's housemate is identified as Felix Tesla, and he is soon tracked down by Leland and another detective. Leland makes a psychologically disturbed Tesla crack and coaxes a confession out of him. This results in extensive publicity, a promotion for Leland, and the electric chair for Tesla, which distresses Leland because it is clear to him that Tesla is insane.

Later, across town, a man kills himself by jumping from the rooftop of the Garden State Park Racetrack grandstand. The case goes unnoticed until the much-younger wife of the dead man, Norma MacIver, comes to Leland's office and asks him to look into it, believing something far more complex is involved.

Leland and partner Dave Schoenstein follow leads. A psychiatrist, Dr. Roberts, clearly knows more about the dead man, Colin MacIver, than he is willing to reveal. The therapist also is familiar with Karen Leland, whose infidelity is putting a great strain on the detective's home life and distracting him from his work.

Leland soon learns that certain powerful interests in the city do not want him to ask questions about their scheme to inflate the value of real estate. Leland discovers MacIver is at the center of the scheme. The incorruptible detective presses on, at risk to his career and life, as he discovers a lurid relationship between the man's suicide and the previous murder. MacIver had met the victim after going to a gay club to "get [homosexuality] out of my system." MacIver then proceeded to murder him following the victim's remarks about being able to recognize MacIver as a homosexual.

MacIver made a taped confession to Dr. Roberts in which he also explains that he used the doctor's name as a front in his real estate scheme. Roberts insists that Leland keep MacIver's confession secret to preserve the detective's professional reputation as well as the powerful interests who do not want their crimes exposed. The film ends after Leland has revealed the truth and is happy to let the chips fall where they may, having unburdened himself of his guilt over Tesla's wrongful execution.

Cast

Casting

Sinatra originally planned to have his then-wife Mia Farrow cast as Norma MacIver, a role that was eventually taken by Jacqueline Bisset after Farrow was kept beyond the previously scheduled end of filming for Rosemary's Baby. This was the last straw for Sinatra, who had the divorce papers publicly served on Farrow on her film's set. Their divorce became final in August 1968, putting an end to a short-lived romance of barely two years.^[5]

Release and critical reception

Box office

Released on May 28, 1968, The Detective was a box office success, becoming the

, exceeding its $4.49 million budget.

According to Fox records the film required $8,800,000 in rentals to break even and by 11 December 1970 had made $10.2 million, therefore making a profit for the studio.^[6]

Critical

Critical reception was mostly positive, with Sinatra receiving praise for delivering one of his most intense and dedicated acting performances. The Hollywood Reporter commented: "Sinatra has honed his laconic, hep veneer to the point of maximum credibility." Roger Ebert praised his performance and the concept of the film, stating: "It is pretty clear that Sinatra wanted 'The Detective' to be as good a movie as he could manage. It provides a clear, unsentimental look at a police investigation, and even the language reflects the way cops (and the rest of us) talk."^[7]

Vincent Canby of The New York Times thought that the Thorp novel on which the film is based "had all the literary grace of a mile-long comic strip without pictures." As for the movie, he wrote, "Although it makes some valid comments about contemporary society, it exploits its lurid subject matter in a show-offy, heavy-handed way designed as much to tease as to teach compassion." He praised it for being "a film of transition. It deals with subject matter available to the new Hollywood in a style that reflects the old."^[4]

The Detective was released on DVD by 20th Century Fox in 2005 as part of a boxed set that included Tony Rome and Lady in Cement.^{[citation needed]}

Legacy

In 1979, Roderick Thorp wrote a sequel to his novel The Detective called

See also

• List of American films of 1968

References

1. ISBN 978-0-8108-4244-1
   . p255
2. ^ Solomon p 230. See also "Big Rental Films of 1968", Variety, 8 January 1969, pg 15.
3. ISBN 0-87951-479-5
4. ^ ^{a b} Canby, Vincent. "The Detective Opens," The New York Times, Wednesday, May 29, 1968. Retrieved August 10, 2022.
5. ^ Mia Farrow profile, loti.com; accessed 4 May 2016.
6. ISBN 9780818404856
   .
7. ^ "Roger Ebert's Review, July 12th 1968".
8. ^ "The Running Man and Die Hard with Steven de Souza: Live from Alamo Drafthouse, episode #57 of I Was There Too on Earwolf". www.earwolf.com.

External links

• The Detective at
  IMDb
• The Detective at Rotten Tomatoes
• The Detective at AllMovie
• The Detective at the TCM Movie Database
• The Detective at the American Film Institute Catalog