Timeline of ankylosaur research

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Skeletal mounts of the ankylosaur Scolosaurus

This timeline of ankylosaur research is a chronological listing of events in the

Delaware people have stories about smoking the bones of ancient monsters in a magic ritual to have wishes granted and ankylosaur fossils are among the local fossils that may have been used like this.[1] The Native Americans of the modern southwestern United States tell stories about an armored monster named Yeitso that may have been influenced by local ankylosaur fossils.[2] Likewise, ankylosaur remains are among the dinosaur bones found along the Red Deer River of Alberta, Canada where the Piegan people believe that the Grandfather of the Buffalo once lived.[3]

The first scientifically documented ankylosaur remains were recovered from

ankylosaurids.[5] Since then, many new ankylosaur genera and species have been discovered from all over the world and continue to come to light. Many fossil ankylosaur trackways have also been recognized.[7]

21st century in paleontology20th century in paleontology19th century in paleontology2040s in paleontology2030s in paleontology2020s in paleontology2010s in paleontology2000s in paleontology1990s in paleontology1980s in paleontology1970s in paleontology1960s in paleontology1950s in paleontology1940s in paleontology1930s in paleontology1920s in paleontology1910s in paleontology1900s in paleontology1890s in paleontology1880s in paleontology1870s in paleontology1860s in paleontology1850s in paleontology1840s in paleontology1830s in paleontologyStegourosSinankylosaurusAkainacephalusInvictarxAcantholipanJinyupeltaPlatypeltaBorealopeltaZuulKunbarrasaurusHorshamosaurusZiapeltaZaraapeltaCrichtonpeltaChuanqilongTaohelongOohkotokiaEuropeltaDongyangopeltaPropanoplosaurusAhshislepeltaTatankacephalusMinotaurasaurusPeloroplitesZhongyuansaurusZhejiangosaurusAntarctopeltaHungarosaurusBissektipeltaAmtosaurusCrichtonsaurusCedarpeltaLiaoningosaurusGobisaurusAletopeltaGlyptodontopeltaNodocephalosaurusAnimantarxShanziaTianzhenosaurusGastonia burgeiGargoyleosaurusPawpawsaurusTexasetesNiobrarasaurusMymoorapeltaTianchisaurusTsagantegiaDenversaurusMaleevusShamosaurusVectensiaMinmi paravertebraDracopeltaAmtosaurusSaichaniaTarchiaSauropeltaSilvisaurusStegosauridesSauroplitesPeishanosaurusTalarususSyrmosaurusBrachypodosaurusPinacosaurusRhodanosaurusPolacanthoidesAnodontosaurusScolosaurusEdmontoniaDyoplosaurusPanoplosaurusLeipsanosaurusHierosaurusAnkylosaurusStegopeltaOnychosaurusHoplitosaurusEuoplocephalusSarcolestesNodosaurusPriconodonRhadinosaurusPleuropeltisHoplosaurusCrataeomusSyngonosaurusEucercosaurusAnoplosaurusPriodontognathusDanubiosaurusStruthiosaurusCryptosaurusAcanthopholisPolacanthusPalaeoscincusHylaeosaurus21st century in paleontology20th century in paleontology19th century in paleontology2040s in paleontology2030s in paleontology2020s in paleontology2010s in paleontology2000s in paleontology1990s in paleontology1980s in paleontology1970s in paleontology1960s in paleontology1950s in paleontology1940s in paleontology1930s in paleontology1920s in paleontology1910s in paleontology1900s in paleontology1890s in paleontology1880s in paleontology1870s in paleontology1860s in paleontology1850s in paleontology1840s in paleontology1830s in paleontology

Prescientific

Osteoderms of Ankylosaurus

19th century

Hylaeosaurus armatus

1830s

1832

  • Quarry workers discovered a fossilized partial skeleton. The remains were sent to paleontologist Gideon Mantell, who recognized that they represented a significant scientific discovery.[11]
  • Mantell reported the specimen discovered by quarry workers that would later be formally named Hylaeosaurus to the Geological Society.[11]

1833

  • Hylaeosaurus armatus.[12] This was the first ankylosaur ever discovered, although the group itself would not be recognized and named for many years.[13]

1840s

1842

Early April

  • Sir Richard Owen published his second report on British fossil reptiles, wherein he formally named the Dinosauria.[14] Hylaeosaurus was included as a founding member and was the third dinosaur to be named.[15]

1843

  • Hylaeosaurus mantellii.[12]

1844

  • Mantell described the new species
    Hylaeosaurus oweni.[12]

1850s

1856

  • Palaeoscincus costatus.[16] He considered it to be an herbivore.[7]

1858

  • Sir Richard Owen published a study on Hylaeosaurus.[17]

1860s

Polacanthus foxii skeletal restoration by Franz Nopcsa von Felső-Szilvás

1865

  • Reverend William Fox discovered the Polacanthus type specimen.[18]

1867

  • Sir Richard Owen described the new genus
    Acanthopholis horridus.[19]

1869

  • Iguanodon phillipsii.[16]

1870s

1871

  • Bunzel described the new genus and species
    Danubiosaurus anceps.[19]

1875

1879

  • Seeley described the new genus and species
    Syngonosaurus macrocercus.[16]

1880s

Nodosaurus textilis
skeleton

1881

1882

  • The British Museum of Natural History bought a large number of fossils from Rev. Fox, including the Polacanthus type specimen.[20]

1888

  • Priconodon crassus.[16]
Palaeoscincus costatus
holotype tooth

1889

1890s

1890

  • Marsh named the
    stegosaurs due to the shared presence of bony plates embedded in the skin.[5]

1892

  • Marsh described the new genus and species
    Palaeoscincus latus.[16]

1893

  • Lydekker described the new genus and species
    Sarcolestes leedsi.[19]

20th century

1900s

Artistic skeletal reconstruction of Ankylosaurus (AMNH 5895) by Barnum Brown, 1908, before the tail club was known
Ankylosaurus magniventris

1901

  • Stegosaurus marshi, and later reclassified it as Polacanthus marshi.[12]

1902

1905

  • Stegopelta landerensis.[19]

1908

  • Brown described the new genus and species
    Ankylosaurus magniventris.[21] He also named the Ankylosauridae and Ankylosaurinae. He followed Marsh's 1890 suggestion that ankylosaurs and stegosaurs were close relatives.[22]

1909

  • Wieland described the new genus and species
    Hierosaurus sternbergi.[16]

1910s

Nopsca
from 1915

1914

  • While collecting fossils in Dinosaur Provincial Park, William Edmund Cutler discovered the type specimen of an ankylosaur taxon that would later be named
    Scolosaurus cutleri in his honor. However, while undercutting the specimen it collapsed on him "resulting in serious upper body injuries."[23]

1915

  • Nopcsa described the new species
    Struthiosaurus transylvanicus.[12]

1918

  • Nopcsa described the new genus and species
    Leipsanosaurus noricus.[12]

1919

  • Lambe described the new genus and species
    Panoplosaurus mirus.[21]

1920s

Life restoration of two Edmontonia from 1922, based on the 1915 AMNH specimen

1923

1924

1927

  • ankylosaurs. As the Stegosauria originally included all armored dinosaurs, Romer's distinction marked the beginning of the modern use of the name to refer to the plate-backed and spike-tailed dinosaurs.[6]
Type specimen of Scolosaurus

1928

1929

1930s

Skeletal reconstruction of Pinacosaurus

1930

  • Palaeoscincus rugosidens.[12]

1932

  • Sternberg described the new ichnogenus and species Tetrapodosaurus borealis from the Early Cretaceous Gething Formation of British Columbia, Canada. He attributed the tracks to ceratopsians, but they would later be attributed to ankylosaurs.[24]

1933

  • Gilmore described the new genus and species
    Pinacosaurus grangeri.[22]

1934

  • Brachypodosaurus gravis.[19]

1935

  • Pinacosaurus ninghsiensis.[22]

1936

  • Nodosaurus coleii.[19]

1940s

1940

  • Russell concluded that ankylosaurs chewed with a simple straight-up-and-down movement of the jaws and only fed on soft vegetation based on aspects of their skull and tooth anatomy.[7]

1950s

Talarurus plicatospineus

1952

1953

  • Stegosaurides excavatus.[16]

1955

1956

  • Maleev described the new species
    Dyoplosaurus giganteus.[22]

1960s

1960

  • Silvisaurus condrayi.[21]

1963

  • F. H. Khakimov discovered a new dinosaur track site in Shirkent National Park, Tajikistan.[25]
  • Zakharov and Khakimov reported the dinosaur track site discovered by the latter to the scientific literature.[25]

1964

  • Zakharov described the new ichnogenus and species Macropodosaurus gravis. He attributed it to a theropod, but these tracks are more likely to have been produced by ankylosaurs.[25]

1969

  • Haas interpreted the ankylosaur diet and consisting of soft plants that ankylosaurs chewed with a simple straight-up-and-down movement of the jaws based on their skull and tooth anatomy.[7]

1970s

Scolosaurus thronus

1970

  • Sauropelta edwardsorum.[21]

1971

  • Walter Coombs published landmark research into ankylosaur taxonomy, bringing order to a once "chaotic and confused" field of study. He recognized two main groups of ankylosaurs, the Ankylosauridae and Nodosauridae.[5] Coombs interpreted the ankylosaur diet as consisting of soft plants that ankylosaurs chewed with a simple straight-up-and-down movement of the jaws based on their skull and tooth anatomy.[7]
  • Haubold reported the presence of the ichnospecies Metatetrapous valdensis from the
    Buckeburg Formation of Germany. This ichnospecies is attributed to ankylosaurs.[26]

1972

  • Coombs observed that Euoplocephalus was so thoroughly armored that there was even a bony plate protecting its eyelids.[27]

1977

  • Saichania chulsanensis.[22] She followed the scheme proposed by Coombs earlier that decade dividing the ankylosaurs into ankylosaurids and nodosaurids.[5] She also made observations regarding ankylosaur limb posture, noting that while the hind limb was nearly straight up and down, the humerus was oriented at an angle downward and toward the rear of the animal. When studying the ankylosaur tail she noted that the centra of the vertebrae near its tip are fused, which would make it hard for the animal to raise the tail club very high.[7]

1978

  • Kurzanov and Tumanova described the new genus and species
    Amtosaurus magnus.[19]
  • Coombs published more work on ankylosaur taxonomy.[5] He noted that ankylosaurs were probably completely unable to walk on their hind legs and published further remarks on ankylosaur limb posture. He argued that while some researchers interpreted some aspects of ankylosaur forelimb anatomy as adaptations for digging, their hoof-like toe nails made this interpretation unlikely.[28]

1979

  • Coombs interpreted the bony
    tendons near the tip of the ankylosaur tail as a means to convey the forces generated by the tail musculature closer to the animal's body all the way down to its club.[7]

1980s

Model of Minmi paravertebra at the National Dinosaur Museum, Canberra
Sauropelta edwardsorum
.

1980

1982

  • Delair described the new genus
    Vectensia.[12]

1983

1984

  • Kenneth Carpenter attributed the ichnogenus Tetrapodosaurus reported by Sternberg from British Columbia in the 1930s to ankylosaurs rather than ceratopsians.[24] He argued that the most likely trackmaker was Sauropelta.[30]
  • Leonardi described the dinosaur footprints reported by Campbell the previous year in detail and named them Ligabuichnium bolivianum. Rather than sauropods, Leonardi argued that these tracks were produced by ankylosaurs or ceratopsians although it was difficult ascertain which of these taxa were responsible due to the poor preservation of the tracks.[29]

1986

  • Galton interpreted the ankylosaur diet and consisting of soft plants that ankylosaurs chewed with a simple straight-up-and-down movement of the jaws based on their skull and tooth anatomy.[7]

1987

  • Paul Ensom described dinosaur footprints from the Purbeck Beds of England once thought to have been left by sauropods. They are now thought to have been left by ankylosaurs.[31]
  • Tumanova erected the new genus Maleevus to house the species Syrmosaurus disparoserratus.[16] Tumanova followed the scheme proposed by Coombs earlier that decade dividing the ankylosaurs into ankylosaurids and nodosaurids.[5]
  • Gasparini and others reported ankylosaur remains from Antarctica.[5]

1988

  • Chassternbergia
    for the species "Edmontonia" rugosidens.

1989

  • Currie reported the discovery of a Tetrapodosaurus track from British Columbia. Although he could not confidently identify its stratigraphic origin, the rock preserving the tracks has since been attributed to the Dunvegan Formation.[32]
  • A worker at the Smoky River Coal Mine near Grande Cache, Alberta alerted the Royal Tyrell Museum to the presence of dinosaur footprints in the area. This site would come to be recognized as the most important ankylosaur track site in the world.[33]

1990s

Skeletal reconstruction of Mymoorapelta at the Wyoming Dinosaur Center

1990

  • Coombs and Maryanska remarked that the boney secondary palate of the ankylosaur skull would have strengthened it by acting as a brace.[7]
  • A well-preserved skeleton of Minmi was excavated from the Allaru Formation in Queensland, Australia by the Queensland Museum and catalogued as QM F18101. The skeleton was mostly articulated, including its armor.[34] Since most ankylosaur specimens do not preserve the life arrangement of their armor, QM F18101 represented a rare find.[35] The specimen also preserved the animal's gut contents, the first to be discovered in any armored dinosaur.[36]

1991

  • Lockley argued that the supposed sauropod tracks reported by Ensom from the Purbeck Beds of Dorset, England were actually made by ankylosaurs.[37]
  • Frank DeCourten discovered dinosaur tracks preserved in the Cedar Mountain Formation of Utah that were likely produced by ankylosaurs.[38]

1993

  • Tumanova described the new genus and species
    Tsagantegia longicranialis.[22]
  • Thulborn proposed that the tail club of ankylosaurs may actually have functioned as a "false head" meant to distract predators. However, this hypothesis has not received much support from the paleontological community, and has been criticized as "dubiou[s]".[7]
  • Grady published an illustration of an ankylosaur trackway from the "Mine" site in the Smoky River Coal Mine at Grande Cache, Alberta.[40]

1994

1995

1996

North American Museum of Ancient Life
  • Blows described the new species
    Polacanthus rudgwickensis.[19]

1997

  • Witmer studied archosaur "craniofacial pneumaticity". He concluded that rather than performing a biological function,
    glands, acted as a resonating chamber for loud vocalizations, or helped conserve body heat and moisture.[7]

1998

Skeletal reconstruction of Tianzhenosaurus
  • Pang and Cheng described the new genus and species
    Tianzhenosaurus youngi.[22]
  • Barret and others described the new genus and species
  • Sereno defined the ankylosaurs as all eurypods more closely related to Ankylosaurus than to Stegosaurus.[43]
  • McCrea and Currie described the dinosaur tracks discovered in the Smoky River Coal Mine at Grand Cache, Alberta. They noted that this was the most important ankylosaur track site ever discovered.[33]
  • McCrea and others reported the first known ankylosaur skin impression to be preserved in a footprint tracks preserved in the Dunvegan Formation near Pouce Coupe, Alberta.[44]

1999

21st century

2000s

Tarchia kielanae

2000

2001

Aletopelta coombsi

2002

2003

2004

  • Averianov, 2002, vide Parish & Barrett, 2004 described the new genus and species
    Bissektipelta archibaldi.[53]
Minotaurasaurus ramachandrani

2005

  • Ősi described the new genus and species
    Hungarosaurus tormai.[54]

2006

  • Salgado and Gasparini described the new genus and species
    Antarctopelta oliveroi.[55]

2007

2008

Europelta carbonensis

2009

2010s

2011

Ziapelta sanjuanensis

2013

2014

2015

2017

Jinyunpelta sinensis

2018

2019

2020s

2020

  • An isolated caudal vertebra representing the first evidence of the presence of an ankylosaur in the Upper Jurassic Qigu Formation (China) is described by Augustin et al. (2020).[88]
  • A study aiming to determine the social lifestyle of ankylosaurs, as indicated by anatomy, taphonomic history, ontogenetic composition of the mass death assemblages and inferred habitat characteristics, is published by Botfalvai, Prondvai & Ősi (2020).[89]
  • Redescription of the anatomy of the holotype specimens of Hylaeosaurus armatus and Polacanthus foxii, and a study on the taxonomy of all ankylosaur specimens from the British Wealden Supergroup, is published by Raven et al. (2020).[90]
  • Fossil stomach contents preserved within the abdominal cavity of the holotype specimen of Borealopelta markmitchelli are described by Brown et al. (2020).[91]
  • Description of the anatomy of braincases of three specimens of Bissektipelta archibaldi is published by Kuzmin et al. (2020).[92]
  • Wang et al. (2020) describe the new genus and species of ankylosaur, Sinankylosaurus.[93]

See also

Footnotes

  1. ^ a b Mayor (2005); "Smoking the Monster's Bone: An Ancient Delaware Fossil Legend," pages 68–69.
  2. ^ a b Mayor (2005); "The Monsters," page 122.
  3. ^ a b Mayor (2005); "Blackfeet and Ojibwe Fossil Discoveries," page 292.
  4. ^ Sarjeant (1999); "Further Finds in England," pages 9–10.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Introduction", page 363.
  6. ^ a b Galton and Upchurch (2004); "Introduction", page 343.
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Paleoecology and Behavior", page 392.
  8. ^ Mayor (2005); "Fossils in Navajo Land," page 119.
  9. ^ Mayor (2005); "The Monsters," page 119.
  10. ^ Mayor (2005); "Fossils in Navajo Land," page 117.
  11. ^ a b Moore (2014); "1832" (1), page 31.
  12. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Table 17.1: Ankylosauria", page 366.
  13. ^ For Hylaeosaurus as the first ankylosaur, see Sarjeant (1999); "Further Finds in England," pages 9–10. For the date of the description of Ankylosauria, see Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Introduction", page 363.
  14. ^ Torrens (1999); "Politics and Paleontology", page 182.
  15. ^ Torrens (1999); "Politics and Paleontology", page 184.
  16. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Table 17.1: Ankylosauria", page 368.
  17. ^ Moore (2014); "1858" (3), page 53.
  18. ^ Moore (2014); "1865" (3), page 61.
  19. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Table 17.1: Ankylosauria", page 367.
  20. ^ Moore (2014); "1882" (1), page 91.
  21. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Table 17.1: Ankylosauria", page 365.
  22. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Table 17.1: Ankylosauria", page 364.
  23. ^ Tanke (2010); "Background and Collection History," page 542.
  24. ^ a b McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Gething Formation, British Columbia (Aptian-Albian)", page 422.
  25. ^ a b c d McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Shirabad Suite, Tadjikistan (Albian)", page 433.
  26. ^ a b McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Wealden Beds, Germany (Berriasian)", pages 421-422.
  27. ^ Vickaryous, Russell, and Currie (2001); "Testing the Hypothesis", page 327.
  28. ^ Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Paleoecology and Behavior", pages 391–392.
  29. ^ a b c McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Torotoro Formation, Bolivia (Campanian)", page 442.
  30. ^ McCrea (2000); "Tetrapodosaurus borealis Sternberg, 1932", page 41.
  31. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Purbeck Beds, England (Berriasian)", page 421.
  32. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Dunvegan Formation, Alberta and Northeast British Columbia (Cenomanian)", page 437.
  33. ^ a b McCrea (2000); "1.2 Previous work on the Gates Formation", page 2.
  34. ^ Molnar (2001); "Introduction", page 342.
  35. ^ Molnar (2001); "Introduction", page 341.
  36. ^ Molnar and Clifford (2001); "Introduction", pages 399-400.
  37. ^ Lockley and Meyer (2000); "The First Ankylosaur Tracks," pages 182-183.
  38. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Cedar Mountain Formation, Utah (Albian-Cenomanian)", page 433.
  39. ^ a b c Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Taphonomy", page 391.
  40. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Gates Formation, Grande Cache, Alberta (Lower Albian)", page 429.
  41. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Gates Formation, Grande Cache, Alberta (Lower Albian)", page 423.
  42. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Saltwick Formation, England (Aalenian-Bajocian)", page 421.
  43. ^ Vickaryous, Maryanska, and Weishampel (2004); "Definition and Diagnosis", page 363.
  44. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Dunvegan Formation, Alberta and Northeast British Columbia (Cenomanian)", page 440.
  45. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Cedar Mountain Formation, Utah (Albian-Cenomanian)", pages 433-434.
  46. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Djadokhta Formation, Mongolia (Campanian)", page 441.
  47. ^ Molnar and Clifford (2001); "Abstract", page 399.
  48. ^ For date and location of discovery, see Molnar (2001); "Introduction", page 342. For catalogue number and stomach contents, see Molnar and Clifford (2001); "Introduction", page 399.
  49. ^ Molnar and Clifford (2001); "Description", page 401.
  50. ^ Molnar and Clifford (2001); "Introduction", page 400.
  51. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Dakota Group (Albian-Cenomanian)", page 435.
  52. ^ McCrea, Lockley, and Meyer (2001); "Blackhawk Formation, Utah (Campanian)", page 440.
  53. ^ Parish and Barrett (2004); "Abstract", page 299.
  54. ^ Ősi (2005); "Abstract", page 370.
  55. ^ Salgado and Gasparini (2006); "Abstract", page 199.
  56. ^ Lü et al. (2007); "Abstract", page 344.
  57. ^ Xu et al. (2007); "Abstract", page 433.
  58. ^ Carpenter et al. (2008); "Abstract", page 1089.
  59. S2CID 140672072
    .
  60. ^ Miles and Miles (2009); "Abstract", page 65.
  61. ^ Parsons and Parsons (2009); "Abstract", page 721.
  62. S2CID 85665879
    .
  63. ^ Burns and Sullivan (2011); "Abstract", page 169.
  64. .
  65. ^ Stanford, Weishampel, and DeLeon (2011); "Abstract", page 916.
  66. ^ Chen et al. (2013); "Abstract", page 658.
  67. ^ Kirkland et al. (2013); "Abstract", page 1.
  68. ^ Penkalski (2013); "Abstract", page 617.
  69. ^ Yang et al. (2013); "Abstract", page 265.
  70. ^ Han et al. (2014); "Abstract", page 1.
  71. ^ Arbour and Currie (2015); "Abstract".
  72. ^ Arbour, Currie, and Badamgarav (2014); "Abstract", page 631.
  73. ^ Arbour et al. (2014); "Abstract", page 1.
  74. ^ Blows (2015); in passim.
  75. ^ Leahey et al. (2015); in passim.
  76. S2CID 130610291
    .
  77. .
  78. ^ "Zuul, Destroyer of Shins". ROM: Royal Ontario Museum. Royal Ontario Museum. Retrieved 11 May 2017.
  79. S2CID 5182644
    . Retrieved 9 March 2018.
  80. .
  81. .
  82. .
  83. .
  84. .
  85. .
  86. .
  87. .
  88. .
  89. .
  90. .
  91. .
  92. .
  93. ^ Wang, K. B.; Zhang, Y. X.; Chen, J.; Chen, S. Q.; Wang, P. Y. (2020). "A new ankylosaurian from the Late Cretaceous strata of Zhucheng, Shandong Province". Geological Bulletin of China (in Chinese). 39 (7): 958–962.

References

External links