United Front for the Liberation of Oppressed Races
United Front for the Liberation of Oppressed Races | |
---|---|
Front unifié de lutte des races opprimées | |
(1976–1992) | |
The United Front for the Liberation of Oppressed Races (FULRO;
Fractured by nature, FULRO was a symbolic alliance of various indigenous and ethnic groups in South Vietnam formed as an armed reaction against US-backed
The movement dissolved almost three decades later in 1992, when the last group of 407 FULRO fighters and their families handed in their weapons to the United Nations peacekeepers in Cambodia.
FULRO built its strength mainly by recruiting Montagnard CIDGs (mostly
Historical origins of FULRO
For centuries, Vietnamese rulers had expanded their domains southward, conquering
The French colonial regime for its part also contributed to separatist movements among the Cham and Khmer by supporting the
The South Vietnamese government that succeeded the French required Khmer Krom people to change their names to Vietnamese sounding names in order to go to school or apply for a job, then forced students to speak only in Vietnamese, and instituted a land reform policy that settled Vietnamese on Khmer Krom land.
These measures led to the creation of several separatist groups, including the republican "Free Khmer", or Khmer Serei, movement founded by Dr. Son Ngoc Thanh in 1958, and the Kaingsaing Sar, or Khmer White Scarves movement, a semi-mystic, semi-military group, founded in 1959 by a monk, Samouk Seng. Prince Norodom Sihanouk of Cambodia supported the White Scarves movement as a counterbalance to the Khmer Serei.[9] The Front for the Liberation of the Kampuchea-Krom, or the FLKK, absorbed the Kaingsaing Sar. The Les Kosem-led "Champa Liberation Front" was founded in Phnom Penh in 1960.[10]
The Vietnamese had also been hostile for years to the Montagnards, the native inhabitants of the Central Highlands (Vietnam), referring to them as "savage" (mọi), based on their distinct religion, culture, language, and the Malayo-Polynesian ethnicity of some Montagnard groups such as the Jarai (Gia Rai).[11] These hostilities intensified when Montagnard-inhabited Central Highlands became open to Vietnamese settlement under French rule.
The South Vietnamese government under
The South Vietnamese government persisted with its "Social and Economic Council for the Southern Highlands" without making any provision for local autonomy, claiming that these communities needed to be "developed" as they were "poor" and "ignorant". Ethnic Vietnamese were settled from the coastal regions into the highlands, with 50,000 Vietnamese settlers moving in the highlands by 1960 and 200,000 by 1963. The Highlander Liberation Front (Mặt trận Giải phóng Dân tộc Thượng, Front de Libération des Montagnards) was founded in 1955 during a meeting of indigenous Montagnards who had originally rallied to Y Thih Eban against the South Vietnamese government cadres.
Montagnard hostility was not limited, however, to the South Vietnamese government, but extended as well to North Vietnam, based on the ill-treatment their communities had received at the hands of the Vietnamese before the division of Vietnam.[14]
BAJARAKA – precursor of FULRO
On May 1, 1958, a group of intellectuals, headed by a French-educated
On July 25, BAJARAKA issued a notice to the embassies of France and the United States and to the United Nations, denouncing acts of racial discrimination, and requesting government intervention to secure independence. BAJARAKA held several demonstrations in Kon Tum, Pleiku, and Buôn Ma Thuột in August and September 1958. These were quickly suppressed and the most prominent leaders of the movement arrested; they would remain in jail for the next few years.
One of BAJARAKA's leaders, Y Bih Aleo, later joined the
The FLHP
The early 1960s were to see increasing military activity in the Central Highlands; from 1961, American military advisers had assisted in setting up armed village defence militias (the Civilian Irregular Defense Groups, CIDG).
In 1963, after the
The Front rapidly split into two factions. One faction, advocating peaceful means, was led by Y Bham Enuol. A second, led by Y Dhon Adrong, a former Rhade teacher, advocated violent resistance. From March to May 1964, Adrong's faction infiltrated the border with Cambodia and set up at the old French base, Camp le Rolland, in Mondulkiri Province within 15 km of the Vietnamese border, where they continued to recruit FLHP fighters.
FULRO
In the meantime, the regional ambitions of Prince Norodom Sihanouk had led to an effort to coordinate the operations of various separatist groups operating within South Vietnam and in the Cambodian border areas.[15] Prince Sihanouk launched the Indochinese People's conference in Phnom Penh March 1963 with Y Bham Enuol.[16]
Y Dhon Adrong's faction of the FLHP made contact with two other groups:
- The Front for the Liberation of Champa (Front pour la Libération du Champa, FLC) led by Lieutenant Colonel Les Kosem, a Cham officer in the Royal Cambodian Army (FARK).
- The Liberation Front of Kampuchea Krom (Front de Liberation du Kampuchea Krom, FLKK), representing the Khmer Krom of the Mekong Delta, led by former monk Chau Dara.
Kosem, the most senior Cham officer in the Cambodian army, had been involved in Cham activism since the late 1950s, and is suspected to have been working as a double agent for both the Cambodian secret service and the French.[17] Chau Dara, the founder of the FLKK, was also suspected of working for the Cambodian secret service.[17]
These contacts were to lead to the establishment of the United Front for the Liberation of Oppressed Races (FULRO), based on the above groups and the FLHP. The flag of FULRO was designed with three stripes: one blue (representing the sea), one red (representing the struggle of the Montagnards) and one green (representing the mountains). Three white stars on the central red stripe represented the three fronts of FULRO. A later form of the flag replaced the blue stripe with black.
While FULRO claimed to speak for the Cham, Khmer and Montagnard communities,[18] its common bond and ideology was anti-Vietnamese sentiment, with questionable allegiance to anything else.
In 1965, FULRO released maps showing that their ultimate goal was for Montagnard and Cham independence within a revived new Champa state and for Khmers to retake Cochinchina.[19] It was based in Ratanakiri and Mondulkiri provinces in Cambodia,[20] and the Central Highlands in Vietnam.[21]
The Viet Cong approached FULRO after its founding.[22] No agreements were reached and hostilities between FULRO and the NLF continued.[23] The US later sought to capitalize on these communities' animosity towards Vietnamese to use FULRO against the NLF.[24]
The 1964 Buôn Ma Thuột rebellion
On September 20, 1964, there was an outbreak of violence by American-trained CIDG troops in the Special Forces bases of Buon Sar Pa and Bu Prang in Quảng Đức Province (now
Outsiders advising and assisting the dissident Montagnards were Y Dhon Adrong, two officers of the Royal Khmer Army, Lieutenant Colonel Y Bun Sur, a member of the M'Nong tribe and Province Chief of Cambodia's Mondulkiri Province, Les Kosem, and Chau Dara.[25]
During the morning of September 21, Y Bham Enuol was quickly abducted from his residence in Buôn Ma Thuột by elements from the Buon Sar Pa group and communiques were issued in his name.[25] Several weeks later, Y Bham's family were quietly taken from his village, Buon Ea Bong, three kilometres northwest of Buôn Ma Thuột, and escorted into the FULRO base in Cambodia's Mondulkiri Province.[25]
On the evening of September 21, 1964, Brigadier General Nguyễn Hữu Cơ, the commander of Military Region II, who had flown down to Buôn Ma Thuột from his headquarters in Pleiku, met with several rebel leaders from Buon Enao, during which he assured them of his partial support of some of their demands in representations to Prime Minister General Nguyễn Khánh and the Saigon government. Following progress in their negotiations, General Co requested that the rebel leaders brief the other dissident elements and ask them to peacefully return to their bases and await the outcome of the negotiations. The leaders who had met with General Cơ the previous night were prevented from briefing the Buon Sar Pa group which, still disgruntled, returned to their Buon Sar Pa Special Forces base, accompanied by Colonel John F. Freund, the US Army advisor to General Cơ. Colonel Freund's decision to accompany the still dissident Buon Sar Pa group was not authorised by General Cơ.[25]
The Buon Sar Pa group continued to defy the Vietnamese authorities and most of the CIDG force deserted their Buon Sar Pa base and moved, with their weapons and equipment, across the international border and into Cambodia's Mondulkiri Province. Those CIDG troops remaining in the Buon Sar Pa base were threatened by General Cơ with a sharp military response and Freund, who had stayed with them, persuaded them to officially surrender to Prime Minister General Nguyễn Khánh. An official surrender ceremony took place in the mostly deserted Buon Sar Pa base; however this resulted in a loss of face for those dissident Montagnards who had agreed to stand down and await the promises made by General Co during negotiations with their leaders on the night of September 21, 1964.[25]
During the weeks that followed, the Buon Sar Pa CIDG deserters in their base in Mondulkiri Province were reinforced by a large number of deserters from the other CIDG Special Forces bases.[26] Y Bham was named head of FULRO, given the rank of General and named President of the High Plateau of Champa, a sign of the influence on the dissidents by the Cham advisers, Lieutenant Colonel Les Kosem and Chau Dara.[25] A Cham goddess's name was used as a call sign by Les Kosem.[27]
Cambodia was suspected of support for the rebellion.
The Americans were unsure who was ultimately responsible for the CIDG rebellion and initially blamed the Viet Cong and French.[17] However, the 'neutralist' Cambodian regime of Sihanouk had probably the greatest hand in events: the 20 September 1964 'Declaration' by the Haut Comité of FULRO contained anti-SEATO rhetoric that bore a strong resemblance to that issued by Sihanouk's regime in the same period.[19] Meanwhile, Sihanouk hosted a conference, the "Indochinese People's Conference", in Phnom Penh in early 1965, at which Enuol headed a FULRO delegation.
Y Bham brought FULRO to the fore in 1965 when FULRO published anti-South Vietnamese propaganda against CIDG troops that attacked the Saigon regime and applauded Cambodia for its support.[16]
Adjacent to Vietnam, the Cambodian forests were a base by FULRO fighters battling the
An FULRO declaration in 1965 announced to the United Nations and the Member States of the Committee of Decolonization that they would be fighting against both South Vietnam and the US to achieve independence. Initial media and sources from Saigon dismissively downplayed the FULRO threats, suggesting that the uprising was held by a small group of "illiterate" highlanders. When the Khánh regime collapsed in June 1965, the administration under new Prime Minister of South Vietnam Nguyễn Cao Kỳ terminated the state's discriminatory development programs to appease the tensions with the indigenous peoples.[29]
Negotiations and divisions
On June 2, 1967, Y Bham Enuol sent a delegation to Buôn Ma Thuột to petition the South Vietnamese government. On June 25 and 26, 1967, a congress of ethnic minorities throughout South Vietnam was convened to finalise a joint petition, and on August 29, 1967, a meeting was held under the direction of Nguyễn Văn Thiệu, President of the National Leadership Committee and Major General Nguyễn Cao Kỳ, President of the Central Executive Committee.
The South Vietnamese government sent a diplomatic contingent to Buôn Mê Thuột in August 1968 to negotiate with FULRO representatives, including Y Bham, after a promise of safe conduct was given to him by Prime Minister Trần Văn Hương. FULRO's grievances against South Vietnam were no longer the top priority for Cambodia at this point, however, because the Khmer Rouge was starting to distract Sihanouk in 1968.[30]
By December 11, 1968, negotiations between FULRO and the Vietnamese authorities had resulted in an agreement to recognise minority rights, establish a Ministry to support these rights, and to allow Y Bham Enuol to remain permanently in Vietnam. However, some elements of FULRO, notably FLC head Les Kosem, opposed the deal with the Vietnamese. On December 30, 1968, Kosem, at the head of several battalions of the Royal Cambodian Army, and accompanied by a group from the militant FULRO wing responsible for the 1965 fighting, surrounded and took Camp le Rolland. Enuol was placed under effective house arrest in Phnom Penh at the residence of Colonel Um Savuth of the Cambodian army, where he was to remain for the next six years.
On February 1, 1969, a final treaty was signed between Paul Nur, representing South Vietnam, and Y Dhon Adrong. These events signified the end of FULRO as a 'political' movement, especially as its previous backer, the
After the fall of Sihanouk and Lon Nol
After overthrowing pro-China Sihanouk, Cambodian leader Lon Nol, despite being anti-Communist and ostensibly in the "pro-American" camp, backed FULRO against both anti-communist South Vietnam and the communist Viet Cong. Lon Nol planned a slaughter of all Vietnamese in Cambodia[32] and a restoration of South Vietnam to a revived Champa state. The Khmer Rouge later imitated Lon Nol's actions.[33]
Lon Nol backed FULRO hill tribes, fighting a proxy war against the NLF via Khmer Krom detachments in South Vietnam and Cambodia's frontier region, as he desired to emulate Van Pao.[34]
On April 17, 1975, the
After the fall of South Vietnam
After
FULRO continued operations in the remote highlands throughout the late 1970s and into the early 1980s, but it was increasingly weakened by internal divisions, and trapped in an ongoing conflict between the Khmer Rouge and Vietnam.[37] China gave FULRO aid and assistance via Thailand to fight the Vietnamese throughout the 1970s and 1980s (and during the Sino-Vietnamese War), while also backing ethnic minorities in northern Vietnam along the border against the Vietnamese.[38] There was high mobility among ethnic minorities such as the Hmong, Yao, Nung, and Tai across the border between China and Vietnam.[39]
As a result, there was a peak in this second phase of the FULRO insurgency during the 1980s.[38] FULRO attacked the PAVN forces and police stations in the provinces of Đắk Lắk, Kon Tum, and Gia Lai.[40] Some estimates gave the total number of FULRO troops in this period at 7,000, mostly based in Mondulkiri, and supplied with Chinese armaments via the Khmer Rouge, which was by this point fighting its own guerrilla war in western Cambodia. However, by 1986, this aid had ceased, a Khmer Rouge spokesman stating that while the tribesmen were "very, very brave", they had "no support from any leadership" and "no political vision".[41]
Following the cessation of supplies, the bitter guerrilla warfare would however in time reduce FULRO's forces to no more than a few hundred. In 1980, a unit of over 200 fighters was forced to split off and take refuge in Khmer Rouge territory on the Thai-Cambodian border. In 1985, 212 of these soldiers, under the command of Y Ghok Nie Krieng and Pierre K'Briuh, moved across Cambodia to the Thai border where Lieutenant General Chavalit Yongchaiyudh, then Commander of the 2nd Royal Thai Army, advised them that the Americans were no longer interested in fighting the Vietnamese. General Chavalit advised them to seek refugee status through UNHCR. Once this was granted, they were moved to North Carolina in the U.S.[42]
In August 1992, journalist Nate Thayer traveled to Mondulkiri and visited the last FULRO base.[43] Thayer informed the group that their leader, Y Bham, had been executed by the Khmer Rouge seventeen years previously. The FULRO troops surrendered their weapons in October 1992; many of this group were given asylum in the United States.[44] Even at this late stage, they only decided to give up armed struggle when they finally heard that Y Bham Enuol had been executed in April 1975.[41]
As many as 200,000 Montagnards may have been killed by Vietnamese forces in the twenty years after the end of the Vietnam War.[45]
Post-insurgency
A 2002 op-ed in the Washington Times written by Michael Benge, a senior adviser to the Montagnard Human Rights Organisation, claimed that Montagnard women were subjected to forced mass sterilization by the Vietnamese government. The article also alleged that the government was stealing lands of Montagnards and attacking their religious beliefs, killing and torturing them in a form of "creeping genocide".[46]
Luke Simpkins, an MP in the Australian House of Representatives, condemned the Vietnamese persecution of the Montagnards in 2011. Noting that both the South Vietnamese government and the regime of unified Communist Vietnam had attacked the Montagnards and conquered their lands as well as how FULRO had fought against the Vietnamese, Simpkins expressed support for the desire of the Montagnards to preserve their culture and language. The Vietnamese government has non-Montagnards settle on Montagnard land and killed Montagnards after jailing them. He also spoke of the 200,000 Montagnard deaths during the war.[47]
According to researcher Seb Rumsby, there are certain but unrecognized imperial relationships between ethnic Kinh colonizers and indigenous minorities, and following that plenty of daily resistance from the Montagnards to state systemic discrimination and repressive assimilation policies. While marginalization and racial stereotypes about the Montagnards are abundant, few of them could be exactly figured out and acknowledged now, because of Kinh chauvinism and
See also
References
- ^ a b c d Written by BBT Champaka.info (8 September 2013). "Tiểu sử Ts. Po Dharma, tác giả Lịch Sử 33 Năm Cuối Cùng Champa". Champaka.info.
- ISBN 978-1-134-12268-4.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ^ ISBN 978-0-19516-0-765.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ^ Dommen, A. J. The Indochinese experience of the French and the Americans, Indiana University Press, 2001, p.615. The Kaingsaing Sar were similar to the Hòa Hảo, in that they evolved from a religious group to an armed nationalist one.
- ^ Po Dharma. "From the F.L.M to Fulro (1955-1975)". Cham Today. Translated by Musa Porome. IOC-Champa. Archived from the original on 2014-03-16.
- ISBN 978-0-7603-1974-1.
- ISBN 978-0-8248-2579-9.
- ^ "The Realities of Vietnam" (PDF). The Ripon Forum. III (9). The Ripon Society: 21. 1967. Retrieved 13 May 2016.
- ISBN 978-0-7864-5470-9.
- ISBN 9780598348661.
- ^ ISBN 978-1-56663-079-5.
- ^ a b c White, T. Swords of lightning: special forces and the changing face of warfare, Brassey's, 1992, p.143
- ^ Smith, Harvey Henry; American University (Washington, D.C.). Foreign Areas Studies Division (1967). Area handbook for South Vietnam. For sale by the Supt. of Docs., U.S. Govt. Print. Off. p. 245.
- ^ a b Christie, C. J. A modern history of Southeast Asia: decolonization, nationalism and separatism, I.B. Tauris, 1996, p.101
- ISBN 978-981-230-162-8.
Sihanouk FULRO.
- ISBN 978-1-58544-054-2.
- ^ American University (Washington, D.C.), Foreign Area Studies (1968). Area handbook for Cambodia. For sale by the Supt. of Docs., U.S. Govt. Print. Off. p. 185.
{{cite book}}
: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ "Weaker Sex Plays Strong Vietnam Role". The Milwaukee Sentinel. Saigon, South Vietnam‒AP‒ Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States. August 28, 1965. p. Page 2, Part 1.
- ISBN 978-0-7043-2580-7.
- ^ a b c d e f g "Tiger Men: An Australian Soldier's Secret War in Vietnam" by Barry Petersen.
- ISBN 978-0-7336-2577-0.
- Rand Corporation. pp. 24, 29, 30.
- ISBN 978-0-333-33957-2.
- .
- ISBN 978-0-253-33854-9.
- ^ Fenton, J. All the Wrong Places, Granta, 2005, p.62
- ISBN 978-0-522-85477-0.
- ISBN 978-0-522-85477-0.
- ISBN 978-0-85345-171-6.
- ^ Dawson, Alan (April 12, 1976). "New Communist governments feeling some opposition". The Dispatch. Lexington, N.C. p. 20.
- ^ Dawson, Alan (April 4, 1976). "Resistance To Communists Grows In Indochina". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. newspaper located at (Sarasota, Florida) author reported from (Bangkok, Thailand (UPI)). p. 12·F.
- ^ Whereas the Vietnamese government still maintains FULRO negotiated an uneasy alliance with the Khmer Rouge in this period, pro-Montagnard groups state that men were in fact kidnapped by the Khmer Rouge to serve as porters and clear minefields.
- ^ a b O'Dowd, E. C. Chinese military strategy in the third Indochina war: the last Maoist war, Routledge, 2007, p.97
- ISBN 978-1-134-12268-4.
- ISBN 978-1-134-12268-4.
- ^ a b Jones, S. et al., Repression of Montagnards, Human Rights Watch, p.27
- ^ Nate Thayer, "Forgotten Army: The Rebels Time Forgot", Far Eastern Economic Review, September 10, 1992, pp. 16-22.
- ^ Nate Thayer, "Montagnard Army Seeks UN Help. Phnom Penh Post, September 12, 1992.
- ^ Nate Thayer and Leo Dobbs, "Tribal Fighters Head for Refuge in USA. Phnom Penh Post, October 23, 1992.
- ISBN 978-0-307-41463-2.
- ^ Johnson, Scott (2002-04-07). "Creeping Genocide in Asia: Vietnam". Montagnard Foundation, Inc. Archived from the original on 2004-10-29.
- ^ "Australia MP Luke Simpkins Speaks Out On Persecution of Montagnards". Montagnard Foundation. Commonwealth of Australia – Vietnam: Montagnard's Speech Wednesday, 6 July 2011 By Authority of the House of Representatives. July 8, 2011. Archived from the original on 2011-12-02.
- S2CID 143293467 – via Taylor & Francis.
- S2CID 234065322 – via Brill Publishers.