Ariston Bathhouse raid
This article's lead section may be too short to adequately summarize the key points. (February 2018) |
The Ariston Bathhouse raid in 1903 was the first anti-gay police raid on an establishment located in New York City. It resulted in thirty-four arrests, sixteen charges of sodomy, and twelve trials, five of which possess transcripts.
Raid
On February 21, 1903, at nine o’clock at night, two
At 1:45 a.m., a group of police officers entered the establishment and blocked the exits so that none of the seventy-eight men inside could escape. They went through the men and found the individuals who they possessed complaints against, and arrested thirty-four men. The rest were let go with a warning. The
It is known that police had spent several weeks collecting evidence against men who entered the bathhouse, which they did in conjunction with the Society for the Prevention of Crime. They used this evidence to create two diagrams of the bathhouse, which were used in the trials that followed.[7]
Trials
In the trial of People v. Kregel, the defense relied on the physical impossibility of sodomy. The
At that point, Dr. Pierre A. Siegelstein was called by the
In People v. Galbert, the defense attorney cited the “physical impossibility” and “mathematical impossibility” of the crime. An employee from the bathhouse was called as a witness, and said that the couches present in the room where Galbert was found were a little more than a foot high, and Charles LeBarbier, Galbert's attorney, suggested that the couches were too low to permit the accused crime to take place. Galbert was an architect for Carrere and Hastings, a prominent firm that lead the Beaux Arts movement. Because of this, John Carrere, an accomplished architect, was called to attest to Galbert's mental health along with four other character witnesses. When Galbert was found guilty, LaBarbier used his resistance against the police during his arrest as a testament to his manliness and masculinity.[8]
In People v. Schnittel,
In People v. Bennett, Walter Bennett's defense attorney also cited his client's heterosexuality and desire for women as proof that he was innocent. The police accused him of wearing a sheet as a woman might, as well as engaging in oral and anal sex with another man. To testify against this, two women and a minister who knew Bennett were called. One of the women, Catherine Bolton, said that she had known Bennett since he was fourteen years old and implied that she had been romantically involved with him at some point. The prosecuting attorney claimed that the feminine perspectives of the women and the minister were not a good indication of Bennett's character, and went on to imply that Bennett was not unlike the women himself.[3]
In People v. Casson, Theodore Casson denied the charge of sodomy placed against him, but did admit to being in the Turkish bath, where he was arrested. The officer who arrested him claimed to have arrested him shortly after the accused act took place, which caused a direct conflict of testimony. The jury returned a verdict of guilty with a recommendation to mercy.[2]
References
- ^ ISBN 9781438461953.
- ^ a b People of the State of New York v Theodore Casson (Trial 350) - Lloyd Sealy Library Digital Collections - John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Retrieved 27 February 2018.
{{cite book}}
:|website=
ignored (help) - ^ a b People of the State of New York v Walter Bennett (Trial 369) - Lloyd Sealy Library Digital Collections - John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Retrieved 27 February 2018.
{{cite book}}
:|website=
ignored (help) - ^ a b The People of the State of New York v Abraham Kregal (Trial 353) - Lloyd Sealy Library Digital Collections - John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Retrieved 27 February 2018.
{{cite book}}
:|website=
ignored (help) - ^ a b People of the State of New York v Michael Schnittel (Trial 355) - Lloyd Sealy Library Digital Collections - John Jay College of Criminal Justice. Retrieved 27 February 2018.
{{cite book}}
:|website=
ignored (help) - ISBN 978-0-7867-2335-5.
- ^ "(Page 4 of 29) - The Ariston Bathhouse Raid of 1903: Character, Class, and the Legal Construction of Sodomy authored by Donovan, Brian". citation.allacademic.com. Retrieved 27 February 2018.
- ^ "(Page 21 of 29) - The Ariston Bathhouse Raid of 1903: Character, Class, and the Legal Construction of Sodomy authored by Donovan, Brian". citation.allacademic.com. Retrieved 27 February 2018.