Talk:Craigie, Angus

Cleanup

Interesting article, a few points:

The content is a bit unbalanced for the title (Craigie, Angus). Bear in mind that Craigie is an existing district of Dundee. It might be worth reading

WP:UKTOWNS

for guidelines on what to include in articles on settlements.

Craigie has not been in Angus for a very long time.

There are a few issues with the style.

WP:LEAD

.

Catfish Jim & the soapdish 13:14, 1 March 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Hi, Catfish Jim!

Thank you very much for your helpful hints and tips. I'm new, as you know, so every bit of advice is welcome!

In hindsight I wish I had created an article entitled "Barony of Craigie (Angus/Forfar)" instead of "Craigie, Angus." The focus is on the history and people of the barony, and not at all balanced in the direction of Craigie, as you noted. I'll make that switch at some point, and abandon Craigie to those with more knowledge than I.

Based on the article

List of Scottish Feudal Baronies

I'll rename "Craigie, Angus" to "Scottish feudal barony of Craigie." If there is an easy way to rename an article versus migrate it, I'm all ears!

I'll adopt the style points you raise when I migrate the article.

Thank you again.

Best regards, Meshuge28 (talk) 15:45, 1 March 2011 (UTC)[reply]