Wikipedia:Wikipedia Signpost/2007-02-05/Arbitration report
Arbitration report
The Report on Lengthy Litigation
The Arbitration Committee opened one case this week, and closed five cases.
Closed cases
- administrators' noticeboard, before being referred to ArbCom for a decision. As a result of the case Nathanrdotcom was blocked indefinitely.
- -related AfDs, which Morwen considered to be "intimidating", and Husnock alleges that she stated that she was "in fear of her life", and that he has been investigated by real-world bodies regarding it. As a result of the case, Husnock's comments were described as "regrettable", and "at least one of [them] could justly be interpreted as a credible threat of harm, and he was desysopped and cautioned on various matters.
- Yoshiaki Omurawhich was criticised by a New Zealand disciplinary tribunal as lacking scientific basis. However, Richardmalter denies that his pro-Omura edits were either biased or unsourced and claims that the mediation process has supported his position. As a result of the case, Richardmalter was described as "[having] edited Yoshiaki Omura in an aggressive, biased manner", and banned from the article indefinitely.
- without prejudice.
- SPAsand others to be blocked indefinitely was enacted.
New case
- feel that there has been abuse of dispute tags.
Evidence phase
- WLU-Mystar: WLU alleges that Mystar has harrassed him, alleging incivility, wikistalking and sockpuppetry, inter alia. Mystar denies the allegations, and claims that WLU has been incivil.
- AN/I for "posting links to sites that some considered to be attack sites". Various users attempted to assist Ilena, but "This was sabotaged...when Fyslee posted a link to a site that attacked Ilena in a personal manner". The title of the case refers to Barrett v. Rosenthal, a decision of the Supreme Court of California, which ruled that internet users and providers were not liable for the republication of defamatory statements, which some editors believe provides protection for Wikipedia. According to Durova, Ilena is the Rosenthal in that case, and she (Ilena) alleges that Fyslee has a close relationship with Barrett.
- WP:COI, as the executive director of the for-profit ACE LLC, which promotes the festival.
- WP:COIbecause he is one of Prechter's employees.
Voting phase
- Thatcher131 alleges that Andries has repeatedly added a link to an unreliable source to the Robert Priddy article, in violation of a remedy in a prior case on the subject, and that SSS108 has edit warred and exhibited signs of article ownership on the page. Both users deny the allegations. remedies have been proposed banning Andries, Wikisunn, SSS108 and Freelanceresearch from editing the article, and requiring Ekantikto edit under one username only. These proposals have the support of two to four arbitrators.
Motion to close
- are named as examples) from reverting the article, and banning Supreme Cmdr for two weeks, as well as an alternative remedy banning him for one year, and another banning him only from the Smart article. These remedies have the support of three to eight arbitrators. A motion to close has been proposed by UninvitedCompany, but opposed by Fred Bauder.
Under review
- Waldorf education: In pursuance of a remedy passed in the initial case, Fred Bauder has initiated a review of all parties' behaviour, and has proposed a remedy banning Pete K from the article and those relating to it indefinitely.
Discuss this story