Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Zanran (2nd nomination)

Re:

Note: Almost all editing by 86.44.31.213 consists of arguing passionately for "keep" in AfDs, including some where there is a clear and strong consensus to delete. JamesBWatson (talk) 09:33, 13 January 2012 (UTC)

47 AfDs prior to this one — 7 !deletes, 3 !redirects, 3 comments, 5 !weak keeps. So something other than a straight !keep ~37% of the time, i believe. In the 26 cases which are resolved, three in which i !voted to keep were closed as delete. i must admit that maths isn't my strong point, but i think that means i fall outside of consensus something like 11% of the time.

Needless to say, Watson's extraordinary scarlet letter is somewhat of a joke. 86.44.31.213 (talk) 19:07, 13 January 2012 (UTC)[reply]

afd — !vote — outcome

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alaska! (2nd nomination) — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/"Giraffes? Giraffes!" — Comment (presented sources) — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Bad Seed (rapper) — !Keep (only !keep vote) — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/'97 Bonnie & Clyde — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2011 Virginia Tech shooting — !Redirect — no consensus

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Numbers In Action — !Keep (first keep !vote) — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Todd Grubbs — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kiss of the Gypsy — !Keep (first keep !vote) — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Melis Bilen — !Keep — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Young Kidd — !Weak Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meyhem Lauren — !Keep (only keep !vote) — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gimme All Your Luvin (Madonna song) — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/V-Nasty (2nd nomination) — !Keep (first keep !vote) — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Windswept House: A Vatican Novel — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mobb Deep (album) — !Delete, incubate or userfy — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hippos in Tanks — !Keep — no consensus

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gan Yao Ming — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Pop Manifesto — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lafrae Olivia Sci — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mahalo Ukuleles — Comment (presented a RS) — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Latch Brothers — !Weak Keep (first keep !vote) — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Folk Hop — !Delete — Deleted

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Every Day and Every Night — !Troutthenom — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/San Francisco is a Lonely Town — !Keep — Kept

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Anónimo Consejo — !Keep — Withdrawn

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/King Kong Company — !Weak Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jezus Factory Records — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rock Dem Records — !Delete — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Addeo — !Delete — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Wesley Sharp — !Delete — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tim Truman (musician) — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Diabologum — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Megan and Liz (5th nomination) — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Waqas Ali Qadri — !Redirect — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Darlings of Chelsea — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tom Flannery — !Weak Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Kate McGill — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Doublemoon — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nasha Records — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Stiff Richards — !Delete — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lemâitre (band) — !Delete — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lisa Young Quartet — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sean Studdah Man De Vore — !Weak Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Evgeniy Gartung (2nd nomination) — !Redirect — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The Affections (band) — Comment — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dumb Blondes — !Keep — Still open

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Counterparts (band) (2nd nomination) — !Keep — Still open