Bowman v United Kingdom

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Bowman v United Kingdom
CourtEuropean Court of Human Rights
Citation(s)[1998] ECHR 4, (1998) 26 EHRR 1
Keywords
Democracy, money

Bowman v United Kingdom [1998] ECHR 4 is a case in the

ECHR article 10
.

The principle in Bowman stands in contrast to the unlimited spending at elections that the

Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, and the licence of corporations to donate money as a protected right of "free speech" in Citizens United v. FEC
, with or without authorisation by their stakeholders.

Facts

European Convention on Human Rights, article 10
.

Judgment

The majority of fourteen out of twenty judges on the European Court of Human Rights held there was a violation of

section 75 was an indirect restriction freedom of expression. The restriction was prescribed by law, and pursued a legitimate aim of protecting others' rights: candidates and the electorate, by seeking to secure equality among candidates. Freedom of expression and the right to free elections were the foundation of a democratic system, but election spending could undermine equal elections. However, a £5 spending limit was practically an absolute bar on distributing information to influence voters. Given the lack of restrictions on political parties, it was not a proportionate response to secure equality between the candidates.

42. Free elections and freedom of expression, particularly freedom of political debate, together form the bedrock of any democratic system. The two rights are interrelated and operate to reinforce each other: for example, as the court has observed in the past, freedom of expression is one of the ‘conditions’ necessary to ‘ensure the free expression of the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature’. For this reason, it is particularly important in the period preceding an election that opinions and information of all kinds are permitted to circulate freely.

Consequences

In response to this judgment, the spending limit of £5 per individual was increased to £500 (for Parliamentary elections) in the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000.[2]

See also

Notes

References

External links