James D. Whittemore
James David Whittemore | |
---|---|
Hillsborough County Circuit Court for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit of Florida | |
In office 1990–2000 | |
Personal details | |
Born | James David Whittemore[1] August 29, 1952[1] Walterboro, South Carolina, U.S.[1] |
Spouse | Martha K. Watford[1] |
Education | University of Florida (BSBA) Stetson University (JD) |
James David Whittemore (born August 29, 1952) is a
Background and early legal career
Whittemore was born in
Judicial career
State judicial service
In 1990, Whittemore was elected to the bench of the Hillsborough County Circuit Court in the Florida Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, and remained on the court until 2000. He was named the 1998 Jurist of the Year by the Hillsborough County Bar Association, and Outstanding Jurist of 1999 by the Florida Bar's Young Lawyers Division.
Federal judicial service
After recommendation by both of Florida's United States Senators,
Notable cases
On June 4, 2001, Whittemore ruled against
Whittemore presided over the criminal trial of Gerald and Betty Payne, the founders of Greater Ministries International Church. Over $450 million was bilked from church followers in the Paynes' fraudulent investment scheme, which was billed as one of the largest Ponzi schemes in United States history. Whittemore sentenced Gerald to 27 years for conduct he called "absolutely despicable." Betty was sentenced to over 12 years, which was increased from what Whittemore initially considered after she repeated a claim they were the innocent victims of government persecution and their religious freedoms were being violated. "It's one thing to have blind faith," Whittemore told her. "It's quite another to cast yourself as a martyr for no apparent good. I just deliberated a matter that you could serve 33 months less. What you've just done is throw that right back in my face."
Schiavo ex rel. Schindler v. Schiavo
Articles relating to the |
Terri Schiavo case |
---|
|
Others involved |
|
![]() |
Whittemore was randomly assigned to hear the
While protesters demonstrated outside his courthouse, Whittemore conducted a
The Schindlers returned to Whittemore's courtroom, again amended their complaint to add claims based on the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Eighth Amendment, and filed an amended motion for a TRO. Whittemore conducted a hearing on the motion the evening of March 24. When one of the Schindlers' attorneys described the removal of the feeding tube as "murder", Whittemore responded "[t]hat is the emotional rhetoric of this case. It does not influence this court and cannot influence this court. I want you to know it, and I want the public to know it." During the hearing, the protesters that still surrounded the area outside the courthouse were temporarily evacuated, so that law enforcement could detonate a suspicious bag that turned out to be harmless. The hearing proceeded inside without interruption, and lasted around four hours.
In an order issued the morning of March 25, Whittemore denied the Schindlers' amended motion. Regarding their ADA claim, Whittemore wrote that the law was inapplicable because Mr. Schiavo and the hospice in care of Terri Schiavo did not fall under the Act's definition of "public entities", nor was the withdrawal of the feeding tube based on discrimination against Schiavo on the basis of her disability. Their claim under the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 was similarly flawed, in that no discrimination was present, and the United States Supreme Court had previously ruled that the Act did not apply to medical decisions. Their Eighth Amendment claim was also rejected by Whittemore, because the amendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment did not apply outside of criminal sanctions. Whittemore closed his order by conveying the court's "appreciation for the difficulties and heartbreak the parties have endured through this lengthy process." A panel of the same three Circuit judges who heard the first appeal affirmed his decision once again on March 25, with the judge who had previously dissented concurring in this second opinion.[2] Rehearing was once again denied by the Eleventh Circuit on March 30,[2] and the Supreme Court also once again denied a stay the same day. The case ended with Schiavo's death on the morning of March 31.
Notes
- ^ Whittemore was appointed to a new seat that was one of four created in the Middle District of Florida by Sec. 309 of 113 Stat. 1501; 106 P.L. 113, enacted November 29, 1999. Some online and media sources erroneously reported that he replaced the "retiring" Judge William Terrell Hodges. Hodges did not retire, however, but instead assumed senior status on May 2, 1999, and as of 2017[update] remains active on the court in the Ocala Division.
- ^ The first complaint filed by the Schindlers was based on habeas corpus and was amended prior to the hearing.
References
- ^ a b c d Confirmation hearings on federal appointments : hearings before the Committee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, One Hundred Sixth Congress, first session, on confirmation of appointees to the federal judiciary. pt.2 (2000)
- ^ a b c d "FindLaw Legal Blogs". Findlaw.
- ^ "US Supreme Court Orders - FindLaw".
Sources
- Judge in Schiavo case a Clinton appointee, by Vickie Chachere, Associated Press. ABC News, March 21, 2005. A profile of the judge and his record.
- Cuban pitcher denied request for free agency, by Fred Goodall, Associated Press. USA Today, June 5, 2001.
- Church Founders Handed Penalties, by Michael Fletcher. Tampa Tribune, August 7, 2001.
Schiavo ex rel. Schindler v. Schiavo
- Judge Hears Schiavo Arguments, but Does Not Rule Yet, by Carl Hulse and Maria Newman. New York Times, March 21, 2005.
- Judge Refuses to Intervene in Schiavo Case, by Manuel Roig-Franzia and William Branigin. Washington Post, March 22, 2005.
- Judge Whittemore's March 22, 2005 order denying motion for a Temporary Restraining Order
- Judge Denies Latest Appeal in Schiavo Case, by Manuel Roig-Franzia. Washington Post, March 25, 2005.
- Judge Whittemore's March 25, 2005 order denying amended motion for a Temporary Restraining Order
- Judge Hears Schiavo Arguments, but Does Not Rule Yet, by Carl Hulse and Maria Newman.
External links
- James D. Whittemore at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges, a publication of the Federal Judicial Center.