Jewish views on lying
In Jewish tradition, lying is generally forbidden but is required in certain exceptional cases, such as to
save a life
.
Hebrew Bible
The Tanakh (
Zephaniah 3, see Zeph 3:13), "And if any prophets appear again, their fathers and mothers who bore them will say to them, “You shall not live, for you speak lies in the name of the Lord”; and their fathers and their mothers who bore them shall pierce them through when they prophesy." (Zechariah 13, see Zech 13:3) "They have taught their tongue to speak lies, they weary themselves to commit iniquity" (Jeremiah 9, see Jer 9:5).[3]
However, in various biblical stories, those who lie and mislead are not necessarily condemned, and in some cases are praised. Biblical figures that engaged in deception include Abraham, Isaac, Simeon, and Levi.[4] The Torah does not prohibit lying if no one is harmed.[5]
Talmud
The
Pesahim 113b) and also forbids fraud in business dealings: "As there is wronging in buying and selling, there is wronging with words. A man must not ask: ‘How much is this thing?” if he has no intention of buying it" (Bava Metzia 4:10).[3]
Bava Metzia 23b-24a lists three exceptions where lying is permitted:[3][6][7]
- It is permissible for a scholar to state he is unfamiliar with part of the Talmud, even if he is familiar (out of humility)
- It is permissible to lie in response to intimate questions regarding one's marital life (as such things should be kept private)
- Lying about hospitality received (to protect the host)
Yevamot 65b states that "It is permitted to stray from the truth in order to promote peace", and Rabbi Natan further argues that this is obligatory.[8]
Later views
Due to the principle of
saving a life, in Jewish law it is required to lie to save a life, such as withholding a diagnosis from a seriously ill patient[9] or concealing one's Jewish faith in a time of persecution of Jews.[10] It may also be required to lie in other cases where a positive commandment would be violated by telling the truth, as positive commandments in Judaism usually take precedence against negative ones.[9] Even in the cases where lying is acceptable, it is preferable to tell a technically true but deceptive statement or employ half-truth. It is also completely forbidden to lie habitually, to lie to a child (which would teach them that it was acceptable), and to lie in the court system.[5]
Rabbi
Eliyahu Dessler redefined "truth" to mean any statement which serves God and "falsehood" to mean any statement that harms God's interests. This would radically change Jewish views on lying.[11]
According to
Reconstructionist rabbi Fred Scherlinder Dobb stated in an interview, "There is no justification whatsoever in Jewish tradition for lies which are either sloppy, systemic or self-serving... every word we utter should reflect our values, and one of the highest of those values is truth."[12]
References
- ^ a b Weiss 2017, pp. 2, 22.
- ^ Weiss 2017, pp. 3, 22.
- ^ a b c d Jacobs, Louis. "Truth and Lies in the Jewish Tradition". The Jewish Religion: A Companion. Oxford University Press.
- ^ Weiss 2017, pp. 3, 21.
- ^ a b Trevino 2014, p. 566.
- ^ Mathewes 2010, p. 125.
- ^ Bava Metzia 23b-24a; the reasons in parentheses are specified by Rashi
- ^ Resnicoff 2002, p. 961.
- ^ a b Resnicoff 2002, p. 964.
- ^ Trevino 2014, pp. 565–566.
- ^ Resnicoff 2002, p. 966.
- ^ "Thou shalt not speak alternative facts: religion and lying". Religion News Service. 16 February 2017. Retrieved 17 August 2020.
Sources
- Freund, Richard A. (1991). "Lying and deception in the Biblical and post‐Biblical Judaic tradition". Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament. 5 (1): 45–61. .
- Mathewes, Charles (2010). "Lying—Judaism". Understanding Religious Ethics. John Wiley & Sons. pp. 124–126. ISBN 978-1-4051-3351-7.
- Resnicoff, Steven H. (2002). "Lying and Lawyering: Contrasting American and Jewish Law". Notre Dame Law Review. 77: 937–976.
- Trevino, Marcella Bush (2014). "Judaism". In Levine, Timothy R. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Deception. SAGE Publications. pp. 563–566. ISBN 978-1-4833-8898-4.
- Weiss, Shira (2017). "The Ethics of Deception in Biblical Narrative". Journal of Jewish Ethics. 3 (1): 1–27. .