Supreme directional control
The Supreme directional control controversy was a dispute among the leadership quorums of
Origin of the controversy
From its beginnings, the Latter Day Saint movement has been concerned with the idea of
However, since many church members did not share Smith's modernistic vision of Zion, the RLDS leader faced the possibility that his dreams might be stymied through the opposition of other church authorities, or of the biennial General Conference. In contrast to the larger and better-known
Core dispute
In April 1924, at a meeting of the Joint Council of Community of Christ leaders, composed of members of the First Presidency, Council of Twelve, and Presiding Bishopric, Frederick M. Smith presented a document, which became known as the "Supreme Directional Control document." In it Smith asserted that "there must be recognized grades of official prerogative and responsibility, with supreme directional control resting in the Presidency as the chief and first quorum of the church."
The crisis came to a head during the April 1925 General Conference. Smith's brother Israel A. Smith, a member of the Presiding Bishopric (who would later succeed his brother as church president), feared terrible consequences if President Smith forced a vote on his Supreme Directional Control document. In a letter to his brother dated April 5, Israel wrote: "If you, because of the mere force of numbers, drive out the strong belief and feelings of the opposition, you shall become responsible to that degree of falling away, the loss of faith, the division which may ensue."[9] The document was debated for a full five days, April 7–11, and finally passed on a vote of 915 to 405, becoming General Conference Resolution (GCR) 849. In response, the Presiding Bishopric resigned, along with Apostle John Rushton; the conference also failed to sustain a second opposition apostle, Thomas W. Williams, ending his ministry in that office.[10] On April 18, Smith issued a revelation (enshrined as Section 135 in the Community of Christ's Doctrine and Covenants) indicating divine approval of his course of action with regard to the Supreme Directional Control document and the resignation of the Bishopric.
The First Presidency's successful assertion of Supreme Directional Control allowed Frederick M. Smith to commence his Zionic endeavor. He began by increasing the church's administrative apparatus, expanding its social programs, and initiating a series of building programs. New projects included the Auditorium and a rebuilt Independence Sanitarium hospital. The church borrowed heavily to finance these programs, with its debt reaching $1.9 million by 1931 ($30.6 million in 2023 dollars).[11] The concurrent onset of the Great Depression caused revenues from tithes and offerings to drop precipitously,[12] which led the 1931 General Conference to pass a resolution returning control over all financial matters to the Presiding Bishopric, whose members became answerable solely to the Conference. This resolution, GCR 915, effectively reversed Supreme Directional Control.[13] The Bishopric instituted a series of severe austerity measures, drastically cutting church staff and services, and the debt was finally retired in 1942.[14]
Schisms
After leaving the Council of Twelve in 1925 because of his opposition to Supreme Directional Control, Thomas W. Williams and other leaders formed a "Protest Movement," which later organized as a separate church known as the "Church of Jesus Christ (Thomas W. Williams)." Williams and his group issued a "Protest Document," charging that "this change from a theocratic democracy to an autocracy—a hierarchy with final and supreme directional control in the hands of one man strikes at the very heart of the principles of church government contained in our
Beginning in 1918, Community of Christ and the Church of Christ (Temple Lot) had entered into an "Agreement of Working Harmony."
Supreme Directional Control is no longer advanced by the members of Community of Christ's First Presidency, although within the
Notes
- ^ Curry, "The Seesaw Shifts," 187-188.
- ^ Howlett at al., Community of Christ, 41.
- ^ See, for example, Follow the Brethren, article by Seventy L. Aldon Porter in Ensign, Nov. 1987, pg. 73.
- ^ Community of Christ: Frederick Madison Smith. Official church website. Retrieved 2011-02-11.
- ^ Community of Christ: Frederick Madison Smith. Official church website. Retrieved 2011-02-11.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:234.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:234.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:236.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:238.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:239-240.
- Gross Domestic Product deflatorfigures follow the MeasuringWorth series.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:278.
- ^ Curry, "The Seesaw Shifts," 186-187.
- ^ Howard, The Church through the Years, 2:285-286.
- ^ Shields, Divergent Paths, 120-121.
- ^ Shields, Divergent Paths, 122.
- ^ Adams, "The Church of Christ (Temple Lot) and the Reorganized Church," 92-94.
- ^ Adams, "The Church of Christ (Temple Lot) and the Reorganized Church," 98-99.
- ^ Onward to Zion from The Story of the Church, by Inez Smith Davis. Retrieved 2011-02-12.
- ^ See, for instance, Elder Richard and Ms. Pamela Price: God Will Cleanse His Church Again, essay published by Price Publishing Company.
References
- R. Jean Addams, "The Church of Christ (Temple Lot) and the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints: 130 Years of Crossroads and Controversies," The Journal of Mormon History, Vol. 36, No. 2 (Spring 2010), 54-127.
- Charles Patterson Curry, "The Seesaw Shifts: The 1932 Reversal of Supreme Directional Control," The John Whitmer Historical Association Journal, Vol. 27 (2007), 184–195.
- Paul M. Edwards, The Chief: An Administrative Biography of Fred M. Smith, Herald House: 1988. ISBN 0-8309-0526-X
- Richard P. Howard, The Church Through the Years, Herald House: 1992. Volume 2: ISBN 0-8309-0629-0
- Steven L. Shields, Divergent Paths of the Restoration, Restoration Research: 1990. Fourth Edition. ISBN 0-942284-13-5