Talk:The Complete Singles Collection 1994–2000

Untitled

Why does the title of this article need to start with "CD"? If it needs to be disambiguated, which I don't think it does, then it should end with (cd). -- Zoe

It is not about a collection of singles, but about a CD containing the songs of those singles, therefore I added CD. I'll put CD at the end. - Patrick 04:18 Dec 15, 2002 (UTC)

But does this really need to be on Wikipedia? This is an encyclopaedia, not a music trivia repository. There's sites like ubl.com for that. I think that a short entry on the band with a list of IMPORTANT albums and singles is quite enough. This goes for all band entries, not just this one. Zocky 12:07 Jan 22, 2003 (UTC)

It would be nicer if comments on songs were added, such as a summary of an interesting song text. - Patrick 12:50 Jan 22, 2003 (UTC)

Not really... It's just not encyclopaedia material. It's not prose. And it just isn't important in any but a very narrow sense.

There are maybe 50 albums in the whole history of pop music that deserve an encyclopaedia entry, because they had important effect on the society as well as on music. I don't even think that most bands that are already on wikipedia deserve an article, but their albums and, god forbid, individual songs just don't. There's plenty of other places to put those - official band site, fan sites, UBL,...

I think a sensible thing to do would be to write an entry for the band with sentences like "in 19xx album xy was released, which..."

Zocky 13:17 Jan 22, 2003 (UTC)

It claims that the track "woman beater" is from Lower Class Crucifixion. That is not true, the song is a rarity.