User:Gerda Arendt/ACE 2022

8 seats are available to be filled, but Arbcom does not need all 8 to be filled.
If you do not believe a candidate is suitable, vote oppose^[a]

This is NOT a voters' guide, just my private quick evaluation, looking at the candidates' answers to my questions, and how I saw them previously (Precious, when, for what, or last years question).

Questions from Gerda Arendt

Do you believe that we still have infobox wars? If yes, do you have better ideas than the 2013 arb ruling to end them? --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:25, 20 November 2022 (UTC)

I asked this question because the Laurence Olivier situation came up, but could not point at it because some would have understood that as canvassing. Now that it was closed, the follow-up question:

Where does the recently closed RfC for Laurence Olivier sit in your perspective?
... and repeating that question after another week of discussions there --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:46, 6 December 2022 (UTC)
... and no answer but it now went to a noticeboard --Gerda Arendt (talk) 23:07, 10 December 2022 (UTC)

Answers

Candidate	nom day	answer day	answers	Precious no.	Precious reason	experience	support	elected
Guerillero	13 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	let go "overly-spirited comments"	751	Toil, tools, tradition and trust	arb	Y	Y
GeneralNotability	13 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	not witnessed "appropriate way to determine a way forward"	-		admin	Y	Y
Robert McClenon	15 Nov	26 + 30 Nov	yes good close	1409	belief in logic		Y
CaptainEek	15 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	no "a thoughtful and considered close"	2440	birds of the Southwestern U.S.	arb	YY	Y
BoldLuis	16 Nov		wait	-
Moneytrees	18 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	editing "temperatures have decreased"	2077	"I edit here when I have nothing else to do, just for fun."	admin	YY	Y
Primefac	19 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	no "fairly tame"	1556	astronomical spectroscopy cleanup	arb	YY	Y
L235	21 Nov	24 Nov + 7 Dec	no I generally feel that RfCs like this are a poor allocation of editor time and effort	1977	supreme court	arb	YY	Y
Tamzin	22 Nov	27 Nov + 1 Dez	no mostly healthy discussions	2728	may memories be for a blessing	admin	YY
SilkTork	22 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	consensus "more encouraging than saddening"	2353	look at both sides	arb	YY	Y
Sdrqaz	22 Nov	25 + 28 Nov	no, detailed observations was aware	2727	stop disruption through discussion	admin	YY
Barkeep49	22 Nov	23 + 28 Nov	faded seems normal content dispute	2109	radiant child	arb	YY	Y

Voting

Today is the birthday of Jean Sibelius, and I'm voting. Most candidates saw that there's not much of a war, at least no recent bloody battles. None of them offered a good idea for peace. The topic is still loaded, as the Olivier discussion shows, and last year's question, How many RfCs do we need to call the infobox wars over?, was not answered, not by the candidates nor the community. We have right now - after a completely quiet year - RfCs not only for Olivier, but also for two composers, a poet and an actress - no links or I would be accused of canvassing. I would like to see peace in 2023, - ideas welcome. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 15:32, 8 December 2022 (UTC)

Notes

^ Template adapted from User:Worm That Turned/ACE2015

[1] Template adapted from User:Worm That Turned/ACE2015

[a]