| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| (State of) Palestine |
Option A |
January 14
|
| Category:14th-century humanists |
delete. ~ |
January 10
|
| Category:14th-century literary critics |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 28
|
| Category:1780s establishments in Michigan Territory |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 25
|
| Category:17th-century academics |
Merge |
January 9
|
| Category:2013 IPC Alpine Skiing World Championships |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 27
|
| Category:21th-century military history |
speedy delete (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Category:8th-century Sasanian monarchs |
delete. — |
January 13
|
| Category:Abbasid humanists |
delete. ~ |
January 10
|
| Category:Abolitionist movements |
split (non-admin closure) |
January 18
|
| Category:Academic journal categories containing exclusively redirects |
keep. Good arguments were made by both sides, but participants overwhelmingly preferred the arguments against deleting the categories.
However, please note that I have have not attempted to evaluate the consensus on the alternative proposal by @ |
January 31
|
| Category:African pangolins |
rename. Unopposed after 11 days. The editor who uses the pseudonym " |
January 26
|
| Category:African-American football quarterbacks |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 February 26#Category:African-American football quarterbacks. ~ |
January 3
|
| Category:African-American Ivy League academics |
delete. — |
January 2
|
| Category:African-American Ivy League alumni |
delete. — |
January 2
|
| Category:Airfields in Ukraine |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 25
|
| Category:Albums arranged by John Fogerty |
Delete |
January 21
|
| Category:Almighty Vice Lord Nation |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 31
|
| Category:Amadlozi Brenda Fassie Album |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:American labor unionists |
Rename |
January 21
|
| Category:Animal media |
delete based primarily on the strong arguments that derive roughly from WP:OVERLAPCAT . ~ |
January 19
|
| Category:Annecy Cristal winners |
delete. — |
January 22
|
| Category:Anthropomorphic geographic features |
Delete |
January 25
|
| Category:Archaeological sites of medieval Anatolia |
withdrawn (non-admin closure) |
January 26
|
| Category:Archbishops of Western Europe |
rename to Category:Archbishops of Orthodox parishes of Russian tradition in Western Europe. ~ |
January 5
|
| Architecture by country |
Rename per revised proposal |
January 12
|
| Category:Armenian parliament shooting |
merge. (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Category:Articles by WikiProject |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:Articles created via the Article Wizard |
Delete |
January 6
|
| Category:Articles needing help |
Merge |
January 14
|
| Category:Articles with Synthlisten |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 22
|
| Category:Artists by Japanese record label |
keep. ~ |
January 29
|
| Category:Asian-American novels |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 19#Category:Asian-American_novels |
January 2
|
| Category:Autism quackery |
Keep and rename to Category:Autism pseudoscience or equivalent. The argument that the existence of a category for this concept is itself an NPOV violation clearly does not have consensus. Evidence has been provided of the existence of pseudoscientific practices and beliefs related to autism, and substantial previous consensus exists for analogous categories. The misapplication of this category to specific individuals may constitute a BLP violation, but that is an issue that needs to be addressed by fixing those pages, not by deleting the category. There is therefore no consensus to delete. The arguments to keep are mostly about the validity of the category as a concept. There is little support for the argument that "quackery" is a neutral, non-pejorative term, in contrast to several reasoned arguments that "quackery" is unnecessarily prejudicial and colloquial. That term therefore needs to be replaced in the name of this category. "Category:Autism pseudoscience" has the strongest support, but an equivalent term would be acceptable. |
January 6
|
| Category:Azonto |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 21
|
| Category:Bakul Institute of Superhard Materials research fellow |
merge to Category:Ukrainian scientists |
January 3
|
| Category:Basilicas in Barcelona |
merge per nom. ~ |
January 8
|
| Category:Battles won by Indigenous peoples of the Americas |
listify. ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Bicycle gangs |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 26
|
| Category:Biotechnology companies disestablished in 1996 |
merge for now as stating see C20 category for disestablishments before 2001. – |
January 28
|
| Category:Bismarck monuments |
Rename ( WP:NAC ). |
January 24
|
| Category:Body swapping in fiction |
Rename |
January 28
|
| Category:Book awards |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 27
|
| Bridges by city in Ukraine |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
January 12
|
| Category:Bridges completed in the 1883 |
speedy delete. (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Category:British princesses by marriage |
Rename without prejudice to any deletion discussion if that is the outcome of the husbands category |
January 5
|
| Category:Bryn Athyn College |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 31
|
| Category:Bubbles |
Rename |
January 14
|
| Category:Buddhism in Seoul |
no consensus |
January 9
|
| Category:Canadian expatriates in foreign political positions |
delete |
January 19
|
| Category:Capacitive touchscreen mobile phones |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 February 25#Category:Capacitive touchscreen mobile phones. ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Case reports journals |
no consensus to delete, therefore rename. – |
January 20
|
| Category:Cat lover culture |
merge to Category:Cats in popular culture. Taken in tandem with the discussion below, that seems to be the outcome which best reflects the mood of the discussion |
January 19
|
| Category:Cat media |
merge to Category:Cats in popular culture. Taken in tandem with the discussion above, that seems to be the outcome which best reflects the mood of the discussion |
January 19
|
| Categories by century |
Rename/merge |
January 25
|
| Category:Catholic Church in Rodrigues |
merge/delete per nom. ~ |
January 9
|
| Category:Chemical education |
Merge |
January 21
|
| Category:Christian anarchists by denomination |
merge. – |
January 20
|
| Category:Christian anarchists by nationality |
merge. – |
January 20
|
| Category:Christian denominations active in Germany |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_February_26#Category:Christian_denominations_active_in_Germany. ~ |
January 4
|
| Category:Christian education in Norway |
withdrawn. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Christian feminists |
Rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Christianity in Bangkok |
delete. ~ |
January 11
|
| Category:Christianity in New Zealand by city |
keep. ~ |
January 11
|
| Category:Christianity in Pakistan by administrative unit |
Merge |
January 16
|
| Churches by city (Europe, 1 merge target) |
merge all per this concurrent CfD with similar arguments. ~ |
January 5
|
| Churches by city (Europe, dual merge) |
merge all. As this is the most thorough discussion on these church nominations, and the arguments made across several of them are the same, I am taking this one as "authoritative" for the moment. While BHG's arguments have merit, it seems clear that they were not convincing to other editors here. In particular, several other editors reasonably argued that they do not see any substantial potential for growth in these categories. ~ |
January 5
|
| Churches by city (France) |
merge all per this concurrent CfD with similar arguments. ~ |
January 3
|
| Churches by city (Italy, 1 merge target) |
merge all per this concurrent CfD with similar arguments. ~ |
January 4
|
| Churches by city (Italy, dual merge) |
merge all per this concurrent CfD with similar arguments. ~ |
January 4
|
| Churches by city (miscellaneous countries, 1 merge target) |
merge all. ~ |
January 7
|
| Churches by city (other continents, dual merge) |
no consensus. This differs from recent nominations of churches because a few categories here currently do have several articles in them. This likely either needs to be split out further to achieve a clear result or individual attention needs to be paid to each category. ~ |
January 7
|
| Churches by city (Spain) |
merge per nom. ~ |
January 2
|
| Churches by city (United States) |
merge all per nom, and per other recent similar CfDs. ~ |
January 6
|
| Commons category tracking |
speedy delete. Tracking categories now empty because tracking has been restructured looks to me like a WP:G6 issue |
January 2
|
| Communes of the Metropolitan City of Rome |
rename to Category:Municipalities of the Metropolitan City of Rome Capital. ~ |
January 18
|
| Category:Converts from Judaism to Hinduism |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 23
|
| Category:Coptic billionaires |
delete. – |
January 23
|
| Category:Corporatism task force articles |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
January 15
|
| Category:Countries of the Indian Ocean |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Country-specific art films already included in the main category |
no consensus. This nomination is somewhat malformed, which I think has caused general confusion around this nomination. Rather than relisting and letting that confusion stand, I am making this close without prejudice against speedy renomination, provided such a nomination is formatted as-is standard. Feel free to ask on WT:CFD (or my user talk) if you need help formatting a nomination. ~ |
January 14
|
| Category:Crimes committed by illegal immigrants |
delete. — |
January 24
|
| Czech small town |
delete. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Dance-pop artists |
Rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Departments of the University of Dublin, Trinity College |
merge to (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Category:Diana, Princess of Wales memorials |
Rename ( WP:NAC ). |
January 24
|
| Category:DtBPageS |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 4
|
| Category:Ducal Lithuanian people |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 26
|
| Category:Dutch academic researchers |
purge and merge. ~ |
January 5
|
| Category:Dutch academics |
speedy close / withdrawn. The correct nomination is on the next day's page |
January 4
|
| Category:Dáil constituencies in the Republic of Ireland (historic) |
withdrawn by nominator |
January 12
|
| Category:Eastern Catholicism in the Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth |
reverse merge. ~ |
January 10
|
| Category:Easy listening artists |
Rename |
January 19
|
| Category:Ecozones |
Rename |
January 20
|
| Category:Egyptian Premier League footballers |
rename per nom. There is a clear consensus that this should be "players", not "footballers". The arguments for renaming this to "Players in the Egyptian Premier League" to avoid ambiguity are not without merit, but they have been countered by arguments that the wider category tree treats similar categories as the nominator suggested. No prejudice against a wider nomination of all potentially ambiguous categories involving national-specific "Premier Leagues". ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Elections not won by the popular vote winner |
delete. — |
January 12
|
| Category:Encounters in Pakistan |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 3
|
| Category:Endemic fauna of Swaziland |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Category:Endemic regions |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 27
|
| Category:Euryhaline fish genera |
Delete |
January 15
|
| Expatriates from Georgia (country) |
Option A |
January 20
|
| Category:Famous animals of Huntsville, Alabama |
Upmerge to Category:Individual animals in the United States |
January 6
|
| Category:Festivals in Former Yugoslavia |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_March_4#Category:Festivals_in_Former_Yugoslavia. ~ |
January 16
|
| Festivals |
) |
January 28
|
| Category:Fictional organizations designated as terrorist |
Merge. (non-admin closure) ― |
January 6
|
| Category:First events |
Delete |
January 4
|
| Category:Fly fishing target species |
delete. I have left a dump of the category's current contents at WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 January 19#Fly_fishing_target_species. And no, I haven't made it a list article, because that requires sources etc ... and when I have previously created bare list articles of category contents, they have just sat around unsourced until deletion. But anyone who wants to create a proper list can do use the dump as a starting point |
January 19
|
| Category:Former populated places in Palestine (region) |
rename, as the arguments against the usual convention (using current polity) are not finally persuasive. The sub-cat Category:Villages depopulated during the Arab–Israeli conflict is a valid but unusual category, and IMHO should remain parented by categories for former populated places in both Israel & State of Palestine, among others. – |
January 31
|
| Category:Former Sri Lankan Roman Catholics |
merge. ~ |
January 13
|
| Category:FPGA device |
rename to Category:Field-programmable gate arrays. ~ |
January 5
|
| Category:France–Israel topics |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 14
|
| Category:Freshwater protostomes |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 30
|
| Category:Games created using AGS |
Rename |
January 11
|
| Category:Gangs in Pittsburgh |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 27
|
| Category:Geologists from Germany |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 12
|
| Category:Georgian opera singers |
delete |
January 12
|
| Category:Government-owned companies of China |
no consensus without prejudice against a fresh nomination of the entire tree of Category:Government-owned companies by country. (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Category:Government-owned companies of China |
relisted, see here. (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:Ha*Ash |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 17
|
| Category:Hairston family (baseball) |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:HBCU alumni |
Merge. (non-admin closure) ― |
January 6
|
| Category:Hijabophobia |
selective merge. – |
January 24
|
| Category:History of Catholicism in Spain |
don't rename. ~ |
January 18
|
| Category:Husbands of British princesses |
Delete |
January 11
|
| Category:I/O Chips |
rename to Category:Input/output integrated circuits. ~ |
January 5
|
| Category:Iceage |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 4
|
| Category:Independent Eastern Orthodox denominations |
relisted at WP:CFD 2019 March 10#Category:Independent_Eastern_Orthodox_denominations |
January 23
|
| Category:India political party color templates |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 3
|
| Category:Indian beatboxers |
dual merge to Category:Beatboxers and Category:Indian hip hop singers. ~ |
January 4
|
| Category:INED |
delete. I will add the parent categories to the main article (non-admin closure) |
January 14
|
| Category:Infinite Zero albums |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 22
|
| Category:Institute of History of Ukraine research fellow |
merge. The category looks empty to me, so I just deleted it |
January 3
|
| Category:Insurgents |
) |
January 13
|
| Category:Invasive plant species |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_March_4#Category:Invasive_plant_species. ~ |
January 17
|
| Category:Israeli revolutionaries |
delete. Per John Pack Lambert, no merge is necessary. The rename suggestion of the target category is noted, but it would need its own nomination, as that category wasn't nominated. ~ |
January 12
|
| Category:Ivorian newspapers |
rename as nominated. (non-admin closure) |
January 30
|
| Category:Ivy League academics |
Delete. ― |
January 3
|
| Category:Japanese-American internment books |
rename. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Japanese-Canadian internment |
Renamed to WP:C2D does not seem to apply here |
January 2
|
| Category:Jewish Roman Empire politicians |
delete. ~ |
January 9
|
| Category:Jews and Judaism in Ankara |
delete. — |
January 3
|
| Category:John F. Kennedy memorials |
Rename |
January 24
|
| Category:Kickstarter-funded animated films |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Category:Krymskyi Institute of Oriental Studies research fellows |
merge to Category:Krymskyi Institute of Oriental Studies people |
January 3
|
| Category:Krypiakevych Institute of Ukrainian Studies research fellow |
merge to Category:Ukrainian academics |
January 3
|
| Category:Least concern biota of California |
Delete |
January 11
|
| Category:LGBT Marxists |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:Lists of British animals |
Rename to Category:Lists of animals of the British Isles |
January 27
|
| Category:Lists of monuments and memorials in Samara Oblast |
merge. ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Lithuanian churches |
delete. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Live at The Fillmore albums |
Merge |
January 7
|
| Category:Marshals of the Bar Confederation |
Merge |
January 8
|
| Category:Mathematical objects |
keep (non-admin closure) |
January 23
|
| Category:Megan Fox |
Delete |
January 10
|
| Category:Military units and factions of the Syrian Civil War |
relisted, see here |
January 17
|
| Category:Miniature wargames |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_March_1#Category:Miniature_wargames. ~ |
January 5
|
| Category:Miyazaki, Miyazaki |
Rename |
January 13
|
| Category:MNL48 |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 25
|
| Category:Modern primitive movement |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_March_4#Category:Modern_primitive_movement. ~ |
January 17
|
| Category:Montreal Jazz |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 26
|
| Category:MOS Integrated Circuits |
Rename |
January 5
|
| Category:MTV Award winners |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 3
|
| Category:Mumble rap |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 29
|
| Category:Naked Music albums |
Delete |
January 25
|
| Category:National People's Party |
Rename |
January 17
|
| Natural history of California by region |
no consensus.. I had to think about this one overnight, because while there is clearly no support for the massive overcategorisation created by @ |
January 30
|
| Natural history of California by region |
relisted, see here |
January 22
|
| NCAA Men's Division I Final Four basketball players by year and subcategories 1939–present |
No consensus |
January 20
|
| Category:New South Wales Stations/Wharves with map |
delete. ~ |
January 2
|
| Norniron pre-Norniron |
merge/delete per nom. Under the protection policy, we cannot creation-protect pages for this reason, but future creations could be deleted per this CfD result without need for an additional nomination. ~ |
January 9
|
| Category:Now Is the Time (Brenda Fassie album) |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:Oligarchy task force articles |
no consensus (non-admin closure) |
January 15
|
| Category:Organizations based in Oman |
keep. Additionally, the later proposal of renaming the defunct organi(z/s)ations subcategory is now moot, since it was renamed via speedy renaming. (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Category:Paid contributors/No listed employer |
speedy delete by RHaworth per G8 . — |
January 29
|
| Category:Palestinian Christian communities |
no consensus. (non-admin closure) ― |
January 31
|
| Category:Palestinian researchers |
procedural close, the category has been deleted by |
January 3
|
| Category:Parishes in Johore |
rename, in fact, Category:Parishes in Johore has already been moved to Category:Mukims of Batu Pahat rendering this discussion moot. But I'm formally closing this discussion. |
January 8
|
| Patriot Bowl |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Category:Pediculariidae |
rename, in fact the renaming has already been implemented. (non-admin closure) |
January 8
|
| Category:People educated at King's College School, Wimbledon |
Rename |
January 27
|
| Category:People involved in controversies about women in science and technology |
delete. — |
January 1
|
| Category:People of Celtic descent |
relist, see here. (non-admin closure) |
January 31
|
| Category:Persecution of homosexuals in Nazi Germany and the Holocaust |
Rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Personal relationships by individual |
Rename |
January 25
|
| Category:Picture books by Sheila Hamanaka |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 21
|
| Places of worship by city (miscellaneous countries) |
upmerge all per rationale of previous nomination. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Politics and violence |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 20
|
| Category:Populated places in Adamawa |
Rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Portuguese-language Brazilian telenovelas |
merge to Category:Brazilian telenovelas |
January 12
|
| Category:Potebnia Institute of Linguistics research fellow |
merge to Category:Ukrainian academics |
January 3
|
| Category:Programming language documentation |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 23
|
| Category:Projects by year of disestablishment |
keep without prejudice against speedy renomination, so long as it is more complete. Pinging Marcocapelle. ~ |
January 1
|
| Province of Rome |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2019_March_10#Province_of_Rome. ~ |
January 18
|
| Category:Psycho films |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 17
|
| Category:Public health education |
relisted at WP:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 19#Category:Public_health_education |
January 25
|
| Category:Radom Confederation |
delete. ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Real Madrid presidents |
Renamed to (non-admin closure) ― |
January 13
|
| Category:Reboot Universe |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 31
|
| Category:Recipients of the Haakon VII 70th Anniversary Medal |
delete |
January 26
|
| Category:Recipients of the Order of Gabriela Silang |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 27
|
| Category:Recreational sublabial drugs |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 12
|
| Category:Reformed State churches in Switzerland |
relisted at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 4#Category:Reformed State churches in Switzerland. ~ |
January 10
|
| Category:Religion in the British Empire |
keep. (non-admin closure) |
January 19
|
| Renaming Australian shadow cabinets categories |
Rename |
January 8
|
| Category:Retired YouTubers |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 13
|
| Category:Revived fictional characters |
delete. To assist anyone who wants to make a list article, I have listed the category's contents at WT:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 January 28#Revived_fictional_characters |
January 28
|
| Category:Ror |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 16
|
| Category:Savoy Conference |
keep |
January 30
|
| Category:Scandals in Northern Ireland |
keep (non-admin closure) |
January 9
|
| Category:Scottish expatriate sportspeople in England |
speedy delete per WP:G7 . Created in error by me as part of an AWB run while diffusing expatriate sportspeople. Thanks for spotting it, @ |
January 5
|
| Category:SDN48 |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 25
|
| Category:Shinty stadiums |
rename to Category:Shinty venues, without prejudice to a fresh nomination for renaming to Category:Shinty venues in Scotland as suggested later in the discussion. (non-admin closure) |
January 6
|
| Category:Small Isles, Inner Hebrides |
rename to Category:Small Isles, Lochaber. This option, while not favoured by everyone, is at least acceptable according to most participants in the discussion. Other options were more persistently opposed |
January 20
|
| Category:Snap elections |
delete. – |
January 23
|
| Category:Sniper video games |
relisted, see here (non-admin closure) |
January 1
|
| Category:Social Darwinist Wikipedians |
delete. I am also deleting |
January 30
|
| Category:Software engineering professionalism |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 17
|
| Category:Songs from Spider-Man soundtracks |
Rename |
January 9
|
| Category:Songs in memory of Kurt Cobain |
delete. Recategorise the one actual article, then delete the category |
January 22
|
| Category:Songs with violin |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 17
|
| Category:Space program of Ireland |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 6
|
| Category:Space program of South Africa |
no consensus per the larger issues in this category scheme. See the exchange involving Nyttend/Grutness below. ~ |
January 6
|
| Category:Space program(me) of Malaysia |
no consensus per the larger issues in this category scheme. See the exchange involving Nyttend/Grutness below. ~ |
January 6
|
| Category:Spacecraft by year of decommissioning |
keep with no prejudice against a more complete speedy renomination, same as above. ~ |
January 1
|
| Category:Sports venues in State of Jefferson region |
delete. — |
January 24
|
| Category:Stadiums in St. Louis |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 5
|
| Category:Standardized tests for Medicine |
rename Category:Standardized tests for Medicine to Category:Standardized tests in healthcare education |
January 24
|
| Category:State-owned enterprises of China |
out-of-process move reverted. New discussion listed below |
January 7
|
| Category:Stateless people from Thailand |
dual merge to Category:Stateless people and Category:Thai people. ~ |
January 3
|
| Category:Students of K. Pattabhi Jois |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 25
|
| Television series based on singers and musicians |
Rename |
January 17
|
| Category:Thai Chinese |
rename (non-admin closure) |
January 14
|
| Category:Thai male triple jumpers |
keep (non-admin closure) |
January 24
|
| Category:The Twilight Zone Guest Appearances |
delete. — |
January 2
|
| Category:Tragedy anime and manga |
delete. — |
January 16
|
| Category:Tragedy video games |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 16
|
| Category:Tropical house singers |
merge, while there is no majority in this discussion the closure is based on weight of argument. (non-admin closure) |
January 7
|
| Category:True Range Multilateration |
speedy delete (non-admin closure) |
January 18
|
| Category:UNESCO Creative Cities Network |
Delete |
January 9
|
| Category:University of Kharkiv researchers |
delete |
January 3
|
| Category:Unsupported IPAc-cmn transclusions |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 28
|
| Category:Uploaded with UploadWizard |
Delete |
January 20
|
| Category:UPN affiliates |
rename. ~ |
January 19
|
| Category:US officers of Georgian descent |
delete (non-admin closure) |
January 13
|
| Category:Veterans Law |
rename to Category:Veterans' affairs law in the United States |
January 17
|
| Category:Victorian-era naval ships |
no consensus. There was no support deleting the top category alone ... and while there was support for deleting some or all of the subcats, those subcats were never tagged. So they can't be deleted. And even though this discussion has been opened for 6 weeks since the nominator (@ |
January 30
|
| Category:Volleyball clubs disestablished in 2018 |
merge (non-admin closure) |
January 4
|
| Category:Wicket-keepers |
Delete |
January 10
|
| Category:WWE Hall of Fame (1994) inductees |
merge. While the numbers are even here, the strength of arguments is rather clearly in favor of a merge. Editors who voted "keep" successfully argued that being in the WWE Hall of Fame is defining, but none attempted an argument about why being inducted specifically in a given year is defining. The argument related to the size of a combined category is extremely weak; a category with 191 articles is downright typical. The unrefuted arguments in favor of a merge are supported strongly by our guidelines. ~ |
January 4
|
| Category:X86 Supercomputers |
rename. ~ |
January 2
|
| Category:Zen Circus albums |
keep. Withdrawn, band article has been resurrected and seems likely more album articles will be created, rendering my original rationale invalid. ♠ |
January 29
|
