Wikipedia:Featured and good topic removal candidates/2012 log

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
edit2006
April
1 promoted
6 not promoted
October 0 promoted
1 not promoted
November
4 promoted
1 not promoted
December
1 promoted
2 not promoted
1 sup.
2007
January
2 promoted
7 not promoted
February
1 promoted
2 not promoted
0 sup.
1 demoted
March
1 promoted
4 not promoted
0 sup.
1 demoted
April
2 promoted
1 not promoted
May
2 promoted
4 not promoted
2 sup.
1 kept
June
3 promoted
2 not promoted
July 0 promoted 0 not promoted
August
1 promoted
0 not promoted
September
4 promoted
6 not promoted
1 sup.
October
4 promoted
1 not promoted
November
2 promoted
0 not promoted
2 sup.
December
3 promoted
1 not promoted
2008
January
3 promoted
0 not promoted
2 sup.
2 demoted
February
2 promoted
1 not promoted
March
4 promoted
2 not promoted
1 sup.
April
5 promoted
4 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept
May
5 promoted
1 not promoted
1 sup.
June
2 promoted
0 not promoted
1 sup.
2 demoted
July
3 promoted
4 not promoted
1 sup.
August
7 promoted
5 not promoted
2 sup.
September
10 FT, 7 GT
14 not promoted
3 sup.
October
2 FT, 7 GT
7 not promoted
3 sup.
1 kept
November
2 FT, 5 GT
3 not promoted
4 sup.
December
7 FT, 11 GT
5 not promoted
2 sup.
2009
January
2 FT, 4 GT
5 not promoted
2 sup.
February
7 FT, 6 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
March
2 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept
April
3 FT, 1 GT
3 not promoted
0 sup.
May
2 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
1 demoted
June
4 FT, 9 GT
2 not promoted
3 sup.
3 demoted
July
2 FT, 6 GT
5 not promoted
3 sup.
2 demoted
August
2 FT, 6 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
September
3 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
2 kept
October
3 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
2 kept, 6 demoted
November
1 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept
December
1 FT, 5 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
2010
January
1 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
2 demoted
February
0 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
3 sup.
2 kept, 2 demoted
March
5 FT, 4 GT
3 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 5 demoted
April
1 FT, 8 GT
3 not promoted
4 sup.
May
0 FT, 7 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
June
2 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
1 demoted
July
5 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
2 sup.
2 demoted
August
1 FT, 6 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
September
1 FT, 1 GT
4 not promoted
0 sup.
October
3 FT, 18 GT
4 not promoted
1 sup.
2 kept, 2 demoted
November
0 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
2 kept, 1 demoted
December
2 FT, 7 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
2011
January
2 FT, 5 GT
3 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
February
1 FT, 11 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
March
0 FT, 4 GT
2 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
April
1 FT, 9 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
May
1 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
June
1 FT, 2 GT
2 not promoted
0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July
2 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
August
1 FT, 8 GT
2 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
September
2 FT, 2 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
October
4 FT, 6 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
December
1 FT, 4 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
2012
January
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February
0 FT, 11 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
2 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April
0 FT, 6 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
May
1 FT, 5 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
June
0 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July
0 FT, 14 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 4 demoted
August
2 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September
1 FT, 6 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup.
2 kept, 0 demoted
October
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November
2 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December
1 FT, 6 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
2013
January
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
February
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
2 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
April
2 FT, 4 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
2 kept, 0 demoted
May
0 FT, 5 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
June
1 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
July
1 FT, 8 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
3 kept, 2 demoted
August
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September
0 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
October
4 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
1 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
December
0 FT, 4 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
2014
January
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
February
0 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
March
0 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
April
1 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
May
1 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
June
2 FT, 4 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
August
4 FT, 1 GT
2 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
September
1 FT, 5 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
October
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
November
1 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
December
1 FT, 0 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
2015
January
0 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
February
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
March
1 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
April
0 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
May
2 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
August
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September
2 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 0 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
December
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
2016
January
1 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
May
0 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
June
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
July
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
August
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
September
0 FT, 7 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
October
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
3 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
0 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 2 demoted
December
0 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
2017
January
2 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
February
0 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
4 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
April
1 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
May
1 FT, 6 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
June
0 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
0 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
August
0 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
October
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
1 FT, 0 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
December
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
2018
January
1 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
February
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
April
1 FT, 5 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
May
1 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
June
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
1 FT, 4 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
August
1 FT, 2 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September
0 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
October
1 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
November
0 FT, 1 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
December
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
2019
January
1 FT, 1 GT
4 not promoted
4 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
February
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
March
1 FT, 3 GT
2 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
May
0 FT, 4 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
June
0 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
August
1 FT, 5 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
October
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 3 demoted
November
0 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
December
1 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
2020
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February
1 FT, 5 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 5 demoted
March
3 FT, 1 GT
1 not promoted
0 sup.
1 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
1 kept, 1 demoted
May
1 FT, 2 GT
1 not promoted
3 sup.
2 kept, 4 demoted
June
0 FT, 8 GT
0 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
July
0 FT, 2 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
August
1 FT, 2 GT
2 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
September
0 FT, 3 GT
0 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 2 demoted
October
0 FT, 5 GT
1 not promoted
2 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
November
1 FT, 0 GT
2 not promoted
0 sup.
0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT
0 not promoted
1 sup.
0 kept, 1 demoted
2021
January
0 FT, 3 GT
1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
February 1 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
April 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 4 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 2 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
July 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 1 kept, 0 demoted
September 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
November 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 1 not promoted 0 sup. 2 kept, 1 demoted
2022
January 0 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 2 kept, 3 demoted
February 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
April 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 2 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 3 demoted
September 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
October 1 FT, 5 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
November 0 FT, 1 GT 1 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2023
January 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
February 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 4 demoted
March 0 FT, 2 GT 0 not promoted 2 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
June 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 1 demoted
July 0 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
August 2 FT, 3 GT 0 not promoted 3 sup. 0 kept, 2 demoted
September 1 FT, 4 GT 0 not promoted 1 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 1 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
2024
January 2 FT, 6 GT 2 not promoted 7 sup. 0 kept, 5 demoted
February 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
March 1 FT, 1 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
April 1 FT, 6 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 1 kept, 1 demoted
May 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
June 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
July 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
August 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
September 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
October 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
November 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted
December 0 FT, 0 GT 0 not promoted 0 sup. 0 kept, 0 demoted

Kept

Iowa class battleships

This topic passed its retention on February 6, 2012 for the article USS Kentucky (BB-66), which was demoted from being a featured article last November. So the topic currently fails criterion 3(a).-- 06:31, 26 July 2012 (UTC)[reply]

You really need to clarify that. Why does the demotion of another article (USS Kentucky) mean
Iowa class battleships must be demoted also? -Fnlayson (talk) 13:40, 26 July 2012 (UTC)[reply
]
Nevermind, delisted from Featured Topic, not Featured Article. -Fnlayson (talk) 13:48, 26 July 2012 (UTC)[reply]
  • ...Yeah, to be fair, I didn't get that part at first either. I've put Illinois and Kentucky up for deletion, depending on what happens at the afd's this'll either be resolved there or if consensus is for keep then OMT personnel can work on Kentucky without feeling that all that work will be for nothing. Also, it would've been nice to have been forewarned that this was coming rather that to have found out about this via my watchlist. TomStar81 (Talk) 00:48, 27 July 2012 (UTC)[reply]
The fact that you weren't forewarned about it last November is what's troubling. At the very least, if you had a stake in the topic, should you not have realized that once one of the article's in the topic loses its status that the status of the topic would also be brought up? Well, the consensus was to keep both articles, so work should get started on the Kentucky if you want to retain the topic's status.-- 10:14, 6 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]
I've done a poor man's two step to see if the basic issues have been addressed, which should be enough to get this up to GA-class for the time being. If I can muster some willpower I might drill into the article and take a closer look at what we have to work with and see if more couldn't be added to it. TomStar81 (Talk) 18:33, 6 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]
Comment The book report is also filled with issues for most of these articles. The topic really needs some work to be up to snuff.
books} 14:45, 10 August 2012 (UTC)[reply
]
The 'book report'? What pray tell is that? TomStar81 (Talk) 03:15, 11 August 2012 (UTC)[reply]
The featured topic box has a few links in the top-left corner. Click on "report" and you will be taken to it.
books} 15:51, 13 August 2012 (UTC)[reply
]
Some dead links and citation needed tags.
Nergaal (talk) 16:27, 21 August 2012 (UTC)[reply
]

Guitar Hero series

I am nominating this for good topic removal because it has been sitting on the

Guitar Hero (iOS) to good or featured status. As this has not been done in the almost 7 months since then, I am (reluctantly) putting this topic up to be delisted on failure of criterion 3.b. ClayClayClay 05:25, 12 March 2012 (UTC)[reply
]

I wasn't even aware someone created the iOS article for this series. Taking at look at what sources might be there, I wouldn't have created it at all, instead merging the content to the existing mobile article with a couple more sources. --MASEM (t) 05:30, 12 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]
The current article is little more than a song list anyways, so merging the content would be easy and it would satisfy my concerns. One thing though, unless you have a hidden mobile article I don't know about, if you end up putting the content into the Guitar Hero Mobile series article, that article might need to be renamed (and refocused a little) because this product isn't branded "Mobile" like the others and AFAIK not part of that series... just something to think about. ClayClayClay 06:03, 12 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]
You're right, I'd dump it to the main series since GHMobile is a specific sub-series of it. --MASEM (t) 06:04, 12 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]
  • Comment As there has been no further discussion, I boldly redirected
    Andrewstalk 05:26, 27 April 2012 (UTC)[reply
    ]

Family Guy (season 5)

I am nominating this for Good Topic Removal as two of the episodes included ("Boys Do Cry" and "Bill & Peter's Bogus Journey") have been delisted from GA status, thus failing criteria 3b. Glimmer721 talk 17:30, 11 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose per
Nergaal (talk) 19:37, 11 March 2012 (UTC)[reply
]
Sorry, new to this; how do we put it up for retention? Glimmer721 talk 20:35, 11 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]
If I did my math correctly, interested editors have until May 26 to restore "Bill & Peter's Bogus Journey" and until May 29 to restore "Boys Do Cry" to GA. Jay32183 (talk) 05:04, 14 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]
Have added this to the retention board, will notify the topic nominator and GA nominators for the two articles if they're different. GRAPPLE X 21:30, 16 March 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Rivadavia-class battleships

Nominating per Negaal's comments

Wikipedia:Featured topic candidates/South American dreadnought race/archive1
. I personally think that having a topic composed of subtopics isn't against the spirit of FT, but community consensus could be against me.

This will also serve as an FTRC for

[majestic titan] 11:31, 22 August 2012 (UTC)[reply
]

Demoted

Confessions

Article "Yeah!" has been delisted as a good article for a number of months now; not sure how that slipped by. It needs to either be worked on to reach GA status again or the topic faces delisting under criterion 3b. GRAPPLE X 18:55, 22 June 2012 (UTC)[reply]

  • Delist for now. Can be renominated when/if "Yeah!" gets back to GA status. Statυs (talk) 19:16, 30 June 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Atlantic Coast Conference football championship games

The retention period of 2011 ACC Championship Game ended on March 3, and the article is still a stub, thus the topic fails criteria 3(a).-- 08:17, 22 June 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Virginia Tech Hokies bowl games

The retention period of 2012 Sugar Bowl ended on April 3, thus the topic fails criteria 3(b).-- 08:13, 22 June 2012 (UTC)[reply]

Family Guy (season 5)

With two article having been demoted from GA status, topic fails criterion 3b. Retention period ended today (May 26) based on demotion of "

first GTRC, to no avail. GRAPPLE X 05:29, 26 May 2012 (UTC)[reply
]