L. J. Greenberg

Edit links
Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

L. J. Greenberg
Born1861
Birmingham, U.K.
Died1931
Resting placeKibbutz Degania, Israel
OccupationJournalist
ChildrenIvan Greenberg

L. J. Greenberg, born Leopold Jacob Greenberg (1861–1931), was a British journalist. He had become an energetic propagandist of the new Zionism in England by the Third Zionist Congress in 1899, at which he and Jacob de Haas were elected as members of the ZO's Propaganda Committee.[1] His frequent dialectical debates were conducted as editor of The Jewish Chronicle, the leading paper in Britain for the Jewish community. Greenberg called for decency and humanity towards World Jewry.

Early Zionism

He was born in Birmingham in 1861, the son of Simeon Greenberg, a successful jewellery manufacturer. He was educated in London, at a private Jewish school in Maida Vale, then at University College School. Greenberg made friends with many political figures in Great Britain at the turn of the twentieth century. This enabled him to partly fulfill the wishes and dreams of Theodor Herzl, whom he invited to his home in London. His primary aim was to gain Zionism acceptance by British Jews; in 1900, 99% of the community were indifferent to the idea. But Greenberg, who had edited a monthly magazine in the 1890s called Young Israel, disseminated the philosophy.[2]

The Jewish Chronicle

Greenberg stressed the need for a platform. So, when he heard that

Tsarist regime
to desist from the murder of civilians. But the government's immediate concerns prevented intervention on behalf of Austro-Jews or Russian Jews: intellectual opposition continued.

Political persuasion

The lawyer Greenberg chose to draw up the Articles of Association of The Jewish Chronicle was a Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) by the name of David Lloyd George. They had established a good relationship long before he became Prime Minister.

Another close acquaintance of his and Liberal Unionist MP was Joseph Chamberlain. Chamberlain later rose to become Secretary for the Colonies in 1902, and Greenberg felt he could approach him with the request that he give the Jewish people a homeland, somewhere in the British Empire, preferably in what is now Israel. But that territory was a Turkish province, so Chamberlain was unable to help. But he did offer the Jewish people Sinai in 1901, as that was distinct from Egypt. The heat and lack of water made it impractical to support a large population, so the offer fell through. Then, in 1903, Chamberlain offered Greenberg the colony of Uganda as a Jewish home. That had a better climate, but the Russian Zionists all rejected it saying with great force, "Israel or nothing" at the 1904 World Jewish Congress in Basel.[6] The Western concept of Zionism, headed by Herzl, was foreign to Russian Jewry.[7]

First World War

After Herzl's death, the Zionist movement languished, with only a small bureau of Herzl's followers remaining in Vienna. On the other side of the English Channel, Greenberg edited The Jewish Chronicle and took vital steps to secure its future as the sole voice of the British Jewish community, assisted by Jacobus Kann, Joseph Cowen, and Leopold Kessler.

Prior to 1914, The Jewish Chronicle had been unrestrained in its criticism of the Russian Empire, because of the ill-treatment the Jews had endured.[8] Greenberg even expressed the view in an editorial that Britain should join Austria and Germany in a war against Russia. But once Germany violated Belgian neutrality, Greenberg had to abandon Russian Jewry, and claimed that Britain should join Russia in a war against Austria/Germany. The Jewish Chronicle placed a placard outside its London offices reiterating that "England has been all she could be to the Jews; the Jews will be all they can to England." In a similar vein, on 4 September 1914, the newspaper argued "From the Russian people Jews have never experienced anything but the deepest sympathy, and with the Russian people they have ever felt on mutually agreeable terms." Early in 1915, Greenberg and Zangwill lobbied the Foreign Office vigorously opposing Weizmann's World View of a Zionist homeland. More for the fears of failure, and bourgeois retrenchment they calculated the friction with Arab tensions would produce years of conflict. Greenberg disliked the communality of global Judaism. "The Zionist Organization was foreign and was almost entirely controlled from alien-enemy countries." Greenberg expressed the fears of the middle-classes of the destructive influence of militarism. The path according to Greenberg was construed to be assimilationist.[9]

In 1916, America remained neutral. Britain was virtually exhausted. A new front had to be opened. The

Edmund Allenby. Still the Americans were neutral. While in Russia, there had been a revolution that had removed the hated Czar and seen Lenin and his Bolsheviks
take control. American opinion turned against Britain, and the Americans were even considering entering the war on the side of Germany.

At this point, Weizmann made an interesting discovery: he found it was possible to extract acetate, needed to produce dynamite, from chestnuts. As the British war effort was almost at a standstill for the lack of acetate, Weizmann's discovery assumed capital importance. The Prime Minister, David Lloyd George, is said to have offered Weizmann anything to show his gratitude. According to legend, Weizmann is said to have replied: "All I want is a homeland for my people". Greenberg, at the same time, was asked: "What can we do to bring American opinion back to supporting Britain?". Greenberg answered: "Give the Jewish people the homeland they have been dreaming of for 2,000 years!". They also asked Greenberg what to do to win back Russian opinion and got the same reply.

Greenberg was present at an important meeting with Sir

Anglo-Jewry.[11]
Greenberg remained a moderating influence, but the Great War changed forever relations within British Jewry. Jibes that he was adopting an English-style manifesto commitment were designs upon integrity. The public debate amongst obsessive secrecy crystallized nationalism, militarism, and the launch of a regiment abroad.

Delayed burial

Greenberg had expressed the wish that he should be

Jewish Agency, a resting place for Greenberg's remains was found at Kibbutz Degania by the shore of the Sea of Galilee
.

Bibliography

Manuscripts

  • Leonard Stein Papers, New Bodleian Library, Oxford University
  • Lucien Wolf Papers, Yivo Institute, New York City and Central Zionist Archive, Israel
  • Israel Zangwill Papers, Central Zionist Archive, Israel

Newspapers

Books

  • Cesarani, David (1994). The Jewish Chronicle and Anglo-Jewry 1841–1991. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    ISBN 0-521-43434-3
    .
  • Weizmann, Chaim (1949). Trial and Error, the Autobiography of Chaim Weizmann. First edition. New York: Harper and Brothers.
    OCLC 512638
    .

References

  1. ^ Nahum Sokolow, History of Zionism 1600–1918, p.xliii (1919)
  2. ^ Cesarani (1994), p.107
  3. ^ "Leopold Jacob Greenberg (1861–1931), journalist and Zionist". The Museum of the Jewish People at Beit Hatfutsot. Archived from the original on 19 October 2008. Retrieved 3 April 2008.
  4. ^ Schneer, p.115
  5. ^ Schneer, p.125
  6. ^ Cesarani 1994 p.101
  7. ^ Weizmann 1949 p.73
  8. ^ Cesarani 1994,
  9. ^ Schneer, pp.143-4
  10. ^ Stein, Balfour Declaration, p.367
  11. ^ Schneer, pp.309-11
Media offices
Preceded by Editor of The Jewish Chronicle
1907–1931 		Succeeded by
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=L._J._Greenberg&oldid=1195042858"