Lord Eliot Convention
The Lord Eliot Convention, or simply the Eliot Convention or Eliot Treaty (
Edward Eliot had become Secretary of Legation at Madrid on 21 November 1821 and was styled Lord Eliot in 1826.[1]
Executions
During the First Carlist War, which began in 1833, Carlist prisoners who did not accept the Liberal
Early Isabeline executions include that of
The Carlists inevitably reacted from their position of weakness by executing their prisoners in this way, not only as acts of reprisal but also due to limited facilities with which to house their prisoners. Not being able to take their prisoners with them on mountain campaigns, for example, the Carlists executed them before moving to a new location. Liberal soldiers found hiding in the aftermath of the Battle of Alegría de Álava (October 27, 1834), were not taken prisoner but shot or bayoneted on sight,[3] and the Liberal commander during that battle, Manuel O'Doyle, was executed by firing squad on October 28, 1834.
A notorious incident was the execution of 118 Isabeline prisoners by the Carlists at
Espartero complained at Bilbao about the barbaric executions of the war, stating that it was prudent for the government to regulate the treatment of prisoners between the two opposing sides, in accordance with practices enacted between two opposing countries, "according to the general laws concerning the rights of men and of war."[4]
British intervention
The issue was discussed by the
"They spoke perfect French and Spanish, and appeared to be admirably prepared for the job for which they were appointed, due to their conciliatory manner and their understanding of the country [i.e. Spain], which one man had acquired through the course of his diplomatic career, while the other through the course of his military career."[6] Lord Eliot was described as "a person of graceful demeanor, of gentle and elegant proportions, thirty-four years old, and of modest dress, without any adornment. Colonel Gurwood accompanied him as secretary, and wore a uniform."[7]
Arrival of Lord Eliot and Gurwood at Spain
Lord Eliot arrived on April 5, 1835 at
Eliot and Gurwood arrived at
The agreement
Meanwhile, the
Zumalacárregui stationed himself at the valley of
Lord Eliot wished to have an autograph of Zumalacárregui; the Carlist general, meanwhile, wrote that "at Asarta, located in the valley of Berrueza, celebrated for the various battles that have occurred there during this century, I had the honor to receive Lord Eliot on April 25, 1835, Lord Eliot - Tomás de Zumalacárregui."
The British commissioners traveled with Zumalacárregui from Asarta to Estella in search of the Isabeline general Gerónimo Valdés, in charge of the operations in the north of Spain after the resignation of Espoz y Mina, to sign the agreement. On the way there, they stopped at the Monastery of Irache; Zumalacárregui reported that at Irache "there were some very beautiful nuns who made an excellent chocolate."[10]
Eliot did not find Valdés at Estella, but found him instead at Logroño. Valdés was not happy with the text that had been signed by Zumalacárregui, and made changes that he considered prudent. He signed the agreement at Logroño on April 27, 1835. A Carlist colonel who had accompanied the British commissioners to Logroño brought back the new text to Zumalacárregui, who signed the newly worded agreement on April 28, 1835 at Eulate.
The Convention contained the following nine stipulations:[11]
- 1. Preservation of Lives of Prisoners
- 2. Periodical exchange of Prisoners
- 3. Number of Prisoners exchanged to be equal.
- 4. Exchange according to Rank
- 5. Towns selected for detention of Prisoners to be respected.
- 6. Political Prisoners to be tried in conformity with the Laws.
- 7. Sick and Wounded to be respected
- 8. Stipulations to be binding in all Provinces of the Monarchy.
- 9. Strict observance of Convention.
Article Six specifically stated:
During the present contest, no person, whoever he may be, civil or military, shall be deprived of life on account of his Political Opinions, without having been previously tried and condemned in conformity with the Laws, Decrees, and Ordinances in force in Spain. This is only to be understood in reference to those who are not in reality Prisoners of War; for as regards them, the stipulations contained in the preceding Articles shall be binding.[12]
Legacy
The treatment of prisoners of the First Carlist War was thus regulated. The positive effects were immediate. A soldier of the
The British and Chapelgorris who fell into their hands [the Carlists], were mercilessly put to death, sometimes by means of tortures worthy of the North American Indians; but the Spanish troops of the line were saved by virtue, I believe, of the Eliot treaty, and after being kept for some time in prison, where they were treated with sufficient harshness, were frequently exchanged for an equal number of prisoners made by the Christinos.[13]
Charles Frederick Henningsen, who had served with the Carlists, dedicated his book, Twelve Months' Campaign with Zumalacárregui, to Lord Eliot, whom he described as "one of the very few who have in any way interfered in the civil strife now desolating Spain, whose name will not be a curse to her people, but on whose head the blessings of all ranks of Spaniards will be showered."[14]
However, though “it was mutually agreed upon to treat the prisoners taken on either side according to the ordinary rules of war, a few months only elapsed before similar barbarities were practiced with all their former remorselessness.”[15]
References
- ^ With the death of his uncle, his father succeeded as second Earl of St Germans.
- ^ La Aurora de España
- ^ William Walton, The Revolutions of Spain, from 1808 to the End of 1836 (R. Bentley, 1837), 309
- ^ Panorama, p. 145.
- ^ Henry Bill, The History of the World (1854), 142.
- ^ Henningsen, p.232
- ^ Zaratiegui, p. 319.
- ^ Henningsen, p.232.
- ^ Zaratiegui, p.321.
- ^ Henningsen, p. 233.
- ^ Edward Hertslet (ed.), The Map of Europe by Treaty (Butterworths: 1875), 957-8.
- ^ Edward Hertslet (ed.), The Map of Europe by Treaty (Butterworths: 1875), 957-8.
- ^ Charles William Thompson, Twelve months in the British legion, by an officer of the Ninth regiment (Oxford University, 1836), 129.
- ^ Charles Frederick Henningsen, The Most Striking Events of a Twelvemonth's Campaign with Zumalacarregui (E. L. Carey & A. Hart, 1836), 3.
- ^ Henry Bill, The History of the World (1854), 142.
Primary sources
- Edward Granville Eliot St. Germans, Papers Relating to Lord Eliot's Mission to Spain in the Spring of 1835 (Bickers, 1871).
Secondary sources
- La Aurora de España. - Madrid, domingo 15 de diciembre de 1833.
- C.F. Henningsen. – Campaña de doce meses en Navarra y las Provincias Vascongadas con el general Zumalacárregui. Buenos Aires, 1947.
- Panorama Español. - Tomo II. Madrid, 1842.
- Antonio Pirala. - Historia de la Guerra Civil. Madrid, 1984.
- J. Antonio Zaratiegui. – Vida y hechos de D. Tomás de Zumalacárregui. San Sebastián, 1946