MTR Metro Cammell EMU (AC)

East Rail line Metro Cammell EMU (MLR)
3094/K01/K03/K05 stock
港鐵中期翻新列車
East Rail line Metro Cammell EMU (MLR); 3094/K01/K03/K05 stock; 港鐵中期翻新列車
	standard gauge
Notes/references
	Bogie centres:16,100 mm (52 ft 9.858 in);

The East Rail line Metro Cammell EMU (also known as Mid-Life Refurbishment Train, Chinese: 港鐵中期翻新列車; or MLR Train) was a model of electric multiple unit built in 1980–1990 by Metro-Cammell for the original Kowloon–Canton Railway (now the East Rail line) in Hong Kong. The 29 sets were owned by and were originally operated by the Kowloon-Canton Railway Corporation (KCRC). They were operated by MTR Corporation (MTRC) after it merged with KCRC in 2007. Although another set of EMU trains from the same manufacturer operate on some of MTR's own lines, there are some significant differences between the two models, with the Metro Cammell EMUs of the original MTR being known as the Modernization Train.

The trains were delivered in several phases. The different phases of this series of train have entitled with different model numbers, including: 3094 stock, K01 stock, K03 stock and K05 stock. Regardless, all model numbers have an identical appearance. After the rail merger, the KCR logos on the MLR trains were replaced with those of MTR, and a revised route map was introduced in the train interiors. Skirts were also added to all carriages, but the pantograph cars had their skirts removed due to heating issues. The interior floor was also changed for a darker blue in between two red aesthetics, and a brighter blue in between two windows.

Since the 2007 merger, the MLR was the second oldest variation of EMU operating on the MTR network, behind the M-Trains from 1979. It was also the only electric multiple unit of the Mass Transit Railway that did not have regenerative braking, as noted due to the lack of motor sound and the presence of air brake sounds while braking. All were retired on 6 May 2022, on the 40th anniversary of the electrification of the East Rail Line, with the Hyundai Rotem EMUs replacing them prior to the opening of the extension of the East Rail line to Admiralty station. It is the first type of electric train in Hong Kong to be removed from service.

History

The trains were ordered during the electrification of the KCR British section, now known as MTR East Rail line, in 1978. Sets E1-E45 and E46-E61 were delivered to KCRC in 2 batches in 1982–1983, when electrification was completed first between Hung Hom and Sha Tin in May 1982, and from then to Tai Po Market station before Lo Wu on 16 August 1983. KCRC also reordered further train sets in 1986 (sets E62-E86) and 1990 (sets E87-E118). In the early days of full electrification, these trains sometimes suffered from a temporary loss of electricity while passing University Station because of neutral sections (or dead zones), which was due to the lack of internal batteries.

The exteriors of the trains before refurbishment featured a red stripe running down the length of the trains, and yellow driving cabs located on the first and last cars. Due to the aforementioned colour of the cab, the trains was commonly referred to as the "Yellow-heads".

The trains were initially operated with 3 cars, they were subsequently extended to 6, 9 and 12 cars to cope with increasing ridership. Trains were inconsistent in terms of length, ranging from 3 to 12 cars. By 1992, all trains were formed of 12 cars.

Refurbishment

Like the DC MTR Metro Cammell EMUs, the KCR Metro Cammell EMUs underwent a major refurbishment from 1996 to 1999 to extend their lifespan, carried out by the successor of Metro-Cammell, Alstom (then known as GEC Alsthom). This reflected the significant role change of the KCR's British section, because of the development of new towns within the New Territories. The first refurbished train was put into service in 1996, while the original yellow-cab train was formally retired with a "Farewell Ride" on 31 October 1999.

The trains were converted to fixed 12-car sets and received a new exterior

ATC/ATO in 2002.^[3]^[4]

The only non-refurbished unit was E44 (144-244-444). E44 was not refurbished since it was the only unit left over after all other units were formed into 12 car trains. It is currently stored at Hung Hom station’s platform 5, the former southern terminus of the East Rail line.

Fleet

Cars of East Rail line Metro Cammell train
car type	driver cab	motor	batteries	pantograph	first class	length (mm)	seat	standing capacity	total
1xx	✓	✗	✓	✗	✗	23750	42	287	29
2xx	✗	✓	✗	✓	✗	23750	52	280	116
3xx	✓	✗	✗	✗	✗	23750	47	275	29
4xx	✗	✗	✗	✗	✓	23750	72	-	29
5xx	✗	✗	✗	✗	✗	23750	51/52	280/281	58
6xx	✗	✗	✓	✗	✗	23750	51/52	280/281	87

Configuration of an East Rail line Metro Cammell EMU is as follows: (southbound) 1xx-2xx-5xx+6xx-2xx-5xx+6xx-2xx-4xx+6xx-2xx-3xx (northbound), or (southbound) 1xx-2xx-5xx-5xx-2xx-6xx+6xx-2xx-4xx+6xx-2xx-3xx (northbound).

Accidents and incidents

Train accidents

1984 Sheung Shui crash incident

On 25 November 1984, an East Rail Metro Cammell EMU train derailed between Sheung Shui and Lo Wu station. The incident occurred when the driver, preparing to back the train up to Sheung Shui station, failed to follow a speed/stop signal while the train was exceeding the speed limit. The train crashed into a boulder buffer with the first two cars piling on top of each other. The degree of damage was so extensive that the cars never returned to service. Passengers were unloaded prior to the crash while the driver sustained only minor injuries. However, the accident caused train services to be suspended for the rest of the day and the incident spurred a series of public outcries concerning railway safety. Set E45 (which was 233-234-235) was hence commissioned as a result of the accident to replace the damaged cars.

The depot accident on 1987 included the only remaining coach no. 233 on E45, and coach no. 272 on E58. 233 took over the crashed 272 on E58 and became the current 458 in the late 90s, which has been retired in 2022 April. After then, the whole set E45 was scrapped in the 90s, and a 1:1 yellow head model was reconstructed until it made room for the retired locomotive 51.

2019 East Rail line derailment

On 17 September 2019, a 12-car Metro Cammell EMU train(E81/E21) servicing the East Rail line derailed while approaching Hung Hom station. Services between Hung Hom station and Mong Kok East station and the Intercity Through Train were cancelled for several days. Eight passengers were injured during the derailing. The derailment was attributed to deteriorated sleepers widening the track gauge.^[5] 4 cars were scrapped (including First Class) and 4 other cars from E92/E70 were repaired and used for the derailment train.

Underframe cracking

On 21 December 2005, an East Rail Metro Cammell EMU train failed while in operation. Following examination of the train, KCRC staff detected minor cracks in the welding of mounting brackets for some underframe components. A review panel commissioned by KCRC looked into the problem from four aspects:^[6]

the rate of change of the acceleration and deceleration of trains
the welding of components' mounting brackets
the profile of the track and train wheels
suspension system

Since the full introduction of

West Rail

to cope with recent maintenance of trains.

The Environment, Transport and Works Bureau reprimanded the KCRC for not immediately notifying the Government when it found problems with its East Rail trains in 2005. Secretary for the Bureau Dr Sarah Liao said she has ordered the KCRC to inspect all its trains, and did not rule out suspending services if there are safety doubts. Dr Liao ordered the chairman to review the corporation's operations, including its management and overall system, and submit a report. KCRC chairman Michael Tien accepted responsibility for the corporation's poor judgement in not sharing the information with the public in a timely matter.

On 21 January 2006, Michael Tien stated that the safety problems of East Rail had been controlled, and the train service was expected to operate as usual, including train service in the Chinese New Year. KCRC East Rail trains reverted to ATO operation on 6 August 2006, after the investigation confirmed that the ATO system is not a direct cause of the cracking.^[3]

Replacement

All 29 MLR sets had been gradually retired from service starting in 2021 (E92/E70 was scrapped in 2020) and, together with the newer SP1900 EMUs built by Kinki Sharyo, were replaced by brand-new Hyundai Rotem EMU trains ordered in December 2012. These 43 9-car "R-Trains" are manufactured by the same company as the K-Stock operating on the Tung Chung line and the Tseung Kwan O line. The MLR was officially retired on 6 May 2022, with the last train leaving Hung Hom at 13:00, formed of train set E112-E71, ending its 40 years of service.^[1]

Other details

Preserved examples

A 1:1 scale model of an in refurbished Metro Cammell EMU was once on display at the Hong Kong Railway Museum, built from components of carriage 272 of set E58. The model has since been scrapped to make room for Locomotive 51.^[7] A portion of a retired refurbished MLR carriage (361, northbound carriage) now exists at the Ying Wa College and Primary School, transformed into a classroom.^[8] Two carriages (196/377) have been sent to Wan Chai Promenade Harbourfront for leisure.^[9]

Scrapped units and surplus cars

E45 (which was 233-234-235) was supposed to be 145-245-445. After the incident, the only remaining coach was coach no. 233. Coach 233 replaced the crashed 272 in E58 and officially became coach no. 272, and then 458. Due to the extensive damage, coaches 234 and 235 were wrecked in the 1984 accident in a siding, and the only remaining historical train was E44 (144-244-444) and 445 (now preserved at Hung Hom Station). If these were not involved, 144 and 145 would have become 644 and 645.

Gallery

Refurbished Metro Cammell EMU in August 2008
MTR Metro Cammell EMU at Lo Wu
First class seating in a MTR Metro Cammell EMU
LED screen at top of window
Refurbishment plaque
KCR Metro Cammell EMU at Tai Wai
Unrefurbished E44 unit (144-244-444) stored at Ho Tung Lau Depot
MTR Metro Cammell EMU (AC) seen next to its replacement, the Hyundai Rotem R-Train, at University Station in December 2021
MTR Metro Cammell EMU (AC) exiting the Beacon Hill Tunnel and arriving at Kowloon Tong Station
Two of the final five sets of MLR-Trains passing by each other south of University Station while serving special runs to Mong Kok East during the evening peak hours in its second last week of service.
MLR-Train arriving at Hung Hom Terminus during its last week of service.
E112-71 arriving at Hung Hom platform 1 for its last run to Shatin at 1300 on 6 May 2022
E71-E112 prepares to depart Sha Tin station for the final time
E61-E110 in Mong Kok East Station on 14 April 2022
MLR E110-E61 and R-Train D091 at Kowloon Tong Station
A MLR train at Fanling station on 6 February 2021
MLR E67-E114 at Hung Hom station on its third last day of service on 4 May 2022
MLR E98 at Sha Tin station on 2 June 2017
MLR E70-E92 at University station on 4 June 2015
MLR First Class carriage 436 at Kowloon Tong station in June 2021
MLR E71-E112 at Tai Wai Station on its second last week of service on 29 April 2022
MLR E71-E112 at Kowloon Tong station on 27 January 2022
2 Metro Cammell EMU (AC) meet at University station on 30 December 2021
MLR E114 at Kowloon Tong station on 19 December 2006
The first MLR train, E1 at Fo Tan Station on 15 January 2022
A MLR train at Fanling station before merger with MTR on 12 December 2007
A shed made up of MLR parts in Tai Po
A collage made of MLR parts at The Wai
MLR train in Wan Chai
Platform Side of MLR carriage 196 in Wan Chai