Sontag: Her Life and Work

Sontag: Her Life and Work is a 2019 biography of American writer Susan Sontag written by Benjamin Moser.

The book won the

In preparation of the biography, Moser was given access to Sontag's restricted archive of unpublished journals, medical files, personal papers, and computer files. Moser also conducted hundreds of interviews with Sontag's family, friends and adversaries, including individuals who had previously not spoken publicly about Sontag such as Salman Rushdie and Annie Leibovitz.^[5][6][7]

Contents

Authorship claim

In May 2019, Alison Flood reported in The Guardian that Benjamin Moser would present evidence in Sontag: Her Life and Work that while Philip Rieff's book Freud: The Mind of the Moralist was based partly on Rieff's research, the book was actually written by Sontag rather than by Rieff. According to Flood, Moser told The Guardian that Sontag agreed for the book to be published as Rieff's work only because she was involved in an "acrimonious divorce" with him and wanted to prevent "her ex-husband from taking her child."^[8]

In an extract from his book published in Harper's Magazine, Moser stated that Sontag always claimed to be the real author of Freud: The Mind of the Moralist after its publication. Moser maintained that there were "contemporary witnesses" to her authorship of the book, and that Sontag's views were apparent in its comments on women and homosexuality. According to Moser, Sontag permitted Rieff to claim to be its author despite advice from her friend Jacob Taubes, and Rieff granted only that Sontag was "co-author" of the book.^[9] The journalist Janet Malcolm criticized Moser's claims, arguing in The New Yorker that he failed to substantiated them and that they reflected his dislike of Rieff.^[10] Len Gutkin, who observed that Rieff's reputation rested partly on Freud: The Mind of the Moralist, wrote in The Chronicle of Higher Education that much of Moser's evidence was "compelling". He also suggested that whoever wrote the book had plagiarized from the critic M. H. Abrams's The Mirror and the Lamp (1953), arguing that it contains closely similar passages.^[11] Kevin Slack, a professor at Hillsdale College, and William Batchelder, a professor at Waynesburg University, have challenged Moser's claim by arguing Moser has a bias against Rieff. They compare Freud: the Mind of the Moralist to Rieff's earlier dissertation, which they argue Moser shows no evidence of having read in Sontag: Her Life and Work. They argue that Sontag's sole authorship is highly unlikely because much of the book is drawn from the dissertation: "To defend his position, Moser would have to make the absurd argument that Sontag wrote every word of Rieff’s earlier dissertation, an argument even Moser balks at making."^[12]

Publication

Sontag: Her Life and Work was published in hardcover, e-book and audiobook format by Ecco, an imprint of HarperCollins, on September 17, 2019.^[13] The audiobook is narrated by Tavia Gilbert.^[14] The book's dust jacket was designed by Allison Saltzman and features a photograph of Susan Sontag in New York on April 10, 1978, photographed by Richard Avedon.^[1]

A

Kirkus Reviews called the book "a comprehensive, intimate—and surely definitive" biography of Sontag.^[17]

Publishers Weekly called it a "doorstopper biography" but felt the book was "likely to deter all but her most ardent admirers" due to its length.^[18]

In her review for