Critical anthropomorphism
This article's tone or style may not reflect the encyclopedic tone used on Wikipedia. The reason given is: Reads like a scientific journal article rather than an encyclopedia entry (April 2014) |
Critical anthropomorphism (from
Background
Implementation
The critically anthropomorphic approach has been applied to a range of species and behavioral and cognitive capacities. Burghardt and Rivas describe case histories of how critical anthropomorphism informed the design and interpretation of animal behavior research.
Historically, an idea like critical anthropomorphism would be at odds with behaviorism, but some contemporary investigators of animal conditioning and learning take exception. For example, Timberlake and Delmater (1991)[8] argued that behaviorists should relax their mechanistic constraints and consider the sensory and perceptual worlds of nonhuman species:
Instead of projecting oneself as a particular type of human into the circumstances of the organism, one attempts to assume both the circumstances and the characteristics of the organism...Experimenters not only need to put themselves in the subject's shoes, they need to wear them – walk, watch, hear, touch, and act like the subject. The humility required to assume this role coupled with the power of the experimental approach should increase the efficiency with which the understanding, prediction, and control of behavior can advance.[9]
Caveats
The idea of an inner world resembles subjective states, contrasting it with behaviorism, particularly
Burghardt[12][13] counters Wynne's arguments by pointing out that: 1) critical anthropomorphism is not by itself intended to be a description and explanation of behavior, but rather as a heuristic for generating testable hypotheses, 2) critical anthropomorphism can—and has—been used to avoid ill-conceived studies of animal behavior, 3) denying our status as animals and that we might share similar experiences of the world with nonhuman species is itself erroneous, and 4) mentalistic explanations of behavior are not, as Wynne suggests, equal to supernatural ones.
See also
References
- ISBN 9780805802528.
- ISBN 9780791431252.
- ^ Burghardt 1991, p. 72.
- ^ PMID 3898938.
- ^ Uexkull, J. von (1985) [1909]. Umwelt and innenwelt der tiere. [translated by CJ Mellor and D. Gove, and reprinted in G.M. Burghardt (ed.) Foundations of Comparative Ethology. New York: Nostrand Reinhold. pp. 222–245.
- ISBN 9780262523226.
- S2CID 5374924.
- PMID 22478079.
- ^ Timberlake & Delamater 1991, p. 39.
- OCLC 40451963.
- .
- .
- PMID 15229581.