Talk:Last Dance (Dua Lipa song)

This review is

transcluded from Talk:Last Dance (Dua Lipa song)/GA1

. The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.

Reviewer: Kyle Peake (talk · contribs) 11:54, 21 July 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Good Article review progress box WP:CV () 3a. broadness () 3b. focus () 4. free or tagged images () 6b. pics relevant () Note: this represents where the article stands relative to the Good Article criteria. Criteria marked are unassessed

Giving a review very quickly after nomination by taking this one on! --Kyle Peake (talk) 11:54, 21 July 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Infobox and lead

• Put (deluxe edition) in brackets after the album's title in the infobox
• Add streaming next to Digital download with the appropriate target
• Target Stephen Kozmeniuk to
  Koz (record producer)
• "Dua Lipa, included on the deluxe edition of her 2017 eponymous debut studio album." → "Dua Lipa from the deluxe edition of her eponymous debut studio album (2017)."
• "and it's producer" → "and its producer"
• Remove the about part of the sentence from here; I will set it for a different area of the lead below
• "was released for digital download on 9 February 2016 through Lipa's independent record label," → "was released for digital download and streaming on 9 February 2016 through" with the appropriate target
• "after premiering on" → "after having premiered on"
• ""Last Dance" is a" → "It is a"
• "song with a" → "song that features a"
• Next sentence should be "Lyrically, the song is about..." with mention of its lyrical meaning
• "received critical acclaim from" → "received acclaim from"
• "peaked at number 4" → "peaked at number four" per
  MOS:NUM
• "It received a music video that premiered on" → "An accompanying music video premiered via"
• "by Jon Brewer and Ian Blair and" → "by both Jon Brewer and Ian Blair, and was"
• Remove wikilink on California
• "and she promoted the single with numerous live performances," → "and was promoted by her with numerous live performances in 2016,"

 Done

Background and composition

• "and
  Koz
  , with the latter of the three solely handling" with the target
• "They wrote it in" → "They wrote the song in"
• "in Toronto after Lipa" → "in Toronto, after Lipa"
• Are you sure "success" is the correct term here? Gives the impression it had already been released by 2014; also, add the song's release year in brackets.

• Changed to "sound"

• "writing session of the day and she" → "writing session in a day and Lipa"
• "how she was able to capture" → "being able to capture"
• "she recalls that moment." → "Lipa recalls that moment."
• "but after hearing the finished" → "though after hearing the finished"
• "She stated that it → "Lipa stated that it"
• "she would take it to producers" → "she would take to producers"
• Add timedtext to the sample
• Wikilink
  MOS:LINK2SECT
• "It begins slowly with Lipa" → "The track begins slowly, with Lipa"
• "The track builds up to" → "It builds up to"
• "is mostly instrumental, with" → "is mostly instrumental, featuring"
• "It has a" → "The track has a"

 Done

Release and promotion

• "on 8 February 2016 on" → "on 8 February 2016 via"
• "was released for digital download" → "was released for digital download and streaming" with the target
• "Dua Lipa Limited as the third single" → "Dua Lipa Limited, as the third single" with the target
• Remove target on eponymous debut studio album
• "in the United Kingdom" → "stations in the United Kingdom"
• "It also received remixes" → ""Last Dance" also received remixes"
• "on Lipa's eponymous debut studio album, but" → "on the album but"
• Move the img to being at the top of the music video sub-section instead
• "with Jaguar titled" → "with [[Jaguar Cars|Jaguar], titled"
• Are you sure punctuation should be inside quotes for the title?

• Put outside quote.

• "at the Eurosonic festival for that year" → "at the Eurosonic festival"
• "on the set list Lipa's" → "on the set list for Lipa's"
• Add the tour's year in brackets
• Mention what year the MTV performance was
• "the song during her MTV Setlist show" → "the song for her MTV Setlist show"

 Done

Music video

• "by Jon Brewer and Ian Blair and" → "by Jon Brewer alongside Ian Blair, while"
• "It premiered on" → "It premiered to YouTube on"
• "was filmed in December 2015" → "was filmed during December 2015"
• "of California. Lipa recalled that" → "of California, with Lipa recalling that"
• "really cold there" → "really cold in the state"
• "The video opens with Lipa" → "It opens with Lipa"
• "she is seen wearing a black bra with" → "Lipa is seen wearing a black bra and"
• "At times, the visuals" → "At multiple points, the visuals"
• Target 3D to an appropriate page
• "looped fragment as well as" → "looped fragment, as well as"
• "as a nod to her" → "for nodding to her"

 Done

Reception

• "received critical acclaim from" → "was met with acclaim from"
• "Lipa's vocal flexibility writing her" → "Lipa's vocal flexibility, writing her"
• "For Pulse Media, Jessica Boyle" → "Writing for Pulse Media, Jessica Boyle"
• "categorize the lyrics as "standalone"" → "categorized the lyrics as "standalone,""
• Remove target on club
• "the song's production and lyric mix as well as" → "the song's production and lyrics mix, while"
• "called it a" → "called "Last Dance" a"
• "to Justin Bieber's Purpose and" → "to Justin Bieber's Purpose (2015), and"
• "compared the song to" → "compared the song to the music of"
• Remove second wikilink on Major Lazer
• Target The 405 to The 405 (magazine)
• "and "infectious" with" → "and "infectious," with"
• "on Billboard's Twitter Emerging Artists chart, where it spent seven weeks." → "on the US Billboard Twitter Emerging Artists chart, lasting for seven weeks on the chart."

 Done

Track listings

• Digital download → Digital download / streaming
• Digital download – Remixes → Digital download / streaming – Remixes

 Done

Credits and personnel

• Recording and Personnel should be separated with subheadings, not subsections
• Target Metropolis Studios to Metropolis Group
• Use {{
  spaced ndash
  }} so there is the right space between credits and personnel

 Done

Release history

• Add streaming for both of the digital download releases

 Done

References

• Top job with the archiving!
• Copyvio score looks amazing at 7.4%!!
• MOS:QWQ
  issues with ref 3
• Cite numerous countries iTunes for ref 13 to verify the release was indeed various and change iTunes to iTunes Store
• Ditto for ref 15, with no wikilinks though
• Would it better to cite a release source, like AllMusic for example, on ref 16? Maybe 17 too if there is another...?

•  Not done, for 16 it's an archived source that has its original pre-order track listing and 17, the AllMusic source isn't accurate.

• Add language for ref 21
• Target The 405 to The 405 (magazine) on ref 29

 Done

Final comments and verdict

• There appears to have been some reverting of edits, but it was not close together so I do believe the article is stable and am placing it  On hold, good luck! --Kyle Peake (talk) 15:22, 22 July 2020 (UTC)[reply]

• Thanks Kyle Peake, I have addressed all your comments. LOVI33 23:13, 22 July 2020 (UTC)[reply]

• LOVI33 Thanks for the quick response, did some brief copy editing but ✓ Pass now! --Kyle Peake (talk) 07:15, 23 July 2020 (UTC)[reply]