Human rights abuses in Chile under Augusto Pinochet

Human rights abuses in Chile under Augusto Pinochet were the
According to the
The systematic human rights violations that were committed by the military dictatorship of Chile, under General Augusto Pinochet, included gruesome acts of physical and sexual abuse, as well as psychological damage. From 1973 to 1990, Chilean armed forces, the police and all those aligned with the military junta were involved in institutionalizing fear and terror in Chile.[1]
The most prevalent forms of state-sponsored torture that Chilean prisoners endured were electric shocks, waterboarding, beatings, and sexual abuse. Another common mechanism of torture employed was "disappearing" those who were deemed to be potentially subversive because they adhered to leftist political doctrines. The tactic of "disappearing" the enemies of the Pinochet regime was systematically carried out during the first four years of military rule. The "disappeared" were held in secret, subjected to torture and were often never seen again. Both the National Commission on Political Imprisonment and Torture (Valech Report) and the Commission of Truth and Reconciliation (Rettig Report) approximate that there were around 30,000 victims of human rights abuses in Chile, with 40,018 incidents of torture and 2,279 executed..[2] The following people have been identified, along with many others, as victims of the Pinochet regime:
- Diana Aron, journalist
- Miguel Enriquez, political activist
- Victor Jara, singer-songwriter and poet
- Jose Liendo, left-wing militant
- Carlos Lorca, political activist
- Reinalda Pereira, doctor and trade unionist
- Arsenio Poupin, politician
- Elizabeth Rekas, social worker
- Alfredo Rojas, engineer and politician
- Bautista van Schouwen, doctor and political activist
- Franco Teruggi, writer and trade unionist
History
He shut down parliament, suffocated political life, banned trade unions, and made Chile his sultanate. His government disappeared 3,200 opponents, arrested 30,000 (torturing thousands of them) ... Pinochet's name will forever be linked to the
Desaparecidos, the Caravan of Death, and the institutionalized torture that took place in the Villa Grimaldicomplex.

The worst violence occurred in the first three months of the coup's aftermath, with the number of suspected leftists killed or "
Following Pinochet's defeat in the
A later report, the
According to the Latin American Institute on Mental Health and Human Rights (ILAS), "situations of extreme trauma" affected about 200,000 persons; this figure includes individuals killed, tortured (following the UN definition of torture), or exiled and their immediate relatives. [citation needed] While more radical groups such as the Movement of the Revolutionary Left (MIR) were staunch advocates of a Marxist revolution, it is currently accepted that the junta deliberately targeted nonviolent political opponents as well.[citation needed]
A court in Chile sentenced, on March 19, 2008, 24 former police officers in cases of kidnapping, torture and murder that happened just after a U.S.-backed coup overthrew President Salvador Allende, a Socialist, on September 11, 1973.[19]
Bureaucratic authoritarianism
The concept of bureaucratic authoritarianism characterizes the military regimes that rose to power in South America between the 1960s and 1980s, specifically in the Southern Cone regions of Argentina, Chile, Paraguay, and Uruguay. These regimes had a technocratic approach to policy-making and were accompanied by substantial repression. Guillermo O'Donnell—a prominent Argentine political scientist— labeled these regimes as "bureaucratic authoritarian" in order to "distinguish them from oligarchical and populist forms of the authoritarian rule found in less modernized countries."[20]
From its inception on September 11, 1973, the Chilean bureaucratic authoritarian regime's ultimate agenda was to repress political dissidents—which some have classified as "
As Pinochet's suspicions grew, the military dictator targeted anyone who was in some way associated with the "leftists," which even included the mothers, wives, and children of the potential subversives.
Instilling a sense of fear
Caravan of Death
From the moment Pinochet assumed power, he wanted to instill a sense of fear in the Chilean population. These fears manifested with his authorization of the "Caravan of Death". Following the coup on September 11, Pinochet ordered this Chilean Army death squad to target the leaders of the PU by any means necessary. The Caravan of Death, under the leadership of Sergio Arellano Stark, killed 68 people within three days, by stabbing, beating, and shooting them. The establishment of the Caravan of Death served three main purposes: 1) silence dissent through murder, 2) weed out military officials who were not aligned with Pinochet's regime and 3) establish fear within leadership ranks. The Caravan of Death resulted in the institutionalization of a state-sponsored system of terror.[27]
DINA
On June 14, 1974, Junta Decree 521 mandated the creation of the National Intelligence Directorate (DINA). There were thousands of people working in this agency. DINA was instituted to "produce the intelligence necessary to formulate policies and planning, and to adopt measures to procure the safeguarding of National Security and development of the country."[28] DINA established interrogation and detention camps, in which former members of Allende's Marxist government and the Leftist movements like the Movimiento de Izquierda Revolucionaria were incarcerated and brutally tortured.[27] Pinochet's goal was to annihilate all forms of opposition. He therefore greatly supported Military Decree 1697, which outlawed the formation of any political party. A large proportion of the Chilean population was vulnerable to surveillance. Chile's churches, universities, businesses, and neighborhoods were all under intense scrutiny.[29]
Joint Command
The Joint Command operated as a
State-sponsored torture and repression
From 1974 to 1977, DINA (National Intelligence Directorate) and other agencies such as the Joint Command were the main institutions responsible for committing most acts of repression. It was during this period when most of the forced disappearances took place. While these agencies committed barbaric acts of physical and sexual torture, they also caused an immense amount of psychological pain and suffering.

Detentions and torture centers
Intelligence agencies under Pinochet's regime instituted secret detention and torture sites to conduct political repression. In total, Chile had 17 torture centers.[31][failed verification – see discussion] On occasion, prisoners were released after being confined and tortured. However, many detainees were also killed and "disappeared."
Cuatro Álamos
Cuatro Álamos was a detention center to which no one outside the DINA had access, except personnel from other intelligence agencies. It was established in 1973, during the earliest phase of the regime. Life in Cuatro Álamos was relatively easier than in other detention sites. It consisted of twelve small cells, one large cell, and staff offices. There were very few instances of torture within the walls of the prison.[30]
Londres 38
Londres 38 was a secret detention center located in downtown Santiago, where DINA members operated from 1973 until the end of 1974. This was one of the many sites previously owned by leftist organizations. Prisoners at Londres No. 38 endured lengthy interrogation periods and continual humiliating treatment. Captors preferred to torture detainees by electrocuting them. Not only were the suspects incarcerated, but their relatives were also arrested. Family members underwent sexual abuse in the presence of their loved ones. However, during the initial period, prisoners were still permitted to interact with each other and share information.[30]
Villa Grimaldi

Villa Grimaldi, located in Santiago, was DINA's most important torture center, which began operating in 1974. Prisoners endured long periods of interrogation. As more people were incarcerated on a massive scale, new places were reconditioned to hold them. The "tower" was designated as a holding center for political prisoners. On the top floor of the building, there was a water tank that included ten tight spaces where prisoners were held. These spaces were so small that victims had to enter them by crawling on their knees. The tower also housed a torture chamber, where prisoners were kept in isolation. Many of them were never seen again. Food was scarce, and the conditions were extremely unsanitary.[30]
Physical torture
One commonly used torture method was the "grill" or "
The Valech Report includes the testimony of a Chilean man who was interrogated by prison captors. They removed his clothes and attached electrodes to his chest and testicles. They also placed something in his mouth to prevent him from biting his tongue while they administered shocks.[32] In another variation of this method, one wire would be attached to the prisoner, typically to the victim's genitalia, while another wire could be applied to different parts of the body. This created an electric current passing through the victim's body, with the strength inversely proportional to the distance between the two electrodes. A smaller distance between the electrodes resulted in a stronger current and therefore more intense pain for the prisoner.
A particularly brutal version of the "grill" involved the use of a metal bunk bed; the victim would be placed on the bottom bunk while a relative or friend was simultaneously tortured on the top bunk. Most prisoners endured severe beatings, and some had their limbs broken or amputated.
At Villa Grimaldi, DINA forced non-compliant prisoners to lie down on the ground. The captors would then run over their legs with a large vehicle, crushing the prisoners' bones.[33] The assailants also beat prisoners in the ears until they became deaf and unconscious; this torture method was known as the "telephone."[34] Most of these acts of punishment were intended to humiliate the prisoners severely.
At the Pisagua Concentration Camp, captors intimidated prisoners by forcing them to crawl on the ground and lick the dirt off the floors. If prisoners complained or even collapsed from exhaustion, they were promptly executed.[35] Prisoners were also immersed in vats of excrement and occasionally forced to ingest it.[36][37]
Sexual abuse
Pinochet's regime perpetrated numerous gruesome and horrific acts of sexual abuse against its victims. Several detention sites were established solely for the purpose of sexually tormenting and humiliating the prisoners. One such facility was the Discothèque (or Venda Sexy), which served as one of DINA's primary secret detention centers. Many of those who "disappeared" were initially held in this prison, where prison guards frequently subjected both men and women to sexual assault. This prison also served as the central hub for internal repression operations.[38]
Women were the primary targets of these gruesome acts of sexual abuse. According to the Valech Commission, almost every single female prisoner fell victim to repeated rape. Military personnel not only raped women but also employed foreign objects and even animals to inflict additional pain and suffering. Women, and occasionally men, reported incidents where spiders and live rats were implanted on their genitals. One woman testified that she had been "raped and sexually assaulted with trained dogs and live rats" and was forced to engage in sexual acts with her father and brother, who were also detained.[39]
In the words of Alejandra Matus, detained women endured a double punishment: first for being labeled as "leftists" and second for not conforming to the military's ideal of women, often being derogatorily referred to as perra ("bitch").[40]
Psychological repression
The military junta often framed leftist individuals and groups in order to justify its agenda to target and torture political dissidents. The junta fostered fear of leftists by staging arsenal captures and portraying leftist extremists in an extremely negative light. The regime falsely accused leftists of stealing dangerous weapons from weapons stores to justify the illegal capture of dissidents. Such fake portrayals of "the revolutionary threat" resulted in the legitimization of the Pinochet regime. The junta commissioned the Chilean public to report the actions of any suspected leftists and proceeded to turn them in. Pinochet also authorized DINA to stage the bombing of a Chilean safe house, placing the blame on leftist extremists to demonstrate the danger they posed to society. Essentially, the military junta made use of brainwashing propaganda to portray the leftists as the enemies.[41]
Psychological torture was used to destroy a prisoner's will, dignity, moral and physical resolve in order to extract pertinent information from the victim. Members of intelligence agencies like DINA and the Joint Command attempted to extract information from victims by threatening their children and loved ones. Many mothers who were incarcerated in illegal detention centers had to choose between saving themselves or their children's lives. On August 21, 1989, military personnel seized Jessica Antonia Liberona Niñoles and detained her in a dark, solitary room. She was stripped naked, forced to lie down on an uncomfortable prison cot, and was not permitted to sleep for five days during the interrogation period. The captors constantly threatened to kidnap her nine-year-old daughter from school if she failed to cooperate.[42]
According to the Valech Commission, waterboarding was one of the torture methods most commonly recorded by victims of imprisonment and torture. The captors poured water over a cloth that covered the victims' faces and breathing passages, causing individuals to experience a drowning sensation and a near-death experience. Waterboarding caused detainees to asphyxiate, while their heads were submerged into the water several times in a row. Often, prisoners were hung upside-down with ropes, and they were dropped into a tank of water, headfirst. The water was contaminated and filled with debris. Waterboarding was employed to cause both physical and psychological pain; however, victims found that the mental suffering they endured was far worse than the physical pain. They attested that even thirty years after being "waterboarded," they still suffered from the devastating effects of psychological torture. Many victims reported suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, humiliation, worthlessness, shame, anxiety, and hopelessness.[43] The Valech Commission Report describes the testimony of a man who experienced waterboarding in September 1973:
They put cotton on both eyes, then taped them and tightened a hood around my neck. They tied my hands and legs, submerged me in a 250-liter tank that had ammonia, urine, excrement, and seawater. They submerged me until I could not breathe anymore. They repeated it over and over, while beating me and asking me questions. That is what they called the submarine.[43]
Disappearances



While "disappearing subversives" was the central instrument of state terror administered by the Argentine military regime from the 1960s to the 1980s, it was also extremely widespread and prevalent in Chile. According to the Rettig Report, 1,248 people were "disappeared" by the Pinochet Regime. However, this number still remains a source of contention, as hundreds of bodies have yet to be discovered. Several different approximations have been made for the number of people who were "disappeared" by the military regime. Many of those who "disappeared" were not given the chance to escape or seek asylum elsewhere.[44] Their bodies were deliberately hidden in undisclosed locations.
Only seven days after Pinochet seized power, he ordered the military to round up approximately 10,000 students, workers, and political activists and jammed them into Santiago's National Stadium on September 18, 1973. This stadium, which symbolized Chile's greatest pastime, turned into a concentration camp within a few days. Many were tortured and gunned down, and several hundred bodies were shuttled into secret mass graves. These were victims of a well-organized program of official, yet clandestine, torture and murder.[45]
Many people were last seen in the detention and torture centers established by the intelligence agencies of the military regime. Following Pinochet's arrest in 1998, Chile made a renewed effort to uncover the atrocities of the past. For the first time in several decades, human rights lawyers and members of the armed forces wanted to investigate where the bodies of the "disappeared" were buried. On January 7, 2000, President Ricardo Lagos made a 15-minute nationwide address, revealing that the armed forces had uncovered information about the fate of approximately 180 people who had disappeared. According to Lagos, the bodies of at least 150 of these people were thrown into lakes, rivers, and the Pacific Ocean. The whereabouts of hundreds more bodies remain unknown.[46]
Institutionalized terrorism
The dictatorship under Pinochet erected a complex web of legal instruments that it used to repress anyone deemed "subversive." Pinochet was extremely tactical in his attempts to camouflage the human rights violations committed by the state. He called for a National Plebiscite in 1980 to approve the 1980 Political Constitution of the Republic of Chile—a seemingly democratic motive.[47] Pinochet promised to cut back inflation, which was around 30-35% in 1978; he was intent on restructuring both the economic and political institutions of the region. These agendas were part of a broader scheme to garner approval from the state, making it more feasible to prosecute, imprison, and execute civilians suspected of subversion.[48] The military and armed personnel, under Pinochet, were able to operate offensively without restrictions, as the Chilean Government had been restructured to Pinochet's liking. Even the Constitution was drafted to give Pinochet impunity. The military dictatorship utilized its own justice system to adjudicate the regime's enemies.[49]
Additionally, the Amnesty Law decreed in 1978 by Pinochet guaranteed impunity to those responsible for the "systematic and widespread human rights violations and was a major obstacle to bringing Pinochet to justice in Chile.[50] Even today, "the Amnesty Law is still in force. It was recently applied by the Chilean Supreme Court in December 2007." While Pinochet was detained under house arrest on October 30, 2006, over "charges including murder, torture, and kidnapping in the years following his 1973 coup, he was never formally convicted. He died before the investigation process reached a conclusion.[51] Pinochet's Amnesty Law effectively insulated the military regime from retribution for even the most brutal and horrific human rights violations.
Repressive agencies
The National Intelligence Directorate (DINA), was the Chilean secret police during the government of Pinochet. DINA was established in November 1973 as a Chilean Army intelligence unit, with General Manuel Contreras as its head and Raúl Iturriaga as its vice-director, who fled from justice in 2007. It became an independent administrative unit in June 1974 under the auspices of decree #521.
DINA continued to exist until 1977 when it was renamed the National Information Center (CNI).
Main violators of human rights
Since human rights violations during the military regime corresponded to state policy, the number of people involved in these acts as authors, accomplices, or accessories is high. While it is difficult to determine their exact number, it is estimated to exceed several hundred. Approximately sixty individuals have been convicted by Chilean courts.[52]
- Sergio Arellano Stark[53]
- Víctor Barría[54]
- Patricio Carranza Saavedra[55]
- Manuel Contreras
- Álvaro Corbalán Castilla[56]
- Patricio Díaz Araneda[57]
- Pedro Espinoza Bravo[58]
- Armando Fernández Larios[59]
- Humberto Gordon[60]
- Carlos Herrera Jiménez[61]
- Raúl Iturriaga Neumann
- Mario Jahn Barrera[62]
- Miguel Krassnoff Martchenko[63]
- Roberto Lawrence Mires[64]
- Gustavo Leigh
- José Toribio Merino
- Marcelo Moren Brito[65]
- Augusto Pinochet
- Alfonso Podlech[66]
- Osvaldo Romo
- Arturo Ureta Sire[67]
- Nelson Valdés Cornejo[52]
- Raúl Quintana Salazar[52]
- David Miranda Monardes[52]
- Klaudio Kosiel Honing[52]
- Vittorio Orvietto Tiplitzky[52]
- Ingrid Olderock
See also
References
- ^ "Thomas Skidmore, Modern Latin America, Oxford University Press., 2004, p. 134
- ^ "Report of the Chilean National Commission on Truth and Reconciliation" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on July 15, 2009. Retrieved 2020-10-21.
- ^ Pinochet Is History: But how will it remember him? National Review Symposium, December 11, 2006
- ISBN 978-0-19-158524-1– via Google Books.
- )
- ^ "Finding Chile's disappeared". January 10, 2001 – via news.bbc.co.uk.
- ^ Thinking About Terrorism: The Threat to Civil Liberties in a Time of National Emergency, Michael E. Tigar, pp. 37-38, American Bar Association, 2007
- ^ Chile: an Amnesty International report, p. 16, Amnesty International Publications, 1974.
- ^ "El campo de concentración de Pinochet cumple 70 años". Archived from the original on 2012-07-29. Retrieved 2021-12-17.
- ^ "Foreign Relations of the United States, 1969–1976, Volume E–11, Part 2, Documents on South America, 1973–1976 - Office of the Historian". history.state.gov. Retrieved 2023-11-01.
- ^ "New Information on the Murders of U.S. Citizens Charles Horman and Frank Teruggi by the Chilean Military". nsarchive2.gwu.edu.
- ^ "Caravan of Death". January 26, 2001 – via news.bbc.co.uk.
- ^ Valech Report
- ^ Augusto Pinochet's Chile, Diana Childress, p.92, Twenty First century Books, 2009
- ^ a b Chile en el umbral de los noventa: quince años que condicionan el futuro, Jaime Gazmuri & Felipe Agüero, p. 121, Planeta, 1988
- ^ "One Carrot, Many Sticks - TIME". December 22, 2008. Archived from the original on 2008-12-22.
- ^ LIFTING OF PINOCHET'S IMMUNITY RENEWS FOCUS ON OPERATION CONDOR
- ^ Chile since the coup: ten years of repression, Cynthia G. Brown, pp.88-89, Americas Watch, 1983.
- ^ Decades after coup, 24 sentenced for rights violations in Chile. CNN. 2008-03-20. Retrieved 2013-07-12.
- JSTOR 2503143
- ^ Luis Roniger and Mario Sznajder, The Legacy of Human Rights Violations in the Southern Cone: Argentina, Chile and Uruguay, 1999, p.10
- ^ "Profile: Salvador Allende". 2003-09-08. Retrieved 2020-10-21.
- ^ Roger Burbach, "The Pinochet Affair. State Terrorism and Global Justice," Nueva Epoca 5:17 (2005), 290-292.
- ^ Rex A. Hudson, ed. "Chile: A Country Study". GPO for the Library of Congress, 1995.
- ^ "Christian Correa, "Waterboarding Prisoners and Justifying Torture:Lessons for the U.S. from the Chilean Experience,"Human Rights Brief 14, no. 2 (2007): p. 21" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on July 20, 2012.
- ^ Thomas Skidmore, p. 134
- ^ a b "Chile-90 Report" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on July 15, 2009. Retrieved 2021-03-07.
- ^ Pamela Constable and Arturo Valenzuela, A Nation of Enemies: Chile Under Pinochet, New York: W.W Norton & Company, 1993., p. 91
- ^ Pamela Constable and Arturo Valenzuela, p.91
- ^ a b c d "Report of the Chilean National Commission on Truth and Reconciliation". Archived from the original on May 9, 2009.
- ^ John Charles Chasteen, Born in Blood and Fire: A Concise History of Latin America, W.W Norton and Company, 2001, 301.
- ^ Peter Kornbluh, The Pinochet File: a Declassified Dossier on Atrocity and Accountability: New York Press, 2003, p. 181
- ^ Temma Kaplan, Taking Back the Streets: Women, Youth, and Direct Democracy. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2004
- ^ Peter Kornbluh, p. 171
- ^ Pamela Constable and Aruto Valenzuela, p.22
- ISBN 1595589120 p. 171.
- ISBN 0739126563
- ^ Peter Kornbluh, The Pinochet File: A Declassified Dossier on Atrocity and Accountability, 169-170
- ^ "Informe de la Comisión Nacional sobre Prisión Política y Tortura," National Commission Report on Political Prisoners and Torture," 2005, 249-250
- ^ Cultura Verdadera Programa Completo del Lunes 14 de Diciembre de 2015 Archived 2017-02-02 at the Wayback Machine, minute 3:20.
- ^ Peter Kornbluh, The Pinochet File: A Declassified Dossier on Atrocity and Accountability, p. 181
- ^ "Pinochet: the case against". The Guardian. 1999-09-28. Retrieved 2021-03-07.
- ^ a b Christian Correa, "Waterboarding Prisoners and Justifying Torture:Lessons for the U.S. from the Chilean Experience,"p.22-23
- ^ Informe de la Comisión Nacional sobre Prisión Política y Tortura," National Commission Report on Political Prisoners and Torture," 2005.
- ^ John Charles Chasteen, 304
- ^ James Reynolds, "Finding Chile's Disappeared," BBC News, January 10, 2001. Accessed April 25, 2013.
- ^ Christian Correa, "Waterboarding Prisoners and Justifying Torture:Lessons for the U.S. from the Chilean Experience,"p.22
- ^ John Charles Chasteen, 301
- ^ Thomas O'Keefe, "The Use of the Military Justice System to Try Civilians in Chile", 61 N.Y. St. Bar J. 46 (1989)
- ^ "Document". www.amnesty.org. Retrieved 2021-03-07.
- ^ agencies, Staff and (2006-10-30). "Pinochet held on murder and torture charges". The Guardian. Retrieved 2021-03-07.
- ^ a b c d e f Condenan a seis miembros de la DINA por cinco crímenes en Tejas Verdes, retrieved on 31 January 2013. The 6th is Manuel Contreras
- ^ "Corte Suprema confirmó seis años de presidio para Sergio Arellano Stark". Cooperativa.cl. Retrieved 2014-08-18.
- ISBN 9789562603225. Retrieved 2014-08-18.
- ^ "La Nación - Los sabuesos de los derechos humanos. Brigada de Asuntos Especiales de investigaciones". Archived from the original on 2014-08-27. Retrieved 2014-08-26.
- ^ S.A.P, El Mercurio (December 28, 2007). "Condenan a 14 ex agentes de la CNI por crimen de José Carrasco Tapia | Emol.com". Emol.
- ^ El Mercurio - Texto completo del fallo de desafuero de Pinochet (I parte)
- ^ "Portal de Registro y Autentificación El Mercurio". Diario.elmercurio.cl. Retrieved 2014-08-18.
- ^ "Fernández Larios acusado en Miami por "caravana de la muerte"".
- ^ "Memoria Viva - Humberto Gordon". Archived from the original on 2010-10-30. Retrieved 2014-08-26.
- ^ "La Nación - Carlos Herrera Jiménez insiste en culpar a ex edecán Krauss de crímenes de Pisagua". Archived from the original on 2014-08-27. Retrieved 2014-08-26.
- ^ "La Nación - Procesan a ex agentes por crimen de primo de Martínez Busch". Archived from the original on 2014-08-27. Retrieved 2014-08-26.
- ^ [1] Archived 2013-06-14 at the Wayback Machine Memoria Viva - Miguel Krassnoff
- ^ "Punto Final - Torturador al descubierto". Archived from the original on 2011-09-28. Retrieved 2014-08-26.
- ^ "Marcelo Luis Manuel Morén Brito | Jefe de la Brigada Caupolicán de la DINA". Archived from the original on May 14, 2011. Retrieved August 26, 2014.
- ^ El Austral - Alta tensión en juicio contra Alfonso Podlech
- ^ "Arturo Ramón Ureta Sire (DINA)". Archived from the original on October 4, 2009. Retrieved August 26, 2014.
External links
- Gorodischer, Jonathan; Maltz, Judy (13 June 2022). "Under Pinochet's Nose: The Israeli Diplomats Who Rescued Hundreds of Leftist Dissidents From Chile". Haaretz. Retrieved 13 June 2022.
- Hiner, Hillary; Garrido, Juan Carlos; Walters, Brigette (2019). "Antitrans State Terrorism: Trans and Travesti Women, Human Rights, and Recent History in Chile". TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly. 6 (2): 194–209. .