Situated approach (artificial intelligence)

This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (October 2012) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)

Part of a series on
Artificial intelligence
Major goals Artificial general intelligence Recursive self-improvement Planning Computer vision General game playing Knowledge reasoning Machine learning Natural language processing Robotics AI safety
Approaches Symbolic Deep learning Bayesian networks Evolutionary algorithms Situated approach Hybrid intelligent systems Systems integration
Applications Projects Deepfake Machine translation Generative AI Art Audio Music Healthcare Mental health Government Industry Earth sciences Bioinformatics Physics
Philosophy Chinese room Friendly AI Control problem/Takeover Ethics Existential risk Turing test Regulation
History Timeline Progress AI winter AI boom AI era
Glossary Glossary
v t e

In artificial intelligence research, the situated approach builds agents that are designed to behave effectively successfully in their environment. This requires designing AI "from the bottom-up" by focussing on the basic perceptual and motor skills required to survive. The situated approach gives a much lower priority to abstract reasoning or problem-solving skills.

The approach was originally proposed as an alternative to traditional approaches (that is, approaches popular before 1985 or so). After several decades, classical

Realizing that in fact all these approaches were aiming at building not an abstract intelligence, but rather an intelligence situated in a given environment, they have come to be known as the situated approach. In fact, this approach stems out from early insights of Alan Turing, describing the need to build machines equipped with sense organs to learn directly from the real-world instead of focusing on abstract activities, such as playing chess.^[relevant?]

Definitions

Classically, a software entity is defined as a simulated element, able to act on itself and on its environment, and which has an internal representation of itself and of the outside world. An entity can communicate with other entities, and its behavior is the consequence of its perceptions, its representations, and its interactions with the other entities.

AI loop

Simulating entities in a virtual environment requires simulating the entire process that goes from a perception of the environment, or more generally from a stimulus, to an action on the environment. This process is called the AI loop and technology used to simulate it can be subdivided in two categories. Sensorimotor or low-level AI deals with either the perception problem (what is perceived?) or the animation problem (how are actions executed?). Decisional or high-level AI deals with the action selection problem (what is the most appropriate action in response to a given perception, i.e. what is the most appropriate behavior?).

Traditional or symbolic AI

There are two main approaches in decisional AI. The vast majority of the technologies available on the market, such as

However, the limits of traditional AI, which goal is to build systems that mimic human intelligence, are well-known: inevitably, a combinatorial explosion of the number of rules occurs due to the complexity of the environment. In fact, it is impossible to predict all the situations that will be encountered by an autonomous entity.

Situated or behavioral AI

In order to address these issues, another approach to decisional AI, also known as situated or behavioral AI, has been proposed. It does not attempt to model systems that produce deductive reasoning processes, but rather systems that behave realistically in their environment. The main characteristics of this approach are the following:

• It is bottom-up: it relies on elementary behaviors, which can be combined to implement more complex behaviors.
• It is behavior-based: it does not rely on a symbolic description of the environment, but rather on a model of the interactions of the entities with their environment.

The goal of situated AI is to model entities that are autonomous in their environment. This is achieved thanks to both the intrinsic robustness of the control architecture, and its adaptation capabilities to unforeseen situations.

Situated agents

In

• they exist in a dynamic (rapidly changing) environment, which
• they can manipulate or change through their actions, and which
• they can sense or perceive.

Examples might include web-based agents, which can alter data or trigger processes (such as purchases) over the Internet, or virtual-reality bots which inhabit and change virtual worlds, such as Second Life.

Being situated is generally considered to be part of being embodied, but it is useful to consider each perspective individually. The situated perspective emphasizes that intelligent behavior derives from the environment and the agent's interactions with it. The nature of these interactions are defined by an agent's embodiment.

Implementation principles

Modular decomposition

The most important attribute of a system driven by situated AI is that the intelligence is controlled by a set of independent semi-

The situated AI community has presented several solutions to modeling decision-making processes, also known as action selection mechanisms. The first attempt to solve this problem goes back to subsumption architectures,[1] which were in fact more an implementation technique than an algorithm. However, this attempt paved the way to several others, in particular the free-flow hierarchies^[2] and activation networks.^[3] A comparison of the structure and performances of these two mechanisms demonstrated the advantage of using free-flow hierarchies in solving the action selection problem.^[4][5] However, motor schemas^[6] and process description languages^[7] are two other approaches that have been used with success for autonomous robots.

Notes and references

• Arsenio, Artur M. (2004) Towards an embodied and situated AI, In: Proceedings of the International FLAIRS conference, 2004. (online)
• The Artificial Life Route To Artificial Intelligence: Building Embodied, Situated Agents, Luc Steels and Rodney Brooks Eds., Lawrence Erlbaum Publishing, 1995. (
  ISBN 978-0805815184
  )
• Rodney A. Brooks Cambrian Intelligence (MIT Press, 1999)
  ISBN 0-262-52263-2
  ; collection of early papers including "Intelligence without representation" and "Intelligence without reason", from 1986 & 1991 respectively.
• Ronald C. Arkin Behavior-Based Robotics (MIT Press, 1998)
  ISBN 0-262-01165-4
• Hendriks-Jansen, Horst (1996) Catching Ourselves in the Act: Situated Activity, Interactive Emergence, Evolution, and Human Thought. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.

• Artificial Intelligence
• Cognitive science

Traditional AI

• Decision Tree
• Finite State Machine
• Expert System
• Automated Planning and Scheduling

Situated AI

• Scruffy AI
• Reactive planning

Robotics

• Behavior-based robotics
• Situated robotics

External links

• Article Artificial Intelligence: The situated approach from the Encyclopædia Britannica
• Nouvelle AI - Definition
• Reactive planning and nouvelle AI