The Brute Man
The Brute Man | |
---|---|
Directed by | Jean Yarbrough |
Screenplay by |
|
Story by | Dwight V. Babcock |
Produced by | Ben Pivar |
Starring |
|
Cinematography | Maury Gertsman |
Edited by | Philip Cahn |
Music by | Hans J. Salter |
Production company | |
Distributed by | Producers Releasing Corporation |
Release date |
|
Running time | 58 minutes |
Country | United States |
Language | English |
Budget | $125,000[1] |
The Brute Man is a 1946 American
The film was released to home video in 1982. The Brute Man received generally negative reviews, drawing particular criticism for Hatton's poor performance. The film was featured in a 1996 episode of the movie-mocking comedy television series Mystery Science Theater 3000. Members of Mystery Science Theater later expressed discomfort in making fun of the film due to Hatton's illness.
Plot
The police investigate a string of murders committed by the Creeper (
The next day, a general store delivery boy named Jimmy (Jack Parker) listens to a radio report about the Creeper's murders. The cantankerous store owner Mr. Haskins (Oscar O'Shea) arrives with a handwritten letter slipped under the door, requesting groceries be delivered to a nearby dock. Jimmy brings the groceries to the dock and leaves them at a door, where the Creeper takes them into his hideout. But, when Jimmy tries to spy on him through a window, the Creeper sneaks up on Jimmy and kills him. Meanwhile, at the police station, Captain M.J. Donelly (Donald MacBride) and Lieutenant Gates (Peter Whitney) receive complaints from the mayor's office about their failure to arrest the Creeper, but they deflect the blame. The two officers then get a call about the missing delivery boy and head to the dock to investigate.
The Creeper sneaks out and escapes while Donelly and Gates infiltrate his hideout and discover Jimmy's corpse. Donnelly also finds a newspaper clipping with a man named Hal Moffet and two of his friends, Clifford Scott (Tom Neal) and Virginia Rogers (Jan Wiley), during their college days. The police visit Clifford and Virginia, who are now married and wealthy. Clifford tells the officers during college, Hal was a handsome college football star who competed with Clifford for Virginia's affections. One day, while helping Hal prepare for a chemistry exam, a jealous Clifford deliberately gave him the wrong answers, resulting in Hal being asked by Professor Cushman to remain after class for extra work. While working on a chemistry experiment, Clifford walks by the window with Virginia to boast. Furious, Hal hurls a beaker to the ground, accidentally causing an explosion that disfigures his face. Donnelly speculates that Hal is the Creeper, and that he killed Professor Cushman and Joan because he holds them partially responsible for his accident.
Meanwhile, the Creeper goes to a pawn store to buy a brooch for Helen, and kills the pawnbroker (Charles Wagenheim) following a fight. He later brings the brooch to Helen, who he realizes for the first time is blind. Hal learns she needs $3,000 for surgery that would restore her eyesight. When Helen tries to touch his face, Hal angrily storms out. He then goes to the Scott residence and demands money from Clifford and Virginia, whom he blames for his disfigurement. Clifford draws a gun and shoots Hal twice in the stomach, but the weakened Hal manages to strangle Clifford to death before escaping with Virginia's jewels. He brings them to Helen, who is concerned about Hal's injuries, but he flees before she can learn he is shot.
Helen brings the jewels to an appraiser, who recognizes them as having recently been reported stolen. Donelly and Gates bring Helen into the station, where they inform her Hal is the Creeper and accuse her of harboring a murderer. Reluctantly, she agrees to help them capture him. The next day, the newspapers run stories about Helen cooperating with police, which infuriates Hal. Feeling betrayed, he sneaks back into her apartment and finds her playing the piano. Sneaking up from behind, Hal is about to strangle her when the police seize and arrest him. The film ends with Donelly and Gates assuring Helen she will get the operation she needs.
Cast
- Rondo Hatton as Hal Moffat / The Creeper
- Tom Neal as Clifford Scott
- Jan Wiley as Virginia Rogers Scott
- Jane Adamsas Helen Paige
- Donald MacBride as Police Captain M. J. Donelly
- Peter Whitney as Police Lieutenant Gates
- Fred Coby as Young Hal Moffat
- Janelle Johnson Dolenzas Joan Bemis
- Jack Parker as Jimmy
- Oscar O'Shea as Mr. Haskins
- Joseph Crehan as Police Commissioner Salisbury (uncredited)
- John Hamilton as Professor Cushman (uncredited)
Production
Writing
The screenplay for The Brute Man was written by
The Brute Man is a quasi-
The film's setting, which appears to be a major city, is never identified in The Brute Man, but it has been suggested to be Manhattan, since that is where House of Horrors took place.[17] Commentators have noted similarities between The Brute Man and other films, including the Charlie Chaplin silent comedy City Lights (1931),[3][18] and the Universal horror film Bride of Frankenstein (1935).[3][13] City Lights, like The Brute Man, included a protagonist (Chaplin's Tramp character) who falls in love with a blind girl and seeks money for an operation to restore her eyesight.[3] Likewise, the scenes between the Creeper and Helen Paige share a similar premise and dialogue as the scenes between Frankenstein's monster and the blind hermit in Bride of Frankenstein. In both films, the protagonists are shunned by society based on their physical appearance, but find companionship in a blind loner who knows nothing about their deformities. In both instances, the protagonist is first drawn to their blind companions by music. The Creeper heard Helen playing the piano, while Frankenstein's monster heard the hermit playing the violin. Commentators have noted other similarities between the two films. For example, the Creeper smashes a mirror after looking at his misshapen face, much like the Monster lashes out at his reflection in a waterfall pool.[13]
Casting
The Brute Man marked one of several films in which Universal cast Hatton as a murderer, taking advantage of his natural deformities for shock value. As a result of his acromegaly, Hatton had abnormally enlarged and shaped bones on his head and hands, and the Universal publicity department often promoted the fact that Hatton did not need make-up for his roles.[7][19][20] Tom Neal, who had recently appeared in the cult classic noir film Detour (1945),[21] was cast as Clifford Scott. Having appeared in dozens of low-budget films throughout the early-1940s, Neal began to become known as the "King of the B Pictures".[22] In The Brute Man, Neal portrayed Scott both in his older years and in the flashback scenes, where the character appears as a college student. To differentiate between the two, Neal was fitted with make-up and costumes to make him better resemble a middle-aged man during his non-flashback scenes.[13] Jane Adams was cast as the blind pianist Helen Paige. Adams had appeared in several Universal films before, including the Lon Chaney Jr. film House of Dracula (1945).[3]
Jan Wiley was cast as Scott's wife, Virginia. Although Wiley had appeared in several movies throughout the 1930s and 1940s, The Brute Man marked one of her final film performances before retiring from the film industry in 1947.[13][23][24] It was also recalled as one of her most memorable film appearances along with another Universal B horror film, She-Wolf of London.[23] However, her performance in The Brute Man proved to be a less than memorable one for her, so much so that in an interview shortly before Wiley's death in 1993, she could barely remember even having appeared in the film.[13] Donald MacBride and Peter Whitney portray the police officers Captain M.J. Donelly and Lieutenant Gates, respectively. Their roles serve as comic relief for the film. Their characters portray the incompetence of the police force in their inability to find and arrest the Creeper and their focus on passing blame for their failures rather than diverting resources toward his arrest.[17]
Filming
The Brute Man was developed by
Release
Distribution
Although produced by Universal Pictures, The Brute Man was distributed by Producers Releasing Corporation (PRC), one of the smaller film studios from Hollywood's Poverty Row. In 1945, Universal merged with the company International Pictures, and the new organization adopted a policy against developing any more B movies, including Westerns, horror films, serials and movies running 70 minutes or less. This resulted in the firing of numerous production personnel members and the sale of several already-developed films, including The Brute Man.[3][8][17] The sale was also perpetuated in part by the death of star Rondo Hatton.[31] He died as a result of his acromegaly on February 2, 1946, about eight months before The Brute Man was first screened, making it his final film.[19][32] Universal feared releasing the film so soon after his death would lead to accusations that the studio was exploiting the illness that ultimately killed Hatton.[7][31] Now embarrassed by the film, the studio was anxious to sell it.[7][29]
Universal sold the film to PRC for $125,000, which represented the negative cost plus interest.[3][17] The transaction occurred around August 1946, but was not made public until it was screened for the trade press on October 1, marking its official release date. The sale occurred so quickly and hastily on the copyright files stores at the Library of Congress, the name Universal Pictures was crossed out and Pathe Industries, PRC's corporate body, was written in its place in pencil. Some pressbook advertisements circulated for the film still included the Universal logo.[3][33] PRC had previously produced a horror film about acromegaly called The Monster Maker (1944), in which a mad scientist injects human subjects with the disease as part of his experiments.[14]
Reception
Dark and morbid, The Brute Man stands out like a bad mark even on a list of Universal's bad films because it weaves into its seamy story autobiographic details of Hatton's actual life. ... The fact that The Brute Man was a "re-imagining" of Hatton's private life, one not overburdened with good taste, could not have been missed by the unfortunate actor.
Universal Horrors: The Studio's
Classic Films, 1931-1946[13]
The Brute Man received generally negative critical reviews following its release on October 1, 1946.
Decades after the film's release, retrospective reviews of The Brute Man were similarly negative, with many commentators criticizing the exploitation of Hatton's real-life acromegaly.[7][13][31] John Stanley, host of the KTVU television show Creature Features, described it as a dull and "shoddy thriller", criticizing both the performances and the mood from the direction and photography.[36] The authors of Universal Horrors: The Studio's Classic Films, 1931-1946 were highly critical of the film's dialogue, and claimed much of the script seemed to be "time-killing stuff" to pad the film's already-short running time. They wrote that Hatton's acting was so bad, it "wouldn't be acceptable even at a pre-production cast get-together and table reading, much less in the movie itself".[13] Donald C. Willis, a writer who wrote about horror and science fiction films, described the horror scenes as completely lacking suspense, and said the film was "so flimsy that its three co-plots seem to be operating independently of one another".[37]
Analysis
The film critic and scholar Keith Brown argued that The Brute Man is an example of what he calls the "terror film", a genre distinguishable from the horror film due to its emphasis on naturally occurring sources of fear, rather than fantastical or otherworldly horror elements. Brown wrote that the Creeper character "blurs the boundary between human and animal on account of his grotesque, deformed features, but is natural and thus a figure of terror".[38] Cory Legassic, in a chapter dedicated to Rondo Hatton in Recovering 1940s Horror Cinema: Traces of a Lost Decade, wrote that The Brute Man's narrative was modeled after Hatton's life. Legassic noted similarities between Hatton and his character Hal Moffet both being handsome sports stars who end up disfigured.[39]
Home media
For decades after the film's theatrical release, copies of The Brute Man were unavailable, and it became regarded as a
Legacy
Rondo Hatton's likeness from The Brute Man inspired the appearance of one of the villain characters in
In 2002, the founders of the website The Classic Horror Film Board created the Rondo Hatton Classic Horror Awards to honor horror works in film, television and publishing. The awards were named after the actor, and award recipients received statuettes with miniature busts of Hatton as he appeared portraying the Creeper in House of Horrors and The Brute Man. The statuettes were sculpted by illustrator Kerry Gammill and cast by modeler Timothy M. Lindsey.[34]
Mystery Science Theater 3000
The Brute Man was featured in a
In 1995,
References
Notes
- ^ "U's 'Brute Man' to PRC but Hangs on to Two Others". 23 October 1946. p. 7.
{{cite magazine}}
: Cite magazine requires|magazine=
(help) - ^ a b Wilt 1991, p. 147
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Wilt 1991, pp. 136–138
- ^ Server 2002, p. 22
- ^ Soister 2004, p. 213
- ^ Jaworzyn 1994, pp. 44
- ^ a b c d e Miller 2004, p. 22
- ^ a b c d e American Film Institute 1999, p. 326
- ^ a b Backer 2004, p. 74
- ^ a b Maltin 2003, p. 189
- ^ Katz 1988, p. 603
- ^ "Rondo Hatton in Jungle Captive". The Irish Times. April 7, 2001.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Weaver, Brunas & Brunas 2007, p. 555
- ^ a b c d Rigby 2007, p. 289
- ^ Fritz, Christopher (August 1, 2003). "Around Philadelphia". The News Journal. p. 1011Z.
- ^ Lovell, Glenn (November 11, 2005). "Films are far from facts". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. p. T28.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Weaver, Brunas & Brunas 2007, p. 556
- ^ a b Pratt 2004, pp. 202–203
- ^ a b Clark 2004, p. 130
- ^ Gifford 1969, p. 129
- ^ Mérigeau & Bourgoin 1983, p. 33
- ^ Nash 2004, p. 887
- ^ a b "Jan Wiley; Former Actress, Model". Los Angeles Times. June 4, 1993. p. A22.
- ^ Wilson 2016, p. 289
- ^ a b c d Hantke 2009, p. 206
- ^ Friedmann 2009, p. 2
- ^ Weaver, Brunas & Brunas 2007, p. 543
- ^ Pitts 2010, p. 150
- ^ Allmovie. Retrieved October 11, 2010.
- ^ Feramisco 2007, p. 214
- ^ a b c Barrios 2002, p. 199
- ^ Reid 2004, p. 119
- ^ Peary 1991, p. 248
- ^ a b c d Weaver, Brunas & Brunas 2007, p. 557
- ^ "Film reviews". Variety. Vol. 164, no. 7. October 23, 1946. p. 10.
- ^ Stanley 2000, p. 72
- ^ Willis 1982, p. 47
- ISSN 1749-9771.
- ^ Legassic 2015, p. 301
- ^ a b Harris, Peter (June 25, 1982). "Stock up on schlock Videocassettes are available on truly terrible turkeys: some are even cult films because they are so awful". The Globe and Mail.
- ISSN 0006-2510.
- ^ Hartl, John (November 25, 1990). "National Film Registry honors writer-director Preston Sturges". The Seattle Times. p. J7.
- ^ "The Brute Man". Video Watchdog (49–54 issn). 1999.
- ^ a b Mahar, Ted (June 21, 1991). "Off with a blast". The Oregonian. p. 15.
- ^ a b Baenen, Jeff (November 23, 1995). "Turkey Day will feature marathon of sci-fi turkeys". Associated Press. p. F10.
- ^ a b Beaulieu 1996, p. 140
- ^ Sinnott, John (December 6, 2011). "Mystery Science Theater 3000: Volume XXII". DVD Talk. Retrieved November 17, 2020.
- ^ Chaplin, Paul (2001). "Episode 702 — The Brute Man". Satellite News (Official). Archived from the original on May 14, 2011. Retrieved December 8, 2010.
- ^ Lucas, Tim. Danger: Diabolik (Blu-ray). Imprint Films. Event occurs at 1:22:43.
- ^ Pehl, Mary Jo. Introduction by Mary Jo Pehl (DVD). Shout! Factory.
Bibliography
- ISBN 0-520-21521-4.
- Backer, Ron (2004). Mystery Movie Series of 1940s Hollywood. ISBN 0-7864-4864-4.
- Barrios, Richard (2002). Screened Out: Playing Gay in Hollywood from Edison to Stonewall. ISBN 0-415-92328-X.
- ISBN 0-553-37783-3.
- Clark, Mark (2004). Smirk, Sneer and Scream: Great Acting in Horror Cinema. ISBN 0-7864-1932-6.
- Feramisco, Thomas M. (2007). The Mummy Unwrapped: Scenes Left on Universal's Cutting Room Floor. ISBN 978-0-7864-3734-4.
- Friedmann, Jonathan L. (2009). "B-Movies, Exploitation, and a Real-Life Monster Man". Golem — Journal of Religion and Monsters. 3 (1). Whittier College: 2.
- Gifford, Denis (1969). Movie Monsters. Studio Vista. ASIN B0031EMUB4.
- Hantke, Steffen (2009). Horror Film: Creating and Marketing Fear. ISBN 978-1-60473-376-1.
- Jaworzyn, Stefan (1994). Shock Xpress: Essential Guide to Exploitation Cinema. ISBN 1-85286-519-9.
- Katz, Ephraim (1988). The Film Encyclopedia: The Most Comprehensive Encyclopedia of World Cinema in a Single Volume (3 ed.). Collins Reference. ISBN 0-06-273492-X.
- Legassic, Cory (2015). The Perfect Neanderthal Man": Rondo Hatton as The Creeper and the Cultural Economy of 1940s B-Films. Lexington Books. ISBN 978-1498503792.
- ISBN 0-452-28478-3.
- Mérigeau, Pascal; Bourgoin, Stéphane (1983). Série B (in French). Paris: Édilig.
- Miller, Jeffrey S. (2004). Horror Spoofs of Abbott and Costello: A Critical Assessment of the Comedy Team's Monster Films. ISBN 0-7864-1922-9.
- Nash, Jay Robert (2004). The Great Pictorial History of World Crime. ISBN 1-928831-20-6.
- ISBN 0-671-74924-2.
- Pitts, Michael R. (2010). Columbia Pictures Horror, Science Fiction and Fantasy Films, 1928-1982. ISBN 978-0-7864-4447-2.
- Pratt, Douglas (2004). Doug Pratt's DVD: Movies, Television, Music, Art, Adult, and More!. Vol. 1. ISBN 1-932916-00-8.
- Reid, John Howard (2004). Memorable Films of the Forties. ISBN 1-4116-1463-1.
- Rigby, Jonathan (2007). American Gothic: Sixty Years of Horror Cinema. ISBN 978-1-905287-25-3.
- Server, Lee (2002). Encyclopedia of Pulp Fiction Writers. ISBN 0-8160-4577-1.
- Soister, John T. (2004). Up from the Vault: Rare Thrillers of the 1920s and 1930s. ISBN 0-7864-1745-5.
- Stanley, John (2000). Creature Features: The Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror Movie Guide. ISBN 0-425-17517-0.
- Weaver, Tom; Brunas, John; Brunas, Michael (2007). Universal Horrors: The Studio's Classic Films, 1931-1946 (2 ed.). ISBN 978-0-7864-2974-5.
- Willis, Donald C (1982). Horror and Science Fiction Films II (1972-1981). ISBN 0-8108-1517-6.
- Wilson, Scott (2016). Resting Places: The Burial Sites of More Than 14,000 Famous Persons, 3d ed. (2 volume set). McFarland. p. 809. ISBN 9780786479924. Retrieved 13 August 2017.
- Wilt, David E. (1991). Hardboiled in Hollywood: Five Black Mask Writers and the Movies. Popular Press 1. ISBN 0-87972-525-7.
External links
- The Brute Man at IMDb
- The Brute Man at AllMovie
- The Brute Man at Rotten Tomatoes