Abraham ben Isaac of Narbonne
Abraham ben Isaac of Narbonne (
Biography
His teacher was
Writings
Like most of the
An idea of his Talmudic knowledge may be gathered from his book Ha-Eshkol. Benjamin Hirsch Auerbach published an 1867 edition of the Eshkol in three volumes with commentary which is now known to be a forgery. Most scholars assume it is an intentional forgery by Auerbach, but Israel Ta-shma, citing the agreement of Jacob Sussman, argues it was forged in the 13th century by Moses de León, the forger of the Zohar and many other books. (HaNigleh SheBaNistar pg. 144 n. 203). However, Auerbach's edition is known to contain a wide variety of much later material. Shalom and Hanoch Albeck published an separate edition from genuine manuscripts in 1935-1938. Albeck writes that the book is, in practice, mostly a redaction of the Sefer haIttim of Judah ben Barzillai.[1] In 1985 a "fourth volume" of Auerbach's edition was published by Bernard Bergman, who had defended Auerbach's edition in a 1974 essay that makes clear that he did not then have access to any manuscript of either the Eshkol or Auerbach's commentary thereon. The fourth volume cites a book which had not yet been published at the time of Auerbach's death. Bergman, who was convicted of Medicaid fraud in 1976, never explained where he obtained the material for this "fourth volume."[2]
His depth and acumen, however, are shown to much better advantage in his responsa, quoted in the collection Temim De'im
Impact
Though he lacked originality, Abraham's influence upon Talmudical study in Provence ought not to be underrated.
See also
References
- ^ שלום אלבעק, מחוקקי יהודה, ברסלויא תרע"א
- ^ "Marc B. Shapiro – Forgery and the Halakhic Process, part 3 – The Seforim Blog". Retrieved 2022-07-05.
- ^ part iv of Tummat Yesharim, by Benjamin Motal, Venice, 1622
- OCLC 232953513.
- OCLC 1041776317
This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Singer, Isidore; et al., eds. (1901–1906). "Abraham b. Isaac of Narbonne". The Jewish Encyclopedia. New York: Funk & Wagnalls. It has the following bibliography:
- Henri Gross, in Monatsschrift, 1868, xvii.241-255, 281-294;
- idem, Gallia Judaica, pp. 414–415;
- Ernest Renan, Les Rabbins Français, pp. 510, 518, 520, 543;
- Michael, Or ha-Ḥayyim, No. 133;
- Leopold Zunz, in Geiger's Zeitschrift f. J. Theol. ii.307-309.