St. Lawrence Iroquoians
Indigenous peoples in Canada |
---|
|
Indigenous North Americas Canada portal |
The St. Lawrence Iroquoians were an
The
Knowledge about the St. Lawrence Iroquoians has been constructed from the studies of surviving
Archaeological evidence has established that the St. Lawrence Iroquoians were a people distinct from the other regional Iroquoian peoples, the Five Nations of the
The name of the country of Canada is probably derived from the Iroquoian word kanata, which means village or settlement.[5]
Historical issues
For years historians, archeologists and related scholars debated the identity of the Iroquoian cultural group in the St. Lawrence valley which
Before this, some scholars argued that the people were the ancestors or direct relations of historic Iroquoian groups in the greater region, such as the
In 1998 James F. Pendergast, a Canadian archeologist, summarized the four major theories with an overview of evidence:
- Huron-Mohawk Option:
- Several historians combined data from early French reports, vocabulary lists, and oral histories of accounts by Native tribes to theorize the early inhabitants were Iroquoian-speaking Huron or Mohawk, two tribes well known in later colonial history. There has not been sufficient documentation to support this conclusion according to 20th-century standards. In addition, archaeological finds and linguistic studies since the 1950s have discredited this theory.[8]
- Mohawk Identity Option:
- Based in part on material from the 18th century, Mohawk(in some cases, they also postulated Onondaga and Oneida) had migrated and settled in the St. Lawrence River valley before relocating to their historic territory of present-day New York. Pendergast says that attribution of Stadacona or Hochelaga as Mohawk, Onondaga or Oneida has not been supported by the archaeological data.
- "Since the 1950s a vast accumulation of archaeological material from Ontario, Quebec, New York State consistently has provided compelling evidence to demonstrate that neither the Mohawk, the Onondaga, nor the Oneida homelands originated in the St Lawrence Valley."[9]
- Based in part on material from the 18th century,
- Laurentian Iroquoian and Laurentian Iroquois Identity: based on language studies, with material added since 1940;[10]
and
- St. Lawrence Iroquoian and St. Lawrence Iroquois Identity:
Since the 1950s, anthropologists, archaeologists, linguists and
As noted, anthropologists and some historians have used definitive linguistic and archaeological studies to reach consensus that the St. Lawrence Iroquoians were a people distinct from nations of the
The St. Lawrence Iroquoians appear to have disappeared from the St. Lawrence valley some time prior to 1580. Champlain reported no evidence of Native habitation in the valley. By then the Haudenosaunee used it as a hunting ground and avenue for war parties.
As the historian Pendergast argues, the determination of identity for the St. Lawrence Iroquoians is important because, "our understanding of relations between Europeans and Iroquoians during the contact era throughout Iroquoia hinges largely upon the tribe or confederacy to which Stadacona and Hochelaga are attributed."[12]
Culture and subsistence
Prehistoric Iroquoian culture and maize agriculture in Canada is first detected by archaeologists in 500 CE at the Princess Point site in Hamilton, Ontario. Iroquoian culture is detected in the Saguenay River region of Quebec in about 1000 CE. By 1250 or 1300 maize was being grown in what would become the Quebec City area. By about 1300, four distinct subculture areas of St. Lawrence Iroquoian culture existed: (1) Jefferson County, New York with a population of about 2,500; Grenville County, Ontario with a population of 2,500; the Lake St. Francis basin west of Montreal with a population of 1,000; and the Montreal and Quebec city areas with a population of 2,000 to 3,000.[13] There were also settlements in northernmost Vermont and neighboring Ontario near Lake Champlain.[14]
Most of the St. Lawrence Iroquoian villages were located in inland locations a few kilometers from the river itself. By the end of the 15th century they were encircled by earthworks and palisades, indicating a need for defense. The villages usually were 2 hectares (4.9 acres) to 3.25 hectares (8.0 acres) in area. Inside the palisades the St. Lawrence people lived in
The Iroquoians occupied their villages for ten or more years until their longhouses deteriorated and the fertility of the soil for their crops declined. Then, they built a new village and cleared land for crops, usually only a few miles from their previous home.[17] The frequent changes of location has given problems to archaeologists in estimating the numbers on the St. Lawrence Iroquoian people. Dating techniques may not be precise enough to determine whether villages were occupied simultaneously or sequentially.[18]
In addition to the characteristic villages, the St. Lawrence Iroquoian peoples had "a mixed economy, in which they drew their subsistence from growing
In 1535, French explorer Jacques Cartier commented on cultural differences between the people of Hochelaga (Montreal area) and Stadacona (Quebec area). Cartier described the large and productive maize fields surrounding Hochelaga, and said its inhabitants were sedentary, as compared to the people of Stadacona who were migratory.[22] The Stadaconans were closer to the salt-water resources (fish, seals, and whales) of the lower St. Lawrence River and the Gulf of St Lawrence and ranged widely in their birch bark canoes in search of marine animals. Moreover, the Quebec area was the most northerly location in northeastern North America in which agriculture was practiced, especially during the cooler temperatures of the Little Ice Age in the 16th century. For Stadaconans, depending on agriculture was a riskier subsistence strategy than for the people of Hochelaga and they probably relied less on agriculture and more on exploitation of sea mammals, fishing, and hunting.[23][24]
The St. Lawrence Iroquoians were not united politically and villages and cultural groups may have been unfriendly and competitive with each other, as well as being hostile to the neighboring Algonquian peoples and other Iroquoian groups.[25]
European contacts
In his follow-up expedition of 1535 and 1536, Cartier visited several Iroquoian villages north of
At just about the period Jacques Cartier contacted them,
Demise
The archaeologist Anthony Wonderley found 500-year-old ceramic pipes in present-day Jefferson County, New York that were associated with the St. Lawrence Iroquoians and the tribes of the Haudenosaunee. Their use appear to have been related to diplomatic visits among the peoples, and he suggests they indicate a territory of interaction that may have preceded the Iroquois confederacy. Related design elements and long recounting in Iroquois oral histories have been significant.[32]
By the time the explorer
By the time Champlain arrived, the Algonquins and Mohawks were both using the Saint-Lawrence Valley for hunting grounds, as well as a route for war parties and raiding. Neither nation had any permanent settlements upriver above Tadoussac, the trading post in the lower St. Lawrence Valley which had been important for years in the fur trade.[3]
Historical debates
Although historians and other scholars have been studying the St. Lawrence Iroquoians for some time, such knowledge has been slower to be part of common historical understanding. The hypothesis about the St. Lawrence Iroquoians helps explain apparent contradictions in the historical record about French encounters with natives in this area.
The origins of the word
Both the
The account of Canada's name origin reflects theories first advanced in the 18th and 19th centuries. General texts have not kept up with the discrediting of such earlier theories by the linguistic comparative studies of the later 20th century. For instance, the "Huron-Iroquois theory" of word origin appeared in the article on "Canada" in the Encyclopædia Britannica of 1996.
The earlier mystery of
Archaeologists have not determined the exact location of Hochelaga. In the early 20th century historians debated this vigorously and the reasons for its disappearance, but changing interests in the field led in other directions.[35] In the late 20th century, First Nations activism, as well as increased interest in history of indigenous peoples renewed attention to the early St. Lawrence Iroquoian villages.[36][37]
Language
Linguistic studies indicate that the St. Lawrence Iroquoians probably spoke several distinct dialects of their language, often referred to as Laurentian. It is one of several languages of the Iroquoian language family, which includes Mohawk, Huron-Wyandot and Cherokee. Jacques Cartier made sparse records during his voyage in 1535-1536. He compiled two vocabulary lists totaling about 200 words. The St. Lawrence Iroquoians may have spoken two or more distinct languages in a territory stretching over 600 km, from Lake Ontario to east of Île d'Orléans.
Legacy and honours
Extensive archaeological work in Montreal has revealed the 1,000-year history of human habitation on the site. In 1992 a new museum,
Major exhibits have displayed the increasing knowledge about the St. Lawrence Iroquoians:
- 1992, Wrapped in the Colours of the Earth: Cultural Heritage of the First Nations, McCord Museum, Montreal, Quebec
- 2006-2007, The Saint Lawrence Iroquoians: Corn People, Pointe à Callière, Montreal Museum of Archaeology and History, Montreal, Quebec. (The exhibition catalogue was published as a book under the same name.)
See also
Notes
- ^ a b "St. Lawrence Iroquoians: Corn People", 2006-2007 Exhibit, Pointe-à-Callière, Montreal, accessed 14 March 2012
- ^ Warrick, Gray and Lesagel, Louis (2016), "The Huron-Wendat and the St. Lawrence Iroquoians: New Findings of a Close Relationship," Ontario Archaeology, p. 137, [1] Archived 2018-09-20 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ a b c d Bruce G. Trigger, "The Disappearance of the St. Lawrence Iroquoians", in The Children of Aataenstic: A History of the Huron People to 1660, vol. 2, Montreal and London: Mcgill-Queen's University Press, 1976, pp. 214-218, 220-224, accessed 2 Feb 2010
- ^ James F. Pendergast. (1998). "The Confusing Identities Attributed to Stadacona and Hochelaga", Journal of Canadian Studies, Volume 32, p. 149, accessed 3 Feb 2010
- ^ ISBN 978-0-313-26257-9. Archivedfrom the original on April 12, 2016.
- ^ a b Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", pp. 156-157
- ^ Claude Chapdelaine, "The St. Lawrence Iroquoians, 1500CE", Wrapped in the Colours of the Earth. Cultural Heritage of the First Nations Exhibition Catalogue, Montreal: McCord Museum, 1992
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", pp. 150-153
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", pp. 153-154
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", pp. 155-156
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", pp. 158-159
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", p. 149
- ^ Warrick, Gary (Dec 2000), "The Precontact Iroquoian Occupation off Southern Ontario," Journal of World Prehistory, Vol. 14, No. 4, p. 415, 454-457. Downloaded from JSTOR.
- ^ Jamison, Thomas (2005), "Filling the Void Saint Lawrence Iroquoians in Alburg, Vermont," Journal of Vermont Archaeology, Vol. 6, [2], accessed 7 Aug 2019.
- ^ Warrick, pp. 454-457
- ^ Abel, Timothy, "The Iroquoian Occupations of Northern New York: A summary of Current Research," pp. 66, [3], accessed 7 Aug 2019
- ^ "A Mohawk Village," [4], accessed 12 Aug 2019
- ^ Jones, Eric E. (2008), "Iroquois Population History and Settlement Ecology, 1500-1700," Dissertation: Pennsylvania State University, [5], accessed 12 Aug 2019
- ^ "The St. Lawrence Iroquoians: who are they?" Cartier-Brebeuf National Historical Site, [6], accessed 9 Aug 2019
- ^ St-Pierre, C. Gates, "Fish and Corn," [7], accessed 14 Aug 2019
- ^ St-Pierre, C. Gates (2015), "Horticulture on the Edge: The Northernmost Evidence for Plant Cultivation in Pre-Contact Northeastern North America," Revista de Antropologia del Museo de Entre Rios, Vol. 1, pp. 20-23
- ^ Stephens, Hiram B. and Saville, Marshall H. (1890), Jacques Cartier and his four voyages to Canada; an essay with historical, explanatory and philological notes, Montreal: W. Drysdale and Company, pp. 61,63
- ^ "The Iroquoians of the Quebec Area," Cartier-Brebeuf National Historic Site, [8], accessed 11 Aug 2019
- ^ St-Pierre (2015), p. 20
- ^ Gates St-Pierre, Christian (2016), "Iroquoians in the St. Lawrence River Valley before European Contact," Ontario Archaeology, Vol. 96, p. 54.
- ^ "Thomas Aubert," Dictionary of Canadian Biography, http://www.biographi.ca/en/bio/aubert_thomas_1E.html, accessed 31 Jul 2019
- ^ Weise, Arthur James (1884), The Discoveries of America to the year 1525, London: Richard Bentley and Son, pp. 298-299
- ^ Cahill, Donald and Ouellet, Martin (Autumn 2015), "An Analysis of Jacques Cartier's Exploration of the Gaspé Coast, 1534," Acadiensis, Vol. 44, No. 2, pp. 90-94. Downloaded from JSTOR.
- ^ Parmenter, p. 7
- ^ Jacques Cartier. (1545). Relation originale de Jacques Cartier. Paris: Tross (1863 edition)
- ^ James F. Pendergast. (1998). "The Confusing Identities Attributed to Stadacona and Hochelaga", Journal of Canadian Studies, Volume 32
- ^ Wonderley, Anthony. 2005. "Effigy Pipes, Diplomacy, and Myth: Exploring Interaction between St. Lawrence Iroquoians and Eastern Iroquois in New York State", American Antiquity. 70, no. 2: 211, accessed 14 March 2012
- ^ Harold A Innis, "The Fur Trade in Canada", 1956 revision of 1930, Chapter 1.
- ISBN 9780824208646.
- ^ W. J. Wintemberg, "Was Hochelaga Destroyed or Abandoned?", American Anthropological Association, 1927, accessed 3 Feb 2010
- ^ Mark Abley, "Where was Hochelaga? Debate simmers over the location and fate of the Indian village Cartier visited in 1535", Canadian Geographic, 1 Nov 1994, accessed 3 Feb 2010
- ^ Pendergast (1998), "Confusing Identities", p. 150
- ^ "About Pointe-à-Callière", Montreal Museum of Archaeology and History website, accessed 14 March 2012
References
- Jacques Cartier. (1545). Relation originale de Jacques Cartier. Paris: Tross (1863 edition). (Vocabulary list on pages 46 to 48)
- Pendergast, James F, and Bruce G. Trigger. Cartier's Hochelaga and the Dawson Site. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1972.
- James F. Pendergast. (1998). "The Confusing Identities Attributed to Stadacona and Hochelaga", Journal of Canadian Studies, Volume 32, pp. 149–167.
- Roland Tremblay. (1999). "Regards sur le passé: réflexions sur l'identité des habitants de la vallée du Saint-Laurent au XVIe siècle", Recherches amérindiennes au Québec, Volume 29, No.1, pp. 41–52.
- Roland Tremblay. (2006). The Saint Lawrence Iroquoians: Corn People, Montréal, Qc, Les Éditions de l'Homme (Published in association with exhibit by same name, 2006-2007)
- "Book Review: Roland Tremblay. (2006) The Saint Lawrence Iroquoians: Corn People", Canadian Journal of Archaeology / Journal Canadien d’Archéologie, 2007.
- Bruce G. Trigger and James F. Pendergast. (1978). "Saint Lawrence Iroquoians", in Handbook of North American Indians, Volume 15, Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution, pp. 357–361.
- Bruce G. Trigger. (1976) "The Disappearance of the St. Lawrence Iroquoians", in The Children of Aataentsic: a History of the Huron People to 1660. Montreal: McGill-Queen's Press, pp. 214–228.
- Juan Francisco Maura. “Nuevas aportaciones al estudio de la toponimia ibérica en la América Septentrional en el siglo XVI”. Bulletin of Spanish Studies 86. 5 (2009): 577-603.
- Juan Francisco Maura. “Sobre el origen hispánico del nombre ‘Canadá’”. Lemir (Revista de literatura medieval y del Renacimiento) 20 (2016): 17-52. http://parnaseo.uv.es/Lemir/Revista/Revista20/02_Maura_Juan.pdf
External links
- Virtual Museum of Canada, The St. Lawrence Iroquoians— a virtual exhibit on the people's culture
Further reading
- Engelbrecht, William; Jamieson, Bruce (2016). "St. Lawrence Iroquoian Projectile Points: A Regional Perspective". Archaeology of Eastern North America. 44. Eastern States Archaeological Federation: 81–98. JSTOR 44808365.
- Gates-St. Pierre, Christian (2016). "Iroquoians in the St. Lawrence River Valley before European Contact" (PDF). Ontario Archaeology. 96. Ontario Archaeological Society: 47–64.
- Jamieson, J.B. "The Archaeology of the St. Lawrence Iroquoians." The Archaeology of Southern Ontario to A.D. 1650, Occasional Publication of the London Chapter, OAS, No.5:385-404, 1990.
- Junker-Andersen, Christen. Faunal Resource Exploitation Among the St. Lawrence Iroquoians: the Zooarchaeology of the Steward (BfFt-2) Site, Morrisburg, Ontario. Toronto: University of Toronto, 1984.
- Loewen, Brad (2016). "Chapter 3: Intertwined Enigmas". In Loewen, Brad; Chapdelaine, Claude (eds.). Contact in the 16th Century: Networks Among Fishers, Foragers and Farmers. Mercury Series. University of Ottawa Press. pp. 57–76. . Examines the relationship between the Basques and the St. Lawrence Iroquoians.
- Pendergast, James F., "The Significance of a Huron Archaeological Presence in Jefferson County, New York," a paper read at McMaster University, 20 February 1982, vide Trigger (1985) 351.
- Pendergast, James F. "The St.Lawrence Iroquoians: Their Past, Present and Immediate Future," The Bulletin (Journal of the New York State Archaeological Association), 102:47-74, 1991.
- Pendergast, James F., Claude Chapdelaine, and J. V. Wright. "Essays in St. Lawrence Iroquoian Archaeology", Occasional Papers in Northeastern Archaeology, no. 8. Dundas, Ontario: Copetown Press, 1993. ISBN 1-895087-07-4
- Pendergast, J. F. (1975). "An In-Situ Hypothesis to Explain the Origin of the St. Lawrence Iroquoians" (PDF). Ontario Archaeology. 25. Ontario Archaeological Society: 47–55.
- Plourde, Michel (2016). "Chapter 5: Saint Lawrence Iroquoians, Algonquians, and Europeans in the Saint Lawrence Estuary between 1500 and 1650". In Loewen, Brad; Chapdelaine, Claude (eds.). Contact in the 16th Century: Networks Among Fishers, Foragers and Farmers. Mercury Series. University of Ottawa Press. pp. 119–148. .
- Steckley, John (2016). "St. Lawrence Iroquoians among the Wendat: Linguistic Evidence" (PDF). Ontario Archaeology. 96. Ontario Archaeological Society: 17–25.
- Trigger, Bruce G., Native and Newcomers: Canada's 'Heroic Age' Reconsidered, (Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1985) 144-8, 351
- Warrick, Gary; Lesage, Louis (2016). "The Huron-Wendat and the St. Lawrence Iroquoians: New Findings of a Close Relationship" (PDF). Ontario Archaeology. 96. Ontario Archaeological Society: 133–143.