Flapping
History and description of |
English pronunciation |
---|
Historical stages |
General development |
Development of vowels |
Development of consonants |
Variable features |
Related topics |
Flapping or tapping, also known as alveolar flapping, intervocalic flapping, or t-voicing, is a
Flapping of /t/ is sometimes perceived as the replacement of /t/ with /d/; for example, the word butter pronounced with flapping may be heard as "budder".[2]
In other dialects of English, such as
Terminology and articulation
The terms
In
In
Distribution
Flapping of /t/ and /d/ is a prominent feature of North American English. Some linguists consider it obligatory for most American dialects to flap /t/ between a stressed and an unstressed vowel.[7][11] Flapping of /t/ also occurs in Australian, New Zealand and (especially Northern) Irish English, and more infrequently or variably in South African English, Cockney, and Received Pronunciation.[12][13][14]
The exact conditions for flapping in North American English are unknown, although it is widely understood that it occurs in an alveolar stop, /t/ or /d/, when placed between two vowels, provided the second vowel is unstressed (as in butter, writing, wedding, loader).[6][15] Across word boundaries, however, it can occur between any two vowels, provided the second vowel begins a word (as in get over [ɡɛɾˈoʊvɚ]).[6][15] This extends to morphological boundaries within compound words (as in whatever [ˌwʌɾˈɛvɚ]).[16] In addition to vowels, segments that may precede the flap include /r/ (as in party)[11][17] and occasionally /l/ (as in faulty).[18][19] Flapping after /l/ is more common in Canadian English than in American English.[20] Syllabic /l/ may also follow the flap (as in bottle).[21] Flapping of /t/ before syllabic /n/ (as in button) is observed in Australian English,[22] while [t] (with nasal release) and [ʔ] (t-glottalization) are the only possibilities in North American English.[23]
Word-medial flapping is also prohibited in
In North American English, the cluster /nt/ (but not /nd/) in the same environment as flapped /t/ may be realized as a
Given these intricacies, it is difficult to formulate a phonological rule that accurately predicts flapping.[7] Nevertheless, Vaux (2000) postulates that it applies to alveolar stops:
Exceptions include the preposition/particle to and words derived from it, such as today, tonight, tomorrow, and together, wherein /t/ may be flapped when intervocalic (as in go to sleep [ˌɡoʊɾəˈslip]).
Homophony
Flapping is a specific type of
For speakers with the merger, the following utterances sound the same or almost the same:/-t-, -nt-/ | /-d-, -n-/ | IPA | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
aborting | aboarding | əˈbɔɹɾɪŋ | |
alighted | elided | əˈlaɪɾəd | With weak vowel merger .
|
ante | Annie | ˈæɾ̃i | |
anti- | Annie | ˈæɾ̃i | |
at 'em | Adam | ˈæɾəm | |
at 'em | add 'em | ˈæɾəm | |
atom | Adam | ˈæɾəm | |
atom | add 'em | ˈæɾəm | |
auntie | Annie | ˈæɾ̃i | |
banter | banner | ˈbæɾ̃əɹ | |
batter | badder | ˈbæɾəɹ | |
batty | baddie | ˈbæɾi | |
beating | beading | ˈbiːɾɪŋ | |
Bertie | birdie | ˈbəɹɾi | With fern-fir-fur merger .
|
Bertie | Birdy; Birdie | ˈbəɹɾi | With fern-fir-fur merger .
|
betting | bedding | ˈbɛɾɪŋ | |
biting | biding | ˈbaɪɾɪŋ | |
bitter | bidder | ˈbɪɾəɹ | |
bitting | bidding | ˈbɪɾɪŋ | |
bitty | biddy | ˈbɪɾi | |
blatter | bladder | ˈblæɾəɹ | |
bleating | bleeding | ˈbliːɾɪŋ | |
boating | boding | ˈboʊɾɪŋ | |
bruter | brooder | ˈbɹuːɾəɹ | With yod-dropping after /ɹ/.
|
butting | budding | ˈbʌɾɪŋ | |
butty | buddy | ˈbʌɾi | |
canter | canner | ˈkæɾ̃əɹ | |
canton | cannon | ˈkæɾ̃ən | |
canton | canon | ˈkæɾ̃ən | |
carting | carding | ˈkɑɹɾɪŋ | |
catty | caddy | ˈkæɾi | |
centre; center | sinner | ˈsɪɾ̃əɹ | With pen–pin merger .
|
chanting | Channing | ˈt͡ʃæɾ̃ɪŋ | |
cited | sided | ˈsaɪɾɨd | |
citer | cider | ˈsaɪɾəɹ | |
clotting | clodding | ˈklɒɾɪŋ | |
coating | coding | ˈkoʊɾɪŋ | |
courting | chording | ˈkɔɹɾɪŋ | |
courting | cording | ˈkɔɹɾɪŋ | |
cuttle | cuddle | ˈkʌɾəl | |
cutty | cuddy | ˈkʌɾi | |
daughter | dodder | ˈdɑɾəɹ | With cot-caught merger .
|
daunting | dawning | ˈdɔɾ̃ɪŋ | |
daunting | donning | ˈdɑɾ̃ɪŋ | With cot-caught merger .
|
debtor | deader | ˈdɛɾəɹ | |
diluted | deluded | dɪˈluːɾəd | |
don't it | doughnut | ˈdoʊɾ̃ət | With toe-tow merger .
|
dotter | dodder | ˈdɑɾəɹ | |
doughty | dowdy | ˈdaʊɾi | |
eluted | alluded | əˈluːɾəd | With weak vowel merger .
|
eluted | eluded | ɪˈluːɾəd | |
enter | in a | ˈɪɾ̃ə | In pen-pin merger .
|
enter | inner | ˈɪɾ̃əɹ | With pen-pin merger .
|
eta | Ada | ˈeɪɾə | |
fated | faded | ˈfeɪɾɨd | |
flutter | flooder | ˈflʌɾəɹ | |
fontal | faunal | ˈfɑɾ̃əl | With cot-caught merger .
|
futile | feudal | ˈfjuːɾəl | With weak vowel merger .
|
garter | guarder | ˈgɑɹɾəɹ | |
gaunter | goner | ˈgɑɾ̃əɹ | With cot-caught merger .
|
goated | goaded | ˈgoʊɾəd | |
grater | grader | ˈɡɹeɪɾəɹ | |
greater | grader | ˈɡɹeɪɾəɹ | |
gritted | gridded | ˈgɹɪɾəd | |
gritty | Griddy |
ˈɡɹɪɾi | |
hearty | hardy | ˈhɑːɹɾi | |
heated | heeded | ˈhiːɾɨd | With meet-meat merger .
|
Hetty; Hettie | heady | ˈhɛɾi | |
hurting | herding | ˈhɜːɹɾɪŋ | With fern-fir-fur merger .
|
inter- | in a | ˈɪɾ̃ə | In non-rhotic accents.
|
inter- | inner | ˈɪɾ̃əɹ | |
iter | eider | ˈaɪɾəɹ | |
jaunty | Johnny | ˈd͡ʒɑɾ̃i | With cot-caught merger.
|
jointing | joining | ˈd͡ʒɔɪɾ̃ɪŋ | |
kitted | kidded | ˈkɪɾɨd | |
kitty | kiddie | ˈkɪɾi | |
knotted | nodded | ˈnɒɾɨd | |
latter | ladder | ˈlæɾəɹ | |
lauded | lotted | ˈlɑɾəd | With cot-caught merger .
|
linty | Lenny | ˈlɪɾ̃i | With pen-pin merger .
|
liter | leader | ˈliːɾəɹ | With meet-meat merger .
|
little | Lidl | ˈlɪɾəl | |
looter | lewder | ˈluːɾəɹ | With yod-dropping after /l/.
|
manta | manna | ˈmæɾ̃ə | |
manta | manner | ˈmæɾ̃ə | In non-rhotic accents.
|
manta | manor | ˈmæɾ̃ə | In non-rhotic accents.
|
Marty | Mardi | ˈmɑːɹɾi | In the term Mardi Gras. |
matter | madder | ˈmæɾəɹ | |
mattocks | Maddox | ˈmæɾəks | |
meant it | minute | ˈmɪɾ̃ɨt | With pen–pin merger .
|
metal | medal | ˈmɛɾəl | |
metal | meddle | ˈmɛɾəl | |
mettle | medal | ˈmɛɾəl | |
mettle | meddle | ˈmɛɾəl | |
minty | many | ˈmɪɾ̃i | With pen–pin merger .
|
minty | mini | ˈmɪɾ̃i | |
minty | Minnie | ˈmɪɾ̃i | |
motile | modal | ˈmoʊɾəl | With weak vowel merger .
|
mottle | model | ˈmɑɾəl | |
mutter | mudder | ˈmʌɾəɹ | |
neater | kneader | ˈniːɾəɹ | |
neuter | nuder | ˈnuːɾəɹ, ˈnjuːɾəɹ, ˈnɪuɾəɹ | |
nighter | nidor | ˈnaɪɾəɹ | |
nitre; niter | nidor | ˈnaɪɾəɹ | |
noted | noded | ˈnoʊɾɨd | |
oater | odour; odor | ˈoʊɾəɹ | |
otter | odder | ˈɒɾəɹ | |
painting | paining | ˈpeɪɾ̃ɪŋ | |
panting | panning | ˈpæɾ̃ɪŋ | |
parity | parody | ˈpæɹəɾi | With weak vowel merger
|
patter | padder | ˈpæɾəɹ | |
patting | padding | ˈpæɾɪŋ | |
patty | paddy | ˈpæɾi | |
petal | pedal | ˈpɛɾəl | |
petal | peddle | ˈpɛɾəl | |
pettle | pedal | ˈpɛɾəl | |
pettle | peddle | ˈpɛɾəl | |
platted | plaided | ˈplæɾəd | |
planting | planning | ˈplæɾ̃ɪŋ | |
pleating | pleading | ˈpliːɾɪŋ | |
plenty | Pliny | ˈplɪɾ̃i | With pen–pin merger .
|
plotting | plodding | ˈplɒɾɪŋ | |
potted | podded | ˈpɒɾɨd | |
pouter | powder | ˈpaʊɾəɹ | |
punting | punning | ˈpʌɾ̃ɪŋ | |
putting | pudding | ˈpʊɾɪŋ | |
rated | raided | ˈɹeɪɾɨd | With pane-pain merger .
|
rattle | raddle | ˈɹæɾəl | |
righting | riding | ˈɹaɪɾɪŋ | |
roti | roadie | ˈɹoʊɾi | |
rooter | ruder | ˈɹuːɾəɹ | With yod-dropping after /ɹ/.
|
rotting | rodding | ˈɹɒɾɪŋ | |
router | ruder | ˈɹuːɾəɹ | With yod-dropping after /ɹ/.
|
runty | runny | ˈɹʌɾ̃i | |
rutty | ruddy | ˈɹʌɾi | |
sainting | seining | ˈseɪɾ̃ɪŋ | |
Saturday | sadder day | ˈsæɾəɹdeɪ | |
satyr | Seder | ˈseɪɾəɹ | |
saunter | sauna | ˈsɔɾ̃ə | In non-rhotic accents.
|
scented | synod | ˈsɪɾ̃əd | With pen-pin merger .
|
scenting | sinning | ˈsɪɾ̃ɪŋ | With pen-pin merger .
|
seating | seeding | ˈsiːɾɪŋ | With meet-meat merger .
|
sent it | senate | ˈsɛɾ̃ɨt | |
set it | said it | ˈsɛɾɨt | |
shunting | shunning | ˈʃʌɾ̃ɪŋ | |
shutter | shudder | ˈʃʌɾəɹ | |
sighted | sided | ˈsaɪɾɨd | |
sighter | cider | ˈsaɪɾəɹ | |
sinter | sinner | ˈsɪɾ̃əɹ | |
sited | sided | ˈsaɪɾɨd | |
skitting | skidding | ˈskɪɾɪŋ | |
sorted | sordid | ˈsɔɹɾɨd | |
slighting | sliding | ˈslaɪɾɪŋ | |
stunting | stunning | ˈstʌɾ̃ɪŋ | |
tarty | tardy | ˈtɑɹɾi | |
tenter | tenner | ˈtɛɾ̃əɹ | |
tenter | tenor | ˈtɛɾ̃əɹ | |
tenting | tinning | ˈtɪɾɪŋ | With pen-pin merger .
|
title | tidal | ˈtaɪɾəl | |
toting | toading | ˈtoʊɾɪŋ | |
traitor | trader | ˈtɹeɪɾəɹ | With pane-pain merger .
|
tutor | Tudor | ˈtuːɾəɹ, ˈtjuːɾəɹ, ˈtɪuɾəɹ | |
tweeted | tweeded | ˈtwiːɾəd | |
utter | udder | ˈʌɾəɹ | |
waiter | wader | ˈweɪɾəɹ | With pane-pain merger .
|
wattle | waddle | ˈwɑɾəl | |
weighted | waded | ˈweɪɾəd | With pane-pain merger .
|
wetting | wedding | ˈwɛɾɪŋ | |
winter | winner | ˈwɪɾ̃əɹ | |
wheated | weeded | ˈwiːɾəd | With wine-whine merger .
|
whiter | wider | ˈwaɪɾəɹ | With wine–whine merger .
|
writing | riding | ˈɹaɪɾɪŋ |
In accents characterized by
Withgott effect
In a dissertation in 1982, M.M. Withgott demonstrated that, among speakers of American English, words seem to be chunked into pronunciation units she referred to as a foot, similar to a metrical unit in poetry. Such chunking was said to block flapping in the word ‘Mediterranean’ ([[Medi[terranean] ], cf. [ [sub[terranean]]). How a word is chunked relates to its morphological derivation, as seen by contrasting morphologically similar pairs such as the following (where the vertical bar shows where Withgott argued there is boundary between neighboring feet):
Initial-type t | vs. | flapped-t | ||
military | [ˈmɪlɨ | tʰɛɹi] | vs. | capital | [ˈkʰæpɨɾl̩] |
militaristic | [ˌmɪlɨ | tʰəˈɹɪstɪk] | vs. | capitalistic | [ˌkʰæpɨɾə | ˈlɪstɪk] |
The medial t in càpitalístic can be flapped as easily as in post-stress cátty [ˈkʰæɾi], in contrast to the medial t in mìlitarístic, which comes at the beginning of a foot, and so must be pronounced as [tʰ], like a t at the beginning of a word.
Long, seemingly monomorphemic words also are chunked in English for purposes of pronunciation. In such words [t]’s — as well as the other unvoiced stops — are pronounced like initial segments whenever they receive secondary stress or are at the beginning of a foot:
Navra tilóva
Abra cadábra
Ala kazám
Rázz matàzz
But:
Fliberti gibety
Humu humu nuku nuku apu a‘a
T-to-R rule
The origins of the T-to-R rule lie in the flapping of /t/ and the subsequent reinterpretation of the flap as /r/, which was then followed by the use of the prevailing variant of /r/, namely the approximant [
The T-to-R rule has also been reported to occur in the
/t/ | /r/ | IPA | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
battle | barrel | ˈbæɾəl | |
batty | Barrie | ˈbæɾi | |
batty | Barry | ˈbæɾi | |
betty | berry | ˈbɛɾi | |
but a | borough | ˈbəɾə | In Cardiff English. But has an alternative form /bə/, with an elided /t/.[44] |
butter | borough | ˈbʌɾə | |
catty | carry | ˈkæɾi | |
catty | kar(r)ee | ˈkæɾi | |
daughter | Dora | ˈdɔːɾə | |
Fetty | ferry | ˈfɛɾi | |
hotter | horror | ˈhɒɾə | |
jetty | jerry | ˈd͡ʒɛɾi | |
Lottie | lorry | ˈlɒɾi | |
matty | marry | ˈmæɾi | |
otter | horror | ˈɒɾə | With h-dropping. |
petty | Perry | ˈpɛɾi | |
starting | starring | ˈstɑːɾɪŋ | |
tarty | tarry | ˈtɑːɾi | Tarry in the sense "resembling tar". |
See also
Notes
- ^ Since North American English normally lacks the distinction between /ɪ/ and /ə/ in unstressed positions, there is variability among linguists and dictionaries in the treatment of unstressed vowels pronounced as /ɪ/ in other varieties of English that have the distinction. They are usually identified as /ɪ/ before palato-alveolar and velar consonants (/ʃ, tʃ, dʒ, k, ɡ, ŋ/) and in prefixes such as re-, e-, de-, and as /ə/ elsewhere.[24]
References
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 325.
- ^ E.g. in Fox (2011:158).
- ^ Ogden (2009), p. 92.
- ^ Ladefoged & Johnson (2011), pp. 175–6.
- ^ a b Wells (1982), p. 249.
- ^ a b c d de Jong (1998), p. 284.
- ^ a b c Shockey (2003), p. 29.
- ^ Derrick & Gick (2011), pp. 309–12.
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 326.
- ^ Collins & Mees (1990), pp. 91–2.
- ^ a b c Goldsmith (2011), p. 191.
- ^ Shockey (2003), p. 30.
- ^ Trudgill & Hannah (2008), pp. 24, 30, 35, 104.
- ^ Hickey (2007), p. 115.
- ^ a b Goldsmith (2011), pp. 191–2.
- ^ Hualde (2011), p. 2230.
- ^ Hayes (2009), p. 143.
- ^ Boberg (2015), p. 236.
- ^ Jones (2011), p. xi.
- ^ Brinton & Fee (2001), p. 428.
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 248.
- ^ Tollfree (2001), pp. 57–8.
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 251.
- ^ Wells (2000), p. xv.
- ^ a b Hayes (1995), pp. 14–5.
- ^ Wells (2011).
- ^ Vaux (2000), p. 5.
- ^ Bérces (2011), pp. 84–9.
- ^ Ladefoged & Johnson (2011), pp. 74–5.
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 252.
- ^ Vaux (2000), pp. 4–5.
- ^ Goldsmith (2011), p. 192.
- ^ Horvath (2004), p. 635.
- ^ Vaux (2000), p. 7.
- ^ Vaux (2000), pp. 6–7.
- ^ Iverson & Ahn (2007), pp. 262–3.
- ^ Hayes (2009), p. 144.
- ^ Wells (1982), pp. 250, 326.
- ^ Hayes (2009), pp. 144–6.
- ^ Gussenhoven & Jacobs (2017), p. 217.
- ^ Wells (1982), p. 370.
- ^ Wells (1982), pp. 616–618.
- ^ Collins & Mees (1990), pp. 91–92.
- ^ Collins & Mees (1990), p. 99.
Bibliography
- Bérces, Katalin Balogné (2011). "Weak and semiweak phonological positions in English". Journal of English Studies. 9: 75–96. doi:10.18172/jes.160.
- ISBN 978-1-11831447-0.
- ISBN 0-521-26479-0.
- Collins, Beverley; Mees, Inger M. (1990), "The Phonetics of Cardiff English", in Coupland, Nikolas; Thomas, Alan Richard (eds.), English in Wales: Diversity, Conflict, and Change, Multilingual Matters Ltd., pp. 87–103, ISBN 1-85359-032-0
- de Jong, Kenneth (1998). "Stress-related variation in the articulation of coda alveolar stops: flapping revisited". Journal of Phonetics. 26 (3): 283–310. .
- Derrick, Donald; Gick, Bryan (2011). "Individual variation in English flaps and taps: a case of categorical phonetics". Canadian Journal of Linguistics. 56 (3): 307–319. S2CID 231889893.
- Fox, Kirsten (2011). VCE English Language: Exam Guide (2nd ed.). Insight Publications. ISBN 978-1-92141193-9.
- ISBN 978-1-4051-5768-1.
- ISBN 978-1-35197471-4.
- ISBN 0-22632104-5.
- Hayes, Bruce (2009). Introductory Phonology. Blackwell. ISBN 978-1-4051-8411-3.
- ISBN 978-0-521-85299-9.
- Horvath, Barbara M. (2004). "Australian English: phonology". In Schneider, Edgar W.; S2CID 243507016.
- ISBN 978-1-40518423-6.
- Iverson, Gregory K.; Ahn, Sang-Cheol (2007). "English voicing in dimensional theory" (PDF). PMID 18496590. Archived from the original(PDF) on 15 April 2012.
- ISBN 978-0-521-15255-6.
- ISBN 978-1-42823126-9.
- Ogden, Richard (2009). An Introduction to English Phonetics. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 978-0-7486-2541-3.
- Shockey, Linda (2003). Sound Patterns of Spoken English. Blackwell. ISBN 0-63123079-3.
- Tollfree, Laura (2001). "Variation and change in Australian consonants: reduction of /t/". In Blair, David; Collins, Peter (eds.). English in Australia. John Benjamins. pp. 45–67. ISBN 90-272-4884-2.
- ISBN 978-0-340-97161-1.
- Vaux, Bert (2000). Flapping in English (PDF). Linguistic Society of America. Chicago. Archived from the original (PDF) on 15 June 2001.
- .
- ISBN 0-582-36467-1.
- Wells, John C. (25 March 2011). "strong and weak". John Wells's phonetic blog.
Further reading
- Withgott, M. Margaret. 1982. Segmental Evidence for Phonological Constituents. Ph.D. Dissertation for the University of Texas at Austin.
- Iverson, Gregory K. and Sang-Cheol Ahn. 2004. English Voicing in Dimensional Theory. Language Sciences (Phonology of English).
- Kahn, Daniel. 1976. Syllable-Based Generalizations in English Phonology. Ph.D. Dissertation for the University of Massachusetts reproduced by I.U. Linguistics Club.
- Steriade, Donca. 1999. Paradigm uniformity and the phonetics-phonology boundary. In M. Broe and J. Pierrehumbert (eds.), Papers in Laboratory Phonology V: Acquisition and the lexicon, 313-334. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.