Battle of Constantinople (1147)
Battle of Constantinople (1147) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||
Belligerents | |||||||
Byzantine Empire | German crusaders (Holy Roman Empire) | ||||||
Commanders and leaders | |||||||
Prosouch, Basil Tzikandyles (Manuel I in overall command) | Unknown (Conrad III in overall command) | ||||||
Strength | |||||||
Unknown – described as smaller than the German force by Byzantine historian John Kinnamos[1] | Unknown – Only part was involved, the entire German army had 20,000 combatants [2] | ||||||
Casualties and losses | |||||||
Unknown | Unknown (possibly heavy according to Michael Angold)[3] |
The Battle of Constantinople in 1147 was a large-scale clash between the forces of the
Though limited in its strategic importance, the battle is significant in being a rare instance where Byzantine tactical dispositions are described in detail in the primary sources of the period.
Background
The
Conrad had insulted Manuel by calling him "King of the
Manuel wished to induce the crusaders to cross to Asia Minor by the
Battle
The Byzantine force was placed under the command of two generals, Prosouch and Basil Tzikandyles. They were instructed to make a stand confronting the Germans, and by their presence provoke an attack. The Byzantine army was smaller than that of the crusaders but, as the contemporary Byzantine historian John Kinnamos states, "it was equally superior in military science and perseverance in battle".[11][12] Prosouch and Tzikandyles had earlier been sent to observe the German army at a place called Longoi. They had reported to Emperor Manuel that, although the Germans were individually impressive and well armoured, their cavalry was not swift and they lacked discipline.[13]
The array of the Byzantine army, unusually, is described in some detail by Kinnamos. To the fore, "far forward", were four units (
The Byzantinist John Birkenmeier argues that this array was dictated by the particular circumstances of the battle; the Byzantines knew the ground intimately as it was just beyond the walls of Constantinople, and were aware of the German dispositions, so that they did not need to use their horse archers as a scouting or screening force. Indeed, the Byzantine array was more like that used by Alexios I Komnenos at the Battle of Philomelion in 1117, where the infantry were used to blunt enemy attacks allowing the cavalry to make controlled counter-attacks from behind the infantry's protective screen. In addition the lighter-armed troops, by being placed in the rear, could both cover a retreat or exploit a victory, depending on circumstances.[16]
According to Kinnamos, that part of the crusading army confronted by the Byzantines was "seized by a great eagerness and disorder" and attacked "at a run". A fierce battle developed; in response to the reckless attack of the Germans, the Byzantines "scientifically resisted and slew them".[11] A contemporary encomium (collection of praise poems) addressed to Manuel I describes the Cuman horse archers as playing a notable part in the fighting.[8][12] The Germans suffered heavy casualties.[10] It is clear that not all of the German crusading army was involved in the conflict; Conrad was with another, possibly larger, section of the army. He appears to have been at a considerable distance from the scene of the action as he did not learn of the reverse that his troops had suffered for some time.[17]
Aftermath
The show of military force on the part of the Byzantines persuaded Conrad to accede to Manuel's wishes and have the bulk of his army speedily ferried across the Bosporos to
Meeting up with the French army at Nicaea, the combined crusader force then took the coastal route towards Attaleia. Though within nominal Byzantine territory, the crusaders continued to be attacked by the Turks who were allegedly aided by the local Greek population. Though the bulk of his army marched to Attaleia, Conrad took ship with his entourage at Ephesus and sailed back to Constantinople. Manuel received him magnificently and personally gave him medical attention when he fell ill. The rapprochement between the two sovereigns was sealed with the negotiation of a dynastic marriage. Manuel undertook to ship Conrad's now diminished force to Palestine, where the forces of the Second Crusade ultimately met with failure when defeated outside the walls of Damascus.[18]
See also
- Komnenian army
References
- ^ Kinnamos, p. 62
- ^ Norwich (1995), pp. 94–95
- ^ Angold, p. 165
- ^ Angold, p. 165
- ^ Angold, p. 164
- ^ Kinnamos, pp. 61–63
- ^ Choniates, pp. 37–38
- ^ a b Manganeios Prodromos
- ^ Runciman, pp. 266–267
- ^ a b c Angold, p. 165
- ^ a b c Kinnamos, p. 65
- ^ a b Harris, p. 104
- ^ Kinnamos, p. 62
- ^ Birkenmeier p. 110
- ^ Kinnamos, p. 203
- ^ Birkenmeier, pp. 79 and 110–111
- ^ Kinnamos, pp. 65–67
- ^ Angold, pp. 165–167
Sources
Primary
- Choniates, Niketas; Magoulias, Harry J. (1984). O City of Byzantium: Annals of Niketas Choniates. Detroit, Michigan: Wayne State University Press. ISBN 0-8143-1764-2.
- Kinnamos, John; Brand, Charles M. (trans.) (1976). Deeds of John and Manuel Comnenus. New York, New York: Columbia University Press. ISBN 0-231-04080-6.
- 'Manganeios Prodromos': a verse encomium to Manuel in Codex Marcianus Graecus XI.22 known as Manganeios Prodromos, poems 20 and 24. See Jeffreys-Jeffreys, p. 102 and Magdalino, p. 49.
Secondary
- ISBN 9780582294684.
- Birkenmeier, John W. (2002). The Development of the Komnenian Army: 1081–1180. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill Academic Publishers. ISBN 90-04-11710-5.
- Harris, Jonathan (2013) Byzantium and the Crusades, 2nd Edition, Bloomsbury, New York, London, New Delhi, Sydney.
- Jeffreys, Elizabeth; Jeffreys Michael (2001). "The "Wild Beast from the West": Immediate Literary Reactions in Byzantium to the Second Crusade" (PDF). In ISBN 0-88402-277-3. Archived from the original(PDF) on 2009-03-26. Retrieved 2014-06-30.
- ISBN 0-521-52653-1.
- ISBN 978-0-670-82377-2.
- Runciman, Steven (1952). A History of the Crusades, Volume II: The Kingdom of Jerusalem and the Frankish East, 1100–1187. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.