Ivan L. Rudnytsky
Ivan L. Rudnytsky | |
---|---|
Іван Лисяк Рудницький | |
Born | Joannes Lysiak[6] 27 October 1919 |
Died | 25 April 1984 Edmonton, Canada | (aged 64)
Spouses |
|
Children |
|
Parents | |
Thesis | Mychajlo Drahomanov: A contribution to the development of political ideas in Eastern Europe ((in German)) (1945) |
Doctoral advisor | Eduard Winter |
Influences | |
Academic work | |
Discipline | History |
Institutions | |
Main interests | History of Ukraine |
Notable works | Essays in Modern Ukrainian History |
Influenced |
Ivan Pavlovych Lysiak Rudnytsky (
Personal background
Ivan Rudnytsky was born in Vienna, Austria where his parents were residing as political refugees from Galicia, which had been invaded by Poland in the aftermath of its successful war against the West Ukrainian People's Republic (1918 – 1919).[9] His father Pavlo Lysiak was a lawyer and his mother Milena Rudnytska was a professor and politician. Both were well-known social and political activists from well connected families. In his youth, Ivan grew to become an intellectual gourmet growing up within the intensely stimulating environment of the extended Rudnytsky family of luminaries: Ivan Kedryn-Rudnytsky (prominent political leader and publicist of Ukrainian identity),[10] Myhailo Rudnytsky (literary scholar, literary critic, translator),[11] Antin Rudnytsky (conductor and composer)[12] and Volodymyr Rudnytsky (lawyer and social activist). After his parents divorced when Ivan was 2 years old he lived with his mother, but his material needs to support his intellectual pursuits were taken care of up to 1953 in large part due to his father and mother’s financial help.[13]
Intellectual development
Rudnytsky began his academic career at the
Driven by a desire to combat the influence of the Ukrainian nationalists, Rudnytsky became a leading member of several student organizations in the 1940s.[16] He was a member of the Ukrainian student society "Mazepyneć", the Ukrainian Student Group in Prague, and the Nationalist Organization of Ukrainian Students of Greater Germany (together with Vasyl Rudko and Omeljan Pritsak). He was a briefly a member of a conservative, monarchist hetmanite organization but was expelled in 1940 by the leadership for meeting an old acquaintance of his mother’s who was associated with the Ukrainian People's Republic, an action they regarded as political treason.[17]
After the war, Rudnytsky attended the
Focus of work
As a result of his early interest in German transcendental philosophy of the 19th and 20th centuries, Rudnytsky’s chief academic interest became the study of historical cognition. In keeping with the evolutionary outlook of idealism characteristic in German historicism, Rudnytsky used history to understand the development of socio-political thought, particularly that of Ukraine from the mid-nineteenth century to the 1930s.[1]
The main focus of Rudnytsky’s work revolved around the following topics:[20]
- The concept and problem of “historical” and “non-historical” nations;
- The intellectual origins of modern Ukraine and the structure of nineteenth-century Ukrainian history;
- The problem of the intelligentsia and intellectual development in Ukraine in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries;
- Galicia under the Habsburg Empireand its contribution to the Ukrainian struggle for statehood;
- The Ukrainian revolution of 1917—21 and the Fourth Universal in the historical context of Ukrainian political thought, or autonomy vs. independence;
- Ukraine within the Soviet system;
- Galician Ukrainian inter-war nationalism;
- Ukrainians and their nearest neighbours, the Poles and the Russians;
- 1848 in Galicia: an evaluation of political pamphlets.
Legacy
According to Eastern Europe historian Timothy Snyder, Rudnytsky decisively argued against the proposition that Ukraine ought to be a homogeneous nation - that it should be exclusively for and about people who spoke Ukrainian and shared Ukrainian culture. Rudnytsky believed, as Mykhailo Hrushevsky did, in Ukraine's social historical continuity of development towards an independent democratic nation,[21][22] and also believed, as Vyacheslav Lypynsky did, that its destiny was to be pluralistic.[23] The opposing view in Ukraine was championed by Dmytro Dontsov who took his cues from Italian fascism[24] and became the far right conservative voice of Ukrainian ethnic nationalism.[25] According to Snyder, Rudnytsky’s response to ethnic nationalism won the argument, both in Ukraine and among North American Ukrainian expatriates, about what the Ukrainian nation should be. Instead of the nation looking for legitimacy in dubious historical claims or assertions of a homogeneous culture, Rudnytsky’s view was that a nation is fundamentally the result of political acts of commitment directed at a common future, which means that in principle, anyone can take part in it.[26]
Works
Books
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (1988) [1987]. Essays in Modern Ukrainian History. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 9780916458195. Retrieved 21 November 2021.
- Basarab, John; Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (1982). Pereiaslav 1654: A Historiographical Study. Edmonton: Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies Press (CIUS) Press, ISBN 978-0920862162.
Books in Ukrainian:
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (2019). ISBN 9789663787084. Retrieved 21 November 2021.
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (1973). Між історією й політикою: Статті до історії та критики української [Between History and Politics:Articles on the History and Criticism of Ukraine] (in Ukrainian). Munich: Suchasnist.
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (1994). ISBN 5770764856.
Rudnytsky edited books
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L.; Himka, John-Paul, eds. (1981). Rethinking Ukrainian History. Edmonton, Alberta: ISBN 978-0920862124.
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L., ed. (1952). Mykhaylo Drahomanov : a Symposium and Selected Writings. New York: The Ukrainian Academy Of Arts And Sciences.
Individual essays
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (1987). Essays in Modern Ukrainian History. Edmonton, Alberta: Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies (CIUS), University of Alberta. ISBN 0-920862-47-0. Retrieved 21 November 2021.
- Rudnytsky, Ivan L. (2014) [1984]. "Various articles". OCLC 724265856.
- Drahomanov, Mykhailo. Vol. 1. (WP article: Mykhailo Drahomanov)
- Ukrainian Radical party. Vol. 5. 1993. (WP article: Ukrainian Radical party))
- Conservatism. Vol. 1. 1984.
- Nationalism. Vol. 3. 1993.
- Feudalism. Vol. 1. 1984.
- Transcarpathia. Vol. 5. 1993. (WP article: Transcarpathia)
- Lypynsky, Viacheslav. 2009. (WP article: Vyacheslav Lypynsky)
- Masaryk, Tomáš Garrigue. Vol. 3. 1993. (WP article: Tomáš Masaryk)
- Poles in Ukraine. Vol. 3. 1993.
- Terletsky, Ipolit Volodymyr. Vol. 5. 1993. (WP article: Hipolit Volodymyr Terletsky)
References
- ^ a b Pritsak 1987, p. xvii.
- ^ a b Snyder 2022.
- ^ Pritsak 1987, p. xv, xvii.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 16.
- ^ Pritsak 1987, p. xxi.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 98.
- ^ Hrytsak 2020, p. 543.
- ^ Pritsak 1987, pp. xvi, xviii.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 2.
- ^ Yaniv 1993.
- ^ Koshelivets 1993.
- ^ Wytwycky 1993.
- ^ Pritsak 1987, pp. xv–xvii.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 19.
- ^ Winter 1981, p. 134.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 22.
- ^ Gyidel 2019, p. 14.
- ^ Enc. Ukraine- Rudnytsky, 2022.
- ^ Dunch 2019.
- ^ Pritsak 1987, p. xix.
- ^ Rudnytsky Chapt07, p. 129.
- ^ Ohloblyn & Wynar 1989.
- ^ Rudnytsky Chapt21, p. 448.
- ^ Genkin 2021.
- ^ Rudnytsky Chapt19, p. 434.
- ^ SnyderClass2 2022, pp. 31:19-42:59.
Bibliography
- Dunch, Ryan (2019). "Symposium:Ivan Lysiak Rudnytsky: Diarist, Historian, Political Thinker". Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies. University of Alberta. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- "Rudnytsky, Ivan Lysiak". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Shevchenko Scientific Society. 2022. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Genkin, Maria (26 October 2021). "The Conflicting Life of Dmytro Dontsov: A Review of Trevor Erlacher's Ukrainian Nationalism in the Age of Extremes". Apofenie. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Gyidel, Ernest (2019). "A historian of a "non-historical" nation- Ivan L. Rudnytsky and development of Ukrainian Studies in North America" (pdf). Academia.edu. University of Alberta. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- ISBN 978-1644693018. Retrieved 23 November 2022.
- Koshelivets, Ivan (1993). "Mykhailo Rudnytsky". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Vol. 4. Shevchenko Scientific Society. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Ohloblyn, Oleksander; Wynar, Lubomyr (1989). "Hrushevsky, Mykhailo". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Vol. 2. Shevchenko Scientific Society. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Rudnytsky, Peter (1987). "Preface". Essays in Modern Ukrainian History. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 9780916458195.
- ISBN 9780916458195.
- Snyder, Timothy (28 January 2022). "Part 6: Nation of Choice". King of Ukraine. SubstackThinking about. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Yale university) – via YouTube.
See 33:10 for Hrushevsky's social historian contribution. See 37:04 for Lypynsky's response to those misusing Hrushevshky and equating the nation with a particular ethnic culture. See 41:28 for establishing this historical context for Rudnytsky's contribution (nation as a political act directed at the future) and Snyder's statement that Rudnytsky's response to Dontsov and the ethnic nationalists is decisive ("he wins"). Click Youtube options ( • • • )for complete transcript.
- Winter, Eduard (1981). Mein Leben im Dienst des Völkerverständnisses- nach Tagebuchaufzeichnungen, Briefen, Dokumenten und Erinnerungen. Akademie-Verlag.
- Wytwycky, Wasyl (1993). "Antin Rudnytsky". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Vol. 4. Shevchenko Scientific Society. Retrieved 21 November 2022.
- Yaniv, Sofiia (1993). "Kedryn, Ivan". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Vol. 4. Shevchenko Scientific Society. Retrieved 21 November 2022.