Military career of Bhoja
The 11th century
Apart from epigraphic records, much of the information about Bhoja's military campaigns comes from legendary accounts, including Hemachandra (12th century), Merutunga's Prabandha-Chintamani (14th century), Rajavallabha's Bhoja-Charitra (15th century), and Ballala's Bhoja-Prabandha (17th century).
Chaulukyas: Vallabha and Durlabha
The kingdom of the
According to the 12th century writer
The 14th century writer Merutunga claims that it was Vallabha's successor Durlabha-raja who passed through Malwa on his way to Kashi, and Munja was the Paramara king at the time. However, this account is historically inaccurate, because Munja died nearly a decade before Durlabha's ascension.[7] Sukrita Sankirtana by Arisimha and Sukrita-Kirti-Kallolini by Udayaprabha Suri, both written under the patronage of Chaulukyas and their successors, claim that Vallabha defeated the king of Malwa. These claims are not supported by any historical evidence either. Only the fact that Vallabha marched against Malwa appears to be historically true, as suggested by the Vadnagar Prashasti inscription of the later Chaulukya king Kumarapala. This inscription claims that the king of Malwa felt a quake on hearing about Vallabharaja's march against him.[8]
Durlabha became the Chaulukya king around 1009 CE, so Vallabha's invasion of Malwa must have happened before this time. Some scholars, such as D. C. Ganguly and K. N. Seth identify Vallabha's rival as Bhoja, who according to them, had just assumed the throne of Malwa around 1008 CE.[4][5] Other scholars, such as Mahesh Singh, believe that Bhoja's ascension took place after 1009 CE, and therefore Vallabha's rival must have been Bhoja's predecessor Sindhuraja.[9]
According to a legend mentioned by Hemachandra, Vallabha's successor Durlabha also fought against the ruler of Malwa. According to this account, Mahendra-raja, the
Chalukyas of Lata
Bhoja's first military aggression appears to be his invasion of the
The ruler defeated by Bhoja appears to be Kirtiraja, who belonged to a
Bhoja did not depose the Chalukyas of Lata: the epigraphic evidence suggests that the dynasty continued even after this defeat. Kirtiraja may have become independent after serving as a feudatory of Bhoja for a brief period.[17][18]
Shilaharas of Konkana
Bhoja's invasion of Lata brought him close to the
In 1017 CE, the Shilahara king Arikesari was independent of Bhoja, as suggested by his 1017 CE inscription discovered at Thane. The Betma copper-plate inscription of Bhoja, dated 3 January 1020 CE, indicates that northern Konkana was under the Paramara control by this date. Therefore, Bhoja must have invaded Konkan sometime during 1017-1020 CE.[20] Bhoja's conquest of Konkana was a first for a Paramara king in this region. He celebrated this victory in a big way by making generous donations to Brahmins. His 1020 CE inscription states that he organized a Konkana-Grahana Vijaya Parva ("Konkan Victory Festival").[21]
The Shilaharas probably continued to administer Konkana as Bhoja's vassals.[22] By the end of his reign, Bhoja had lost the control of this territory. According to D. B. Diskalkar, the Western Chalukya king Jayasimha II conquered this region from Bhoja. The 1024 CE Miraj inscription of Jayasimha states that after subduing the lords of "the seven Konkanas", he encamped near Kolhapur in order to conquer the northern regions. Diskalkar believed that the term "northern regions" here refers to northern Konkana, which Jayasimha must have captured some time before 1024 CE. The critics of this theory point out that the Miraj inscription only refers to a plan, not the actual conquest of the northern regions. Moreover, none of the Chalukya inscriptions refer to their victory over the Paramaras in Konkana, although they mention their other successes against Bhoja. According to P. V. Kane, the lords defeated by Jayasimha were the Kadambas of Goa.[23] K. N. Seth believes that it was Jayasimha's successor Someshvara I, who evicted the Paramaras from northern Konkana, around 1047 CE.[24]
Chalukyas of Kalyani: Jayasimha II
The
The Chalukya inscriptions state that they forced Bhoja's army to retreat. The 1019 CE
D. C. Ganguly believes that Bhoja achieved some early victories against the Chalukyas, but was ultimately defeated. Others, including D. B. Diskalkar and H. C. Ray, believe that Bhoja was defeated by Jayasimha after some early successes, but ultimately emerged victorious against the Chalukyas after 1028 CE. According to Georg Bühler, the struggle probably ended with some advantage for Bhoja, which might have been exaggerated into a great victory by the Paramara poets.[31]
Swati Datta notes that the 1022 CE Depalpur inscription of Bhoja records the grant of a village to a
A Bhoja-Charitra legend claims that shortly after becoming the king, Bhoja saw a play which depicted the killing of his uncle Munja by Tailapa. An enraged Bhoja launched an expedition against Tailapa, captured him, humiliated him and finally executed him. The story is historically inaccurate, as Tailapa died before Bhoja ascended the throne.[33]
Indraratha
The Udaipur Prashasti states that Bhoja defeated a ruler named Indraratha. A king with the same name is also mentioned in
The
According to the 16th century Muslim historian
Mahmud attacked the
Firishta also states that in 1043 CE, the Raja of Delhi formed an alliance with other Hindu kings to re-capture the territories lost to Mahmud of Ghazni. The allies expelled Mahmud's governors from
A
Chandelas and Kachchhapaghatas
The
Bhoja was able to extend his influence among the Chandela feudatories, possibly after Vidyadhara's death. The Kachchhapaghatas of Dubkund were the northern neighbours of the Paramaras. During Arjuna's reign, they were Chandela vassals. However, Arjuna's successor Abhimanyu accepted Bhoja's suzerainty. The 1088 CE Dubkund inscription of Abhimanyu's grandson Vikramasimha states that the intelligent and illustrious king Bhoja-deva praised Abhimanyu's skills as a general.[45]
The 1092 CE Sasbahu Temple inscription of the Kachchhapaghata ruler Mahipala states that his ancestor Kirtiraja defeated the prince of Malava, whose soldiers fled the battlefield, leaving behind their spears. Earlier scholars identified the defeated king as Bhoja, but it is more likely that this king was his predecessor Sindhuraja.[30]
Gurjaras
According to the Udaipur Prashasti inscription, Bhoja defeated the
The Gurjara-Pratihara capital was located at Kanyakubja (Kannauj). After their decline, the area around Kanyakubja was controlled by the
In any case, historical evidence indicates that Bhoja could not retain control of Kannauj for a long time, if at all.
Sahavahana
The 1046 CE Tilakawada copper plate inscription states that Bhoja's general Suraditya stabilized his royal fortune by slaughtering one Sahavahana in a battle.[49]
Earlier scholars, including D. C. Ganguly and K. M. Munshi, identified Sahavahana with Sahila Verman of Chamba's Mushana dynasty. This identification is not correct, as Sahila Verman's reign ended in the mid-10th century, much before Bhoja's ascension. Another theory identifies Sahavahana with Salavahana, a descendant of Sahila Verman. However, it is unlikely that the small hill state of Chamba could gather an army formidable enough to destabilize Bhoja's kingdom, located nearly 1,500 km away from Chamba.[50]
D. B. Diskalkar believed "Sahavahana" to be a variant of "
According to K. N. Seth, Sahavahana might not have been a king at all, as the inscription does not mention his title. He might have been a general of one of Bhoja's rivals, possibly the Kalachuri king Karna.[52]
Chahamanas
The various branches of the Chahamana[disambiguation needed]s occupied territories to the north of Bhoja's kingdom. Later texts such as Surjana-Charita, Hammira-Kavya and Prabandha Kosha claim that the Shakambhari Chahamana king Vakpati II defeated Bhoja. These sources provide also provide some fictitious details about the supposed conflict. However, this claim is not reliable.[53] According to the Prithviraja Vijaya, Bhoja defeated and killed Vakpati's successor Viryarama. If Vakpati had indeed defeated Bhoja, Bhoja's campaign against Viryarama may have been aimed at avenging this defeat.[16]
Encouraged by this success, he also waged a war against the Chahamanas of Naddula (Nadol). But in this second campaign, his army was forced to retreat, and his general Sadha was killed in a battle against Anahilla.[54]
Chalukyas of Kalyani: Someshvara I
During the last years of Bhoja's reign, Jayasimha's son and successor
Multiple Chalukya inscriptions dated between 1058 and 1067 CE state that Someshvara invaded Malwa, and plundered its important cities, including Dhara, Ujjayni and Mandapa. Vikramankadeva-Charita by Bilhana, a court-poet of Someshvara's son Vikramaditya VI, states that Bhoja deserted his capital Dhara, which was then sacked by Someshvara. Kuvalayananda of the 16th century philosopher Appayya Dikshita also appears to refer to this attack on Malwa by Kuntaleshvara ("Lord of Kuntala", presumably Someshvara I).[55]
Someshvara's generals in this expedition included Gundamaya, Jomarasa, Madhusudana (Madhuva) and Nagadeva.[56] The 1058 CE Nagai inscription of Madhusudana states that the Chalukya king burned Dhara and Ujjayini. It credits Madhusudana with forcing the ruler of Dhara to flee the city. A 1059-1060 CE states that Nagadeva was like "a garuda to the serpent Bhoja". A 1060 CE inscription names Gundamaya as the general who captured the Mandapa fort. The 1067 CE Hottur inscription of Jomarasa describes him as "a flame of doom to Bhoja".[57]
Kalachuris of Tripuri: Gangeya
The
Bhoja and Gangeya were once part of an alliance against the
A contradictory theory is that the two turned enemies after their Chalukya campaign.
The Hindi-language aphorism "Kahaan Raja Bhoj, kahan Gangu Teli" ("where is King Bhoj, where is Gangu Teli") contrasts something very important with something very inconsequential. According to K. N. Seth, the term "Gangu Teli" may have derived from Bhoja's victory over Gangeya ("Gangu") and the ruler of Telangana ("Teli").[61]
The Udaipur Prashasti also claims that Bhoja defeated one Togglala.[65] S. K. Bose identifies this person with Gangeya's predecessor Kokalla II.[66]
Last days
Chaulukyas: Bhima
According to Merutunga, the
Bhima launched an expedition against the Paramara branch at Abu, some time before 1031 CE. Dhandhuka, the ruler of Abu, had to seek shelter with Bhoja as a result. Bhima installed Vimala of the Pragvata family as his governor in Abu. The shrine of Adinatha in Abu was commissioned by Vimala in 1031 CE, so Bhima must have defeated Dhandhuka before this year. According to Jinaprabha Suri's Tirtha Kalpa, Bhima later restored Dhandhuka as his vassal.[69]
Kalachuris of Tripuri: Karna
Karna, the Kalachuri king of Tripuri and the successor of Gangeya, attacked the Paramara kingdom during the last years of Bhoja's reign, or after his death. According to a legend mentioned by Merutunga, Karna challenged Bhoja to either a war or a palace-building contest. Bhoja, who was an old man by this time, chose the second option. The contest involved construction of a palace of pre-determined height in the shortest time possible. Karna managed to build his palace in Kashi, while Bhoja's palace in Ujjain remained incomplete. The loser of the contest was supposed to accept the victor's suzerainty, but Bhoja went back on his words. Therefore, Karna, in alliance with Bhima of Gujarat, invaded Malwa. According to Merutunga, Bhoja died of a disease at the same time the allied army attacked his kingdom.[72][73]
Alliance of Bhima and Karna
The historicity of Merutunga's legend is doubtful, but it might have some historical basis.[74] The Nagpur inscription of Bhoja's grandson Udayaditya mentions that he removed the "clouds of difficulties" which had spread over the Paramara capital Dhara after Bhoja's death. It appears that the alliance of Bhima and Karna attacked Malwa shortly before Bhoja died or after his death.[75]
The
Some historians, such as R. D. Banerji and H. C. Raychaudhuri, proposed that Bhoja died while facing a defeat at the hands of the enemy confederacy. According to Raychaudhuri, besides Karna and Bhima, the confederacy may have included Someshvara (Chalukya of Kalyani) and Trilochanapala (Chalukya of Lata).[75] However, other historians believe that the Karna-led invasion of Dhara happened after Bhoja's death.[77][74]
See also
- Bhoja
- Paramara dynasty
- History of Madhya Pradesh
- List of rulers of Malwa
- List of Rajput dynasties and states
References
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 155–156.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 162–163.
- ^ a b Mahesh Singh 1984, pp. 60–62.
- ^ a b c Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 130–131.
- ^ a b Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 39.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 38.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 135.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 132.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 40.
- ^ Asoke Kumar Majumdar 1956, p. 40.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 133–134.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 41.
- ^ Asoke Kumar Majumdar 1956, pp. 40–41.
- ^ a b c Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 136.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 43.
- ^ a b c d Arvind K. Singh 2012, p. 20.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 137.
- ^ a b c Sailendra Nath Sen 1999, p. 320.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 138.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 139.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 140–141.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 46.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 141–142.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 144.
- ^ M. C. Choubey 2006, p. 63.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 144–145.
- ^ Saikat K. Bose 2015, p. 27.
- ^ a b c Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 145.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 48.
- ^ a b Arvind K. Singh 2012, p. 19.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 50.
- ^ Swati Datta 1989, p. 99.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 146.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 167–168.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, pp. 56–57.
- ^ a b Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 60.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 155.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 157.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 158.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 163–165.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, pp. 61–62.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 166.
- ^ Alf Hiltebeitel 2009, pp. 273–275.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 69.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, pp. 172–173.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 174–175.
- ^ Roma Niyogi 1959, p. 43-44.
- ^ Roma Niyogi 1959, p. 15.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 175.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 175–176.
- ^ Harihar Vitthal Trivedi 1991, p. 52.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 176.
- ^ Dasharatha Sharma 1959, p. 34.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 177.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 151–153.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 153.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 154.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 56.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 168–169.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 64.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 170.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 65.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 171.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 66.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 36.
- ^ Saikat K. Bose 2015, p. 281.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 178.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 148-150.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 180–181.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, pp. 179–180.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 181.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 182.
- ^ a b Mahesh Singh 1984, pp. 66–67.
- ^ a b Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 183.
- ^ a b Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 67.
- ^ Krishna Narain Seth 1978, p. 184.
- ^ Mahesh Singh 1984, p. 68.
Bibliography
- ISBN 9780226340555.
- Arvind K. Singh (2012). "Interpreting the History of the Paramāras". Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society. 22 (1): 13–28. JSTOR 41490371.
- Asoke Kumar Majumdar (1956). Chaulukyas of Gujarat. Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan. OCLC 4413150.
- Harihar Vitthal Trivedi (1991). Inscriptions of the Paramāras, Chandēllas, Kachchapaghātas, and two minor dynasties. Archaeological Survey of India.
- Krishna Narain Seth (1978). The Growth of the Paramara Power in Malwa. Progress. OCLC 8931757.
- M. C. Choubey (2006). Tripurī, history and culture. Sharada. ISBN 9788188934287.
- Mahesh Singh (1984). Bhoja Paramāra and His Times. Bharatiya Vidya Prakashan. OCLC 11786897.
- Roma Niyogi (1959). The History of the Gāhaḍavāla Dynasty. Oriental. OCLC 5386449.
- Sailendra Nath Sen (1999). Ancient Indian History and Civilization. New Age International. ISBN 9788122411980.
- Swati Datta (1989). Migrant Brāhmaṇas in Northern India. Motilal Banarsidass. ISBN 978-81-208-0067-0.
- Saikat K. Bose (2015). Boot, Hooves and Wheels: And the Social Dynamics behind South Asian Warfare. Vij Books. ISBN 978-9-38446-454-7.