Criticism of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action
The
In Iran, debate over the deal has become representative of a number of persisting social, economic, and political conflicts that have played a large role in the rift between
Background and content
Negotiation on Iran's nuclear program between the international community and Iran have occurred on and off since 2006, however the negotiations that led to the 2015 framework agreement, and the eventual final agreement, began in March 2013.
Further negotiations between P5+1 and Iran took place over the course of 2014 in pursuit of a more comprehensive deal. In June 2014, the deadline to meet the goal of a comprehensive agreement was not met and the deadline was therefore extended to November 2014. After the goal of November 2014 was not met, another extension was made to June 2015.[11]
In April 2015, the negotiations produced a
As of 2018,
Key provisions
- Reduction of Iran's stockpile of Isfahan Province, Iran.
- An exhaustive system of inspections by international observers from the fiber opticseals on equipment, sensors, and surveillance cameras. Dedicated IAEA inspectors for Iran, will triple from 50 to 150. IAEA inspectors also have the ability to request physical access to sites if specific concerns of non-compliance arise.
- Iran will cut down on the number of operational IAEAsupervision.
- Iran is forbidden from constructing additional heavy water sites or accumulating additional heavy water for a period of fifteen years. Iran's existing Arak heavy water reactor site will be forbidden from producing power above 20 MWth (megawatt thermal) and will undergo a redesign to limit its capability to produce weapons grade plutonium. All heavy water in Iran's possession that exceeds the limitations of the deal will be placed for sale on the international market.
- Iran will not participate in spent fuel reprocessing in any capacity for a period of fifteen years and all spent fuel in Iran will be shipped out of the country.
- The centrifugescurrently installed at Fordow, only 1,044 will be allowed to remain. Enriching of uranium at the site will also be heavily restricted.
- A "snapback" mechanism that automatically replaces all
Controversial features
Sanctions relief
The lifting of economic and military sanctions on Iran led to much ire among conservatives and some liberals in the United States who viewed the move as detrimental to security in the region.
Effect on Israel
Shortly after the announcement of the deal, critics within the
Benjamin Netanyahu, who called the Iran nuclear deal a "historic mistake", told President Barack Obama that Israel was under increased threat because of the deal and said in a statement, "In the coming decade, the deal will reward Iran, the terrorist regime in Tehran, with hundreds of billions of dollars. This cash bonanza will fuel Iran’s terrorism worldwide, its aggression in the region and its efforts to destroy Israel, which are ongoing."[21] Many conservatives in the United States claimed the deal would usher a financial windfall for Iranian sponsored groups in the Middle East that pose a threat to Israel including Hezbollah and Hamas. In addition the lack of focus on Iran's ballistic missile program and the lifting of weapons embargoes was also viewed as a peril for Israel.[22] President Donald Trump criticized what he viewed as the deal's "near total silence on Iran's missile programs."[23]
Inspection regime
Under the deal, international monitors are authorized to monitor declared Iranian nuclear sites through numerous electronic means including but not limited to: fiber-optic seals, cameras, sensors that detect radioactive particles, and commercial satellite imagery. President Obama said that
Opposition in Iran
Iran was less bitterly divided over the deal than the United States but opposition in the form of hardliners, especially in more conservative religious institutions such as the
Iranian president Hassan Rouhani, who in many ways paved the way for the deal, said the alternative to the deal was an "economic Stone Age" brought on by sanctions and economic isolation. He also chastised the Revolutionary Guard Corps for its opposition.[30] Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei gave his tacit approval of the deal and characterized it as a win for Iran exclaiming, "After 12 years of struggling with the Islamic republic, the result is that they have to bear the turning of thousands of centrifuges in the country", a move that is likely to quell the resistance of the country's hardliner factions.[31]
Hardliners are against the deal for a variety of the reasons, notably their desire to turn Iran into a nuclear armed state in order to deter the United States and Israel, its violations of the Ayatollah Khamenei's red lines, and their belief that international inspections are a front for American intelligence-gathering.[32] Unofficially, members of the Revolutionary Guard worry that opening Iran up to global trade with the removal of sanctions will impede the organization's profits. The Revolutionary Guard Corps is believed to control a third of Iran's economy, a staggeringly high figure that could be reduced with more international commerce.[33] Economic liberalization brought on by the deal could loosen the IRGC's control of the economy and lead to fresh resentment within the organization. In addition, the removal of U.S. sanctions also denies the Guard Corps from using the United States, or the West for that matter, as a propaganda tool and scapegoat for Iran's domestic problems.[34]
One of the most prominent opponents of the JCPOA in Iran is former Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council Saeed Jalili who lambasted the deal and its negotiators for having offered too many concessions to American negotiators.[35] Jalili claimed the nuclear deal "violated Iran's independence and national sovereignty."[36]
Media in Iran is also divided on partisan lines as well, with conservative newspapers such as the
In many ways, the battle over the
Challenges
Outside of conservative political backlash there still remains a great litany of economic, social, and military challenges to the implementation of the Iran nuclear deal within Iran itself. Much of the popular support for the Iran deal comes from the public's perception of economic upsurges as a result of the sanctions relief brought on by the
Iran's increasing military involvement in the
Opposition in the United States
Political opposition
The Iran deal was met with almost unanimous derision and denunciation by
In the
Representative
A
In September 2015, Republican congressional leaders organized a
On the contrary,
The
Polling
A
Experts
William H. Tobey, a senior fellow in
In August 2015, a letter signed by 190 former generals and admirals was sent to Congressional leaders expressing opposition to the bill. The letter argued that the deal put too many limitations on IAEA access to Iranian sites, would provide Iran with $150 billion in sanctions relief much of which would surely go funding
Trump administration
The Trump administration has characterized Iran as an adversary of the United States on numerous occasions and has been critical of the government in Tehran and the Iran nuclear deal. Over the course of the 2016 election, Donald Trump repeatedly attacked the deal. During a speech to the pro-Israel lobbying group AIPAC he said dismantling the Iranian nuclear deal was his first priority.[72] During a presidential debate he described it as a "horrible deal".[73]
After assuming office, Trump administration
On 8 May 2018, Trump announced United States withdrawal from JCPOA.[81]
See also
- Nuclear facilities in Iran
- Joint Plan of Action
- Iran nuclear deal framework
- Iran and weapons of mass destruction
- Views on the nuclear program of Iran
- Timeline of the nuclear program of Iran
- Iran Nuclear Achievements Protection Act
References
- ^ The Times Editorial Board (2018-01-13). "Trump is inching closer to blowing up the Iran nuclear deal". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Reuters Editorial (2015-07-14). "McConnell says Iran agreement flawed, promises thorough review". U.S. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
{{cite web}}
:|author=
has generic name (help) - ^ Erdbrink, Thomas (2015-07-14). "Iran Celebrates Nuclear Deal, Tempered by Cynicism and Hard-Liner Warnings". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Not Everyone's Happy: Hardliners in Iran Criticize Geneva Nuclear Deal". Time. 2013-11-25. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Fisher, Max (2016-03-02). "How the nuclear deal boosted Iran's moderates - and showed Iranian elections can matter". Vox. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Timeline of Nuclear Diplomacy With Iran". Arms Control Association. 2018-01-12. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Reuters Editorial (2013-11-24). "U.S., Iran held secret talks on march to nuclear deal". U.S. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
{{cite web}}
:|author=
has generic name (help) - ^ Naji, Kasra (2017-05-20). "Profile: Hassan Rouhani". BBC News. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "At inauguration Hassan Rouhani urges more talks". Al Jazeera. 2017-08-05. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "World powers reach nuclear deal with Iran to freeze its nuclear program". Washington Post. 2013-11-23. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Lyons, Kate (2015-07-14). "Iran nuclear talks: timeline". the Guardian. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Borger, Julian; Lewis, Paul (2015-04-02). "Iran nuclear deal: negotiators announce 'framework' agreement". the Guardian. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Porter, Gareth (2015-09-05). "Behind the Scenes: How the US and Iran Reached Their Landmark Deal". The Nation. Archived from the original on 2016-12-21. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ IAEA Director General Yukiya Amano: Introductory remarks at press conference, 5 March 2018.
- ^ Panda, Ankit; Diplomat, The (2015-07-15). "How the Iran Deal's 'Snap Back' Mechanism Will Keep Tehran Compliant". The Diplomat. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Key Excerpts of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA)". whitehouse.gov. 2015-07-14. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Lawmakers alarmed over Iranian nuclear windfall". USA Today. 2015-07-05. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Gladstone, Rick (2015-08-05). "Value of Iran Sanctions Relief Is Hard to Measure". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ "Tom Cotton: No ordinary freshman congressman". Washington Post. 2012-12-05. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Beinart, Peter (2015-07-14). "Why the Iran Deal Makes Obama's Critics So Angry". The Atlantic. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Kershner, Isabel (2015-07-14). "Iran Deal Denounced by Netanyahu as 'Historic Mistake'". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ "Republican and Democratic Platforms on Iran". The Iran Primer. 2016-07-25. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ JNi.Media (2017-10-14). "Israel, Saudis, Applaud, Europe Condemns Republicans' Interjecting Realism into Iran Nuke Deal - The Jewish Press - 25 Tishri 5778 – October 14, 2017 - JewishPress.com". JewishPress.com. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ "Text and Video: Obama's Address on the Iran Nuclear Deal". The New York Times. 2015-07-14. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Kaplan, Rebecca (2015-07-14). "Obama says inspectors get access to "any" site in Iran. Is it true?". CBS News. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Lewis, Paul; Siddiqui, Sabrina; Jacobs, Ben (2015-07-15). "Republicans fume over Iran nuclear deal but hope of undermining accord is slim". the Guardian. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ "Access To Military Sites Debated As White House Reconsiders Iran Nuclear Deal". NPR. 2017-09-13. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Knott, Paul (2018-05-01). "Iran Deal: a Stepping Stone to Further Talks on Regional Security". The Globe Post. Retrieved 2018-05-02.
- ^ Naji, Kasra (2015-07-26). "Iranian press 'ordered to praise nuclear deal'". BBC News. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Erdbrink, Thomas; Gladstone, Rick (2015-07-23). "Iran's President Defends Nuclear Deal in Blunt Remarks". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Erdbrink, Thomas (2015-07-16). "Ayatollah Khamenei, Backing Iran Negotiators, Endorses Nuclear Deal". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Milani, Abbas; McFaul, Michael (2015-08-11). "What Do Iranians Think of the Iran Deal?". The Atlantic. Retrieved 2018-01-20.
- ^ Gregory, Mark (2010-07-26). "Iran's Revolutionary Guards and their business empire". BBC News. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ a b Milani, Abbas; McFaul, Michael (2015-08-11). "What Do Iranians Think of the Iran Deal?". The Atlantic. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ akarami. "Former Iran deal negotiator slams concessions in nuclear deal". Al-Monitor. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ISBN 978-3-319-44120-7.
- ^ Kangarlou, Tara (2015-08-13). "Tehran's Nuclear Pact Debate Mirrors Washington's". Al Jazeera America. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Iran's Guardian Council passes nuclear bill into law". Reuters.
- ^ "Poll 1: Iranian Views on Nuclear Deal". The Iran Primer. 2016-07-13. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Challenges to the Nuclear Deal: The Economy" (PDF). RAND Corporation.
- ^ "Challenges to the Nuclear Deal: Geopolitics" (PDF). RAND Corporation.
- ^ "First to Weight In: Graham". Lindsey Graham: Press Release. 2015-07-16. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ LoBianco, Tom; Tatum, Sophie (2015-07-14). "GOP 2016 hopefuls slam Iran nuclear deal - CNNPolitics". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Reuters Editorial (2015-07-14). "U.S. House Speaker Boehner says Iran accord looks like a 'bad deal'". U.S. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
{{cite web}}
:|author=
has generic name (help) - ^ Walsh, Deirdre; Barrett, Ted (2015-07-22). "Boehner vows to 'do everything' to block Iran deal - CNNPolitics". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "McConnell: Iran Deal a Result of 'Flawed Perspective' - Politics News". ABC News Radio. 2011-05-12. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Corker warns of 'breathtaking' concessions on Iran deal". USA Today. 2015-06-15. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Burr on Iran Deal: American People Aren't Buying Into Bad Deal". U.S. Senator Richard Burr of North Carolina. 2015-08-05. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Gohmert Vows To Quit Congress And Await 'Nuclear Holocaust' If Iran Deal Passes". Talking Points Memo. 2015-09-09. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Gohmert Introduces Resolution to Declare Iran Deal a Treaty and Offers Not to Run ONLY IF the Constitution is Followed Regarding the Iran Treaty". Louie Gohmert. 2015-09-09. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Mullen, Tom (2015-09-10). "Iran is Giving up Far More Than the United States in Nuclear Deal". HuffPost. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Thousands pack New York's Times Square to protest Iran nuclear deal with US". the Guardian. 2015-07-23. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Stokols, Eli; Gass, Nick (2017-12-15). "Trump storms Washington". Politico. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Donald Trump, Ted Cruz headline Capitol rally against Iran nuclear deal". Washington Post. 2015-09-09. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Yglesias, Matthew (2015-07-14). "Hillary Clinton makes the case for Obama's Iran nuclear deal". Vox. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Bernie Sanders defends Iran nuclear deal". Washington Post. 2015-08-09. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Gass, Nick (2015-07-15). "Webb breaks from 2016 Dems in dinging Iran deal". Politico. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Davis, Julie Hirschfeld (2015-08-05). "It's Either Iran Nuclear Deal or 'Some Form of War,' Obama Warns". The New York Times. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Lobbyists Spending Millions To Sway The Undecided On Iran Deal". NPR. 2015-08-06. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Agiesta, Jennifer; Diamond, Jeremy (2015-08-20). "Poll: Most Americans want Congress to reject Iran deal". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "Support for Iran Nuclear Agreement Falls". Pew Research Center for the People and the Press. 2015-09-08. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "UMD Study Finds that After Weighing Options, a Majority of Americans Approve Iran Nuclear Deal". UMD Right Now :: University of Maryland. 2015-09-02. Archived from the original on 2017-10-18. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ JTA (2015-09-11). "Jews Back Iran Deal by Narrow Margin, Poll Says". The Forward. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ "PAAIA Releases National Public Opinion Survey of Iranian Americans & the American Public - PAAIA". paaia.org. 2015-08-12. Archived from the original on 2015-08-12. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Struyk, Ryan (2017-10-20). "CNN poll: Two-thirds want to stay in Iran nuclear deal". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-13.
- ^ Mecklin, John (2015-07-14). "The experts assess the Iran agreement of 2015". Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Fleitz, Fred (2015-07-14). "Iran nuclear deal much worse than experts predicted". Fox News. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Robbins, James S. (2016-03-15). "Iran Shoots a Hole in the Nuclear Deal". U.S. News & World Report. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Read: An open letter from retired generals and admirals opposing the Iran nuclear deal". Washington Post. 2015-07-14. Archived from the original on 2017-10-18. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Read: An open letter from retired generals and admirals on the Iran nuclear deal". Washington Post. 2012-06-07. Archived from the original on 2017-08-30. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Thompson, Mark (2015-08-27). "Retired Generals Wage Letter War Over Iran Nuclear-Deal Vote". Time. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Begley, Sarah (2016-03-21). "Read Donald Trump's Speech to AIPAC". Time. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "The first Trump-Clinton presidential debate transcript, annotated". Washington Post. 2016-09-26. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Flynn Puts Iran On Notice After Ballistic Missile Test". NPR. 2017-02-02. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Savransky, Rebecca (2017-10-15). "Tillerson: Staying in the Iran deal in best interest of the US". TheHill. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Starr, Barbara; Cohen, Zachary; Browne, Ryan (2017-10-03). "Mattis: US should stay in Iran deal". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ "Trump waives Iran nuclear sanctions 'for last time'". Al Jazeera. 2018-01-12. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Diaz, Daniella (2017-09-21). "McMaster: Iran deal 'fundamentally flawed'". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Bash, Dana (2017-10-05). "Senate Dems sense McMaster not sold on decertifying Iran deal". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Diamond, Jeremy (2018-01-12). "Trump issues warning, but continues to honor Iran deal". CNN. Retrieved 2018-01-14.
- ^ Landler, Mark (8 May 2018). "Trump Abandons Iran Nuclear Deal He Long Scorned". The New York Times.