Trinitarian universalism
This article possibly contains original research. (February 2011) |
Part of a series on |
Christianity |
---|
Trinitarian universalism is a variant of belief in
History
Traditionally, the doctrine of Christian universalism was traced by Universalist historians
During the
Modern Trinitarian Universalists include Robin Parry[10] an evangelical writer, who under the pseudonym of "Gregory MacDonald" released a book The Evangelical Universalist, (2006)[11] and Thomas Talbott author of The Inescapable Love of God (1999).[12]
Theology
Thomas Talbott offers three propositions which are biblically based, but which he asserts to be mutually exclusive:
- God is omnipotent and exercises sovereign control over all aspects of human life and history.
- God is omni-benevolent, is ontologically Love, and desires the salvation of all people.
- Some (many) persons will experience everlasting, conscious torment in a place of (either literal or metaphorical) fire.[13]
Traditional theology clarifies omnipotence or omni-benevolence to resolve the contradiction.
Bible passages cited to support Universalism
- Romans 5:12–20
- 1 Corinthians 15:20–28
- 2 Corinthians 5:18–21
- Colossians 1:15–23
- Philippians 2:9–11
- 1 Timothy 2:3–6
- 1 Timothy 4:10
Universalism and heresy
Heresy is "adherence to a religious opinion contrary to church dogma".[15] Because dogma varies among denominations, what is considered heresy by one denomination or congregation may be accepted as doctrine or opinion by another. In a socially free world, free moral agents may identify with whichever perspectives and positions, persons and communities, and traditions (or subtraditions) they find most intellectually, emotionally, and spiritually palatable. However, the results of their exercise of this operational freedom may be understood or interpreted differently by different persons.
There are three generally accepted understandings of hell:
- A literal place of fire where the damned suffer eternal conscious torment.
- A metaphorical hell where the suffering is real but is not literally fire and brimstone. The pain may be physical, emotional or spiritual.
- Conditional, where souls are punished until retributive justice is met or accomplished, after which these punished souls are annihilated.[16]
There is also the doctrine of purgatory, distinct from hell, where imperfect souls are cleansed and made ready for heaven. It may be a place of rehabilitation, correction, or retribution.
Universalists believe that every person will be saved, where more orthodox Roman Catholics believe that only those who died in God's grace will find purgation for their venial sins in Purgatory.[17]
The Argument
There are four major theories about human salvation in Christendom:
- Exclusivism: Salvation is exclusively found in Christianity. Anyone who is not a Christian will go to hell.
- Inclusivism: Some adherents of other religions may find salvation, but it is still only Jesus Christ who can (and may or will) save them.
- Pluralism: One's own religion is not the sole and exclusive source of truth; salvation, in principle, may be found in any religion, although salvation is not necessarily found in one's search of any (other) religion(s).
- Universalism: All persons (and peoples?) will be saved.[18]
Christian denominations and churches will generally profess one of the above to be true and the others as error; however, they are not all mutually exclusive. For example, some[citation needed] who hold to #4 "Universalism" also hold to #1 "Exclusivism." For these, anyone who is not a Christian will go to hell, but ultimately everyone will become a Christian and therefore be saved. Others may be #2 "Inclusivists" and #3 "Pluralists." For those who might hold to these, because God may use the tools of any particular religion or culture to reveal his grace in Christ (Inclusivism), other religions therefore, potentially exhibiting the effects of this work, may in fact hold valuable insights to truth for theology (Pluralism), consequently calling the members of a particular congregation/denomination/religion to be open to that possibility.
Objections
Arminian objections
A Trinitarian Universalist believer might counter that for God to allow his misguided and confused children to suffer eternal separation from him is the very opposite of grace, runs counter to his loving and sovereign nature, and would compare unfavorably to the attitude and behavior of even average human parents toward their children. The Bible seems to teach that those who believe do so because God caused them to believe, not by any freedom of choice of their own (Ephesians 2:8–10), and they might cite the following in support their answer:
"He choose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him. In love He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intention of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace, which He freely bestowed on us in the Beloved." Ephesians 1:4–6
"For He says to Moses, 'I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.' So then it {does} not {depend} on the man who wills or the man who runs, but on God who has mercy." Romans 9:15–16 (See also: John 15:16, Philippians 1:29, Ephesians 1:11)
Also, the Bible in several places refers to freedom being only for those freed through Christ, and that those who are not in Christ are in darkness under the dominion of Satan (Acts 26:18), and are slaves to sin (John 8:34). Therefore, it would make no sense to maintain that someone can have the "freedom" to "reject God"—it is only by sin that people reject God. Those in sin are slaves to sin and Satan, and therefore it is only God who can, by his grace, release them from that bondage and make them able to believe:
"The Lord's bond-servant must not be quarrelsome, but be kind to all, able to teach, patient when wronged, with gentleness correcting those who are in opposition, if perhaps God may grant them repentance leading to the knowledge of the truth, and they may come to their senses {and escape} from the snare of the devil, having been held captive by him to do his will."
Mortalist objections
Hope of universal salvation
Apart from the dogmatic belief that a sentence of endless torment in hell is incompatible with God's moral character there are notable theologians who believe that God wants everyone to be saved and that it is possible for God to save everyone but, at the same time, they will not limit God's sovereign right to choose not to save everyone.
While
See also
- Apocatastasis
- Christian views on Hell
- Problem of Hell
- World to come
References and notes
- ^ The Universalist quarterly and general review: Volume 5 – Page 393 1848 "At that time, it was supposed that the only Trinitarians, in our ministry, were Mr. Dean of Boston, and Mr. Mitchell of New York; the latter of whom, though a highly respected preacher of Universalism, was never in formal fellowship as his attachments to Mr. Murray's peculiarities were so strong as to prevent him uniting with the denomination."
- ^ Russell E. Miller The larger hope: the first century of the Universalist Church in America, 1770–1870 Unitarian Universalist Association, 1979
- ^ Jabez Thomas Sunderland, Brooke Herford, Frederick B. Mott The Unitarian: a monthly magazine of liberal Christianity: Volume 6 1891 "Trinitarian Universalism has been displaced by Unitarian Universalism. Belief in vicarious atonement has given way to the moral-influence idea of Christ's work. Calvinistic and Arminian Universalism have given way to that eclecticism."
- ISBN 0-8028-2764-0. 'Universalism in the History of Christianity'. by Morwena Ludlow. Chapt. 10
- ISBN 978-0-664-22472-1
- ^ "CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Apocatastasis". www.newadvent.org.
- ^ Reformers in the wings: from Geiler von Kaysersberg to Theodore Beza By David Curtis Steinmetz p151
- hdl:10036/21494.
- ^ http://uudb.org/articles/hoseaballou.html Biography of Hosea Ballou from UUA, retrieved Dec. 23, 2006
- ^ "I am the Evangelical Universalist". theologicalscribbles.blogspot.com.
- ^ ISBN 1-59752-365-8
- ISBN 978-1-58112-831-4.
- ^ ISBN 1-58112-831-2.
- ^ Talbott's views are most completely delineated in his book The Inescapable Love of God. A book entitled Universal Salvation?: The Current Debate has recently come to print, in which multiple authors from various fields (Theology, Philosophy, Church History, etc.) build arguments to either support or deny his Universalist tenets. See also: *http://www.thomastalbott.com/
- ^ "Definition of HERESY". www.m-w.com.
- ISBN 0-310-21268-5
- ^ "CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Purgatory". www.newadvent.org.
- ^ "Vlach, Michael J., PhD. What Are Pluralism, Inclusivism, and Exclusivism? Theologicalstudies.org. retrieved Dec. 12, 2006". theologicalstudies.org.
- ISBN 0-06-065295-0
- ISBN 0-8028-2764-0
- ISBN 0-89870-207-0
External links
- Christian Universalism at Curlie
- Discovering Trinitarian Universalism — Trinitarian Universalists found within and without the Unitarian Universalist Association.