Living fossil

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
"Living Fossil" redirects here. For the story by L. Sprague de Camp, see Living Fossil (short story).

The coelacanths were thought to have gone extinct 66 million years ago, until a living specimen belonging to the order was discovered in 1938.

A living fossil is a term for an

phenotypically resembles related species known only from the fossil record, though scientifically the term is deprecated and avoided. To be considered a living fossil, the fossil species must be old relative to the time of origin of the extant clade. Living fossils commonly are of species-poor lineages, but they need not be. While the body plan of a living fossil remains superficially similar, it is never the same species as the remote relatives it resembles, because genetic drift
would inevitably change its chromosomal structure.

Living fossils exhibit stasis (also called "bradytely") over geologically long time scales. Popular literature may wrongly claim that a "living fossil" has undergone no significant evolution since fossil times, with practically no molecular evolution or morphological changes. Scientific investigations have repeatedly discredited such claims.[1][2][3]

The minimal superficial changes to living fossils are mistakenly declared as an absence of evolution, but they are examples of

morphological evolution.[4]

The term is currently deprecated among paleontologists and evolutionary biologists.

Characteristics

Fossil and living ginkgos
170 million-year-old fossil Ginkgo leaves
Living Ginkgo biloba plant

Living fossils have two main characteristics, although some have a third:

  1. Living organisms that are members of a taxon that has remained recognizable in the fossil record over an unusually long time span.
  2. They show little morphological divergence, whether from early members of the lineage, or among
    extant species
    .
  3. They tend to have little taxonomic diversity.[5]

The first two are required for recognition as a living fossil; some authors also require the third, others merely note it as a frequent trait.

Such criteria are neither well-defined nor clearly quantifiable, but modern methods for analyzing evolutionary dynamics can document the distinctive tempo of stasis.[6][7][8] Lineages that exhibit stasis over very short time scales are not considered living fossils; what is poorly-defined is the time scale over which the morphology must persist for that lineage to be recognized as a living fossil.

The term living fossil is much misunderstood in popular media in particular, in which it often is used meaninglessly. In professional literature the expression seldom appears and must be used with far more caution, although it has been used inconsistently.[9][10]

One example of a concept that could be confused with "living fossil" is that of a "Lazarus taxon", but the two are not equivalent; a Lazarus taxon (whether a single species or a group of related species) is one that suddenly reappears, either in the fossil record or in nature, as if the fossil had "come to life again".[11] In contrast to "Lazarus taxa", a living fossil in most senses is a species or lineage that has undergone exceptionally little change throughout a long fossil record, giving the impression that the extant taxon had remained identical through the entire fossil and modern period. Because of the mathematical inevitability of genetic drift, though, the DNA of the modern species is necessarily different from that of its distant, similar-looking ancestor. They almost certainly would not be able to cross-reproduce, and are not the same species.[12]

The average

Coelacanthiformes, of which the genus Latimeria was found to be extant in 1938. About that there is little debate – however, whether Latimeria resembles early members of its lineage sufficiently closely to be considered a living fossil as well as a Lazarus taxon has been denied by some authors in recent years.[1]

Coelacanths disappeared from the fossil record some 80 million years ago (in the upper Cretaceous period) and, to the extent that they exhibit low rates of morphological evolution, extant species qualify as living fossils. It must be emphasised that this criterion reflects fossil evidence, and is totally independent of whether the taxa had been subject to selection at all, which all living populations continuously are, whether they remain genetically unchanged or not.[14]

This apparent stasis, in turn, gives rise to a great deal of confusion – for one thing, the fossil record seldom preserves much more than the general morphology of a specimen. To determine much about its physiology is seldom possible; not even the most dramatic examples of living fossils can be expected to be without changes, no matter how persistently constant their fossils and the extant specimens might seem. To determine much about

noncoding DNA is hardly ever possible, but even if a species were hypothetically unchanged in its physiology, it is to be expected from the very nature of the reproductive processes, that its non-functional genomic changes would continue at more-or-less standard rates. Hence, a fossil lineage with apparently constant morphology need not imply equally constant physiology, and certainly neither implies any cessation of the basic evolutionary processes such as natural selection, nor reduction in the usual rate of change of the noncoding DNA.[14]

Some living fossils are taxa that were known from palaeontological fossils before living representatives were discovered. The most famous examples of this are:

All the above include taxa that originally were described as fossils but now are known to include still-extant species.

Other examples of living fossils are single living species that have no close living relatives, but are survivors of large and widespread groups in the fossil record. For example:

All of these were described from fossils before later being found alive.[15][16][17]

The fact that a living fossil is a surviving representative of an archaic lineage does not imply that it must retain all the "primitive" features (

plesiomorphies
) of its ancestral lineage. Although it is common to say that living fossils exhibit "morphological stasis", stasis, in the scientific literature, does not mean that any species is strictly identical to its ancestor, much less remote ancestors.

Some living fossils are relicts of formerly diverse and morphologically varied lineages, but not all survivors of ancient lineages necessarily are regarded as living fossils. See for example the uniquely and highly autapomorphic oxpeckers, which appear to be the only survivors of an ancient lineage related to starlings and mockingbirds.[18]

Evolution and living fossils

The term living fossil is usually reserved for species or larger clades that are exceptional for their lack of morphological diversity and their exceptional conservatism, and several hypotheses could explain morphological stasis on a geologically long time-scale. Early analyses of evolutionary rates emphasized the persistence of a taxon rather than rates of evolutionary change.[19] Contemporary studies instead analyze rates and modes of phenotypic evolution, but most have focused on clades that are thought to be adaptive radiations rather than on those thought to be living fossils. Thus, very little is presently known about the evolutionary mechanisms that produce living fossils or how common they might be. Some recent studies have documented exceptionally low rates of ecological and phenotypic evolution despite rapid speciation.[20] This has been termed a "non-adaptive radiation" referring to diversification not accompanied by adaptation into various significantly different niches.[21] Such radiations are explanation for groups that are morphologically conservative. Persistent adaptation within an adaptive zone is a common explanation for morphological stasis.[22] The subject of very low evolutionary rates, however, has received much less attention in the recent literature than that of high rates.

Living fossils are not expected to exhibit exceptionally low rates of molecular evolution, and some studies have shown that they do not.[23][24] For example, on tadpole shrimp (Triops), one article notes, "Our work shows that organisms with conservative body plans are constantly radiating, and presumably, adapting to novel conditions... I would favor retiring the term 'living fossil' altogether, as it is generally misleading."[24] Some scientists instead prefer a new term stabilomorph, being defined as "an effect of a specific formula of adaptative strategy among organisms whose taxonomic status does not exceed genus-level. A high effectiveness of adaptation significantly reduces the need for differentiated phenotypic variants in response to environmental changes and provides for long-term evolutionary success."[25]

The question posed by several recent studies pointed out that the morphological conservatism of coelacanths is not supported by paleontological data.[26][27] In addition, it was shown recently that studies concluding that a slow rate of molecular evolution is linked to morphological conservatism in coelacanths are biased by the a priori hypothesis that these species are 'living fossils'.[1] Accordingly, the genome stasis hypothesis is challenged by the recent finding that the genome of the two extant coelacanth species L. chalumnae and L. menadoensis contain multiple species-specific insertions, indicating transposable element recent activity and contribution to post-speciation genome divergence.[28] Such studies, however, challenge only a genome stasis hypothesis, not the hypothesis of exceptionally low rates of phenotypic evolution.

History

The term was coined by

Lepidosiren
(the South American lungfish):

All fresh-water basins, taken together, make a small area compared with that of the sea or of the land; and, consequently, the competition between fresh-water productions will have been less severe than elsewhere; new forms will have been more slowly formed, and old forms more slowly exterminated. And it is in fresh water that we find seven genera of Ganoid fishes, remnants of a once preponderant order: and in fresh water we find some of the most anomalous forms now known in the world, as the Ornithorhynchus and Lepidosiren, which, like fossils, connect to a certain extent orders now widely separated in the natural scale. These anomalous forms may almost be called living fossils; they have endured to the present day, from having inhabited a confined area, and from having thus been exposed to less severe competition.

— On the Origin of Species, 1859[29]

Other definitions

Long-enduring

Elephant shrews resemble the extinct Leptictidium of Eocene Europe.

A living taxon that lived through a large portion of

geologic time
.

The Australian lungfish (Neoceratodus fosteri), also known as the Queensland lungfish, is an example of an organism that meets this criterion. Fossils identical to modern specimens have been dated at over 100 million years old. Modern Queensland lungfish have existed as a species for almost 30 million years.[30] The contemporary nurse shark has existed for more than 112 million years, making this species one of the oldest, if not actually the oldest extant vertebrate species.

Resembles ancient species

A living taxon morphologically and/or physiologically resembling a fossil taxon through a large portion of geologic time (morphological stasis).[31]

Retains many ancient traits

extant
spiders.

A living taxon with many characteristics believed to be primitive. This is a more neutral definition. However, it does not make it clear whether the taxon is truly old, or it simply has many plesiomorphies. Note that, as mentioned above, the converse may hold for true living fossil taxa; that is, they may possess a great many derived features (autapomorphies), and not be particularly "primitive" in appearance.

Relict population

Any one of the above three definitions, but also with a

relict distribution in refuges
.

Some paleontologists believe that living fossils with large distributions (such as Triops cancriformis) are not real living fossils. In the case of Triops cancriformis (living from the Triassic until now), the Triassic specimens lost most of their appendages (mostly only carapaces remain), and they have not been thoroughly examined since 1938.

Low diversity

Any of the first three definitions, but the clade also has a low taxonomic diversity (low diversity lineages).

Mimidae, but appears to be the most ancient of these groups. Biogeography strongly suggests that oxpeckers originated in eastern Asia and only later arrived in Africa, where they now have a relict distribution.[18]

The two living species thus seem to represent an entirely extinct and (as Passerida go) rather ancient lineage, as certainly as this can be said in the absence of actual fossils. The latter is probably due to the fact that the oxpecker lineage never occurred in areas where conditions were good for fossilization of small bird bones, but of course, fossils of ancestral oxpeckers may one day turn up enabling this theory to be tested.

Operational definition

An operational definition was proposed in 2017, where a 'living fossil' lineage has a slow rate of evolution and occurs close to the middle of morphological variation (the centroid of morphospace) among related taxa (i.e. a species is morphologically conservative among relatives).

morphometric analyses used to classify tuatara as a living fossil under this definition have been criticised however,[33] which prompted a rebuttal from the original authors.[34]

Examples

Some of these are informally known as "living fossils".

ground zero
. They still live there today.
Osmunda claytoniana, maintaining evolutionary stasis for at least 180 million years.[35][36]

Bacteria

  • Cyanobacteria – the oldest living fossils, emerging 3.5 billion years ago. They exist as single bacteria or in the form of stromatolites, layered rocks produced by colonies of cyanobacteria.[37]

Protists

Plants

  • Moss
  • Pteridophytes
    • Horsetails
      – Equisetum
    • Lycopods
    • ferns
  • Gymnosperms
  • Angiosperms
    • flowering plants
    • Magnolia – a genus whose form is little changed since the earliest days of flowering plant evolution in the Cretaceous and possibly earlier[43][1]
    • Trapa
       – water caltrops, seeds, and leaves of numerous extinct species are known all the way back to the Cretaceous.
    • Nelumbo – several species of lotus flower are known exclusively from fossils dating back to the Cretaceous.
    • Sassafras – many fossils of sassafras are known from the late cretaceous through the late Pleistocene.
    • Platanus Sycamore fossils are very abundant throughout the northern hemisphere with several extinct species. Sycamore leaves and fruits are quite common in plant fossils. Sycamores exhibit many primitive features as well such their exfoliating bark which is a result of a lack of elasticity. Platanus occidentalis fossils are known from the Pliocene and the Pleistocene in North America.
    • Nyssa Blackgum fossils go way back to the late Cretaceous period. Many extinct species are recorded as well.
    • Liriodendron Fossils from the Cretaceous and the Tertiary period are found with many extinct species. Tulip trees at one point were present in Europe during the Cretaceous and the early Paleocene. Liriodendron tulipifera fossils dating from the Pliocene and Pleistocene were discovered at the Chowan formation in North Carolina.
    • Liquidambar Sweetgums appeared during the mid-late Cretaceous and several extinct species are found throughout Asia, Europe and North America. The genus was once widespread in Europe and Asia especially during the Miocene. The American sweetgum is a living fossil itself since fossil specimens dating from the Miocene, Pliocene and Pleistocene were discovered in the eastern United States

Fungi

Animals

Echidnas are one of few mammals to lay eggs.
Vertebrates
Hoatzin hatch with two visible claws on their wings, but the claws fall out once the birds reach maturity.
Crocodilians survived the K–Pg extinction event that killed off the non-avian dinosaurs.
Tuatara are reptiles, yet retain more primitive characteristics than lizards and snakes.
extant representative of the family Mitsukurinidae, a lineage some 125 million years old (early Cretaceous
).
Nautilus retain the external spiral shell that its other relatives have lost.
With little change over the last 450 million years, the horseshoe crabs appear as living fossils.
Invertebrates

See also

Notes

Baiji is not officially classified as extinct, but instead critically endangered, possibly extinct and has the unofficial status of functional extinction.[56]

References

  1. ^
    S2CID 2751255
    .
  2. PMID 23638400
    .
  3. PMID 25454211
    .
  4. S2CID 11055926
    .
  5. ^ Eldridge, Niles; Stanley, Steven (1984). Living Fossils. New York: Springer-Verlag.
  6. S2CID 4795316
    .
  7. PMID 28565714
    .
  8. S2CID 17544335
    .
  9. S2CID 206535984
    .
  10. doi:10.3389/fevo.2014.00049
    .
  11. ^
    S2CID 25506765
    .
  12. ^ Mark Carnall (6 July 2016). "Let's make living fossils extinct". The Guardian.
  13. ISBN 978-0-19-854829-4
    .
  14. ^
    ISBN 978-81-8356-477-9
    .
  15. ^
    S2CID 84169394
    .
  16. ^
    PMID 23850812
    .
  17. ^
    doi:10.1130/G35456.1
    .
  18. ^
    PMID 16806992. Archived from the original
    (PDF) on 2021-10-25. Retrieved 2011-02-20.
  19. ^ Simpson, George (1953). The Major Features of Evolution. New York: Columbia University Press.
  20. PMID 16537124
    .
  21. doi:10.1111/j.1095-8312.1991.tb00598.x
    .
  22. S2CID 18734233
    .
  23. ^ "Diversification in Ancient Tadpole Shrimps Challenges the Term 'Living Fossil'". Science Daily. 2 April 2013. Retrieved 2013-04-02.
  24. ^ a b Ed Yong (2 April 2013). "The Falsity of Living Fossils". The Scientist. Retrieved 2015-12-03.
  25. PMID 25275563
    .
  26. S2CID 23069133
    .
  27. PMID 16555794
    .
  28. PMID 26442185
    .
  29. ^ On the Origin of Species, 1859, p. 107.
  30. ^ "Ann Kemps Lungfish - Queensland - Australia". annekempslungfish.com.au. Retrieved 2025-01-18.
  31. ^ "The University of Chicago Medical Center: Scientists find lamprey a 'living fossil' ". Uchospitals.edu. 26 October 2006. Retrieved 2012-05-16.
  32. ^
    hdl:1983/940fdc51-30db-47c0-9ac6-97fda3c2ea01
    .
  33. S2CID 134902015
    .
  34. S2CID 133726749
    .
  35. S2CID 38248823
    .
  36. ^ Kazlev, M. Alan (2002). "Palaeos website". Archived from the original on 2006-01-05. Retrieved 2008-07-22.
  37. ^ "cyanobacteria". ircamera.as.arizona.edu. Archived from the original on 2019-05-03. Retrieved 2019-04-27.
  38. doi:10.1016/j.marmicro.2015.01.002
    .
  39. S2CID 84425685
    .
  40. doi:10.1511/2005.56.981
    .
  41. PMID 22021670
    .
  42. PMID 38485767
    .
  43. ^ Vallejo-Marin, Mario (1 August 2017). "Revealed: the first ever flower, 140m years ago, looked like a magnolia". The Conversation. Retrieved 2023-05-17.
  44. S2CID 19327437
    .
  45. ISBN 978-1-4613-8273-7
    .
  46. doi:10.18563/m3.3.2.e1
    .
  47. ^ a b Braulik, Gill; Atkore, Vidyadhar; Shahnawaz Khan, Mohammad; Malla, Sabita (July 2021). "Review of Scientific Knowledge of the Ganges river dolphin" (PDF). World Wildlife Fund: 5.
  48. ^ "Red panda". National Zoo. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution. 22 April 2016. Retrieved 2017-05-04. Red pandas are considered by many to be living fossils. They have no close living relatives, and their nearest fossil ancestors, Parailurus, lived 3–4 million years ago.
  49. PMID 23256199
    .
  50. ^ "'Extinct' whale found: Odd-looking pygmy whale traced back 2 million years". Christian Science Monitor. 23 April 2012. Retrieved 2012-12-19.
  51. doi:10.1002/9781118792919.ch54
    .
  52. ISBN 978-1-4613-8273-7
    .
  53. doi:10.1007/s10336-010-0537-5
    . Retrieved 2013-06-10.
  54. ^ Morelle, Rebecca (4 June 2013). "Rediscovered hula painted frog 'is a living fossil'". BBC News. Retrieved 2013-06-04.
  55. S2CID 85340338
    .
  56. ^ Zhou, Kaiya; Smith, Brian; Randall Reeves (IUCN SSC Cetacean Specialist Group); Braulik, Gillian; Barlow, Jay; Robert Pitman (Protected Resources Division, Southwest Fisheries Science Center/NOAA); Ding Wang (Institute of Hydrobiology, Chinese Academy of Sciences) (20 August 2017). "IUCN Red List of Threatened Species: Lipotes vexillifer". IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Archived from the original on 2025-01-05.
Look up living fossil in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Living_fossil&oldid=1298143208"