User:Cdjp1/sandbox/stratos
< User:Cdjp1 | sandbox
6 May 2022
| Part of the Politics series |
| Basic forms of government |
|---|
| List of countries by system of government |
 Politics portal |
A stratocracy (from
Ancient Greek στρατός (stratós) 'army', and κράτος (krátos) 'dominion, power'),[2] also called stratiocracy,[3][4][5] is a form of government headed by military chiefs.[6] The branches of government are administered by military forces, the government is legal under the laws of the jurisdiction at issue, and is usually carried out by military workers.[7]
Description of stratocracy
The word stratocracy first appeared in 1652 from the
honorably discharged, have the right to elect or govern. The military's administrative, judicial, and/or legislative powers are supported by law, the constitution, and the society.[6] It does not necessarily need to be autocratic or oligarchic by nature in order to preserve its right to rule. The political scientist Samuel Finer distinguished between stratocracy which was rule by the army and military regimes where the army did not rule but enforced the rule of the civil leaders.[9] Peter Lyon wrote that through history stratocracies have been relatively rare, and that in the latter half of the twentieth century there has been a noticeable increase in the number of stratocratic states due to the "rapid collapse of the West European thalassocracies".[8]
Notable examples of stratocracies
Historical stratocracies
Sparta
The
Spartans were put through the agoge, necessary for full-citizenship, which was a rigorous education and training program to prepare them to be warriors.[11] Aristotle describes the kingship at Sparta as "a kind of unlimited and perpetual generalship" (Pol. iii. 1285a), while Isocrates refers to the Spartans as "subject to an oligarchy at home, to a kingship on campaign" (iii. 24).[12]
Rome
One of the most distinguished and, perhaps, long-lived examples of a stratocratic state, is
Punic Wars, the Roman political and military system experienced drastic changes.[16] Following the so-called "Marian reforms", de facto political power became concentrated under military leadership, as the loyalty of the legionaries shifted from the Senate to its generals.[17][18]
Through the First Triumvirate[19] this led to, following a series of civil wars, the formation of the Roman Empire, the head of which was acclaimed as "Imperator", previously an honorary title for distinguished military commanders.[18] Following the formation of the Empire, the Roman Army either approved of or acquiesced in the accession of an emperor, with the Praetorian Guard having a decisive role in the succession until Emperor Constantine abolished it.[20] Militarization of the Empire increased over time and emperors were increasingly beholden to their armies and fleets, yet how active emperors were in actually commanding in the field in military campaigns varied from emperor to emperor, even from dynasty to dynasty. The vital political importance of the army persisted up until the destruction of the Eastern (Byzantine) Empire with the fall of Constantinople in 1453.[21]
Goryeo
From 1170 to 1270, the kingdom of Goryeo was under effective military rule, with puppet kings on the throne serving mainly as figureheads.[22] The majority of this period was spent under the rule of the Choe family, who set up a parallel system of private administrative systems from their military forces.[23]
Cossacks
proto-state[28] that existed between the 16th and 18th centuries, and existed as an independent stratocratic state as the Cossack Hetmanate for over a hundred years.[29][30][31]
Military frontier of the Habsburg monarchy
The
Austro-Hungarian Empire).[32][33] The military frontier acted as the cordon sanitaire against incursions from the Ottoman Empire. Located in the southern part of Hungarian crown land, the frontier was separated from local jurisdiction and was under direct Viennese central military administration from the 1500s to 1872. Unlike the rest of the Catholic dominated territory of the empire, the frontier area had relatively freer religious laws in order to attract settlements into the area.[34][35][36]
Modern stratocracies
The closest modern equivalent to a stratocracy, the
Myanmar (Burma), which ruled from 1997 to 2011,[37] arguably differed from most other military dictatorships in that it completely abolished the civilian constitution and legislature.[38][39] A new constitution that came into effect in 2010 cemented the Tatmadaw's hold on power through mechanisms such as reserving 25% of the seats in the legislature for military personnel.[40] The civilian constitutional government was dissolved again in the 2021 Myanmar coup d'état, with power being transferred back to the Tatmadaw through the State Administration Council.[41]
The
Sovereign Base Areas of Akrotiri and Dhekelia on the island of Cyprus, provides another example of a stratocracy: British Forces Cyprus governs the territory, with Air vice-marshal Peter J. M. Squires serving as administrator from 2022.[42] The territory is subject to unique laws different from both those of the United Kingdom and those of Cyprus.[43]
States argued to be stratocratic
USA
The political scientist
military-industrial complex in the US as evidence of it being a stratocratic state.[10] The expansion and prioritisation of the military during the administrations of Reagan and H. W. Bush have also been described as signs of stratocracy in the US.[44] The futurist Paul Saffo[45] and the researcher Robert Marzec[46] have argued that the post 9/11
projection of the United States was trending towards stratocracy.
USSR
The philosopher and economist Cornelius Castoriadis wrote in his 1980 text, Facing the War, that Russia had become the primary world military power. To sustain this, in the context of the visible economic inferiority of the Soviet Union in the civilian sector, he proposed that the society may no longer be dominated by the one-party state bureaucracy of the Communist Party but by a "stratocracy"[47][48][49] describing it as a separate and dominant military sector with expansionist designs on the world.[50][51] He further argued that this meant there was no internal class dynamic that could lead to social revolution within Russian society and that change could only occur through foreign intervention. Timothy Luke agreed that under the secretaryship of Mikhail Gorbachev this was the USSR moving towards a stratocratic state.[52]
African states
Various countries in post-colonial
Côte d'Ivoire and the Central African Republic.[63]
Other
The French historian François Raguenet wrote in 1691 of the stratocracy of Oliver Cromwell in the Protectorate, and commented that he believed William III of England was seeking to revive the stratocracy in England.[64]
The Prussian military writer Georg Henirich von Berenhorst wrote in hindsight that ever since the reign of the soldier king, Prussia always remained "not a country with an army, but an army with a country" (a quote often misattributed to Voltaire and Honoré Gabriel Riqueti, comte de Mirabeau).[65] It has been argued the subsequent dominance of the Kingdom of Prussia in the North German Confederation and German Empire and the expansive militarism in their administrations and policies, saw a continuance of the stratocratic Prussian government.[66]
Sonderweg
British commentators such as Sir Richard Burton described the pre-Tanzimat Ottoman Empire as a stratocratic state.[67]
The Warlord Era of China is viewed as period of stratocratic struggles[68] with the researcher Peng Xiuliang pointing to the actions and policies of Wang Shizhen, a general and politician of the Republic of China, as an example of the stratocratic forces within the Chinese government of the time.[69]
Occupied Poland in World War I was put under the General-Militärgouvernementen (general military governments) of Germany and Austria-Hungary. This government was a stratocratic system where the military was responsible for the political administration of Poland.[70] - Stephan Burián von Rajecz
Various military juntas of central and south America have also been described as stratocracies.[71]
Since 1967, the
Palestinian National Authority that governs the Palestinian territories, only East Jerusalem and the Golan Heights were annexed into Israeli territory from 1980 which is still internationally unrecognized and once referred to these territories by the United Nations as occupied Arab territories.[74][75]
Fictional stratocracies
Stratocratic forms of government have been popular in fictional stories.[76]
- The country of Amestris in the Fullmetal Alchemist manga and anime series is a nominal parliamentary republic without elections,[77] where parliament has been used as a façade to distract from the authoritarian regime,[77] as the government is almost completely centralized by the military, and the majority of government positions are occupied by military personnel.[76]
- Bowser from the Super Mariovideo game franchise is the supreme leader of a stratocratic empire in which he has many other generals working under his militaristic rules such as Kamek, Private Goomp, Sergeant Guy, Corporal Paraplonk and many others.
- The Cardassian Union of the Star Trek universe can be described as a stratocracy, with a constitutionally and socially sanctioned, as well as a politically dominant military that nonetheless has immense totalitarian characteristics.[76]
- In Bryan Konietzko and Michael Dante DiMartino's Avatar: The Last Airbender, the Earth Kingdom is very divided and during the Hundred Year War relies on an unofficial confederal stratocratic rule of small towns to maintain control from the Fire Nation's military, without the Earth Monarch's assistance.[76]
- Both Eldia and Marley from the Japanese manga and anime series Attack On Titan are stratocratic nations ruled by military governments. After a coup d'état, the government of Eldia was displaced in favor of a military-led system with a puppet monarchy as its public front.[78]
- The Galactic Empire from the original Star Wars trilogy can be described as a stratocracy. Although ruled by Emperor Palpatine, the functioning of the entire government was controlled by the military and explicitly sanctioned by its leaders. All sectors were controlled by a Moff or Grand Moff who were also high-ranking military officers.[76]
- The Global Defense Initiative from the Command & Conquer franchise is another example: initially being a United Nations task force to combat the Brotherhood of Nod and research the alien substance Tiberium, later expanding to a worldwide government led by military leaders[79] after the collapse of society due to Tiberium's devastating effects on Earth.[80]
- warlords.
- In Aberdeen, Scotland when governments collapsed following a world war.[81] While national service is voluntary, earning citizenship in the Federation requires civilians to "enroll in the Federal Service of the Terran Federation for a term of not less than two years and as much longer as may be required by the needs of the Service."[82][83] While Federal Service is not exclusively military service, that appears to be the dominant form. It is believed that only those willing to sacrifice their lives on the state's behalf are fit to govern. While the government is a representative democracy, the franchise is only granted to people who have completed service, mostly in the military, due to this law (active military can neither vote nor serve in political/non-military offices).[76]
- The Turian Hierarchy of Mass Effect is another example of a fictional stratocracy, where the civilian and military populations cannot be distinguished, and the government and the military are the same, and strongly meritocratic, with designated responsibilities for everyone.[84][85]
- The five members of Greater Turkiye in the manga and anime Altair: A Record of Battles are called stratocracies, with them being based on the Ottoman Empire.[86]
ot
Chinese Warlord Era List of warlords and military cliques in the Warlord Era Warlord, https://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTotal-HBGD201303004.htm, https://www.amazon.co.uk/s?i=stripbooks&rh=p_27%3APeng+Xiuliang&s=relevancerank&text=Peng+Xiuliang&ref=dp_byline_sr_book_1, Wang Shizhen (Beiyang government)
Autocratic military regimes - Shogunate,
Sri Lanka https://www.pressreader.com/sri-lanka/sunday-times-sri-lanka/20200726/282226603047808
The Marketing of War in the Age of Neo-Militarism https://www.routledge.com/The-Marketing-of-War-in-the-Age-of-Neo-Militarism/Gouliamos-Kassimeris/p/book/9780415853774
From a Distance: A "Disciplined" Democracy Comes Undone in Myanmar https://escholarship.org/content/qt6vt6x07p/qt6vt6x07p.pdf
Rejector Islamists: al-Qaeda and Transnational Jihadism https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781137313492_6#main-content
KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT: PROJECTS, SYSTEMS AND TECHNOLOGIES https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Toma-Plesanu/publication/220008044_The_5th_International_Conference_on_Knowledge_Management_Projects_Systems_and_Technologies/links/02faf4f384bf699007000000/The-5th-International-Conference-on-Knowledge-Management-Projects-Systems-and-Technologies.pdf#page=146
Supreme People's Assembly, 1990 North Korean parliamentary election
See also
References
- ^ JSTOR 3292889.
- from the original on 15 August 2021.
- ISBN 9780814341629.
- ^ A Pallas nagy lexikona (in Hungarian). Vol. 15. 1897.
- Révai Nagy Lexikona(in Hungarian). Vol. 17. 1925. p. 755.
- ^ ISBN 978-1-886363-80-9.
- ^ de Grazia 1970.
- ^ JSTOR 3992118.
- JSTOR 3992119.
- ^ a b c d Gouliamos, Kostas; Kassimeris, Christos (2012). "Stratocracy: The Growing Hypertrophy of the LifeWorld Militarization". In Gouliamos, Kostas; Kassimeris, Christos (eds.). The Marketing of War in the Age of Neo-Militarism. Routledge.
- ^ Harley, T. Rutherford (May 1934). The Public School of Sparta, Greece & Rome. Vol. 3. pp. 129–139.
- ^ One or more of the preceding sentences incorporates text from a publication now in the public domain: Tod, Marcus Niebuhr (1911). "Sparta". In Chisholm, Hugh (ed.). Encyclopædia Britannica. Vol. 25 (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press. pp. 609–14.
- ISBN 9780520246188.
- S2CID 153671867. Retrieved 4 December 2021.
- ISBN 978-1107657021.
- JSTOR 24563133.
- ISBN 978-0-521-00390-2 – via Google Books.
- ^ a b Reid, Conor. "The Marian Reforms". Academia.
- ^ Launspach, Charles W. L. (1908). State and Family in Early Rome. London: George Bell And Sons. pp. xi.
The Gabinian and Manilian Laws had rehearsed the stratocracy of the first Triumvirate; and after the renewed convulsions which followed Caesar's murder the world gladly found refuge in Octavians ordered despotism.
- ^ Andrews, Evan (29 August 2018). "8 Things You May Not Know About the Praetorian Guard". HISTORY. Archived from the original on 29 October 2021. Retrieved 23 August 2020.
- ^ Kaegi, Walter Emil (1983). Army, Society and Religion in Byzantium: Byzantine Military Unrest 471-843. Amsterdam: Adolf M. Hakkert.
- OCLC 9283320.
- OCLC 70769296.
- ^ Lebedynsky, Iaroslav (September 2002). "Les Cosaques, de la société de guerriers à la caste militaire" [The Cossacks, from the society of warriors to the military caste] (in French). Archived from the original on 7 May 2021. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
- ^ Magocsi, Paul Robert. A History of Ukraine. pp. 179–181.
- ISBN 978-0-312-22774-6 – via Google Books.
- ^ Mytsyk, Yu (2003). "Volʹnosti Viysʹka Zaporozʹkoho Nyzovoho" Вольностi Вiйська Запорозького Низового [Freedoms of the Zaporozhian Lowland Army]. Entsyklopediya istoriyi Ukrayiny Енциклопедія історії України [Encyclopedia of History of Ukraine] (in Ukrainian).
- ISBN 978-1912390106.
- ^ Okinshevych, Lev; Zhukovsky, Arkadii (1989). "Hetman state". Encyclopedia of Ukraine. Vol. 2. Archived from the original on 23 November 2021. Retrieved 9 September 2017.
- (PDF) from the original on 23 November 2021. Retrieved 20 January 2016.
- ^ Saltovskiy, Oleksandr (2002). "Kontseptsiyi Ukrayinsʹkoyi Derzhavnosti v Istoriyi Vitchyznyanoyi Politychnoyi Dumky (vid vytokiv do pochatku XX storichchya)" Концепції Української Державності в Історії Вітчизняної Політичної Думки (від витоків до початку XX сторіччя) [Concepts of Ukrainian Statehood in the History of Domestic Political Thought (from its origins to the beginning of the XX century)]. litopys.org.ua (in Ukrainian). Kyiv. Archived from the original on 23 November 2021. Retrieved 22 December 2014.
- ISBN 0472082604 – via Google Books.
- ^ Horvat, Rudolf (1906). Najnovije doba hrvatske povjesti [The latest era of Croatian history] (in Croatian). Matica hrvatska. (Wikisource)
- ISBN 9789004221987 – via Google Books.
- ^ Végh, Ferenc (2017). "Doprinos mađarske historiografije istraživanju "Vojne krajine" u ranom novom vijeku (16.-17. stoljeće)" [The Contribution of the Hungarian Historiography to the Research on the "Military Frontier" in the Early Modern Period (16th-17th Centuries)]. Academia (in Hungarian). University of Pécs Institute of History. p. 169.
The Habsburg government in this way came to relatively cheap military force using the South Slavic (Croatian, Vlach, Serbian) grencers
- ISBN 978-1138525542.
- Myanmar Times. Archived from the originalon 16 September 2011. Retrieved 21 August 2011.
- Encyclopedia Britannica.
- ^ Resource Information Center (17 September 1998). "Burma [Myanmar]: State Law and Order Restoration Council (SLORC)/ State Peace and Development Council (SPDC)/ National League for Democracy (NLD)/Burmese Dissidents". United States Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services. Retrieved 7 February 2022.
- ^ "Burma 'approves new constitution'". BBC News. 15 May 2008. Archived from the original on 21 July 2008.
- ^ "Myanmar Leader Aung San Suu Kyi, Others Detained by Military". Voice of America. 31 January 2021. Archived from the original on 31 October 2021. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
- ^ "No. 63825". The London Gazette (Supplement). 27 September 2022. p. 18258.
- ^ The SBA Administration. "Sovereign Base Area - Court". sbaadministration.org. Archived from the original on 27 February 2021. Retrieved 24 March 2015.
- ^ ISBN 9780595326785.
- ^ Saffo, Paul (3 January 2006). "A stratocracy in America's future?". Retrieved 5 May 2021.
- S2CID 246279338.
- ^ Castoriadis, Cornelius (February 1980). "Facing the War". Telos (46): 48.
- .
- ISBN 0-203-99283-0.
- ISBN 9782213009605.
- JSTOR 27688245.
- S2CID 144281892. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
- ^ Ujomu (2020), pp. 97–115; George (1988), pp. 390–419; Christie (2004); Jaywant (2014)
- ^ Vatikiotis (1968); Anthony (1980); Barfi (2018); de Grazia (1970)
- ^ Gaub, Florence (February 2014). "Behind and beyond al-Sisi's bid" (PDF). Issue Alert. 14. European Union Institute for Security Studies.
- ^ Dentice, Giuseppe (1 April 2018). "Politics of Restoration". The Battle for Sinai: The Inside Story of Egypt's Political Violence (PDF). Al Jazeera Centre for Studies. p. 8.
- ^ Dentice, Giuseppe (6 March 2018). "Stratocracy, the economy and the Egyptian elections". Aspenia. Aspen Institute.
- ^ George 1988, pp. 390–419.
- ^ Akpeninor (2013); Ogunjimi (1992), pp. 12–16; Bangura (1991); de Grazia (1970)
- ^ Tshabalala, Jeffrey; Nhlengethwa, Cyprian; Rupiya, Martin (2005). "Caught between tradition and regional warfare: The Umbutfo Swaziland Defence Force since 1968". In Rupiya, Martin (ed.). Evolutions & Revolutions: A Contemporary History of Militaries in Southern Africa (PDF). Institute for Security Studies.
- .
- ISBN 9781138995871.
- ISBN 978-0-387-34576-5.
- ISBN 9781315604152.
- ^ Georg Heinrich von Berenhorst (1845). Aus dem Nachlasse [From the estate] (in German). Dessau: Eduard von Bülow.
- ^ Stapleton, F.G. (September 2003). "'An Army with a State, not a State with an Army'". History Review (46). Archived from the original on 8 May 2021.
- JSTOR 3698107.
- ^ Lin, Hsu-Ta (2005). Reflavored nostalgias: A history and ethnography of Taiwan's muted marginality, 1895–2004 (PhD). Princeton University Press.
- ^ Xiuliang, Peng (2013). A Biography of Wang Shizhen (in Chinese). Zhonghua Book Company.
- ^ Zoltán, Tefner (2016). "István Burián and the Settling of the Polish Issue during the First World War". Prague Papers on the History of International Relations (2): 82–103.
- CiteSeerX 10.1.1.1064.997.
- ^ Abdelrahman, Sabreen (3 September 2020). "Us Police Brutality Isn't Just Homegrown, It's Imported Too".
- S2CID 146759349.
- ^ "The situation in the occupied Arab territories". Repertoire of the Practice of the Security Council 1989–1992 (11th supplement) (PDF). pp. 758–810.
- ^ Zarchin, Tomer (9 July 2012). "Legal Expert: If Israel Isn't Occupying West Bank, It Must Give Up Land Held by IDF". Haaretz. Archived from the original on 8 November 2021. Retrieved 12 March 2017.
'If the Levy Committee is pushing the government to determine that Israel's presence in the West Bank does not violate international law, Israel is in a dangerous position facing the rest of the world,' said Sasson this morning to Haaretz. ... 'For 45 years, different compositions of the High Court of Justice stated again and again that international law applies to the West Bank, which is clearly opposed to Levy's findings. This is a colossal turnaround, which I do not think is within his authority. He can tell the government that he recommends changing legal status, and that's all,' said Sasson.
- ^ a b c d e f Olson 2020.
- ^ a b Grimes, Hannah (22 June 2021). "Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Things You Need To Know About Amestris". cbr.com. Archived from the original on 28 June 2021. Retrieved 1 December 2021.
- ^ Isayama, Hajime (April 2016). "70". Attack on Titan. Kodansha Comics. pp. 1, 18–25.
- ^ Finger, Penina; Isgreen, Adam; Yeo, Erik (1997). Command & Conquer: Instruction Manual (PDF). Las Vegas, Nevada: Westwood Studios. Archived (PDF) from the original on 24 February 2021.
- ^ Stojsavljević, Rade; O'Miley, Ryan (1999). Command & Conquer: Tiberian Sun: Operations Manual. Las Vegas, Nevada: Westwood Studios.
- ISBN 978-0450044496.
- ^ Salter, Alexander (11 August 2016). "The Political Economy of "Starship Troopers"". The Imaginative Conservative. Archived from the original on 15 September 2016. Retrieved 29 November 2021.
- ^ Allen, Natalie (2020). "Voting Rights in Starship Troopers and Early American History". Embry–Riddle Aeronautical University. Archived from the original on 29 November 2021. Retrieved 29 November 2021.
- ^ Childers, Juliet (9 November 2020). "Mass Effect: Everything You Didn't Know About Turians". thegamer. Archived from the original on 19 May 2021. Retrieved 1 December 2021.
- ^ Delgreco, Marina (19 November 2020). "A Deep Dive Into Mass Effect's Loyal and Dedicated Turian Alien Race". gamerant. Archived from the original on 20 November 2020. Retrieved 1 December 2021.
- ISBN 9784063731125.
Bibliography
- Akpeninor, James Ohwofasa (28 February 2013). Merger Politics of Nigeria and Surge of Sectarian Violence. AuthorHouse. ISBN 9781467881715.
- Anthony, David J. (June 1980). Political Culture and the Nature of Political Participation in Egypt (PDF) (MA). Naval Postgraduate School. Retrieved 9 May 2021.
- Bangura, Yusuf (March 1991). Authoritarian Rule and Democracy in Africa: A Theoretical Discourse (PDF) (Report). United Nations Research Institute for Social Development. Retrieved 13 May 2021.
- Barfi, Barak, ed. (September 2018). "Shaping an Elite". Egypt's New Realism: Challenges Under Sisi. The Washington Institute.
- Christie, Ross (November 2004). 'Britain's Crisis of Confidence': How Whitehall Planned Britain's Retreat from the extra-European World, 1959-1968 (PDF) (PhD thesis). University of Stirling. Retrieved 13 May 2021.
- George, David (1988). "Distinguishing Classical Tyrannicide from Modern Terrorism". The Review of Politics. 50 (3). S2CID 146523905. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
- de Grazia, Alfred (1970). "The Perennial Stratocrats". Kalos: What is to be done with our World?. Archived from the original on 25 May 2021. Retrieved 25 May 2021.
- Jaywant, Sameer (4 April 2014). Military Rule & Economic Growth in Post-Independence Uganda: A Synthetic Counterfactual Approach (PhD). New York University.</ref>
- Olson, Matthew A. (5 July 2020). "Worldbuilding: 36 Types of Government (Part 2)". Chatoicanwriter. Archived from the original on 5 May 2021. Retrieved 5 May 2021.
- Ogunjimi, Bayo (1992). "The Herd Instinct and Class Literature in Nigeria Today". Issue: A Journal of Opinion. 20 (2). JSTOR 1166986.
- Ujomu, Philip Ogochukwu (19 May 2020). "Africa's Crisis of Social and Political Order and the Significance of Ubuntu Human Values for Peace and Development". Culture and Dialogue. 8 (1). S2CID 219772170. Retrieved 6 May 2021.
- Vatikiotis, Panayiotis Jerasimof (1968). "Some Political Consequences of the 1952 Revolution in Egypt". In Holt, Peter M. (ed.). Political and Social Change in Modern Egypt. London: Oxford University Press. p. 370.
Stanislav Kulchytsky
Stanislav Kulchytsky, while recognising the Holodomor as a genocide,[1] in work with Hennadii Yefimenko claim that mortality, in all cases, among different ethnic groups in Ukraine reflects the ethnic distribution of the rural population of Ukraine. Ethnic Ukrainian, Moldovan and Bulgarian people were disproportionately affected by the famine mainly because of their rural status.[2]: 64
- ^ Kulchytsky, Stanislav [in Ukrainian] (September 2017). "The Ukrainian Holodomor against the Background of the Communist Onslaught, 1929–1938" (PDF). Holodomor Research and Education Consortium. Translated by Kinsella, Ali; Olynyk, Marta D. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 January 2021.
- ISBN 978-966-02-3014-9. Archived from the originalon 31 October 2019. Retrieved 6 November 2019.
Статистичні таблиці, створювані на основі даних, що збиралися органами ЗАГС, непереконливі, коли йдеться про кількість жертв голоду. Проте вони дають відповідь на питання про національну приналежність померлих. Статистика смертності в національному розрізі за 1933 р. виглядає таким чином: Аналізуючи цю таблицю, слід пам'ятати, що в ній подається як природна смертність, так і смертність від толоду. Спрямований проти українського села терор голодом захопив усіх, хто проживав у ньому. У формах звітності за національною ознакою була зареєстрована більша кількість смертей, ніж у формах природного руху (1850,3 тис. чоловік). Частка українців серед загиблих приблизно відповідає їх питомій вазі у сільському населенні республіки. Молдавське, польське, німецьке і болгарське населення майже повністю проживало в селах. Тому воно постраждало від голоду в таких же пропорціях, як українці. Євреї мешкали більшою частиною у містах. Тому смертність серед них мало відрізнялася від нормальної. Переважна більшість росіян теж проживала в містах. Серед порівняно нечисленного населення в російських селах зареєстрована основна частина померлих. Треба прийняти до уваги, що облік смертності в містах майже не зазнав деформацій і тому був відносно повним. Навпаки, в селах органи ЗАГС спромоглися зареєструвати менше половини смертних випадків. Все це вказує на те, що терор голодом цілив своїм вістрям не в етнічних українців, а в сільське населення.
[Statistical tables created on the basis of data collected by the registry office are inconclusive when it comes to the number of victims of famine. However, they answer the question about the nationality of the deceased. National mortality statistics for 1933 are as follows: Analyzing this table, it should be remembered that it presents both natural mortality and death from frostbite. The terror directed against the Ukrainian village captured everyone who lived in it with hunger. A greater number of deaths were registered in the forms of reporting by nationality than in the forms of natural movement (1,850.3 thousand people). The share of Ukrainians among the dead roughly corresponds to their specific weight in the rural population of the republic. The Moldavian, Polish, German and Bulgarian population lived almost entirely in the villages. Therefore, it suffered from hunger in the same proportions as Ukrainians. Jews mostly lived in cities. Therefore, mortality among them differed little from normal. The vast majority of Russians also lived in cities. Most of the dead are registered among the relatively small population in Russian villages. It should be taken into account that the record of mortality in cities was almost not deformed and therefore was relatively complete. On the contrary, in the villages, the civil registry office managed to register less than half of the deaths. All this indicates that the terror of hunger was aimed not at ethnic Ukrainians, but at the rural population.]